Jhana & Awakening Retreat 2026

Recordings and edited transcripts of the sixteen sessions of the Jhana & Awakening Retreat at Nameless Mountain, Boulder, Colorado, November 6–14, 2026: evening talks and morning instruction, each with questions and answers, and guided practice.

Below, each session is broken down into the topics of the talk and the questions that came up. Choose a topic to open that session's transcript at that point. The time beside it is where it begins in the recording, so you can drag the player there to listen.

Sessions

  1. Friday, November 6 · Evening: Opening talk: bodhicitta, the four noble truths, the eightfold path, refuge and precepts (48 min)
  2. Saturday, November 7 · Morning: Mindfulness immersed in the body: breath and metta, the five hindrances; guided whole-body breathing (1 hr 24 min)
  3. Saturday, November 7 · Evening: Five recollections, access concentration and the first jhana; guided metta (1 hr 40 min)
  4. Sunday, November 8 · Morning: The first four jhanas in context: lineages, the Anapanasati tetrads, transitions and similes; Q&A (1 hr 49 min)
  5. Sunday, November 8 · Evening: The Snake and the two viewpoints: becoming, non-becoming and the fruits of the contemplative life; Q&A; the four brahmaviharas (1 hr 49 min)
  6. Monday, November 9 · Morning: Feeding and starving the hindrances; Q&A; guided whole-body breathing (59 min)
  7. Monday, November 9 · Evening: The Rod Embraced; Q&A on awakening, stream entry and kensho, jhana and ethics, karma and purification (56 min)
  8. Tuesday, November 10 · Morning: The formless attainments and cessation; the Foam Sutta (SN 22:95); Q&A (1 hr 7 min)
  9. Tuesday, November 10 · Evening: Quarrels and Disputes (Sn 4:11); Q&A on cessation, sukha, perception and consciousness, open-eye practice, dreams (59 min)
  10. Wednesday, November 11 · Morning: Four modes of practice, four ways to arahantship, defilements of concentration (MN 128) and the thorns (AN 10:72); Q&A (52 min)
  11. Wednesday, November 11 · Evening: Exertion (Sn 3:2), Before the Break-up (Sn 4:10) and The Cow (AN 9:35); Q&A on siddhis, purification, teachers and koan practice; Hakuin’s soft-butter method (1 hr 20 min)
  12. Thursday, November 12 · Morning: Insight: the three characteristics (AN 3:137), insight from jhana (AN 9:36), Ud 8:4; Q&A; guided insight into impermanence (1 hr 38 min)
  13. Thursday, November 12 · Evening: Surveying the World (Ud 3:10), Kevaddha’s question (DN 11) and the unfabricated (SN 43); Q&A on sila, bodhicitta, meaning and beauty (1 hr 1 min)
  14. Friday, November 13 · Morning: Renunciation, transformation, recognition; Bahiya (Ud 1:10) and Tilopa’s Ganges Mahamudra; nature of mind; Q&A (1 hr 7 min)
  15. Friday, November 13 · Evening: Shido Bunan’s old man and Hakuin’s Song of Zazen; Q&A on impermanence, Nagarjuna, practice after retreat, Zen and jhana, Dzogchen, vitakka and vicara (1 hr 10 min)
  16. Saturday, November 14 · Evening: The Noble Search and the Buddha’s first encounters; coming off retreat and keeping practice going; Kappa’s question; Q&A on mixing methods, 5-MeO, trauma and retreat centers; closing blessings (58 min)

Friday, November 6 · Evening

Opening talk: bodhicitta, the four noble truths, the eightfold path, refuge and precepts · 48 min

The opening talk set out the frame for the whole retreat: bodhicitta as the beginning and end of the path, and the gradual path of the four noble truths and the eightfold path in between. It ended with refuge, precepts and the instruction to keep practice continuous.

Talk

  • 0:00:33Settling in: gratitude for the conditions that brought everyone here; setting down worries for the week.
  • 0:04:47The Pali homage.
  • 0:06:20Bodhicitta: relative (the aspiration to awaken for all beings) and ultimate (the empty, wakeful nature of mind).
  • 0:10:40Jamgön Kongtrul on naked awareness. If it isn't recognized directly, the gradual path gives a stable base.
  • 0:12:24The four noble truths, starting with dukkha: the predicament of a subject in a world of objects.
  • 0:15:59The eightfold path, factor by factor (SN 45:8, MN 117). Renunciation as radical honesty about what helps practice.
  • 0:21:39Right speech includes internal speech and the internet.
  • 0:25:52Right effort as relaxed diligence: continuity matters more than willful striving; not too tight, not too loose.
  • 0:29:07Right mindfulness, with the body and breath as the anchor (MN 10).
  • 0:32:03Right concentration is defined as the four jhanas. Notes on the current jhana boom.
  • 0:33:59The three refuges, outer and inner.
  • 0:36:16The five and eight precepts (AN 8:39, AN 3:71), including what the adornment and entertainment precepts mean today.
  • 0:42:41Instruction for the week: keep mindfulness of body and breath going through every activity, not just on the cushion.

Q&A

  • 0:44:47Will the schedule be posted? Yes, and it will be updated for those online.
  • 0:46:48Can we ask questions on a silent retreat? Yes, at the end of talks and possibly in the middle.

Listen and read the full transcript →

Saturday, November 7 · Morning

Mindfulness immersed in the body: breath and metta, the five hindrances; guided whole-body breathing · 1 hr 24 min

The first morning introduced the two main techniques for the retreat, breath and metta, and the five hindrances that get in the way. It closed with a guided body scan and whole-body breathing.

Talk

  • 0:00:00Breath and metta as the two main routes to jhana (MN 10, MN 119).
  • 0:01:49The Satipatthana opening. Keep mindfulness going in the shower, at meals and on walks.
  • 0:06:15Mindfulness of breathing (MN 118), with a short guided sit.
  • 0:12:04Two ways to work with the breath: the whole body, or the entrance to the nostrils.
  • 0:14:19The basic loop: notice the drift, release it, return, with an appreciative attitude.
  • 0:17:14Metta (AN 8:63): phrases and images as scaffolding, dropped once the felt sense holds on its own.
  • 0:28:22The five hindrances in practice (DN 2). They're habits, worn away by not feeding them (SN 46:51).
  • 0:36:49The DN 2 similes for freedom from the hindrances, and the chain from gladness to concentration.
  • 0:40:00A whole retreat spent deepening access concentration would still be well spent.

Q&A

  • 0:26:46Do you stay with the breath during metta? No, metta is the object then. Switching is fine, but test it.
  • 0:42:20What are the five hindrances again?
  • 0:44:00Aversion to the sensation at the nostrils. Come to the nostrils from an already settled place, or use another spot.
  • 0:45:22Physical pain. Get curious about its texture, or attend to the space around it (SN 36:6).
  • 0:50:49Procrastination, and anxiety about loose ends at home.
  • 0:53:25Spasms and involuntary jerks.
  • 0:54:50Does a narrow object give stronger concentration than a broad one?
  • 0:57:03Will the guided practice be on Zoom? Yes.
  • 0:58:53If you're exhausted, take a nap rather than slog.

Guided practice

  • 1:01:11Body scan, then whole-body breathing. Closing notes on the lute simile (AN 6:55) and walking with the gaze downcast.

Listen and read the full transcript →

Saturday, November 7 · Evening

Five recollections, access concentration and the first jhana; guided metta · 1 hr 40 min

This talk covered access concentration and the first jhana, dipping into the second. The long Q&A was mostly about piti: how to ride it, calm it and keep it from becoming a goal. It ended with a guided metta practice.

Talk

  • 0:00:00The five recollections (AN 5:57).
  • 0:09:36Access concentration. The term is commentarial; its far end can be deeper than what many call jhana. Signs to look for.
  • 0:13:20The signs of piti: electric, fizzing, sometimes heat and shaking.
  • 0:14:54Riding a pleasant sensation up into piti, and piti up into the first jhana.
  • 0:16:20The first jhana and the bathman simile (DN 2).
  • 0:19:07Leigh Brasington's approach (build strong access first) versus Rob Burbea's (stay with piti as soon as it appears).
  • 0:21:47Right effort and striving, without the hype.
  • 0:23:38Shifting from the buzz of piti to the warmth of sukha: dipping into the second jhana.
  • 0:25:31The jhana factors (MN 43).
  • 0:28:34Appreciative attention: attend to the breath as you would to the eyes of someone you love.

Q&A

  • 0:30:40Between formal sits, keep the nostril object or broaden to the body?
  • 0:33:43When savoring piti, the sense of the body gets less clear.
  • 0:36:26Piti alongside sleepiness: sloth and torpor can coexist with piti.
  • 0:36:26Bouncing between the breath and pain. Moving piti into the pain.
  • 0:39:23Leigh's method versus Rob's when piti is present.
  • 0:43:35Shades of metta: learning what metta is over hours of practice.
  • 0:46:40Heat, sweating and jolts. Calming excess piti with a long out-breath, moving attention down the body, or a foreground–background switch.
  • 0:51:29Working with expectation after early piti.
  • 0:54:26The "quick and dirty" route to access concentration, demonstrated on the tip of a finger.
  • 0:59:48Eyes open: keep a relaxed, unfocused gaze.
  • 0:59:48Pain as an object, and the old Vietnamese monk who found that pain isn't solid.
  • 1:04:00Fear and vertigo in deep access. Reassure yourself and bring in metta (MN 128).

Closing

  • 1:10:19The Bhaddekaratta verses (MN 131) and the Metta Sutta, then guided metta, sending and receiving.

Listen and read the full transcript →

Sunday, November 8 · Morning

The first four jhanas in context: lineages, the Anapanasati tetrads, transitions and similes; Q&A · 1 hr 49 min

This talk put the first four jhanas in context: the competing lineages, jhana inside breath and metta practice, and how to move from one jhana to the next. The Q&A was the longest yet and ranged from saliva to self-doubt.

Talk

  • 0:00:00Jhana lineages: Leigh Brasington and Ayya Khema's lighter jhanas; Pa Auk and the Visuddhimagga's deep absorptions (0:01).
  • 0:03:29What's realistic on a retreat of this length.
  • 0:04:59The jhana factors inside the Anapanasati tetrads (MN 118).
  • 0:07:17Jhana through metta and the other brahmaviharas (AN 8:63).
  • 0:09:49The point isn't notches on the meditative belt. It's enjoying the fruit and turning it to insight.
  • 0:10:19Instructions: riding access into the first jhana, then marinating there.
  • 0:13:59The jacuzzi metaphor for the transitions: jets on full blast, jets off, cooling water, a float-tank cover.
  • 0:15:32Moving into the second jhana. Jhanas and the heavenly realms (AN 4:123).
  • 0:20:04The third jhana.
  • 0:21:36The fourth jhana: fathomless stillness.
  • 0:23:45The DN 2 similes for all four.

Q&A

  • 0:26:44Saliva building up in deep stillness.
  • 0:30:09Are the formless attainments what later teachers call jhanas five to eight? Yes.
  • 0:31:41When piti is too strong to be pleasant.
  • 0:33:05How to tell how much time has passed, and mastery of the second jhana.
  • 0:34:31Setting a time resolve, and a timer.
  • 0:35:36Metta through abstract qualities such as color. Jhana synesthesia is a thing.
  • 0:38:50Strong piti during the talk. Don't fear giddiness, but it can signal over-efforting (0:42).
  • 0:43:57Dropping into darkness, a state like boundless space. Is it dissociation, or skipping steps (0:46)?
  • 0:48:49Jhana through visualizing emptiness.
  • 0:52:20A participant compares the lineages. How access works in Visuddhimagga-style jhana (0:55).
  • 0:58:52Working with self-doubt: warmth and acceptance toward your conditioning, and his own childhood phobias.
  • 1:05:25Pushing anxious thoughts away versus sliding into dullness.
  • 1:10:48Napping to relax into practice.
  • 1:12:34Posture and tension: where to rest the hands, and permission for imperfect posture.
  • 1:18:37Holding difficult emotion alongside the object. The Korinji story.
  • 1:25:05Emotional numbness, especially with metta, for the heady, conceptual type.
  • 1:28:01Where in the body jhana should sit. Aim for the whole body; let a local feeling spread.
  • 1:29:29Combining metta and breath.
  • 1:30:58Involuntary swaying and rocking. It usually settles over time.

Guided practice

  • 1:38:59A short sit at the nostrils, with the image of striking a bell and letting it ring (1:45).

Listen and read the full transcript →

Sunday, November 8 · Evening

The Snake and the two viewpoints: becoming, non-becoming and the fruits of the contemplative life; Q&A; the four brahmaviharas · 1 hr 49 min

The talk turned from concentration to what it's for: the Snake Sutta, the two wrong viewpoints of becoming and non-becoming, and the higher fruits of the contemplative life. The Q&A went deep into awakening, emptiness and the two truths. It closed with the four brahmaviharas.

Talk

  • 0:00:00The five recollections (AN 5:57).
  • 0:04:10The Snake Sutta (Sn 1:1): sloughing off the near shore and far, as a snake its old skin.
  • 0:07:24Two viewpoints (Iti 49): some hold back, delighting in becoming; some slip past, seeking non-becoming. Seeing what has come to be as it is.
  • 0:18:06The fruits of the contemplative life after the jhanas (DN 2): knowledge and vision, then the ending of the effluents (0:23).
  • 0:27:01The king's question to the contemplatives, retold: what's in it for you?

Q&A

  • 0:29:13What are the effluents (asavas)?
  • 0:34:15Should we hold off on insight and stay with jhana for now?
  • 0:34:15Relative and ultimate bodhicitta during the retreat.
  • 0:37:08Evenings on Twitter and Star Wars: how to become more disenchanted with all of it.
  • 0:44:24A compassion mantra (Om mani padme hum) as the object.
  • 0:47:12Is this Pali Canon awakening, and how does it compare with other schools?
  • 0:52:02The non-duality of samsara and nirvana. Both empty, yet the path still points one way (Iti 44).
  • 0:55:27Madhyamaka analysis: beautiful, and possibly a total waste of time.
  • 0:58:53Does non-becoming mean more than permanent death?
  • 1:04:03The recollections speak of persons and death, yet the awakened have no birth or death. The two truths (AN 2:25).
  • 1:07:43When metta feels slippery and nothing seems to be happening.
  • 1:11:29Pain and hunger as signals, versus craving and aversion.
  • 1:16:34Insight versus concentration at this stage.
  • 1:17:57"Leigh" is Leigh Brasington, not Ajahn Lee. The shaken-up bottle method (1:19).
  • 1:20:25Working with the fear of death. Charnel grounds, and the body as one (MN 10).

Closing

  • 1:26:22The four brahmaviharas, chanted and guided.

Listen and read the full transcript →

Monday, November 9 · Morning

Feeding and starving the hindrances; Q&A; guided whole-body breathing · 59 min

A practical talk on what feeds each hindrance and what starves it. The Q&A was mostly about desire, regret and the breath. It closed with a guided body scan and whole-body breathing.

Talk

  • 0:00:00More detail on the hindrances, and how they sound in your head: "Maybe there's something wrong with that guy at the front."
  • 0:03:44Feeding and starving the hindrances (SN 46:51).
  • 0:03:44Sensual desire is fed by attention to beauty and starved by its opposite, such as the parts of the body (MN 10).
  • 0:06:59Ill will is fed by irritation and starved by goodwill and compassion. Noises, earplugs, coughing and sneezing.
  • 0:14:17Restlessness and anxiety are fed by non-stillness and starved by stillness.
  • 0:17:15Uncertainty is fed and starved the same way.

Q&A

  • 0:18:53Regret over unskillful living, when you can't go back and undo it (0:21).
  • 0:22:43How to tell sensual desire from the rapture of jhana (MN 66).
  • 0:24:33Lustful imaginings during practice. Can that energy move into piti (0:28)?
  • 0:29:36Noticing the phases of the breath, versus just sensation.
  • 0:31:53In whole-body breathing, should the breath or the body be in the foreground?
  • 0:33:43Lights and images in the closed-eye visual field, with the breath or a mantra.
  • 0:35:02A participant's share on holding frustration: "double dukkha" (SN 36:6).

Guided practice

  • 0:39:34Body scan, then whole-body breathing, closing in metta (0:56).

Listen and read the full transcript →

Monday, November 9 · Evening

The Rod Embraced; Q&A on awakening, stream entry and kensho, jhana and ethics, karma and purification · 56 min

A short reading from "The Rod Embraced" opened onto a long Q&A about awakening: how it's mapped, what stream entry is, and how jhana relates to ethics and karma.

Talk

  • 0:00:00The five recollections (AN 5:57).
  • 0:03:20Day three: the first days of a retreat are often a kind of clearing.
  • 0:05:26"The Rod Embraced" (Sn 4:15): the Buddha's terror at people floundering like fish in small puddles.
  • 0:10:43"I call greed a great flood." Burning up what's before and having nothing for after (0:12).
  • 0:14:04"For one unperturbed, who knows, there's no accumulating." Taking inspiration from this for the rest of our lives.

Q&A

  • 0:16:19How do you define awakening? Different lineages map it differently. The ten fetters and the four paths (0:19, AN 3:88).
  • 0:21:28Kensho, seeing the nature of mind, compared with stream entry.
  • 0:23:10What "stream" refers to in stream entry (SN 56:11). Different routes to it (0:24).
  • 0:26:11Jhana and ethics. Some misconduct makes jhana hard to reach (0:28).
  • 0:29:44Marinating in one jhana versus climbing the ladder.
  • 0:33:23If you're on the path to awakening, why engage the world or help others?
  • 0:36:48What karma is, and whether jhana purifies it (AN 6:63). Neural annealing (0:38).
  • 0:42:59How much practice it takes: retreat versus daily life.
  • 0:45:04Rob Burbea's model of awakening and soulmaking. Is there a single endpoint (0:49)?
  • 0:51:06When the nostrils become unpleasantly sensitive.

Closing

  • 0:54:05Chanted reflections on universal well-being.

Listen and read the full transcript →

Tuesday, November 10 · Morning

The formless attainments and cessation; the Foam Sutta (SN 22:95); Q&A · 1 hr 7 min

The talk mapped the formless attainments, jhanas five to eight, and cessation, then read the Foam Sutta in full. The Q&A was mostly about effort, the slog and how long things take.

Talk

  • 0:00:00Starting from a well-consolidated fourth jhana: unspeakably still, perhaps with bright white light.
  • 0:05:00Boundless space. Nothing bad will happen; the fear passes with acclimatization (0:07).
  • 0:09:00Boundless consciousness: only a boundless mind can know boundless space (0:10). Rob Burbea on using the aftereffects for insight.
  • 0:13:16Nothingness.
  • 0:15:39Neither perception nor non-perception: like a television tuned away from all the channels.
  • 0:17:46The cessation of perception and feeling (MN 44). Hard to be fooled by the magic show once you've seen it taken apart.
  • 0:19:56The Foam Sutta (SN 22:95): form as foam, feeling a bubble, perception a mirage, fabrications a banana tree, consciousness a magic trick.
  • 0:24:48Disenchantment with the aggregates (SN 35:28).

Q&A

  • 0:27:13When piti feels clamped or held in place.
  • 0:29:56How long to sit. Three or four hours at a stretch is fine.
  • 0:31:32Strain and fatigue. Sometimes drop it, do something else and come back fresh (AN 6:55).
  • 0:32:47Is getting from the fourth jhana to the fifth a bigger hurdle than the first four? Is reaching access the hardest part?
  • 0:39:11Slogging and tantrums: a participant's technique of getting angry at the inner critic.
  • 0:41:17Playing with a wider or narrower aperture while balancing effort.
  • 0:43:56Refining the breath. Does the breath disappearing count? Shortening it a little (0:45)?
  • 0:46:45Quantifying the slog: if an hour a day for a year hasn't worked, is something off (0:48)? Building a container and a checklist (0:51).
  • 0:53:09When to adjust for hip discomfort versus fidgeting.
  • 0:55:24From the seventh jhana to the eighth: releasing clinging to nothingness (0:56).
  • 0:57:34Lying down for hypnagogic relaxation, and conceptual elaboration (0:59). How long does it take (1:01)?
  • 1:02:10Open-eye practice and the formless states.

Listen and read the full transcript →

Tuesday, November 10 · Evening

Quarrels and Disputes (Sn 4:11); Q&A on cessation, sukha, perception and consciousness, open-eye practice, dreams · 59 min

A short reading of "Quarrels and Disputes" traced conflict back to contact and name-and-form. Most of the session was Q&A on cessation, the terms for mind, open-eye practice and sleep.

Talk

  • 0:00:34The five recollections: how will we use our time?
  • 0:02:55"Quarrels and Disputes" (Sn 4:11): disputes come from what is dear, desire, contact, and name-and-form (0:05).
  • 0:07:03When form disappears, contacts don't touch.
  • 0:08:49Some of the wise say this is the utmost purity. The sage ponders dependencies and doesn't dispute (0:09).

Q&A

  • 0:11:08Is cessation like getting whacked? Zen stories of teachers striking students, and Hakuin (0:14).
  • 0:16:19What you remember from deep jhana versus cessation.
  • 0:16:19Sukha feels dull next to piti. It comes in grades too (0:18).
  • 0:18:16Grounding the terms: perception, consciousness, name-and-form (MN 43).
  • 0:22:23Consciousness is also dependent, and empty, not a resting place.
  • 0:25:34The breath shifting and speeding up in the first jhana. "Have I been poisoned?" (0:27).
  • 0:28:52Modulating effort: high effort brings piti but tires you out.
  • 0:30:36Are there thoughts in access concentration? Echoes are fine.
  • 0:30:36Open-eye jhana with a visual object, such as a webcam light: how to hold the gaze (0:33, 0:34).
  • 0:36:21Pain, dullness and wandering.
  • 0:42:06Simplicity has its virtues. Which technique is best (0:43)?
  • 0:43:53Restless dreams, and practicing as you fall asleep (0:47).
  • 0:50:24How to orient to piti after a mind-blowing experience.
  • 0:55:36Without much body sensation, how can you tell the mind is unifying?
  • 0:57:07Staying with the object while eating.

Listen and read the full transcript →

Wednesday, November 11 · Morning

Four modes of practice, four ways to arahantship, defilements of concentration (MN 128) and the thorns (AN 10:72); Q&A · 52 min

No new instructions this morning. Instead, four short texts gave a more nuanced map of how practice unfolds and what disturbs concentration. The Q&A was mostly about excitement and piti.

Talk

  • 0:00:00The four modes of practice (AN 4:162): painful or pleasant, with slow or quick intuition. There's no fifth category where it doesn't work (0:02).
  • 0:06:45His own path: for a while, practice was the only relief from intense aversion.
  • 0:07:15Four ways to arahantship (AN 4:170): insight preceded by tranquility, tranquility preceded by insight, the two in tandem, and restlessness about the Dhamma brought under control.
  • 0:09:58The defilements of concentration (MN 128): Anuruddha's lights and forms, and what made them fall away, including excitement (0:13).
  • 0:17:40The thorns (AN 10:72): noise is a thorn to the first jhana. Earplugs help (0:20).
  • 0:22:15Perception and feeling are a thorn to cessation.

Q&A

  • 0:24:05How to define passion, aversion and delusion, with examples.
  • 0:28:17A new hindrance: deep joy and gratitude, "as if someone gave me MDMA."
  • 0:32:48Piti that resonates with every sound and sensation.
  • 0:34:11How to be less excited when piti arises.
  • 0:36:51The five grades of piti (Visuddhimagga IV.94–99).
  • 0:41:46Slow walking can sustain concentration better than sitting. If so, walk more (0:44).
  • 0:45:37Experiences like LSD. Are they still within the possible kind of weird (0:46)?
  • 0:48:22Why not follow the breath inside from the nostrils?

Listen and read the full transcript →

Wednesday, November 11 · Evening

Exertion (Sn 3:2), Before the Break-up (Sn 4:10) and The Cow (AN 9:35); Q&A on siddhis, purification, teachers and koan practice; Hakuin’s soft-butter method · 1 hr 20 min

Three readings on resolve, peace and consolidating each stage before the next. The Q&A covered siddhis, purification, his teachers and a long thread on koan practice. It closed with Hakuin's soft-butter method, guided.

Talk

  • 0:00:00The five recollections. Final, capping instructions over the next two days.
  • 0:02:10Exertion (Sn 3:2): Mara's "Live, good sir!" (0:04), the Bodhisatta's resolve (0:05) and "Do I carry munja grass?" (0:06).
  • 0:08:10Mara gives up, like a crow pecking a stone that looked like fat.
  • 0:10:16Before the Break-up (Sn 4:10): the one at peace is secluded from the hindrances even amid sense contact (0:11). "No swellings of pride are his" (0:13).
  • 0:16:31The Cow (AN 9:35): the foolish mountain cow and the wise one, moving through the jhanas step by step (0:17), then the higher knowledges (0:20).
  • 0:23:03Only lift your hind leg when your foreleg is firmly placed.

Q&A

  • 0:24:36Advanced access: going back to the breath when it feels nicer.
  • 0:25:49The siddhis in the suttas. Are they real possibilities? No consensus experience of them (0:28).
  • 0:28:36Physical purification in intense practice. Not a boot camp: rest, eat more fatty food (0:31). His own experience with tummo (0:32).
  • 0:34:40Something like sleep paralysis after jhana.
  • 0:36:09Ping-ponging between sukha and piti. His teachers, Theravada and Zen (0:38–0:41).
  • 0:43:03It's the same practice all the way through. Is there any benefit to koans on top of Theravada?
  • 0:44:27Awakening without mastery of jhana, in the suttas and in modern Theravada (0:45).
  • 0:47:28Smiling as part of your posture. He's pro-smiling.
  • 0:49:04His experience with the koan Mu (Gateless Gate).
  • 0:54:28Could you answer it for us now? Each answer is different; the teacher judges where it comes from.
  • 0:54:28The Mahayana ideal. Why doesn't this retreat have a Mahayana flavor? "Not yet" (0:56).
  • 0:58:14What has to be realized to pass a koan? Is it stream entry, or a gold star?
  • 1:00:29Is there an end to koan practice? For Buddhahood, the final koan is "not yet."

Guided practice

  • 1:04:36Hakuin's soft-butter method: a ball of warm ghee at the crown, melting down through the body.

Listen and read the full transcript →

Thursday, November 12 · Morning

Insight: the three characteristics (AN 3:137), insight from jhana (AN 9:36), Ud 8:4; Q&A; guided insight into impermanence · 1 hr 38 min

The turn to insight: the three characteristics, how to work with them from within jhana and what can go wrong. A long, practical Q&A followed, then a guided session from access into insight into impermanence.

Talk

  • 0:00:38Insight practice within the early teachings.
  • 0:00:38The three characteristics (AN 3:137): "this property stands" whether or not Tathagatas arise (0:02).
  • 0:05:57See them in experience, not as doctrine or more labels.
  • 0:05:57Insight from jhana (AN 9:36): the ending of the effluents depends on each jhana (0:07).
  • 0:08:48Can you do insight without jhana? It depends on depth of concentration.
  • 0:10:24Many bad outcomes of insight practice come from too little concentration.
  • 0:12:23Splitting a session between concentration and insight. Seeing piti, sukha and thought rise and fall (0:12–0:13).
  • 0:15:33On the brink of letting go, the mind can recoil.
  • 0:17:23Like a tensed fist, even rapturous absorption holds subtle stress. Appropriating a formless self (0:19, MN 102).
  • 0:20:55Look for the knower: back here, up here, around?
  • 0:22:30Turning away and inclining the mind to the deathless (AN 9:36). Short of full awakening, you get partway (0:23).
  • 0:25:20Why the formless attainments are treated differently.

Q&A

  • 0:27:51How to do insight on a clenching in the stomach: close observation, not concepts (0:29). The clenched-fist exercise (0:31).
  • 0:32:19Does attention itself create the change you observe?
  • 0:33:51Stay local, or follow when a new sensation pops up?
  • 0:36:37Impermanence in the visual field and the other senses.
  • 0:36:37When to start insight, and what problems can come up (0:38). Lights, distortions and visions (0:40).
  • 0:42:59Boundless space feels like a solid wall. Is it really unchanging?
  • 0:44:12When no object seems to go anywhere. No need to make it harder than it is (0:46).
  • 0:48:17Letting go as the way into the first and second jhanas.
  • 0:49:26Will focusing on emptiness weaken the seventh jhana later? "Emptiness" is a slippery word (0:50).
  • 0:51:41A report of jhana in a dream. Practice before sleep may carry over (0:54).
  • 0:54:38Can insight practice be done outside jhana?
  • 0:55:53What "inclining the mind" means.
  • 0:57:35What to know about intention.
  • 0:59:03Not-self is frightening to think about.
  • 0:59:40Insight feels conceptual. Impermanence is not subtle (1:01); not-self isn't finding a special self (1:02).
  • 1:03:53Training a way of seeing, like a muscle (1:04).
  • 1:06:31After awakening: is there still some reified experience? Fluctuation and breakpoints. Eventually you can't not see the characteristics (1:07).
  • 1:08:07Ud 8:4: "There being no yearning, there is no coming or going" (1:09).

Guided practice

  • 1:10:46Access and the first jhana, then impermanence in the hands and body (1:24), thoughts and attention (1:30), sound and sight (1:31–1:33), and letting go (1:35).

Listen and read the full transcript →

Thursday, November 12 · Evening

Surveying the World (Ud 3:10), Kevaddha’s question (DN 11) and the unfabricated (SN 43); Q&A on sila, bodhicitta, meaning and beauty · 1 hr 1 min

Three readings on what lies beyond the world and its elements. The Q&A was some of the most searching of the retreat: what's good about the path, bodhicitta, meaning, beauty and suffering.

Talk

  • 0:00:00The five recollections. Actions have consequences: we are what we do (0:02).
  • 0:03:55Surveying the World (Ud 3:10): seven days at the Bodhi tree. "Where there's delight, there is fear" (0:05).
  • 0:06:31Kevaddha's question (DN 11): the monk asks the gods, up to Brahma (0:11), where the four elements cease. The shore-sighting bird (0:13).
  • 0:13:18The answer: "Consciousness without surface" (0:14, MN 49).
  • 0:14:24Epithets of the unfabricated (SN 43): the unbent, the effluent-free, the true, the beyond (0:16).

Q&A

  • 0:20:51Sila: what is good about the path?
  • 0:23:06What bodhicitta is, how it's cultivated and how it relates to the hindrances. Ultimate bodhicitta (0:25).
  • 0:27:18The path is interwoven with the three poisons. It's fabricated and deals in conventions (0:28, Sn 1:1, MN 22).
  • 0:30:12What "not yet" means.
  • 0:32:28What is the point? Samvega, and what actually fulfills us (0:34).
  • 0:36:34Care and compassion come as you become freer (Blue Cliff Record case 89). Meaning is emergent (0:38).
  • 0:40:17Something feels radically incomplete: was Beethoven creating out of suffering and ignorance? Beauty and the sublime (0:42).
  • 0:44:49Finding redemption for suffering in a larger scheme often looks like cope.
  • 0:49:52Finding pain almost aesthetically pleasing. Views of suffering can be skillful, given time, place and condition (0:51–0:53).
  • 0:55:29A more tantric view: working with energy and transformation (0:56).
  • 0:56:42Balancing your own path with helping others. Put your own oxygen mask on first (0:58).

Closing

  • 1:00:15Your own wish for freedom, followed through, reaches out to others: conventional and ultimate bodhicitta.

Listen and read the full transcript →

Friday, November 13 · Morning

Renunciation, transformation, recognition; Bahiya (Ud 1:10) and Tilopa’s Ganges Mahamudra; nature of mind; Q&A · 1 hr 7 min

Three kinds of path, renunciation, transformation and recognition, served as a bridge from the early texts to Mahamudra and Dzogchen. Bahiya's teaching and Tilopa's song led into an eyes-open pointing-out exercise.

Talk

  • 0:00:00Three kinds of path: renunciation, transformation and recognition. Outer and inner renunciation (0:01).
  • 0:03:14Paths of recognition, typified by Zen and Dzogchen. His regard for the early Dharma (0:05).
  • 0:06:38Bahiya (Ud 1:10): the deva's prompt, and the urgent request on the alms round (0:09–0:10).
  • 0:11:08"In reference to the seen, only the seen." Bahiya's awakening and death (0:12–0:13).
  • 0:14:35A bridge to the later traditions: Naropa meets Tilopa by the river (0:16).
  • 0:18:13Tilopa's Ganges Mahamudra: mind without a focal point (0:19), and non-meditation (0:21).
  • 0:23:09Studying this won't bring you an inch closer.
  • 0:24:23The torrent, the Ganges and the sea. For those of lesser ability, the winds and a consort (0:25), and the tantric "carrots" (0:26).
  • 0:28:27With recognition, the defilements transform into the five wisdoms.
  • 0:29:16His advice: persist in gradual practice. Mipham on gaining stability (0:30–0:31).
  • 0:33:31Eyes-open exercise: is there a boundary between inside and outside (0:34)? Your mind is already empty and awake (0:36).
  • 0:38:05"Just this" is what's meant by Buddha, and by bodhicitta.

Q&A

  • 0:39:05The subject–object split persists. Open awareness before recognition, and Longchenpa on ordinary mind versus awareness (0:41–0:43).
  • 0:47:04Looking for the looker feels like derealization; samadhi feels more real.
  • 0:50:46From the second jhana to the third: letting go of the remnants of agitation (0:53).
  • 0:53:15How body and space change from the second to the third. Does the body disappearing mean stronger concentration (0:55)?
  • 0:55:44Is there a place here for ritual, offering and ceremony? Are they necessary (0:58), and where can you learn more (0:59)?
  • 0:59:46What that object is: a vajra, and what it symbolizes (1:01).
  • 1:01:51How the jhanas relate to enlightenment, and the "ninth jhana" (SN 38:1, SN 43).

Listen and read the full transcript →

Friday, November 13 · Evening

Shido Bunan’s old man and Hakuin’s Song of Zazen; Q&A on impermanence, Nagarjuna, practice after retreat, Zen and jhana, Dzogchen, vitakka and vicara · 1 hr 10 min

Two short Zen readings opened the penultimate evening. The long Q&A ranged from Nagarjuna and Dzogchen to practical advice for keeping practice going after the retreat.

Talk

  • 0:00:00The penultimate night: thoughts turn to home. The five recollections.
  • 0:04:37Shido Bunan's old man, reciting the nembutsu. What is at the origin of mind? "Nothing" (0:06–0:07).
  • 0:08:42"If one has no self, one is the Buddha."
  • 0:10:24Hakuin's Song of Zazen: "All beings by nature are Buddha, as ice by nature is water."

Q&A

  • 0:13:11Why impermanence matters, and seeing it at subtler levels (0:14).
  • 0:16:15Is awareness always at objects?
  • 0:17:56"If one has no self, one is the Buddha": do you believe it?
  • 0:19:44The Song of Zazen as poetry that opens something. Conventional designations (DN 9).
  • 0:21:18Not hardening the three characteristics into new views (SN 22:122). Nagarjuna's dedicatory verse (0:23).
  • 0:25:33How to get into deeper absorption.
  • 0:30:07"Fifteen minutes on the object" doesn't mean fifteen minutes without thoughts (0:31).
  • 0:32:01After the retreat: how much to sit to keep the momentum.
  • 0:34:15Can insight help you into samadhi?
  • 0:36:06How to "look for the observer." Is there an origin point to attention (0:37)?
  • 0:39:28Is there anything jhana-like in Zen? Is it frowned upon (0:40)?
  • 0:42:34Open-eye practice: start in access, or with eyes open? Tilopa's six nails (0:44).
  • 0:44:34Samsara has no discernible beginning (SN 15:3). Dzogchen's origin myth of Samantabhadra (0:46–0:47).
  • 0:49:09Recognition versus stability: consolidating blips into longer stretches.
  • 0:52:20What it means to exhaust one's karma.
  • 0:54:06Is trekchö a preliminary before recognition? No.
  • 0:55:14How concentration practice carries over into the rest of the day (0:56).
  • 0:58:16An online question about thinking playfully, with space as the object.
  • 1:02:47Getting dull and trancey. A standing practice; you can enter the four jhanas standing (1:04).
  • 1:04:43An online follow-up. Vitakka, vicara and ekaggata: earlier and later meanings (1:06, MN 44).
  • 1:09:23To let piti expand, feel it rather than think about it.

Listen and read the full transcript →

Saturday, November 14 · Evening

The Noble Search and the Buddha’s first encounters; coming off retreat and keeping practice going; Kappa’s question; Q&A on mixing methods, 5-MeO, trauma and retreat centers; closing blessings · 58 min

The closing talk told the story of the Buddha's search and his first encounters after awakening, then turned to keeping practice going at home. The last Q&A covered methods, psychedelics, trauma and retreat culture. It ended with traditional blessings.

Talk

  • 0:00:00The five recollections for the last time, and the Zen evening verse.
  • 0:05:16The Noble Search (MN 26): seeking the unexcelled, and awakening (0:07).
  • 0:08:27Hesitating to teach a Dhamma that goes against the flow. Brahma Sahampati's plea (0:09) and the lotuses in the pond (0:10).
  • 0:11:34His former teachers, Alara Kalama and Uddaka Ramaputta, have died. The meeting with Upaka (0:12–0:14).
  • 0:16:39Coming off retreat: momentum, good friends, and reaching out if there's trouble (0:18).
  • 0:18:06Two hours of formal practice a day if you can, plus continuous mindfulness (0:19). Practice whenever it occurs to you (0:21).
  • 0:21:45Kappa's question (Sn 5:10): "Having nothing, free of clinging: that is the island" (0:23).

Q&A

  • 0:23:50Mixing and matching methods. "This practice is enough" (0:26).
  • 0:26:02Feeling the breath at different spots in the nostrils. Shaila Catherine's point just above the skin (0:28).
  • 0:30:12Using 5-MeO after the retreat. His write-up from the QRI retreat on 5-MeO and jhana (0:31).
  • 0:33:30Can anyone get far down the path?
  • 0:35:14Practice and trauma (Treleaven). The window of tolerance (0:38).
  • 0:38:35The illiterate sweeping monk, Cula Panthaka, and the student given curse words as a mantra (0:40).
  • 0:42:14A participant's share from the bench on the mesa. A Kagyu lama's platter of shit (0:43).
  • 0:43:58Red flags in retreat centers. The four-day retreat where everyone was enlightened (0:46).
  • 0:48:45Doing jhana practice covertly at Goenka centers.
  • 0:48:45How not to cling to jhana. Wanting progress is fine (0:51).
  • 0:53:14Piti arising on its own while just hanging out: a fruit of practice (MN 36, 0:54).

Closing

  • 0:55:52Traditional anumodana blessings, then a break and the final sit.

Listen and read the full transcript →