Jhana & Awakening Retreat 2026 · Session 12 of 16

Thursday, November 12 · Morning

Insight: the three characteristics (AN 3:137), insight from jhana (AN 9:36), Ud 8:4; Q&A; guided insight into impermanence

Recorded November 12, 2026, 10:00 am Mountain Time · Nameless Mountain, Boulder, Colorado · 1 hr 38 min

The turn to insight: the three characteristics, how to work with them from within jhana and what can go wrong. A long, practical Q&A followed, then a guided session from access into insight into impermanence.

Topics and questions in this session

Talk

  • 0:00:38Insight practice within the early teachings.
  • 0:00:38The three characteristics (AN 3:137): "this property stands" whether or not Tathagatas arise (0:02).
  • 0:05:57See them in experience, not as doctrine or more labels.
  • 0:05:57Insight from jhana (AN 9:36): the ending of the effluents depends on each jhana (0:07).
  • 0:08:48Can you do insight without jhana? It depends on depth of concentration.
  • 0:10:24Many bad outcomes of insight practice come from too little concentration.
  • 0:12:23Splitting a session between concentration and insight. Seeing piti, sukha and thought rise and fall (0:12–0:13).
  • 0:15:33On the brink of letting go, the mind can recoil.
  • 0:17:23Like a tensed fist, even rapturous absorption holds subtle stress. Appropriating a formless self (0:19, MN 102).
  • 0:20:55Look for the knower: back here, up here, around?
  • 0:22:30Turning away and inclining the mind to the deathless (AN 9:36). Short of full awakening, you get partway (0:23).
  • 0:25:20Why the formless attainments are treated differently.

Q&A

  • 0:27:51How to do insight on a clenching in the stomach: close observation, not concepts (0:29). The clenched-fist exercise (0:31).
  • 0:32:19Does attention itself create the change you observe?
  • 0:33:51Stay local, or follow when a new sensation pops up?
  • 0:36:37Impermanence in the visual field and the other senses.
  • 0:36:37When to start insight, and what problems can come up (0:38). Lights, distortions and visions (0:40).
  • 0:42:59Boundless space feels like a solid wall. Is it really unchanging?
  • 0:44:12When no object seems to go anywhere. No need to make it harder than it is (0:46).
  • 0:48:17Letting go as the way into the first and second jhanas.
  • 0:49:26Will focusing on emptiness weaken the seventh jhana later? "Emptiness" is a slippery word (0:50).
  • 0:51:41A report of jhana in a dream. Practice before sleep may carry over (0:54).
  • 0:54:38Can insight practice be done outside jhana?
  • 0:55:53What "inclining the mind" means.
  • 0:57:35What to know about intention.
  • 0:59:03Not-self is frightening to think about.
  • 0:59:40Insight feels conceptual. Impermanence is not subtle (1:01); not-self isn't finding a special self (1:02).
  • 1:03:53Training a way of seeing, like a muscle (1:04).
  • 1:06:31After awakening: is there still some reified experience? Fluctuation and breakpoints. Eventually you can't not see the characteristics (1:07).
  • 1:08:07Ud 8:4: "There being no yearning, there is no coming or going" (1:09).

Guided practice

  • 1:10:46Access and the first jhana, then impermanence in the hands and body (1:24), thoughts and attention (1:30), sound and sight (1:31–1:33), and letting go (1:35).
Thursday, November 12 · Morning

Edited transcript. The time at the start of each paragraph is where it begins in the recording above; drag the player to that point to listen. Participants' names are omitted. [Square brackets] mark editorial insertions; [unclear] marks words that couldn't be made out.

0:00:00That worked. Namo tassa bhagavato arahato sammā-sambuddhassa.

0:00:38Okay. Today I'm going to talk about vipassana, insight and insight practice, still largely within the early Buddhist frame, so if it seems a little grim or harsh, it's serving a purpose: encouraging detachment. Everyone's favorite topic is where we'll start: the three characteristics, impermanence, dis-ease or dissatisfaction, and not-self. This is "The Orderliness of the Dhamma": "I have heard that on one occasion the Blessed One was staying near Savatthi in Jeta's Grove, Anathapindika's monastery. There he addressed the monks, saying, 'Monks.' 'Yes, lord,' the monks responded to him. The Blessed One said, 'Whether or not there is the arising of Tathagatas...'" (an epithet of the Buddha, or of those who have that realization: the ones thus gone) "'...this property stands, this steadfastness of the Dhamma, this orderliness of the Dhamma: all fabrications are inconstant'" (impermanent). "'The Tathagata directly awakens to that, breaks through to that. Directly awakening and breaking through to that, he declares it, teaches it, describes it, sets it forth. He reveals it, explains it, makes it plain: all fabrications are inconstant.1

0:02:07"'Whether or not there is the arising of Tathagatas, this property stands, this steadfastness of the Dhamma, this orderliness of the Dhamma: all fabrications are stressful'" (all fabrications are dukkha). "'The Tathagata directly awakens to that, breaks through to that. Directly awakening and breaking through to that, he declares it, teaches it, describes it, sets it forth. He reveals it, explains it, makes it plain: all fabrications are stressful. Whether or not there is the arising of Tathagatas, this property stands, this steadfastness of the Dhamma, this orderliness of the Dhamma: all phenomena are not-self. The Tathagata directly awakens to that, breaks through to that. Directly awakening and breaking through to that, he declares it, teaches it, describes it, sets it forth. He reveals it, explains it, makes it plain: all phenomena are not-self.' That is what the Blessed One said. Gratified, the monks delighted at his words." So what are fabrications? Form, feeling, perceptions, mental formations, awareness of these things in terms of substance, subject and object, self and other: designating all the aggregates, which we'll get to in the next bit (form, feeling, perception, mental formations and consciousness). These are all compounded; these are all fabrications. They're put together, they're made up, and because they're made up, because they're put together, they inevitably break apart.

0:03:40Eventually there's a kind of stress in maintaining them, and if we're attached to them in any way whatsoever, we'll lament, we'll grieve, we'll suffer pain and distress when they break. And if we cling to any of them as self ("This form, this body, this is me, this is mine; these clothes, this house, this world, this political party, this ideology")... Any form, internal or external: inconstant, stressful, not self or what belongs to self. Any feeling, pleasant, unpleasant or neutral: arising and passing away, not me, not mine, fabricated, put together, bound. And perception, my labeling and designating this as opposed to that: conditional, dependent, put together. All my mental fabrications, my intentions, my ideas, my more variegated emotions, all my mental fabrication: likewise impermanent, inconstant, stressful, not me, not mine. And even my awareness, even my consciousness, the knowing of these things, is not personal, is not me. Anything at all, awareness or attention, small or vast, with no objects: all of that is bound, made up, compounded, stressful, impermanent. So how does one actually realize this, and what's the point?

0:05:57If you see these things not as a matter of doctrine, and not as a matter of slapping more labels on your experience, but through direct perception, through practice; if you see these things clearly, your mind will naturally unbind. It will naturally let go, and you will open to a freedom that goes beyond impermanence and change, that goes beyond self, that is not stressful, that is not compounded, not subject to arising and passing away in the way all fabrications are, but that is only revealed when the mind stops clinging. So, connecting this to what we've been working on and talking about so far: how does one take the concentration developed through jhana and turn it to this kind of seeing, which allows letting go, the release of clinging? This is the Jhana Sutta: "I tell you, the ending of the effluents" (becoming, sensuality, ignorance) "depends on the first jhana... the second jhana... the third... the fourth... the dimension of the infinitude of space... the infinitude of consciousness... the dimension of nothingness.2

0:07:30"I tell you, the ending of the effluents depends on the dimension of neither perception nor non-perception. 'I tell you, the ending of the effluents depends on the first jhana': thus it has been said. In reference to what was it said? There is the case where a monk, quite secluded from sensuality, secluded from unskillful qualities, enters and remains in the first jhana: rapture and pleasure born in seclusion, accompanied by directed thought and evaluation. He regards whatever phenomena there that are connected with form, feeling, perception, fabrications and consciousness as inconstant, stressful, a disease, a cancer, an arrow, painful, an affliction, alien, a disintegration, an emptiness, not-self." So even within a rapturous, blissful state... A practical point here: you may be so absorbed that you can't in fact engage in analysis. If that's the case, you may need to become slightly less absorbed to begin your insight practice, in which case, do that. But there's also a lot of sectarian bickering about this: "Okay, does one do insight only coming out of jhana? Are these unconnected?"

0:08:48From experience, it just depends on the depth of absorption. Yes, you can't do insight practice if you're so fused in the absorption that the mind can't analyze and begin to reflect on experience in these ways. So you just become slightly less absorbed. You don't have to leave the state; you can still be at some depth of any of the jhanas and begin insight practice from there, without departing. The jhana and its factors may break up when you begin the insight practice, but there's no need to leave. And with the mind thus made malleable, pliant, attained to imperturbability, immersed in rapture and pleasure, your mind has already let go of quite a lot to get to that point: the five hindrances, and a lot of the usual structuring of self is already quite attenuated in a good first jhana. So when you then turn the mind to whatever there is (in the body, the fabrications, my awareness, my attention, my intending, my willing, whatever sensory contacts there are), with the mind immersed in rapture and pleasure, and begin to regard form, feeling, perception, fabrications and consciousness as inconstant, stressful, a disease, a cancer, an arrow, painful, an affliction, alien, a disintegration, an emptiness, not-self,

0:10:24you won't be overcome by distress. A lot of the adverse outcomes of insight practice appear to me to result from engaging those themes of contemplation with a mind that's still quite unsteady, quite wavering, not well secluded from the hindrances, still thickly caught up and stuck in the ordinary structuring of selfhood, pretty close to baseline consciousness. If that isn't softened and made malleable by deep samadhi, it's: "What do you mean, my body is impermanent and it's dissolving all the time, and I can't grasp it even for a minute, and even my thoughts and my feelings are not me? Hold on, wait, no, hold on, where's the ground? Stop the ride, I want off." Not to say there won't be any unpleasantness in insight practice even if you've really mastered jhana well, but there will likely be less. Practically speaking, impermanence is the most common of these themes to begin with and really run with. Say you're in the first jhana, and the rapture and pleasure, at whatever intensity, are running and rushing through. You've been immersed there for some time, the mind is well secluded, and it's time to turn to insight practice.

0:12:23You can divide your formal session half and half, or three quarters and one quarter; up to you. Leigh likes this metaphor, as do I. You may be familiar with the image of the bodhisattva of wisdom, who wields a flaming sword of wisdom. Developing deep samadhi is like sharpening that sword, so that with a single clean cut the afflictions, the bonds of ignorance, can be severed. Trying to cut through without deep samadhi may be like trying to cut down a redwood with a butter knife. It's not that it's impossible, but it might not happen so quickly, and your arm is going to get real tired. Why not have a chainsaw, or a lightsaber, or a flaming sword instead? So, with whatever depth of samadhi you have, turning the theme of impermanence onto the factors of the absorption, and onto whatever remnants of ordinary consciousness and sensory contact there are, is a very fruitful way to practice. Instead of tuning into and savoring and enjoying the rapture, can you discern its shimmering, rapid fluctuation in as fine detail and with as much clarity as possible?3

0:13:58Likewise with the happiness: can you discern its rising and falling away? Likewise with any residual thoughts, any sounds occurring, any bodily sensations not taken up with jhanic factors. There are maps of the progress of insight, and if you want you can look those up on your own time; I'm not going to go through them here. But there's a general progression: becoming more and more aware of arising, and then of simultaneous arising and passing away, where no sooner are phenomena arising than they're already passing away. And then the mind turns more to passing, to dissolution, and all kinds of things. As with jhana, as with the development of access concentration, you may experience all kinds of sensory distortions. There may be increases in light and bliss and the jhanic factors as you move through insight practice. You may feel space warping, your body dissolving, things fluctuating and shimmering and popping and crackling and sizzling, all kinds of things. It's not uncommon, at a threshold of deeper concentration, for fear to arise when the perception of impermanence, or of these other themes, gets quite intense.4

0:15:33On the brink of letting go more deeply, the mind can recoil. Just as with entering deeper concentration, this is partly an acclimatization issue. It might help to go back into absorption, into jhana, to stabilize the mind and have it contented and malleable. Likewise the brahmaviharas: these are protective practices that can steady the mind and make it well prepared to see and to let go. And if you see any of these three characteristics, if you really see even one of them all the way through, you'll see the other two as well. Impermanence happens to be the easiest for most folks to notice, to begin to get traction with and work with. For dukkha, stress: see if you can appreciate how any compounded sensation has a kind of pressure, a tension, a torsion in it. Even the subtlest mental motion, even the subtlest sensation of resistance, even the arising of the jhanic factors, rapture and pleasure: there's a kind of pressure, a kind of tension in consciousness that's stressful to produce and maintain. All fabrication is like this: I'm tensing my hand very hard, maintaining this. It's tense; it doesn't feel good.

0:17:23And just as with feeling into a tensed fist, even in a state of absorption that is by most standards rapturous and pleasurable, if you can notice that even this refined state of pleasure and absorption is compounded, put together, fabricated, and you feel into the distress of that, the mind can develop disenchantment and dispassion, and relax, release, let go. Not-self can be the trickiest of the three. It can help just to apply the lens of "not me, not mine." You can engage in some thinking to prompt and frame it, and (with any of the characteristics as well) you can move through any of the five aggregates, or through the six senses, singly or all together. Self shows up as a kind of split and a kind of tension, like dukkha, but there's a localization and appropriation of a certain aspect of experience as me, as what I am, even in the most subtle and refined states of absorption, the realm of nothingness or the realm of neither perception nor non-perception. There were apparently contemplatives at the time of the Buddha who, entering, remaining in and emerging from those states, thought, "Aha!"5

0:19:22They made a formless appropriation of a self on that basis: "Okay, that's my self, which is eternal. That's me, that's mine, and that's where all of this arises from. That's the source, that's the ground, that's what I am." So the appropriation, the grasping, the clinging, the view of me, of mine, of what I am, can be very subtle. For this (I'll speak a bit more about it tomorrow) it can also help to get really curious and turn attention back to whatever seems to be observing. If there's a sense of an observer, what is that, actually? Where is it? You could look at this as observing consciousness, the sense of knowing. What does it actually consist of? Can I find it? Does it have a definite location? All of this impermanent, stressful fabrication: what is it that knows all of that? We usually identify with the knowing, even when everything else... "Okay, yes, everything else comes and goes and is stressful, but the knowing of it, that's me, that's what I am," right?

0:20:55Kind of back here, or up here, or down here, or somehow around. Get quite curious. So, "regarding whatever phenomena there are that are connected with form, feeling, perception, fabrications and consciousness as inconstant, stressful, a disease, a cancer, an arrow, painful, an affliction, alien, a disintegration, an emptiness, not-self," you "turn your mind away from those phenomena" (with the release of clinging and grasping), "and having done so, incline your mind to the property of deathlessness: 'This is peace, this is exquisite: the pacification of all fabrications, the relinquishing of all acquisitions, the ending of craving; dispassion; cessation; unbinding.' Suppose that an archer or archer's apprentice were to practice on a straw man or a mound of clay, so that after a while he would become able to shoot long distances, to fire accurate shots in rapid succession, and to pierce great masses. In the same way, there is the case where a practitioner enters and remains in the first jhana: rapture and pleasure born of seclusion, accompanied by directed thought and evaluation. Regarding whatever phenomena there are that are connected with form, feeling, perception, fabrications and consciousness as inconstant, stressful, a disease, a cancer, an arrow, an affliction, alien, a disintegration, an emptiness, not-self,

0:22:30"he turns his mind away from those phenomena, and having done so, inclines his mind to the property of deathlessness: 'This is peace, this is exquisite: the pacification of all fabrications, the relinquishing of all acquisitions, the ending of craving; dispassion; cessation; unbinding.'" In the analogy there, practicing on a straw man to fire accurate shots in rapid succession can give you a sense of the active quality of insight. With everything that arises, absolutely everything (all sensation, internal and external, everything seen, heard, felt, inside and outside of absorption, and in the transitions in between): can you notice that it's impermanent? Can you notice that it's fabricated? Can you notice that there's an appropriation of self somewhere here, as one or a combination of the aggregates? One after another. "Staying right there, he reaches the ending of the effluents. Or, if not, then through this very Dhamma-passion, this Dhamma-delight, and from the total ending of the five lower fetters" (those being self-identification, grasping at habits and practices, uncertainty, sensual passion and irritation) "he is due to arise spontaneously in the Pure Abodes, there to be totally unbound, never again to return from that world."

0:23:53So if you don't attain full awakening, full unbinding, you'll get partway there. "'I tell you, the ending of the effluents depends on the first jhana': thus it was said, and in reference to this it was said." And then likewise with the second, the third and the fourth jhana. The deeper you can conduct this kind of contemplation, the more stable the absorption you have, the more powerful the investigation will be, and the keener and quicker your mind will be to perceive, and the easier a time it'll have letting go, turning away from fabrication. And likewise with infinite space, and consciousness, and nothingness. And then, an interesting distinction: "Thus, as far as the perception-attainments go" (that's the four jhanas and then the three formless attainments), "that is as far as gnosis-penetration goes. As for these two dimensions (the attainment of the dimension of neither perception nor non-perception and the attainment of the cessation of perception and feeling), I tell you that they are to be rightly explained by those monks who are meditators, skilled at attainment, skilled at emerging from those attainments, who have attained and emerged in dependence on them."

0:25:20So, because neither perception nor non-perception is not technically a perception attainment, and the cessation of perception and feeling also (there's no perception there), a reading and implication of the sutta is that one can't really conduct insight from within the eighth jhana; you have to emerge from it. (Or not the eighth jhana: the fourth formless attainment, or the eighth jhana, whatever.) And that accords with my own experience. If you're in that state, as soon as the mind moves a little, you're out of it. Compared to the others it's a fragile state; really, anything will knock you out. Not that you can't stabilize it, but it's not compatible with that kind of investigation as the prior seven states are. Likewise with the cessation of perception and feeling: you're out. You might be able to do insight practice on the way coming out, and that would probably be of great fruit, great benefit, but it's not going to be happening while you're in it. Okay, I'll have more to say tonight, but maybe that's enough for now, and I'll open it to questions, after first saying this. For the remainder of this retreat, if you want to just continue deepening into samadhi, working on access concentration, or jhana if that's opened up for you, you're welcome to do that. I'm not going to tell you how best to use your time. And if you'd like to start incorporating insight practice, then my recommendation is to get as strongly, deeply concentrated as you can, and when you've been hanging out there for a while (I'm not going to put a time on it), begin to investigate that state: begin to take up these lenses of impermanence, of dukkha, of not-self,

0:27:51and see what happens. Okay. Yeah, go on. "So, if I'm understanding correctly: say I wanted to do insight. I'd get into as deep an access concentration state as possible, or, it sounds like, maybe up to jhana 3, let's say." However deep you can go, yeah. "So my question is: say at that point I'm like, 'All right, I'm going to do some vipassana, some scanning of my body,' and then I feel something, let's say a clenching in my stomach. I'm still unclear about the most fruitful way to do the insight, because I tend to get very analytical, very conceptual, very quickly. So how would I do something like that?" Yeah. It's not, from the question, a kind of conceptual analysis. In the same way that bringing attention to the object and immersing in jhana is not an analytical practice, likewise vipassana, working with the three characteristics, is not that kind of analytical practice.

0:29:21You're parsing experience into its constituent elements, taking up one of these themes (impermanence or not-self) and applying it, applying that perception, that theme, to whatever you encounter. So take that example of the tension in the stomach. Notice, as best you can, the fluctuation within the sensations of that stomach tension. If anything appears solid, pay closer attention to it. Can you discern any rising or falling, increase or decrease, growing larger or smaller around the edges? Is it solid, or does it in fact fluctuate? "Okay. I'm trying, I'm doing my best to do that now. So if I'm understanding correctly, it's a deep observation of it. Would it be helpful, then, to use some phrase or some question to go deeper into it?" It might be helpful at the beginning. With all three of these characteristics, eventually it's just non-verbal, direct observation of these felt properties in experience.

0:31:02Once you get a wedge into one of the characteristics, the deeper and more sustained your contemplation of it, the more you're able to see things in its light. You may be able to notice impermanence most easily at first with bodily sensation, and that's what I'd recommend: most people are able to notice it most easily and most pronouncedly in the frame of the body, whether in the jhanic factors or just in plain sensation. Okay, here's an example for everyone; this is an exercise, as before. Clench your fist really hard, as hard as you can; both if you want, sure. As you're clenching it, close your eyes if it helps, and bring your attention to the sensation of clenching. Is it a solid block, a solid mass? Or does it move? Does it change? And likewise, in that clenching of the fists, is there something stressful, uneasy, unsatisfactory? And if you were to survey it top to bottom, side to side, up and down, would it be correct to say, "This is me, this is what I am"?

0:32:19And now release the fists. When you release them, likewise keep the attention in your hands. You may notice some tingling, a fluctuation of sensation; you may notice an easing of the tension. And whether tightly bound up or more released, still: is this ultimately me? Is this what I am? Does that make it more tangible? "I have a follow-up question to that. This may be a technique question. What's the distinction between observing it versus... I notice that, of course it's related, but wherever my attention goes, that's where the observation goes, right? So there's the idea that, okay, there's impermanence, there's movement in the sensation in my hand. But how much of that is me almost making it happen with my attention, versus it just happening because it's happening?" Yeah, this is great. This is an aspect of dependent origination that you can discern in real time for yourself: "Oh, what arises in experience is quite dependent on my attention: where my attention is placed, its angle of approach."

0:33:51If you pay attention to the theme of impermanence, it becomes more prominent, more relevant. And likewise: was the sensation in your left pinky toe present until I mentioned it? Does it matter, in direct experience? Not really. But what appears in your field of experience is partly dependent on your attention, and on the way it's modulating and interacting with phenomena moment to moment. "So would you say, for the way we're doing it, does it matter? Say I was unclenching my fist and all of a sudden I noticed a sensation in my chest, or my earlobe. Since I'm trying to stay in concentration, do I go, 'Oh, come back to the hand'? Or do I just observe?" Yeah. There are several things you can do. This is a fine and good way to practice: like a dog with a bone, you can stay with a particular local patch of sensation until you're able to perceive clearly whatever theme or characteristic you're working with.

0:35:09As with a more conventional concentration practice, you just stay with whatever it is (the sensation in the hand, the pain in the stomach, the tingling in the ear) until you're able to perceive the characteristic clearly there, locally at least. Once you find perceiving impermanence a little easier, it can be really natural and good just to let attention flow to wherever impermanence is most prominent. Sometimes that might be in a flush through the face. It might be in the arising and passing away of sounds. It might be free-floating through all the senses. Also, the tendency with focusing on these characteristics, partly as a consequence of developing a kind of absorption in the theme (even if not in a fully jhanic state), is for attention to become broader and more encompassing, and for the contemplation to include more and more of the senses all at once. So if you're really immersed and far along in the contemplation of impermanence, your whole field of experience is all at once like a symphony of simultaneous arising and dissolution, or fading and dissolving,

0:36:37and you're perceiving that. As with sound and bodily sensation, you can perceive the visual field falling away all at once, not localized. And likewise with dukkha, likewise with not-self. But at first it's usually easier to work with something more localized, and you could stay in one area. Once you feel you have a working grasp of the theme, it can also help, to keep it interesting and keep motivation up: "Okay, I can perceive impermanence in my hand. What about in my foot? What about in my chest? What about in my thought stream? What about in sound?" "Yeah, thank you. That was very helpful." You're welcome. Yeah. "You mentioned that insight practice can be psychologically distressing if you've got too much selfing going on, or something along those lines. Are there particular milestones at which it becomes a good idea to start doing insight meditation?" Yeah. If you want my straightforward recommendation: have good fluency with the brahmaviharas, if possible, as a protective meditation and as something that softens up and works with whatever might be going on emotionally and psychologically, and then get fluency, if not mastery, with the first four jhanas. Then you're less likely to run into problems doing insight practice, and you can always fall back on those meditations.

0:38:29Whether you'll run into problems or not depends on your personality and your character and what's going on for you, and it can be fairly unpredictable. So if I'm saying, "Here's the way most likely to be safe and not so distressing": get that under your belt first. I'm not sure who's next. [Participant]. "When you say problems, can you elaborate?" Yeah. As with concentration: anxiety, panic, racing thoughts. The feeling of the solidity and substantiality of your phenomenal experience falling away can be fear-inducing. Likewise, if you're heavily contemplating impermanence, not-self and dukkha, and you weren't signed on for this, you may find yourself with an increasing lack of interest in conventional affairs. If a lot of your identity, and a lot of your satisfaction and enjoyment in life, is built around satisfying and achieving drives connected with what's impermanent, unsatisfactory and ultimately not-self, it can be quite confronting and challenging to see how much of your life and your activities have been built on a shaky and insubstantial foundation, and that can be threatening to your personality structure.

0:40:25And as with deep concentration, you may experience lights, odd distortions, visions. It happens pretty frequently that folks come to meet with me after having been on some other retreat, insight-focused or not, where they encountered some of this territory without much framing or context for it, and they're freaked out because some weird shit is going on in their experience that they weren't warned about and weren't prepared for. It may be ongoing even after the retreat ends, and it can really shake up someone's life. Thankfully, with every person I've personally interacted with around this, most of the worry and anxiety could be ameliorated just by letting them know: "Uh-huh. You're not going crazy. This is normal. You're all right. You can stop the practice if it's too intense. You can shift your attention back to something more stabilizing, more straightforwardly wholesome and soothing, like one of the brahmaviharas, plain old samadhi. Go for a walk, eat some heavy food, watch some cat videos."

0:41:58Does that give some context? "Yeah." You're welcome. [Participant]? "[unclear], and then I guess on this [unclear] I had a lot of these insights, and I was depressed for a week: 'Everything is fake. I made that.' But [unclear]. That was my story: a week of it. Knowing that it could happen made it much better: 'Ah, this is within the range of what could happen.' And it went away. So even if you feel that, it's temporary; it goes away. It's the typical story. That was my story. And the question is: doing vipassana on, let's say, the piti and sukha, I can see how they're [changing]. But in J5, the vibe of space feels like a flat, constant wall that doesn't change. Can that sensation be... can one vipassana-ize the space, the spacey sensation?"

0:42:59Yes. Get really curious. "Okay. If that boundless space appears, it feels very much like a solid wall, unchanging, but it's probably not unchanging?" Okay. What can help is building up some momentum. If you're trying to apply one of the characteristics, or see one of the characteristics, in an element of experience where you haven't seen it yet, it can help to build up momentum with it first. So if you were trying to see the impermanence of the fabrication of space: rev up on the body, rev up on sound, something, and then translate that to space. "Okay." "Yeah. I guess I'm wondering (it's kind of a two-part question) how the object we pick affects the meditation. Because for me, focusing on my breath, it just doesn't feel very good. I've tried focusing on a potted plant in front of me, or on roughly where my third eye is on my forehead.

0:44:12None of those things have really gotten me anywhere, and I feel like maybe that's just because I don't like them. And the things I do like, that have really gotten me into the jhanas, are focusing on a little orb of light (though I'm trying to simplify the light orb, and not make it too much visuals, too much thought around it), and also, from there, focusing on emptiness. That's the biggest thing my brain loves to go to, because every single thought or distraction that comes in, I can just turn into emptiness. And the other thing that was helping me get into jhana was the mantra 'Gate, paragate': gone, gone beyond, gone beyond even that, awakening. So the two main things that have really gotten me into jhana are emptiness and that mantra, which is essentially emptiness as well, like release. Both of those are really just letting go. And I loved your analogy about the blade, because I've almost been visualizing it (not visualizing a point, but thinking about it): it's like a blade where I'm balancing on the center between focus and concentration on one side and relaxation on the other, kind of balancing my way down the middle of it.

0:45:41But I've found that when I try to go into deep concentration, it doesn't really go anywhere. So I guess I'm wondering how much of jhana is also just about letting go, you know what I mean? How important is that aspect of it? So my two questions are: how much of it is really about letting go into that relaxed focus? And how important is it for the object we're focusing on to be something we like? Or would it be helpful for me to also pick objects I don't like?" Yeah, thanks for the questions. I'll answer the second one first. Until you're quite fluent with entering, exiting and traversing deeper states of concentration and jhana, you might as well just go with something you like, something pleasant. If focusing on a visualization of a small, simple orb of light allows your mind to settle and cohere enough for the jhanic factors to arise and for you to absorb into them, great, do that.

0:46:53No need to make it more difficult than it needs to be. At a certain point, it is quite useful training to learn and experience for yourself that the object doesn't matter. You can get as easily concentrated on a blank white wall, or a pebble, or the vast expanse of the sky. Or, if you're not a visual person, try visualizing something, even if it's unsteady. The malleability of mind that results from attaining reasonable access concentration, let's say, with any object, is well worth training for. And it shows you something deeply revealing about the nature of mind: that the development and enjoyment of a state depends not so much on the object as on the quality of mind engaging it. "I see. Okay." And likewise, you can do it even with the theme of something unattractive or conventionally repulsive. You can attain deep access concentration doing corpse contemplation, meditating on the conventionally, traditionally disgusting parts of the body (phlegm, pus, your skeleton). You can get deeply concentrated with that.

0:48:17Yeah. Could you remind me of the other question? "Yeah. The other question was: for me, getting into the first and second jhanas has been easiest through letting go more. So how much does that play into, I guess, all of them? How important is it to the practice?" Yeah. People differ in the balance of their faculties, and in where they need to shore things up so the mind is balanced enough to enter these states. It's true that a lot of going through the jhanas, and through the formless attainments, is just following a kind of downward slope of letting go of subtler and subtler levels at which the mind is fabricating experience. And you can enter jhanic states... there's actually crossover with insight here. If you see impermanence deeply and the mind lets go as a result, you may get the arising of the jhanic factors.

0:49:26You may end up in boundless space. For this reason, people on vipassana retreats will end up in jhanic territory, usually not in a consolidated absorption, but just from the mind releasing and letting go of fabrication. So, okay: if it works, if inclining the mind towards emptiness or vacuity in whatever way (that felt sense, that visual sense) is resulting in the signs of concentration and the factors arising: if it works. "Okay. And one final question: if I keep focusing on emptiness, which has been my main point of concentration, will that reduce the potency when I eventually want to get to jhana seven? Because that's essentially emptiness. So I'm wondering if that's the step I should be taking from six to seven: switching to emptiness?"

0:50:29Well, this word "emptiness" can be a little slippery; it can mean different things. I'm not in your experience, so I don't know exactly how you're using your mind here. Maybe you could say a bit more about the felt sense, or however it's manifesting in your experience, when you're focusing on emptiness. What precisely do you mean? "Before this retreat, it was a lot of very vivid visuals: almost everything, my body turning into light, everything around me turning into light and energy, and then watching all the energy of the universe and time kind of collapsing into itself, into just an empty void. But now, since I realized that too much of this visualization is a bit distracting for my deep concentration, I've just been concentrating on the base point, just the void, and letting any thoughts or feelings that come in and take me away from that relaxed focus just turn into the void, you know what I mean?

0:51:41And maybe using some insight for them to turn into the void, but I've also been trying not to use too much insight." Yeah. If you can have a felt sense or a visual sense of dissolution and ride it out to a relatively formless state, that's great. And, as I think I said in one of the other sessions earlier, it can be good to fill out the middle and see everything in between as well. Do we have an interview later today? "Yeah, I think so." We can talk more about it then; let's talk more about it one-on-one. "Thank you. Thanks so much." "Yeah, so I want to report, real quick: jhana in dreams. Legit. I expected it; it's something I was doing before, while I was building access concentration, but a lot. What caught me off guard was that it just kind of happened by accident; I'm not exactly an experienced dreamer or whatever. And it made me ponder: is it possible, in deeper access concentration, where the sword has been sharpened so much,

0:53:04that it's almost as if, if you accidentally drop it on something, it'll penetrate really deep? Because the piti erupted so neatly in the dream. I couldn't even control it; I knew it was coming. And it makes me want to... and this happened more: the sword, the attention, goes somewhere and you really zoom in, really quickly, these kind of funny accidents, and maybe being prepared for that in different ways." Yeah. Jhana in dreams can happen. If you're meditating a whole lot, on retreat or off, you may find that even without becoming lucid you find yourself meditating in dreams, and you may become lucid as a result, or you may enter in the dream space a state you're cultivating in waking life. That can certainly happen. So enjoy it if it's happening. And the unpredictability: yes. The more refined and collected your mind becomes, the more these kinds of accidents may happen, whether with straight samadhi practice or vipassana. If you're cultivating it deeply, it may sneak up on you; it may surprise you.

0:54:38You may discern the characteristics, or fall into deeper states, without much warning, or you may get unpredictable results. That's part and parcel of the territory. Apart from knowing that it can happen, I don't have anything else to say. "That's okay." "A few short questions. Just a follow-up on that question: you said 'cultivating in waking life.' I have an idea of it, but can you explain?" Oh, I just mean that the meditative states or practices you're doing in your waking hours, from the time you get up in the morning until you go to sleep at night, may carry over into the dream state. That's all. "Okay, I'd heard it differently. Next question: insight practice is something that can be done outside of jhana?" Yes. The way I'm presenting it here, in the structure of the retreat, and just generically, I'd encourage you to take up insight practice from a deep foundation of samadhi. But you can just jump in and start.

0:55:53You can develop concentration to the degree of deep access, or to a jhanic level of concentration (it won't be as absorbed), by just starting with impermanence and getting concentrated that way. Yeah, [participant]. "Hey, you used a word a bit ago that I've been thinking about. You said 'inclining the mind.' I was thinking about it on a drive earlier: I was watching the breath and thinking, how could I incline the breath towards being slower and longer at both ends?" What's the question here? "Could you tell me more about what you and others mean by the phrase 'inclining'? It feels gentle to me." Yeah. If I incline the mind towards the breath, my attention just naturally... It's like an intention with maybe a gentle push. There's a watercraft on a lake, and you sight the direction you want it to go with your eye line, give it a gentle nudge, and then it drifts, without your hammering it. Or you set a ball on a slope, and it just rolls down. And the more familiar you are with the destination... You can incline the mind to the first jhana: if your baseline of samadhi is high enough and you're familiar with the state, you can just intend, incline the mind to the first jhana, and it'll stabilize.

0:57:35Likewise, you just incline the mind to a perception of impermanence, incline the mind to a perception of dukkha, incline the mind to a perception of not-self, and if you're familiar with those themes, with that range, it will manifest. "So as you were saying all that, the word 'intention' came up in my mind, and then you said the word 'intend.' And the question here... there's not a lot of time left, but what do you feel I, or we, need to know about intention?" It's exceptionally important. A large part of practice is refreshing intention: intending to attend to the meditation object, to the theme of your contemplation.

0:58:32It's one of the factors of the path: right intention, or right resolve. And, as a consequence of the momentum of refreshing the same intention over and over again, and also as a function of the coherence and collectedness of your mind, there can be an increasing purity and straightforwardness and directness of intent that becomes more and more powerful, and that carries you down the path.

0:59:03"I'm noticing I don't understand intent, but I'll let you go now." It was like this... Well, get curious about it. What actually happens in your direct experience when you intend to stand up to get a glass of water? Intention, as a mental factor, is directly observable in your experience, as part of the chain of causation that moves this mind and body around. "Yeah, I get freaked out. I get freaked out thinking about that."

0:59:40Okay. [Participant], and then maybe one more question. "Yeah. One question about the instructions on insight meditation. The way I'm seeing it now is more conceptual, analytical. You go to the states... I understood that you need to experience the concept, like impermanence. But the way I'm seeing it now, you have this concept, impermanence, and then you're there concentrating, and then you search for it, observing it in whatever arises. But it's difficult, because with the first jhana, or concentration, it's very easy: you focus on the breath, or find pleasant sensation, and then it intensifies, so it's easy to follow. But with this one you need to search for it. So the way I'm seeing it, you have this concept, a verbal concept, a language, and then you need to be curious, investigating, searching for the experience of that concept. Is that right, or not?" Yeah, the words are concepts; I'm communicating with concepts here. But a straightforward question: have you ever found any of your sensations to be permanent, without having the concept?

1:01:12"No." Okay. Yeah. My hand is moving across the screen right now. Impermanence is not subtle. As a function of your samadhi, your increasing discernment and the power of your mind, you'll perceive it at subtler and subtler scales and in a more encompassing way. But impermanence is not subtle. "Yeah. Right. Yes. I think with not-self, for instance, it's maybe easy to perceive the self, right? Where I'm behind my nose, here, or... But the not-self of what is: that's also a concept that's more difficult to [see]. But I guess when you're there, in that situation, more consistently, maybe it's easier to see those things. But now I'm seeing it more conceptually, not with any experience of it." Yeah. Not-self is the subtlest of the three, we could say. "Okay." And therefore it's often easier to get a wedge in with impermanence, or dis-ease, stress. "Okay.

1:02:25"Stress also." Yeah. "Okay. No, that's okay. Thank you." And with not-self, it's not that you find a speck in your experience: "There it is. There's the not-self." No. It's more that you realize a certain way the mind is gripping to itself. There's a seeing of the selfing, and then a release of that, and you see it as a superimposition, a tangling of experience happening. And then the impersonality of everything gets clearer and clearer. Okay, last one. "With the not-self practice, it seems I'm finding a point, either a contraction in the body or some subtle flavor of me (I don't know how I'd describe it), and there's a release, and it seems to affect the whole field. It's not just that the point is gone: the whole field, and it seems the whole world and others as well. The whole experience just enters a really alien, voidy place.

1:03:53I guess the question is: is the goal to practice that way of seeing, like a muscle, and just be able to hit that void? There's also an element of pleasure, I guess. I don't know; I'm just curious. This seems like the right path. It feels good." Yeah. Good noticing. Every part of the field of experience is intimately, causally connected to every other part of the field of experience, and this is something you can perceive with more and more clarity as a function of concentration and insight. So if you're perceiving through the lens of not-self, and there's a release of clinging, and some dukkha goes out of the field, that propagates; it affects the whole field of experience.

1:04:49Good noticing. And yes, meditating on these themes, developing fluency with them, is like developing a muscle, like an exercise. And often these things that seem like downers ("Oh, impermanence. Oh, stress. Oh, not-self"), by meditating on them with some constancy and fervor, and refining the subtlety and scope of our perception of them, result in the most exquisite pleasure and release, culminating ultimately in total unbinding, total release, which is the highest pleasure, the highest happiness. "Another quick question about that: this ultimate release. This is my curiosity about the experience of awakening: is it like you pop out of it and can't go back in the same way? Or is it how Rob puts it, where you can pop back into a reified experience of self and world and still see it as dependently originating?" Yeah. In my own path (and it's not that different from how it's described in some places in traditional sources) you progress through some phases of alternation, where sometimes things are more reified and sometimes less. However you want to map out this territory, there are breakpoints, thresholds after which reification, or duality, can't really come back in the same way.

1:06:31"And you can still experience some degree of reified stuff?" Yeah. One way to describe the completion, the theoretical endpoint of the path (for me it's theoretical; if one of you reaches it, maybe you can come help me), is that all tendency to reify, all tendency, is exhausted, and it just doesn't come back. But yes, there's fluctuation, and breakpoints. My own experience has been fluctuation: seeing, not seeing, not seeing, not seeing, ka-funk, a big shift, a kind of threshold it can't pass back beyond again, but still fluctuating. "So you're in the world, not of it: a holographic experience?"

1:07:18Yeah. Past a certain point, you can't not see things in terms of these characteristics; they're manifestly evident. Even if you're not inclining the mind towards them, it's not subtle. The emptiness, the selflessness, the impermanence, and the stress of fabrication: it's not subtle, and you can't not see it. And, as part of that, the you that's doing the seeing... I'm done. On that note: I was going to save this for tonight, but it seems like a good one to end on. There are actually a bunch of suttas that are the unbinding, or nibbana, suttas, and this is one of them.

1:08:07"I have heard that on one occasion the Blessed One was staying near Savatthi at Jeta's Grove, Anathapindika's monastery. On that occasion the Blessed One was instructing, urging, rousing and encouraging the monks with a Dhamma talk concerned with unbinding. The monks, receptive, attentive, focusing their entire awareness, lending ear, listened to the Dhamma. Then, on realizing the significance of that, the Blessed One on that occasion exclaimed: 'One who is dependent has wavering. One who is independent has no wavering. There being no wavering, there is calm. There being calm, there is no yearning. There being no yearning, there is no coming or going. There being no coming or going, there is no passing away or arising. There being no passing away or arising, there is neither a here nor a there nor a between the two. This, just this, is the end of stress.'" The end of dukkha, the end of suffering. It's a neat passage, and short.6

1:09:07"There being no yearning, there is no coming or going." The perception of things coming and going, the perception of objects, of solid space and time, which we fixate out of dualistic confusion and yearn and long for, widens the gap, and is stressful and inconstant. But when the perception of things stops, there's no perception of arising and passing away, and the duality of here and there, as well as then and now, falls away completely. Not here, not there, not in between. No arising, no passing away. No things.

1:10:03So realize that, and then what might seem cryptic now won't, then. Okay, let's take a break, come back and sit.

1:10:46Okay. In this next 40 minutes or so, I'm going to guide us through access concentration, however far into it you can get, then point to the first jhana at least, and then direct us all to incline the mind towards impermanence. You can follow along, or let my words flow through [unclear]; up to you.

1:12:24Settle in with whatever your primary object is for this session. I'm going to be working with the breath at the nostrils.

1:12:49A gentle, soft approach, resting the attention with the object, not gripping. Like the analogy the other night: like holding a baby bird in your hands. Not too tight; you don't want to hurt it. Not too loose, letting it fly out and escape. Find that balance for yourself.7

1:14:22Any time you notice the mind drifting to something other than the object (a sound, another sensation, a thought), with a minimum of thought and energy expended, just let it go and gently return. Fold your attention back into the object.

1:17:52As and if you notice signs of concentration arising (relaxation, pleasure in the body, the beginnings of the jhana factors, light, whatever there may be), stay with the object for longer. Let those things come and go in the background.

1:18:21Let them stabilize, and settle your mind as you stay with the object.

1:22:21You can just stay with the primary object from now on. But if there's enough stability, if there's some stable, pleasant sensation you can turn your attention to, or if piti is present, you can turn your attention to those.

1:23:16And let them stabilize and intensify, if they're present.

1:23:35Whether there's just a little piti and sukha, or it's gushing and geysering, or stably pervading the body, just stay with it, with that same gentle holding of attention. And then, wherever you've come to in samadhi, begin with bodily sensation.

1:24:11You can take the body as a whole, or, if you like, you can start just with the hands, and notice as best you can any and all arising and passing away of physical sensation: increasing, decreasing, growing larger, smaller, movement in three dimensions, tingling, getting warmer, colder.

1:25:22And just as you would with a meditation object, if you find your mind drifting from this theme, this perception of impermanence, bring it back.

1:25:52Sense and feel, with as much clarity as you can muster, all the minute change occurring in your experience.

1:26:19Subtler perceptions of impermanence might feel wavy, or like a fine mist, or vibrating, like bubbles, ripples. But whether the perception of the theme is subtle or gross, stay with it, whether locally in an area like the hands, or through the whole body.

1:30:16Notice as well how any thoughts, any intentions, even any movement of attention, are likewise just fluctuations within the field of experience.

1:30:47Any sense of orientation, of observation, of looking, of knowing, of being, of having: all of these transient, fabricated,

1:31:21groundless, empty.

1:31:51Any sound you may hear: just waves within the field.

1:32:09Turn your attention towards your visual field. You may see a mixture of brightness and darkness; you may see light. Is it solid, or changing? If you were to open your eyes, what would you really be seeing? Shapes and colors, patches of bright and dark, all of which change if you move your eyes or turn your head, or if you were to gaze for long enough.

1:33:00You'd see that even the apparently external visual world is a play of insubstantial light.

1:33:39Pleasure, pain, happiness, sadness, motion, stillness, expansion, contraction: all impermanent, all fabricated,

1:34:17all compounded, all stressful,

1:34:42without an essence, a core, a self in any of it.

1:35:08And seeing this can let your mind, as much as it's able, release, relax, let go. There's no need to hold together what must inevitably come apart, or to grasp what's changeable and stressful as me or mine,

1:35:47and no need to keep shoring up and maintaining stressful fabrication.

1:37:40Okay, thank you, everyone. I'll see some of you for interviews, and if not, then this evening.

Sources

Translations are Thanissaro Bhikkhu's on dhammatalks.org unless noted.

  1. “Whether or not there is the arising of Tathagatas, this property stands ... all fabrications are inconstant” AN 3:137 Dhamma-niyama Sutta (The Orderliness of the Dhamma) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN3_137.html ↩
  2. Insight conducted on each jhana and formless attainment; the archer simile; “as far as the perception-attainments go” AN 9:36 Jhana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN9_36.html ↩
  3. Sharpening the sword of wisdom. Leigh Brasington, Right Concentration (Shambhala, 2015) ↩
  4. Maps of the progress of insight. Mahasi Sayadaw, The Progress of Insight (Access to Insight); cf. Daniel Ingram, Mastering the Core Teachings of the Buddha. accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/mahasi/progress.html ↩
  5. Contemplatives who took a formless attainment as an eternal self. MN 102 Pañcattaya Sutta (Five and Three) dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN102.html ↩
  6. “One who is dependent has wavering ... neither a here nor a there nor a between-the-two” Ud 8:4 Nibbana Sutta (Unbinding 4) dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/Ud/ud8_4.html ↩
  7. Holding attention like a baby quail, neither too tight nor too loose. MN 128 Upakkilesa Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN128.html ↩

← Wednesday, November 11 · Evening · All sessions · Thursday, November 12 · Evening →