Saturday, November 14 · Evening
The Noble Search and the Buddha’s first encounters; coming off retreat and keeping practice going; Kappa’s question; Q&A on mixing methods, 5-MeO, trauma and retreat centers; closing blessings
The closing talk told the story of the Buddha's search and his first encounters after awakening, then turned to keeping practice going at home. The last Q&A covered methods, psychedelics, trauma and retreat culture. It ended with traditional blessings.
Topics and questions in this session
Talk
- 0:00:00The five recollections for the last time, and the Zen evening verse.
- 0:05:16The Noble Search (MN 26): seeking the unexcelled, and awakening (0:07).
- 0:08:27Hesitating to teach a Dhamma that goes against the flow. Brahma Sahampati's plea (0:09) and the lotuses in the pond (0:10).
- 0:11:34His former teachers, Alara Kalama and Uddaka Ramaputta, have died. The meeting with Upaka (0:12–0:14).
- 0:16:39Coming off retreat: momentum, good friends, and reaching out if there's trouble (0:18).
- 0:18:06Two hours of formal practice a day if you can, plus continuous mindfulness (0:19). Practice whenever it occurs to you (0:21).
- 0:21:45Kappa's question (Sn 5:10): "Having nothing, free of clinging: that is the island" (0:23).
Q&A
- 0:23:50Mixing and matching methods. "This practice is enough" (0:26).
- 0:26:02Feeling the breath at different spots in the nostrils. Shaila Catherine's point just above the skin (0:28).
- 0:30:12Using 5-MeO after the retreat. His write-up from the QRI retreat on 5-MeO and jhana (0:31).
- 0:33:30Can anyone get far down the path?
- 0:35:14Practice and trauma (Treleaven). The window of tolerance (0:38).
- 0:38:35The illiterate sweeping monk, Cula Panthaka, and the student given curse words as a mantra (0:40).
- 0:42:14A participant's share from the bench on the mesa. A Kagyu lama's platter of shit (0:43).
- 0:43:58Red flags in retreat centers. The four-day retreat where everyone was enlightened (0:46).
- 0:48:45Doing jhana practice covertly at Goenka centers.
- 0:48:45How not to cling to jhana. Wanting progress is fine (0:51).
- 0:53:14Piti arising on its own while just hanging out: a fruit of practice (MN 36, 0:54).
Closing
- 0:55:52Traditional anumodana blessings, then a break and the final sit.
0:00:00And for the last time on this retreat, anyway (though hopefully not the last time you take them up), the subjects for frequent recollection. We've now almost concluded this brief retreat. Although it may sometimes seem to drag on, and some folks are feeling it as a bit of a slog, it's almost over. Time passes quickly. At the conclusion of the monastic schedule in Soto Zen monasteries, there's an evening verse: "Time swiftly passes by. Opportunity is lost. Each of us should strive to awaken. Take heed. Do not squander your life." It's the last thing you hear before the evening concludes. Byadhi-dhammomhi byadhim anatito: I am of the nature to sicken; I have not gone beyond sickness. We'll soon all be traveling. Well, some of us are local to Boulder, actually, but many of us will soon be traveling, and who knows what pathogens we may pick up along the way. A practical reminder: take precautions. We're moving into flu season; who knows what else may be going around in the air. But also, we never know. Life is precarious. Marana-dhammomhi maranam anatito: I am of the nature to die; I have not gone beyond dying. We think our lives are much longer than that of a mayfly, or of the prairie dogs out there that are being taken out over our preferences about how the land should be used. For those online: there are prairie dogs here, which in this area are kind of an invasive species, and they're being gassed out of their burrows.12
0:02:41Rather grim. In terms of the termination of our lives, our fate is no different from theirs. Do you want a vivid reminder of death? Think of those poor prairie dogs. All that is mine, beloved and pleasing, will become otherwise, will become separated from me. Early on in the retreat, I was so happy walking on the trail, seeing the little prairie dogs putting their heads up. And then one day I looked at the sign: a notice of extermination. I had cherished the prairie dogs, I had delighted in them, and then I saw what is inevitably bound to happen to them. So that's sadness. We can't hold on to anything, even prairie dogs. This retreat, which I've enjoyed so much, is almost over. I am the owner of my action, heir to my action, born of my action, related to my action, and abide supported by my action. Whatever action I shall do, for good or for ill, of that I will be the heir. So, going back out, let's be mindful and recollect all of these facts of our life, and intend for our own and others' welfare to continue to practice. Or maybe you've had enough; you've decided after this retreat that this isn't for you. But at least intend good for yourself and others, and act on it, for your own welfare, for long-term benefit and happiness.
0:05:16Thus we should frequently recollect. "In search of what might be skillful, seeking the unexcelled state of sublime peace, I wandered by stages in the Magadhan country and came to the military town of Uruvela. There I saw some delightful countryside, with an inspiring forest grove, a clear-flowing river with fine, delightful banks, and villages for alms-going on all sides. The thought occurred to me: 'How delightful is this countryside, with its inspiring forest grove, clear-flowing river with fine, delightful banks, and villages for alms-going on all sides. This is just right for the exertion of a clansman intent on exertion.' So I sat down right there, thinking, 'This is just right for exertion.' Then, being myself subject to birth, seeing the drawbacks of birth, seeking the unborn, unexcelled rest from the yoke, unbinding, I reached the unborn, unexcelled rest from the yoke, unbinding. Being myself subject to aging, illness, death, sorrow, defilement, seeing the drawbacks of aging, illness, death, sorrow, defilement, seeking the ageless, illnessless, deathless, sorrowless, undefiled, unexcelled rest from the yoke, unbinding, I reached the ageless, illnessless, deathless, sorrowless, undefiled, unexcelled rest from the yoke, unbinding. Knowledge and vision arose in me:3
0:07:05"'Unprovoked is my release. This is the last birth. There is now no further becoming.' Then the thought occurred to me: 'This Dhamma that I have attained is deep, hard to see, hard to realize, peaceful, refined, beyond the scope of conjecture, subtle, to be experienced by the wise. But this generation delights in attachment, is excited by attachment, enjoys attachment. For a generation delighting in attachment, excited by attachment, enjoying attachment, this/that conditionality and dependent co-arising are hard to see. This state, too, is hard to see: the pacification of all fabrications, the relinquishing of all acquisitions, the ending of craving; dispassion; cessation; unbinding. If I were to teach the Dhamma and others wouldn't understand me, that would be tiresome for me, troublesome for me.'" The Buddha's first thought upon awakening: "Nailed it. Got it. Done. This is really subtle. No one's going to get this. Trying to communicate it? That would be annoying." "Just then these verses, unspoken in the past, unheard before, occurred to me: 'Enough now with teaching what only with difficulty I reached. This Dhamma is not easily realized by those overcome with aversion and passion.
0:08:27"'What is abstruse, subtle, deep, hard to see, going against the flow, those delighting in passion, cloaked in a mass of darkness, won't see.' As I reflected thus, my mind inclined to dwelling at ease, not to teaching the Dhamma. Then Brahma Sahampati" (a very high god), "having known with his own awareness the line of thinking in my awareness, thought: 'The world is lost! The world is destroyed! The mind of the Tathagata, the arahant, the rightly self-awakened one, inclines to dwelling at ease, not to teaching the Dhamma!' Then, just as a strong man might extend his flexed arm or flex his extended arm, Brahma Sahampati disappeared from the Brahma world and reappeared in front of me. Arranging his upper robe over one shoulder, he knelt down with his right knee on the ground, saluted me with his hands before his heart, and said to me: 'Lord, let the Blessed One teach the Dhamma! Let the One Well-Gone teach the Dhamma! There are beings with little dust in their eyes who are falling away because they do not hear the Dhamma. There will be those who will understand the Dhamma.' That is what Brahma Sahampati said. Having said that, he further said this:
0:09:30"'In the past there appeared among the Magadhans an impure Dhamma devised by the stained. Throw open the door to the Deathless! Let them hear the Dhamma realized by the Stainless One! Just as one standing on a rocky crag might see people all around below, so, intelligent one with all-around vision, ascend the palace fashioned of Dhamma. Free from sorrow, behold the people submerged in sorrow, oppressed by birth and aging. Rise up, hero, victor in battle! O Teacher, wander without doubt in the world. Teach the Dhamma, O Blessed One: there will be those who will understand.' Then, having understood Brahma's invitation, out of compassion for beings, I surveyed the world with the eye of an awakened one. As I did so, I saw beings with little dust in their eyes and those with much, those with keen faculties and those with dull, those with good attributes and those with bad, those easy to teach and those hard, some of them seeing disgrace and danger in the other world. Just as in a pond of blue or red or white lotuses, some lotuses, born and growing in the water, might flourish while immersed in the water, without rising up from the water;
0:10:32"some might stand at an even level with the water; while some might rise up from the water and stand without being smeared by the water; so too, surveying the world with the eye of an awakened one, I saw beings with little dust in their eyes and those with much, those with keen faculties and those with dull, those with good attributes and those with bad, those easy to teach and those hard, some of them seeing disgrace and danger in the other world. Having seen this, I answered Brahma Sahampati in verse: 'Open are the doors to the Deathless. Let those with ears show their conviction. Perceiving trouble, O Brahma, I did not tell people the refined, sublime Dhamma.' Then Brahma Sahampati, thinking, 'The Blessed One has given his consent to teach the Dhamma,' bowed down to me and, circling me on the right, disappeared right there." And then the thought occurs to the Buddha: "Okay, there are some who will get it. Who do I go to first?" "The thought occurred to me: 'Alara Kalama'" (one of the Buddha's former teachers) "'will get it.'" And then, with his psychic power, he realizes: "Oh, no. He died seven days ago." "Okay. To whom should I teach the Dhamma first?
0:11:34"Who will quickly understand this Dhamma?" Uddaka Ramaputta, another of the Buddha's former teachers, who taught him deep states of absorption and mastery in meditation, but who hadn't himself reached the deathless; the Buddha wandered on and found the path to its culmination on his own. But they were wise and intelligent in their own way, so he thinks he'd like to repay the favor. "The second teacher, Uddaka Ramaputta, is wise, competent, intelligent. He has long had little dust in his eyes. What if I were to teach him the Dhamma first?" And then a deva comes to him and says, "Sorry. He died last night." Okay, then, it's not them. "Then the thought occurred to me: 'They were very helpful to me, the group of five monks who attended to me when I was resolute in exertion'" (when he was undergoing his ascetic practices). "'What if I were to teach them the Dhamma first?'" And with his psychic powers he sees where they're staying and sets straight off for them. But along the way, newly awakened, the first human being the Buddha encounters, he's going along a road, and: "Upaka the Ajivaka" (the Ajivakas were a sect of non-Buddhist contemplatives) "saw me on the road between Gaya and the place of awakening and, on seeing me, said to me, 'Clear, my friend, are your faculties. Pure your complexion, and bright.
0:12:54"'On whose account have you gone forth? Who is your teacher? In whose Dhamma do you delight?'" ("When this was said, I replied to Upaka the Ajivaka in verses.") Coming on retreat, engaging in practice, having some measure of samadhi, some measure of insight, we may often leave feeling very inspired, as the Buddha did. Well, you'll see what happens next. "When this was said, I replied to Upaka the Ajivaka in verses: 'All-vanquishing, all-knowing am I, with regard to all things, unadhering. All-abandoning, released in the ending of craving: having fully known on my own, to whom should I point as my teacher? I have no teacher, and one like me can't be found in the world with its devas. I have no counterpart, For I am an arahant in the world; I, the unexcelled teacher; I, alone, am rightly self-awakened. Cooled am I, unbound. To set rolling the wheel of Dhamma I go to the city of Kasi. In a world become blind, I beat the drum of the Deathless.'" Upaka replies: "'From your claims, my friend, you must be an infinite conqueror.'"
0:14:17And the Buddha replies: "'Conquerors are those like me who have reached effluents' end. I've conquered evil qualities, and so, Upaka, I'm a conqueror.' When this was said, Upaka said, 'May it be so, my friend,' and, shaking his head, [unclear]." Now, as far as I'm aware, no one on this retreat has reached the effluents' end and attained arahantship. If you have, let me know; help me out. But regardless, I wanted to devote some of tonight's talk, before opening it up for any final questions, to the issue of transitioning out of retreat: integration. As you can see, even for the Buddha, fresh off his total unbinding, it didn't work right the first time, with the first person he met. He had to consider the audience when delivering the message, let's say. If you do want to share the benefit of practice with others, the best thing you can do is exemplify it in your conduct, in your manner of being, in the transformation you undergo in your own life, not by speaking about it. It's fine to speak about it, but we don't need to go around, as the Buddha did here, declaring ourselves conquerors of all, all-knowing, all-seeing.
0:16:39So, even on a retreat that's not so long in the grand scheme of things (only eight full days), you can build up quite a lot of momentum in concentration, and transitioning back out into your more regular routines (traveling, getting back into socializing) things may be a little weird, especially for those of us who have been on retreat full-time. So I'd really recommend being gentle and slow as much as you're able. If there's anything you can let rest for the next day, or the next couple of days, you don't need to charge right back in. If possible, I'd avoid checking in on all the news and social media. Unless there are urgent emails or other stuff you need to look at, just give your system time to acclimatize gently to the stimulation you'll soon be encountering out in the unreal world. And sometimes, coming off a retreat, there can be high highs, and you may experience some low lows as you move back into your routines and environment. If you do run into trouble,
0:18:06you can send me an email. Rely on good friends, and don't hesitate to reach out if there's any trouble integrating the experience back into the day-to-day. And as for how to maintain the practice (this has come up a bunch in these last two days of interviews), either maintaining it where it is, or keeping it going, keeping the progression going: everything that makes a retreat like this conducive to advancing in practice, to deepening in samadhi, to becoming ripe for insight and integrating it into our being, all of those same factors apply. If you want to continue swiftly along the path at home, the more you move your daily habits and home life towards retreat, the better the conditions for samadhi, for the progression of practice, for the attainment of insight, for all of these things. A standard recommendation (I don't know how this number got settled on, but it seems to be a rough consensus among the teachers I know): if you can, two hours a day of formal practice is really excellent. An hour in the morning and an hour before you go to bed at night, or a two-hour block, or a 90-minute block and a 30-minute block. That will allow you to really maintain the momentum you've built up on a retreat like this one, and to continue.
0:19:43That, along with continuous mindfulness, just as we've been practicing here together: mindfulness of the body, mindfulness of the mind, mindfulness of mental qualities, the breath, metta. As though one's head were on fire, regardless of whether you're in a monastery or in the world, on retreat or off retreat. One of my own teachers, Shugen, once said: "What's the purpose of a retreat like this? Why are we waking up so early? What's the intention behind all of this structure? It's kind of artificial, isn't it?" To which you replied, "Yeah, absolutely." The point of this kind of restrictive container (waking up early, being forced by the strictures to be with your mind all day long and into the night, depending on what kind of sleep deprivation you're going for) is to show that you can practice that way all the time. There is no actual difference between your regular life and retreat in terms of how you can approach it with your practice. Especially at the beginning, things are more conducive to continuous practice on retreat. Yes, absolutely. But if you want to move along the path swiftly, there's no substitute for moment after moment after moment, not only in whatever time you give to formal practice, but all the time: walking, seated, standing, lying down, waking up, falling asleep, in conversation, at work.
0:21:45Every moment when it's possible for you, when it even occurs to you that you could be practicing, then, right then and there, throw yourself into practice. It doesn't matter whether you're on retreat or not. It doesn't even matter whether you have that much time to devote to formal practice. If you can genuinely approach each moment fresh with that intention, then your life will become practice. Your life will unfold within practice, and you won't get caught up in the habit of splitting: "My life is one thing, practice is another. I have to somehow fit practice into my life, or get rid of certain things to allow practice to happen." So by all means prioritize, and set aside as much time as you can and want for plunging deeply back into samadhi, into insight practice. And my sincere wish is that all of you, in no long time, may reach and remain in the goal; that all of you may know the deathless for yourselves, and may live from that realization. Okay, a last quote. This is "Kappa's Question": "For one stranded in the middle of the lake, in the flood of great danger, birth overwhelmed with aging and death: tell me the island, dear sir. Show me the island, so that this may not happen again." The Buddha replies: "For one stranded in the middle of the lake, in the flood of great danger, birth overwhelmed with aging and death:4
0:23:50"Kappa, I will tell you the island. Having nothing, free of clinging: that is the island, there is no other. That's unbinding, I tell you, the total ending of aging and death. Those knowing this, mindful, fully unbound in the here and now, don't serve as Mara's servants, don't come under Mara's sway." Okay. Any lingering questions about practice, about moving out of retreat? Anything at all? "[unclear] focusing on doing one thing, just [dropping] everything else, versus 'Ah, let's do some Mahamudra now, some Theravada stuff now, Soulmaking now.' Advice, basically." Yeah: mixing and matching. I don't have that much room to judge here; I'm quite eclectic myself. But I know for certain that, within my own life history and practice, I've made the swiftest and longest strides when I've thrown myself fully into one method and not looked left or right or around at what else there is. So while I've sampled and continued with different paths and different practices and different views, and worked with a bunch of different teachers, I've been best served along the way, even if only for periods of time, by throwing myself fully in and forgetting absolutely about everything else. And at some points by making a resolution: "This practice: I have faith, I have confidence.
0:26:02"This practice is enough to realize what I want to realize, to see what I want to see. I will not look around for anything else. I will see it through with this." So conviction and determination serve well, and they're well supported by making a decision and seeing it through, rather than hopping around. And, as I said earlier, in my own experience of practice (of Zen, of Dzogchen, of tantric methods, of Theravadan jhana and vipassana), they have different, on the surface contradictory, views. But in my own experience these methods of practice have led to the same emptiness, the same realization of selflessness, the same freedom from duality and confusion and attraction, the same recognition of the nature of mind. [unclear] "I'm trying to do the practice where I keep my focus on a very small space, right here. And as I'm focusing on the breath, I'm noticing the breath at different places in my nostrils. I guess I'm noticing that when I'm feeling more concentrated, I'm not focusing on the breath directly so much as using it to point to this place. I guess that's the correct way to go about it?" Yeah. If you're using the breath at the nostrils, the recommendation is not to follow it up into the nasal cavity.
0:28:30Just keep it in one spot. Even in the gaps between the breaths, the object is still actually that space where the sensation would be, and you just keep that continuously. "Gotcha. One quick follow-up question. I remember reading Shaila Catherine's book Wisdom Wide and Deep a while ago, and she talked about how, even when you're keeping the point of your attention right here, you want to keep it slightly above your skin, or something like that, which I don't think I fully comprehend. How is that possible? If I'm trying to keep my attention on a touch sensation, how do I keep it in space?" Yeah. My own experience working with this object is that at a certain point the breath sensation congeals into just this energetic space, and at a certain depth of concentration it does seem to move off a little. It's not actually in the space of the nostrils; at a certain point the breath object doesn't actually correspond to the physical location of the nostrils. I don't know how or why that works, but it does seem to work that way for most people. If that's not obvious yet, it may make more sense soon. Just stay with it at the entrance, where you can actually feel the sensation,5
0:30:12and it may move off on its own. "Gotcha. I guess it's one of those things that will hopefully make sense with more concentration. All right, thank you." Yeah. "So, theoretically, if you were to integrate the support of 5-MeO after the retreat, I'm curious if you have any recommendations. Does it help stabilize jhana? Do you recommend getting to jhana before using it? Are there any rough things you'd have to say?" Yeah. So the question is about 5-MeO. And of course I do not recommend doing anything with a scheduled substance in an area where it's prohibited by the laws of this great nation. But I was involved in QRI's research down in Mexico, and I've had the chance to do quite a bit of 5-MeO and play around with it, mixing and matching with a bunch of different techniques. As with any other psychedelic, if you're going to engage with those things, I think it's best integrated within the container of practice:
0:31:43before, during and after. Right. In my own experience (you can read my write-up from the QRI retreat on the similarities and differences between 5-MeO and jhana experience), there are non-trivial similarities between them. Not exactly the same, but non-trivial similarities. On lower doses of 5-MeO, I can incline my mind and get into a 5-MeO-inflected jhanic space pretty readily. So I'm not going to recommend anything, but those are some thoughts. "Do you think it helps with practice? Or is it just a cool space to explore?" Yeah. My suspicion is that, used skillfully, it and other psychedelics (especially the ones that don't introduce too much content and fabrication) may help, both likely on a neurobiological level, because of the neuroplastic effects (if you're integrating it within a space of intensive practice, you may just be able to have more rapid skill acquisition and deepening as a result of the neuroplasticity, even apart from any experience that happens as a result of the compound), and because of the non-trivial phenomenological similarities between 5-MeO and classically desirable [contemplative] states. It wouldn't surprise me if it were useful.
0:33:30But these are still relatively uncharted waters, and there are inherent risks with everything, and caution is well warranted with everything. "Could you talk a bit about your degree of confidence, and your reasons for it, that pretty much anyone can get at least pretty far down the path? Can you imagine a person of whom you'd say, 'You know what, this guy just doesn't have the sauce'?" The one who doesn't have the sauce is the one who has no interest. For anyone who has a genuine interest, yes, I think they can walk the path as far as they want to, given the circumstances: they don't get killed by a cow, like Bahiya, that afternoon. My faith and confidence in that come from the fact that the core of most of the practices doesn't require any special characteristics or qualities. You don't have to have a great intellect; in fact, that can be a barrier, if one is attached to conceptuality. You don't have to be any particular age. You don't have to come from any particular status. All you need is attention, awareness, and the willingness to apply them.6
0:35:14And every human being I've ever met has those things. Now, earlier there were the four categories of practitioners: those with pleasant practice and quick intuition, those with pleasant practice and slow intuition, those with painful practice but quick intuition, and those with painful practice and slow intuition. So, sure, have I met many people who have an easier or a harder time with certain practices, or with the path as a whole? Yeah, absolutely, depending on their conditioning, their karma, their past action. For sure. But there's no quality lacking in anyone I've ever met. And the better part of my faith and confidence comes from its seeming blindingly obvious that what the end and goal of the path is, is everyone's nature already. It's not something that needs to be created, just seen. If it were something that needed to be created, then we might have problems, and it also wouldn't be the worthy goal that it is, because then it would be conditional; it would be dependent. But if you're a sentient being, your nature is Buddha. "Sounds good." Yeah. "I'm wondering if you can speak to how walking the path can combine, positively or negatively, with trauma. Maybe any resources you can point to?" Yeah. Well, there's the book that I think has become the standard reference: David Treleaven, Trauma Informed Mindfulness, I think, is the book.78
0:37:10I haven't actually read it, but I understand it's good. Going deep into concentration, or deep into insight territory or insight practice, with a heavy trauma load can be contraindicated, because it can surface a lot and break down some of the barriers and defenses that may be keeping the pain at bay, and if that all opens up prematurely, it can be disruptive to a person. Or if someone is disembodied and dissociated because of a heavy trauma load, and suddenly they're being asked to pay attention to their affect in their body in such a way that all these emotions and memories come flooding up, and they're unprepared or not well supported for that, then engaging in practice can actually do more harm. Just as if someone... I mean, you hear these horror stories, both of people going unprepared and uninformed onto intensive meditation retreats, and into psychedelic spaces, without being informed of the risks and benefits, and often not well supported or facilitated. So it's just a matter of care and caution and calibration.
0:38:35There's a window of tolerance for the degree of distress within practice that's reasonable to sustain, and beyond it you might need to bring in other emotional supports, modalities, conventional psychiatric care, medication, whatever. Broad strokes. Is that helpful? "Yeah. A note on whether people have the sauce or not: wasn't there a monk in a monastery, the one who sweeps or whatever, who didn't know language? He was illiterate, but he knew the word 'sweep.' He was given 'sweep,' and that's all he would say, 'sweep,' all day, and eventually..." I have heard that story. I'm not actually sure what the source is, but yes, I've heard it. "Can you connect it to how that came to be practice, and how that went?" Yeah. If I'm remembering the story a bit more, the monk was given the instruction just to sweep, using the sweeping as a practical metaphor for sweeping away the obscurations of mind. And through the intense mindfulness of the body and of the mind that was developed just through this constant sweeping, that became the embodied practice. Deep samadhi was probably reached even without much conceptual sophistication or understanding at that level.9
0:40:25But thank goodness awakening is non-conceptual. So somehow that broke open for that person. There's another story that illustrates a similar point. I'm forgetting which teacher it was; I can look it up afterwards. A famous, realized teacher was asked by an illiterate practitioner: "Oh, you've just come back from India to Tibet with all of this great learning and different practice systems. Please, would you give me something simple, something easy to practice and understand, that will bring me to enlightenment?" And the teacher just gave the practitioner a string of foreign curse words. But the practitioner had such devotion, such trust and faith and confidence in the words of the guru, that they were very quickly able to enter a profound concentration on the "mantra," which was actually just filthy, obscene language. They didn't understand it, and through profound practice they were able to attain awakening in that very life, in not too long a time.
0:42:14"I've been spending a lot of time walking and running on the trails nearby, enjoying the prairie dogs, blissfully unaware. There's a bench at the top of the mesa that's a really nice spot for open-eye meditation. I was sitting there one afternoon, having just walked up the path leading up the mesa to the bench, and a couple of people and a couple of dogs were walking up the path toward the bench. One of the dogs ran ahead about halfway up the path, and the owner started calling, 'Aspen, Aspen,' presumably the dog's name. And Aspen was just not having it; it stopped halfway up the path. What the owner couldn't know, but what I could see, having progressed farther along the path, was that Aspen was eagerly gobbling down mouthfuls of fresh horseshit. I observed this and thought: it is well to remember that the pleasant or unpleasant qualities of sense objects are a function of the mind, rather than inherent in the objects."
0:43:58Thank you. Well said. I interviewed a Kagyu lama for the podcast (you can go check it out if you want), and talking about emptiness, he was illustrating much the same point: "If I were to hand you a platter of shit, how would you feel? People get all excited about these fancy, sexy tantra practices. Nobody wants to eat shit. That's in the tantras too, okay?" "Until the last couple of years, most of my retreat time was spent with Westernized Theravada, at these big vipassana-run retreat centers. I know you have some criticisms, and I know from personal experience there's quite a range of teaching quality. But I'm curious whether there are any specific things you'd look out for, things you think will put one off track or stall progress, from what you know about that sort of teaching and retreating." In my own experience, surveying and bouncing around within the Western Buddhist world, such as it is, across these different traditions: if there's a taboo, or pooh-poohing, or hush-hushing, or a weird social awkwardness around deep practice and attainment ("What are we doing here? Really? Like, really?"), that's one big red flag. A similar kind of odd flag is when people are really bombastic about their community or their teacher: "Oh my God, it's the best, it's the fastest.
0:46:40"You have no idea. I went to this four-day retreat, and everyone was blown out of the water into perfect realization of emptiness." I hear there are even some Buddhist people [unclear]. It's like: "Um, okay." Both ends of that spectrum are... Yeah. And to whatever extent the community, the teacher, the environment is focused on anything other than diligent and continuous practice... You can often tell the seriousness and quality of the teaching, of the organization, of the teacher, by how much they prioritize actual practice: ass on cushion, or walking, actual practice. The more an organization, a teacher or a community spends its time and energy on anything other than that, the more they're not focusing on what the Buddha wandered all over the Gangetic plain attempting to propagate, after initially not wanting to: actual practice. "Yeah. The last two I haven't really encountered much, but the first one is the whole shtick of the retreat centers I mostly attended. For the last couple of retreats I just realized, well, the teachers aren't that important, but this retreat center is convenient, it's a nice place, it's easy to practice. Do you think it inhibits your own practice to be in a space where everyone else is doing another thing that isn't focused on...
0:48:45"There's literally, I would guess, maybe one other person secretly doing jhana practice." I have a very good friend who's a really incredible practitioner (I won't out him) who has done a huge amount of practice in Goenka vipassana centers, going hard and deep into territory they would not approve of, or using methods that are just outside their wheelhouse. He's done great. If you're the kind of practitioner with the ability to sustain that motivation independent of the social reinforcement around you and of direct teacher support, then no. If you need to be a covert, hidden yogi within a convenient retreat space, cool. It is nice, it is helpful, when the people around you (the community, the teacher, the atmosphere, the vibe, the structure) are driving, and everyone's pulling in the same direction. It's nice, but it's not necessary, and unfortunately it's rather hard to find. "Thank you." You're welcome. Yeah, [participant]. "Do you have any tips for not clinging to jhana as we continue to go along, obviously trying to achieve higher levels of jhana? How do we not cling to wanting that great, amazing feeling, or these different levels of opening up? Maybe the same question could go for clinging to a path of enlightenment."
0:51:03Yeah. I'm very pro wanting the path, wanting awakening, wanting progress, wanting... "One generates endeavors, generates desire and persistence, for the attainment of the as-yet-unattained." As soon as that becomes a fixation on the future, or a dejection about where one is in the present, that prevents one from actually doing the practice in that very moment, then, whoops. So it's good to keep a balanced motivation. Eyes on the prize, the mountain in the distance. And how do you get to the mountain? You put one foot, and then another foot. And you enjoy the sights along the way, and you take refreshment in the spring water and the food you take along the way. Why not? It vitalizes you and keeps you going. But always walking ahead, focused on the next step. "Beautiful. Okay, so some desire for enlightenment or jhana is somewhat okay, as long as we don't... as long as we're in the present moment of, I don't know, how would you say that again? As long as we're in the present moment of, yeah, each... just focusing on one step, I guess." Yeah, beautifully said. Okay. Ardent desire, even: a traditional form of practice is to begin every session of practice by generating the fervent and urgent desire and wish to liberate oneself as soon, as quickly, as expediently as possible, so that you can begin the work of helping others to do the same, right?
0:52:59"Yeah. Thank you." Yeah.
0:53:14We may have come to the end. Okay, one more. "Yeah. I had a really interesting experience today. I've been coming to an understanding of the kind of momentum that builds up, for me, over a week of relatively intense practice. I was sitting in here today, just chilling, hanging out, and it felt like piti was arising in various parts of my body. I wasn't practicing or trying to do anything, and I'm curious how to respond to moments like that. I tried to sit down and be with it, invite it and grow it, and nothing happened. I'm just wondering if there's a recommendation there." Yeah. As you gain momentum in samadhi, as the hindrances subside, you may find yourself just falling into some strong arising of the jhanic factors. That'll happen. And if it does, strike while the iron is hot. Why not? Sit down, get comfortable, and return to the object. If the factors will sustain your attention, you can turn to the piti and see what happens. And, as with the earlier instruction, if you turn your attention to the piti and it breaks up or disappears, then the concentration is strong enough for it to begin to arise, but not strong enough to sustain it, so go back to the breath, or metta, or whatever. And enjoy it.
0:54:49It's a fruit of practice. "Will do. Thank you." Yeah. On that note, clinging to jhana: I think I quoted this bit earlier, but along his own path [the Buddha asked]: "Why should I be afraid of that pleasure that has nothing to do with affliction, that has nothing to do with sensuality?" (the usual confused attraction and aversion we feel towards our sensory experience). Why should I be afraid of that pleasure, which is wholesome and skillful, which leads onwards to peace, which allows the development of insight? No reason.10
0:55:34"That's very helpful. Thank you." Yeah. Okay.
0:55:52Before we break and then sit, here are some traditional well-wishes. "Just as rivers full of water entirely fill up the sea, even so will what's been given here bring blessings to departed spirits. May all your hopes and all your longings come true in no long time. May all your wishes be fulfilled, as on the fifteenth day of the moon, or like a bright and shining gem. May all misfortunes be avoided. May all illness be dispelled. May you never meet with dangers. May you be happy and live long. For those who are respectful, who always honor their elders, four are the qualities that will increase: life, beauty, happiness and strength." A little commentary there: there's a set of verses about the qualities of a venerable monk that are worthy of emulation and of respect, and it's not a matter of age or seniority, but rather of the attainment of virtue, concentration and wisdom. So that's what's meant by elders in most contexts here. But also: be good to old people.1112
0:57:00"Four are the qualities that will increase: life, beauty, happiness and strength. May every blessing come to be, and all good spirits guard you well. Through the power of all the Buddhas, may you always be at ease. May every blessing come to be, and all good spirits guard you well. Through the power of all the Dhamma, may you always be at ease. May every blessing come to be, and all good spirits guard you well. Through the power of all the Sangha, may you always be at ease."
0:57:29We'll break for 10 and then sit. We'll be back here. For those online: if you can join, if you want to join tomorrow, we'll have the final sit of the retreat at 6 a.m. Boulder time, and then a brief closing and sharing. So if you can join, please do. And that'll be it. Thank you all.
Sources
- The five recollections. AN 5:57 Upajjhatthana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN5_57.html ↩
- Zen evening verse: “Time swiftly passes by...” Evening verse chanted in many Soto and Western Zen communities (a form of the Verse of the Han). No single canonical source. ↩
- The Noble Search: Uruvela, Brahma Sahampati’s invitation, Alara Kalama and Uddaka Ramaputta, Upaka the Ajivaka. MN 26 Ariyapariyesana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN26.html ↩
- Kappa’s question: the island. Sn 5:10 Kappa’s Question. dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/StNp/StNp5_10.html ↩
- Keeping the attention just off the skin at the nostrils. Shaila Catherine, Wisdom Wide and Deep: A Practical Handbook for Mastering Jhana and Vipassana (Wisdom Publications, 2011) ↩
- Killed by a cow. Ud 1:10 Bahiya Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/Ud/ud1_10.html ↩
- The four modes of practice (from the Nov 11 morning talk) AN 4:162 Modes of Practice in Detail. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN4_162.html ↩
- Trauma and meditation. David Treleaven, Trauma-Sensitive Mindfulness: Practices for Safe and Transformative Healing (W. W. Norton, 2018) ↩
- The monk given only “sweep” The story of Cula Panthaka (Cudapanthaka); Pali version in the Dhammapada Commentary on Dhp 25. ↩
- “Why should I be afraid of that pleasure?” MN 36 Maha Saccaka Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN36.html ↩
- Closing blessings, and the four qualities that increase for one respectful of elders. Traditional Theravada anumodana chants; the elders verse is Dhp 109. dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/Dhp/Ch08.html ↩
- An elder by virtue, not by age. Dhp 260–261. dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/Dhp/Ch19.html ↩