Thursday, November 12 · Evening
Surveying the World (Ud 3:10), Kevaddha’s question (DN 11) and the unfabricated (SN 43); Q&A on sila, bodhicitta, meaning and beauty
Three readings on what lies beyond the world and its elements. The Q&A was some of the most searching of the retreat: what's good about the path, bodhicitta, meaning, beauty and suffering.
Topics and questions in this session
Talk
- 0:00:00The five recollections. Actions have consequences: we are what we do (0:02).
- 0:03:55Surveying the World (Ud 3:10): seven days at the Bodhi tree. "Where there's delight, there is fear" (0:05).
- 0:06:31Kevaddha's question (DN 11): the monk asks the gods, up to Brahma (0:11), where the four elements cease. The shore-sighting bird (0:13).
- 0:13:18The answer: "Consciousness without surface" (0:14, MN 49).
- 0:14:24Epithets of the unfabricated (SN 43): the unbent, the effluent-free, the true, the beyond (0:16).
Q&A
- 0:20:51Sila: what is good about the path?
- 0:23:06What bodhicitta is, how it's cultivated and how it relates to the hindrances. Ultimate bodhicitta (0:25).
- 0:27:18The path is interwoven with the three poisons. It's fabricated and deals in conventions (0:28, Sn 1:1, MN 22).
- 0:30:12What "not yet" means.
- 0:32:28What is the point? Samvega, and what actually fulfills us (0:34).
- 0:36:34Care and compassion come as you become freer (Blue Cliff Record case 89). Meaning is emergent (0:38).
- 0:40:17Something feels radically incomplete: was Beethoven creating out of suffering and ignorance? Beauty and the sublime (0:42).
- 0:44:49Finding redemption for suffering in a larger scheme often looks like cope.
- 0:49:52Finding pain almost aesthetically pleasing. Views of suffering can be skillful, given time, place and condition (0:51–0:53).
- 0:55:29A more tantric view: working with energy and transformation (0:56).
- 0:56:42Balancing your own path with helping others. Put your own oxygen mask on first (0:58).
Closing
- 1:00:15Your own wish for freedom, followed through, reaches out to others: conventional and ultimate bodhicitta.
0:00:00Good evening, everyone. As per usual, we'll open with these cheery reflections. Handa mayam abhinha-paccavekkhana-patham bhanamase. Jara-dhammomhi jaram anatito: I am of the nature to age; I have not gone beyond aging. All that here is rising, having arisen, may appear to persist for a while, but inevitably everything compounded will change, decay and eventually vanish: body, mind, lifespan, vitality. What we call youth doesn't last long. I am of the nature to sicken; I have not gone beyond sickness. Likewise health: temporary, transitory, put together, not a refuge, not a lasting source of safety or security, bound up with conditions. Health, too, must go. Marana-dhammomhi maranam anatito: I am of the nature to die; I have not gone beyond dying. And finally this life will end. Everything gathered together will part, and where before we imputed a being, its parts having broken apart, we might conjecture as to what happened to it. Something was there, and then it's gone, or so it seems. Sabbehi me piyehi manapehi nanabhavo vinabhavo: all that is mine, beloved and pleasing, will become otherwise, will become separated from me. We can't hold on to a damn thing, not even one. Kammassakomhi kammadayado kammayoni kammabandhu kammapatisarano, yam kammam karissami kalyanam va papakam va tassa dayado bhavissami: I am the owner of my action, heir to my action, born of my action, related to my action, and abide supported by my action. Whatever action I shall do, for good or for ill, of that I will be the heir.1
0:02:46Cause and effect: actions have consequences, no getting around it, underneath it, over it. We are what we do, to the extent that we are anything, in body, speech and mind. Thus we should frequently recollect. So, having introduced the topic of insight, of impermanence, of stress, of not-self: when this contemplation is followed through, where does it lead?
0:03:55"I have heard that on one occasion the Blessed One was staying at Uruvela on the bank of the Nerañjara River at the root of the Bodhi tree" (the tree of awakening) "newly awakened." Fresh off success. "On that occasion he sat at the root of the Bodhi tree for seven days in one session, sensitive to the bliss of release." The man's got a bladder of steel. He sat for seven days without moving; possible, I suppose, but my goodness. "Then, with the passing of seven days, after emerging from that concentration, he surveyed the world with the eye of an awakened one. As he did so, he saw living beings burning with the many fevers and aflame with the many fires born of passion, aversion and delusion. Then, on realizing the significance of that, he on that occasion exclaimed" (odd guy: sits seven days still, sits up, and just exclaims): "'This world is burning, afflicted by contact. It calls disease a self. By whatever means it supposes anything, it becomes otherwise than that. Becoming otherwise, the world is attached to becoming, afflicted by becoming, and yet delights in that very becoming.2
0:05:13"'Where there's delight, there is fear. What one fears is stressful. This holy life is lived for the abandoning of becoming. Whatever contemplatives or brahmans say that liberation from becoming is by means of becoming, all of them are not released from becoming, I say. And whatever contemplatives or brahmans say that escape from becoming is by means of non-becoming, all of them have not escaped from becoming, I say.'" Damned if you do, damned if you don't. The only way out isn't through relying on that polarity of becoming or non-becoming, being or non-being. There's something to see outside of that. "'For this stress comes into play in dependence on every acquisition. With the ending of every clinging, there's no stress coming into play. Look at this world: beings, afflicted with thick ignorance, are unreleased from passion for what has come to be. All levels of becoming, anywhere, in any way, are inconstant, stressful, subject to change. Seeing this as it's come to be with right discernment, one abandons craving for becoming and doesn't delight in non-becoming. From the total ending of craving comes fading and cessation without remainder: unbinding.
0:06:31"'With a monk unbound through lack of clinging, there's no further becoming. He has conquered Mara, won the battle, having gone beyond becomings: Such.'" Gone beyond becoming: what would that even mean? It doesn't do to ponder it. You can compose treatises and commentaries and tracts; many have. They fill up libraries in Buddhist institutions of higher learning; people make their hay and their living chewing over the dried turds of contemplatives of the past. It's not worth it. It doesn't lead to freedom. You have this chance, this life. Why not see what there is to see? Why not be as free as one can be? A little story, from another sutta: "Once, Kevaddha" (a layman the Buddha is speaking to), "this train of thought arose in the awareness of a certain monk in this very community of monks: 'Where do these four great elements (the earth property, the liquid property, the fire property and the wind property) cease without trace?' Then he attained to such a state of concentration that the way leading to the devas appeared in his concentrated mind.3
0:08:29"So he approached the devas of the retinue of the Four Great Kings and, on arrival, asked them, 'Friends, where do these four great elements (the earth property, the liquid property, the fire property and the wind property) cease without trace?' When this was said, the devas of the retinue of the Four Great Kings said to the monk, 'We also don't know where the four great elements cease without trace. But there are the Four Great Kings, who are higher and more sublime than we. They should know where the four great elements cease without trace.' So the monk approached the Four Great Kings and, on arrival, asked them, 'Friends, where do these four great elements cease without trace?' When this was said, the Four Great Kings said to the monk, 'We also don't know where the four great elements cease without trace. But there are the devas of the Thirty-three, who are higher and more sublime than we. They should know.' So the monk approached the devas of the Thirty-three and, on arrival, asked them, 'Friends, where do these four great elements cease without trace?'
0:09:18"When this was said, the devas of the Thirty-three said to the monk, 'We also don't know where the four great elements cease without trace. But there is Sakka, the ruler of the devas, who is higher and more sublime than we. He should know.' So the monk approached Sakka, the ruler of the devas, and, on arrival, asked him, 'Friend, where do these four great elements cease without trace?' When this was said, Sakka, the ruler of the devas, said to the monk, 'I also don't know where the four great elements cease without trace. But there are the Yama devas...'" And this pattern continues: the Yama devas, Suyama, the Tusita devas, Santusita, the Nimmanarati devas, Sunimmita, the Paranimmitavasavatti devas, Vasavatti. "The deva Vasavatti said to the monk, 'I also don't know where the four great elements cease without trace. But there are the devas of Brahma's retinue, who are higher and more sublime than I. They should know.'" And he goes to the devas of Brahma's retinue, and they also don't know. "'But there is Brahma, the Great Brahma, the Conqueror, the Unconquered, the All-Seeing, All-Powerful, the Sovereign Lord, the Maker, Creator, Chief, Appointer and Ruler, Father of All That Have Been and Shall Be.
0:10:26"'He is higher and more sublime than we. He should know where the four great elements cease without trace.' 'And where, friends, is the Great Brahma now?' 'Monk, we also don't know where Brahma is, or in what way Brahma is. But when signs appear, light shines forth, and a radiance appears, Brahma will appear. For these are the portents of Brahma's appearance: light shines forth and a radiance appears.' Then it was not long before Brahma appeared. So the monk approached the Great Brahma and, on arrival, said, 'Friend, where do these four great elements (the earth property, the liquid property, the fire property and the wind property) cease without trace?' When this was said, the Great Brahma said to the monk, 'I, monk, am Brahma, the Great Brahma, the Conqueror, the Unconquered, the All-Seeing, All-Powerful, the Sovereign Lord, the Maker, Creator, Chief, Appointer and Ruler, Father of All That Have Been and Shall Be.' A second time, the monk said to the Great Brahma, 'Friend, I didn't ask you if you were Brahma, the Great Brahma, the Conqueror, the Unconquered, the All-Powerful, the Sovereign Lord, the Maker, Creator...
0:11:22"'...Father of All That Have Been and Shall Be. I ask you, where do these four great elements cease without trace?' A second time, the Great Brahma said to the monk, 'I, monk, am Brahma, the Great Brahma, the Conqueror, the Unconquered, the All-Seeing, All-Powerful, the Sovereign Lord, the Maker, Creator, Chief, Appointer and Ruler, Father of All That Have Been and Shall Be.' A third time, the monk said to the Great Brahma, 'Friend, I didn't ask you if you were Brahma, the Great Brahma... Where do the elements cease without trace?' Then the Great Brahma, taking the monk by the arm and leading him off to one side, said to him, 'These devas of the retinue of Brahma believe, "There is nothing that the Great Brahma does not know. There is nothing that the Great Brahma does not see. There is nothing of which the Great Brahma is unaware. There is nothing that the Great Brahma has not realized." That is why I did not say in their presence that I, too, don't know where the four great elements cease without trace.
0:12:17"'So it's your own wrongdoing, your own mistake, that, bypassing the Blessed One, you search outside for an answer to this question. Go back to the Blessed One and, on arrival, ask him this question. However he answers you, that's how you should remember it.' Then, just as a strong man might extend his flexed arm or flex his extended arm, the monk disappeared from the Brahma world and immediately appeared in front of me. Having bowed down to me, he sat to one side. As he was sitting there, he said to me, 'Lord, where do these four great elements (the earth property, the liquid property, the fire property and the wind property) cease without trace?' When this was said, I said to him, 'Once, monk, some sea-faring merchants, taking a shore-sighting bird, set out across the ocean in their ship. When they could not see the shore from their ship, they released the shore-sighting bird. It flew to the east, it flew to the south, it flew to the west, it flew to the north, it flew straight up, it flew to the intermediate directions.
0:13:18"'If it saw the shore in any direction, it flew there and was gone. If it did not see the shore in any direction, it returned right back to the ship. In the same way, monk, having searched as far as the Brahma world and not receiving an answer to this question, you have come right back to my presence. The question should not be asked in this way: "Where do these four great elements (the earth property, the liquid property, the fire property and the wind property) cease without trace?" Instead, the question should be asked like this: "Where do earth, water, fire and wind have no footing? Where are long and short, coarse and fine, fair and foul, name and form brought to a stop without trace?" And the answer to that is: "Consciousness without surface, without end, luminous all around: here water, earth, fire and wind have no footing. Here long and short, coarse and fine, fair and foul, here name and form are all brought to a stop without trace. With the cessation of the aggregate of consciousness, each is here brought to a stop."'
0:14:24"That is what the Blessed One said. Gratified, Kevaddha the householder delighted in the Blessed One's words." In the verse with which he answers, the elements, along with the paired dualities (long, short, coarse, fine, fair, foul) and name and form (which in one reading stand in for mentality and materiality, body and mind, things we usually assume are separate, distinct, polarized, in binary opposition): all of these are brought to a stop without trace. "Consciousness without surface," which is referred to in only several other passages in the canon. With the total stopping of objectification, there's no place for craving and clinging to land, to proliferate, to objectify, to reify, to acquire, to bind. Consciousness without surface, without end, without border, without boundary, luminous all around. Okay, one last little thing, and then I'll open it up to questions. "Which, monks, is the unfabricated? Whatever is the ending of passion, the ending of aversion, the ending of delusion: this is called the unfabricated." And then there's a long... this is a good sutta, but too long to go through, and it includes many synonyms for the goal of the path:45
0:16:29the unbent, the effluent-free, the true, the beyond, the subtle, the very hard to see, the ageless, permanence, the undecaying, the surfaceless (as it was referred to in the last sutta), non-objectification, peace, the deathless, the exquisite, bliss, rest, the ending of craving, the amazing, the astounding, the secure, security, unbinding, the unafflicted, dispassion, purity, release, the attachment-free, the island, shelter, harbor, refuge, the ultimate. So when objectification completely ceases, when the mind is not bent, when it's not obscured and clouded by passion, aversion and delusion, there are no things. And not only the four elements: all binary oppositions, all dualities, collapse, and you reach the island, the shelter, the harbor, the refuge, release, the unafflicted, the amazing, the astounding, the deathless. No one to die: the unborn, the unfabricated. So, seeing everything fabricated as it truly is (as impermanent, as stressful, and as not-self), the mind can release, can unbind, can be free from passion, aversion and delusion, and realize the end of objectification, the end of craving. Okay. Tomorrow, to cap off the instructions and the retreat, my yapping and exposition will shift more into the positive description that the later tradition furnishes of the nature of mind, which, though it perhaps lays more traps for reification, can also be motivating, in contrast and comparison with, or in addition to, what you'll find here in the early tradition.
0:19:51So I hope all of this has been inspiring and motivating, and I wish for everyone here, and everyone, that in no long time they reach the deathless. Okay: questions about insight practice, about jhana, about all of this nonsense, this effing of the ineffable?
0:20:51"I want to ask you about ethics, or I think the way I'll say it is sila, or something." What's the question here? "I want to understand... maybe this is about bodhicitta, but what is good about the path?" What's good about the path? It's good in the beginning, it's good in the middle, it's good in the end. Restraining oneself from harm to oneself and from harm to another, acting in accord with both conventional and unconventional virtue, leads to benefit for oneself here and now and to one's long-term welfare and happiness, and you provide that safety and security to all those around you through your behavior and through your cultivation. And the ultimate fruit is that within this very life, within this very body, you realize a deathless peace, and release from craving and clinging and from the supposition of a self bound within space and time. Sounds like a pretty good deal to me, man; I don't know where you're going to find a better one. "I feel like you answered my question. I think I have a follow-up about bodhicitta, but I'll let everyone else get some more questions in before that, and sit with it a little more."
0:23:06Maybe people are exhausted with questioning and we can just sit; totally possible. "I'm interested in bodhicitta as well. I was wondering if you could say a bit about what it is exactly, how it's cultivated, and its relationship to the hindrances." Sure. I opened the retreat talking a little about bodhicitta, which is mostly a term and concept used in the later tradition. It means the awakening, or awake, heart, and, as I said at the beginning, there's relative and ultimate, or aspirational and fruition. What brings anyone to practice is bodhicitta; this is one way of looking at it. Your heart, your being, feels a draw, feels something out of alignment, feels the stress and suffering of not seeing clearly, and so you're motivated, to be interested at the very least. There's something in what you've heard or read that struck a chord, and your heart resonated with whatever that was, initially. That's bodhicitta already. The explicit aspiration, which one can cultivate through formal practices, takes the form of sincerely intending to attain awakening, the fullest awakening, Buddhahood, for the benefit of all beings, oneself included, and to accomplish benefit for self and other.
0:25:03Ultimate bodhicitta (and citta here is both heart and mind; they're not distinguished in the source language) is the nature of your mind already. We could look at the hindrances, or the defilements, or any list of mental obscurations or afflictions, like this. There was reference earlier to "the unbent": the afflictions, the hindrances, are bends in the nature of mind that arise from non-recognition, from ignorance. In essence there's no gap between a deluded mind and an awakened mind. They're not two different substances, never the twain to meet. A deluded mind is an awake mind that hasn't recognized itself, and the hindrances, the afflictions, the passion, aversion and delusion are a tangle, a misalignment, in your own awake mind. So: become unbent. Yeah. "I think this is from a sutra, some old text. I heard it at a monastery, and the teacher said something along the lines of being defiled by defilements and then being liberated by defilements. Do you know the passage I'm referring to?" I don't know the specific passage you're referring to, and I'll talk more about this tomorrow. But if one regards the defilements, the hindrances, the afflictions, as substantial and real, and increases one's clinging and aversion on the basis of those things appearing in consciousness, then one is defiled by defilement.
0:27:18You're heaping problems on problems. But if there's enough stability in the mind, or indeed some recognition, even if partial, of the nature of mind, then the arising of the defilements can uncoil and self-liberate, and each arising of confusion can be an occasion for release, and actually for the enhancement of wisdom. "And my bigger question, too: in this whole path, the way I've been seeing it, my own journey has oscillated between these polarities, letting go of what seems like the path altogether, and then finding the need for a path. But it seems that ingrained in the path there's a degree of aversion to, say, suffering; a degree of grasping at, say, freedom and not suffering; and a degree of passion for a path, for ethics and service. So it's interwoven with the three poisons. And then my mind goes to Shinzen's whole thread, which I see as your way of relating: suffering is discomfort and resistance. So the relationship to passion, greed and aversion kind of determines samsara and nirvana. Do you see what I'm saying?"
0:28:45Yeah, I think so. And to your point: the path deals in conventions. The path is fabricated. It's a fabricated path for fabricated confusion, which leads to its own undoing. In some of the earlier suttas I quoted, like a snake sloughing off its skin, the accomplished practitioner lets go of both the near shore and the far, the near shore being samsara and the far shore being nirvana. The later tradition makes much more of this: the non-duality of samsara and nirvana. When the goal is accomplished, when the goal is realized, then from that standpoint there was never a being that needed to be liberated, there was never a path that needed to be cultivated, there was never... right. But until that's a realization, while one is still entangled with fabrication, the path, dealing in convention, is helpful. "It makes me think of the Zen, what you were saying yesterday about your Zen teacher: the whole 'not yet' koan. It seems very non-dual. Do you see what I'm saying with that?"67
0:30:12I'm not sure. I could guess, but why don't you say more? "The whole 'not yet' thing, that it's something you take when you're done with the koans, for the rest of your life. So it's almost like you hit this completion point, and the completion point is never actually completing it. Does that make sense?" Yeah. One of the things that goes is this longing for an end, for a completion. Completion only appears attractive to something that's incomplete. Yeah. "A question about how progress on the path affects, I guess, the big picture: your view or your attitude towards life. Something that comes up for me sometimes, maybe increasingly when I really turn my mind to practice, is questioning the value of anything I do in life. Like you were talking about earlier today, I'm increasingly recognizing that so many of the things I chased, that I thought were important, that I thought would make me happy, have a whole lot of obsessive assumptions in there, and they're not what I thought they were, or what I thought they'd bring me. And if I turn my mind to it, it can get to the point of: what is the point of doing anything, if anything you do, even any person you help, whatever, is whatever? And I don't mean that in a despairing, nihilistic sense; I mean it quite dispassionately.
0:32:28What is the point? Are there things that are meaningful, things worth doing? And what is your internal compass for that? I wonder if this has come up much for you, whether it has shifted as you've progressed along the path. I'm interested in your thoughts about that." Did the question come through? Were you all able to hear it? Yeah. I was overcome with despair and frustration; I think I mentioned before the real disgust and aversion and hatred, directed internally and externally, and I felt an overwhelming futility. I wouldn't encourage that; it's not necessary. But this does get at something. The word for it is samvega, sometimes translated as urgency: you see that not only you, but, if you take a look, everyone or almost everyone around is in a constant game of chasing bait that will hook them and never actually satisfy. It's tragic. The situation of sentient beings is by and large one of confusion and perpetual frustration, and what we think we'll get out of many of our activities is just mistaken.
0:34:22What we think will fulfill us most often won't. What we think will provide us security doesn't, not in the sense we're hoping for. And the deep longings we cherish and hold for conventional aims: there's nothing wrong with any of it, none of it is inherently deficient, but the formation of hope and fear around all the activities of normal human life is confused, and so will inevitably cause frustration and dissatisfaction and oscillation between hope and fear. To see that clearly within your own life, and to reflect honestly (you don't have to go yelling it from the street corners), and to see the condition of the people around you, of the society you live in, of the world, and to look at that honestly, is a powerful motivation to practice. When I saw that, in my own experience, I came to a total conviction that nothing but awakening would relieve the dis-ease, the longing, the pain, the frustration, the anguish and anxiety I felt. And I did find relief and release from all of that. And you asked about an internal compass: what's the point of doing anything?
0:36:34Care, compassion. As you become more free and more clear within yourself, and know your own state and your own mind more and more, you also see the condition of others more clearly. And without the hard barrier of your heart and your being split between self and other, what naturally arises, being bodhicitta, is the wish; not only the wish, but the spontaneous responsiveness that sees suffering and inevitably responds. When you're walking along and see someone about to step out into traffic who doesn't see what's happening, you don't have to think: you reach out and pull them back. There's a koan (this will be a paraphrase, and I apologize): What is the compassion of Avalokiteshvara, the bodhisattva of compassion, like? Like reaching behind one's head for a pillow in the dark. So genuine seeing, genuine freedom, necessarily results in compassionate activity. So before and after, in the middle, all the way through, there's every point in kindness and care and compassion and creativity and play (why not?), but without the confusion.8
0:38:45Is that helpful? "I think so, it is. The way you're describing it, it sounds like meaning is emergent, rather than defined by some specific goal or outcome, because creativity, play and compassion are qualities that are found, experienced and enjoyed in the moment, rather than 'In 10 years' time I'm going to whatever,' or 'The purpose of life is X.'" Freedom from fixed meaning, and responsiveness to the actual context of one's life, one's immediate situation: finding embodied meaning there, which is actually where it was all along. In the way that most of us, myself included, relate even to the path: "The path is something outside of me. My life has meaning insofar as I follow the path well, and do all these things, check these boxes, tick these things, get these states, have the teacher tell me I'm doing well, whatever." We place meaning, we place freedom, we place whatever outside ourselves, and also in an abstracted conceptual space, and that's delusion. That's confused from the start.
0:40:17So there's all the meaning in the world, just not how it appeared to be before. "Yeah. Okay, I see how I've over-weighted conceptuality in how I've been conceiving of meaning." "Hearing all this has brought up a lot, and I think there's a question here; I want to try to speak to something. I can't get rid of this feeling that this somehow feels radically incomplete, as if things only have value once we free ourselves from suffering, or as if the point is really just to suffer less, or to care more, or something like that. I've been chewing on this: was Beethoven just creating out of suffering and ignorance? It's so beautiful. I just see the beauty that comes out of deep suffering, and I wonder where that fits in the path." Yeah. A lot of beauty is in the whole tragedy of the human condition. It's tragic and comic and beautiful, all of those things. And insofar as we want to engage the Buddhist path and practices, Siddhartha put it pretty plainly: "I teach suffering and its cessation." So was Beethoven, enraptured with aesthetics, pursuing his composing out of confusion and suffering?9
0:42:57Yes, certainly, to some extent. We all are. To the extent that we're not fully awakened, yes, we're doing that; everyone is. And if Beethoven had relieved his confusion and his suffering, he might still have been a composer; he might even have been a better one. There are great examples: Hakuin is one. And in the Tibetan tradition, these [unclear] Buddhist paths, there are civil engineers: Thangtong Gyalpo, who was responsible for building iron bridges across the gorges of Tibet, some of which still stand. Great art and music and painting and calligraphy and all these things come out of awakening as well. You could also frame it this way: the longing for the kind of rapture and dissolution we experience in an aesthetic display... To a large extent, what we appreciate and feel as sublime, as beautiful, is what allows our self-structure to merge or dissolve. It resonates with our mind, our attention, our emotions in such a way that we feel moved and soothed, or excited, and we can become immersed, and the sense of separation can be eased to a certain extent. That's a large part of what aesthetic rapture consists in.
0:44:49So if you're interested in suffering and its end, the Buddhadharma has everything you might want, and it doesn't exclude any particular domain or sphere of life or activity. But a lot of the reconciliation of suffering into a grander scheme of coherence and poignancy, to be bluntly honest, often appears to me as a kind of cope. There's a line of argument that there's a redemption or compensation of suffering when it's found to be within a larger structure: an aesthetic poignancy, a grand arc of history, a cosmic cycle. And all of these are fabrications that soothe, ease and contextualize a broken heart.
0:46:58"Yeah, no. I don't suppose I have anything more [unclear]." "I have a lot of follow-up to that, I don't know." Sure. Okay, maybe one or two more. [Participant], yeah. "It's a short question, I guess. When you were talking about bodhicitta a bit ago, you mentioned practices to generate it. I think I caught you saying something about generating the wish through practice. Could you elaborate a little more?" Yeah. In a formal way, one might put one's hands in anjali mudra in front of one's heart (okay, I'm going to do it), and from the depths of one's being, from the gut, from the soles of the feet on up through the heart, like an up-rushing column of energy, seeing one's own suffering and the suffering of all beings, form the heartfelt wish: whatever it takes, however long it takes, whatever is involved, I will attain awakening for my own and others' benefit. In more traditional and elaborate formulas, that might include gathering blessings from celestial bodhisattvas and buddhas raining down on one, supporting and propelling one, giving one energy to proceed.
0:49:26But from the very simple to the most elaborate forms of that kind of practice, it all gets at the same thing: providing nourishment and encouragement and propulsion to proceed along the path. "Thank you. I felt that. I don't know; I felt it."
0:49:52"Can I follow up on your response to [the earlier question], specifically the part about contextualizing suffering possibly being a cope? Something I've been doing in my practice is learning, as I like to describe it, not only to accept things that feel unpleasant (emotions, physical pain, whatever) but to find something almost aesthetically pleasing in them. It started during a period when I was going through a lot of emotional turbulence, and I was like, 'Girl, do something before this destroys me,' and then I came to this practice. And I've made some degree of progress in being able to welcome difficult emotions and feel them in a way that's enjoyable in a kind of meta sense, like how you might enjoy a sad movie and cry, or something. I wonder what your thoughts are: does this sound like it's heading in the right direction, or is it a cope?
0:51:24"[unclear] I feel more suffering than that. So I said all of that." Views of suffering can be skillful. Working with transformation, exploring different ways of viewing, affects the body, affects emotion, affects sensation. The path is fabricated, but that doesn't mean it's not useful or not skillful, or even not necessary. Employing views, perspectives, narrative and structure to relate to what's difficult to bear, difficult to work with: we couldn't get along without it, until we can abandon all views. But if you try to do that prematurely (I'm just speaking from experience), you're likely just to wallow in misery, and actually be mired and entrenched in views you're unaware of. So though all views and all paths and all practices are fabricated, skillful use eases suffering, and the most skillful leads to fabrications that lead to their own unfabrication. Is that helpful? "Yeah, it is. Thank you." If I were working in hospice, and someone professed a grand cosmic narrative that gives their life a redemptive meaning and arc and purpose within what appears to me to be a fabricated concoction, I'm not going to be like... that would be cruel.
0:53:53So there's time, place, condition, appropriateness, skillfulness. "Yeah. So it seems useful as a kind of provisional practice, but something I'd eventually need to abandon at some point." Yeah. All practices, all views, up to the very last moment when clinging can be completely released, are provisional. "And even whatever the pain or the emotion is, it can just be met exactly as it appeared, without massaging it?" Yeah. We'll get more into this tomorrow. But if there's recognition of emptiness, if there's recognition of the nature of mind, then no antidote is needed. No transformation is needed. No effort is needed. There can just be an even and complete resting in the nature of empty phenomena's play, without any need to form a view or a conception, or adjust or do anything. Until then, there's much to be done. "I can't help but wonder if they're the same: you can have that kind of holographic experience of suffering where it's still empty, and you're almost mining it, extracting the beauty out of it,
0:55:29and then having the ability to de-reify and step out of self and objectification. I guess it's sort of a more tantric view. I think [the earlier question is] coming from [that], yeah, for sure. And it seems really similar to something I heard Rob say, which I really find true in my own path: there's some suffering (obviously not objective, but I do believe there are tiers of really deep release where it's not quite necessary) that only a recognition of some beauty or meaning can help to ease." Yeah, a hundred percent. And that view of self-liberation without antidote or transformation or effort, even with no path, no particular practice, is often shown as the fruition of, or practiced in tandem with, the paths of transformation and renunciation. So it depends on the strength of the affliction, on the depth and stability of one's recognition, on one's aesthetic predilections or enjoyments. Yeah.
0:56:42Sure, one can still do all of that. "Yeah. So are you saying yes, you think you can have both?" Okay. "Cool." Yeah. And there are ways of practicing tantric sadhana where you're working with energy, working with transformation, but you never depart from a recognition of the nature of mind. "Yeah. Cool. A different kind of internal art, right? It's more creative; you're almost the artist." Exactly. The canvas is wisdom's display. Right. Yeah. "I'm wondering how you think about balancing walking the path for yourself versus helping others get on it, if you're not very far ahead. Some amount of suffering in me is causing me to strive in this direction, and I've learned something along the way. If I'm halfway out of the hole, do I pull some people up with me? Or is it better just to walk the path and then [help]? Making sense of suffering in some larger scheme seems very close to the cope side, but it also seems pragmatic to bring everyone with you.
0:58:17"[unclear]." Yeah, of course. If you have something helpful to say or to do, do it. If you can provide some comfort, some assistance to those around you, do it. But one can get so immersed in that that one doesn't proceed. And the general thrust of more traditional teaching is: okay, the plane's going down; put your own oxygen mask on first, and then you can help others put theirs on. If yours is loosely secured, or not even on, you'll quickly lose consciousness, and you might flail around and actually hurt someone. But no, there's no reason not to help when it's obvious that you can, and when that's good for you and good for someone else. But your capacity to be of benefit only increases as a function of how far you've walked. What the balance in that is, for you or for anyone, is up to your own discernment. But it's been true for me, from my own life experience and all the places I've been and people I've met and circumstances I've seen, that the dividends (to use an investment metaphor) are very great when you invest in your own freedom, always deepening, while not leaving others behind.10
1:00:15And maybe a final note before we break: your own wish for freedom, your own desire for happiness, for peace, is exactly the same thing that, as a function of your freedom, will reach out to help others. That's both the conventional and the ultimate level of bodhicitta. The same impulse that causes you to want to relieve your own suffering is what reaches out. It's the same in the beginning as in the, quote-unquote, end. All right: 10 minutes, and then we'll sit.
Sources
- The five recollections, chanted in Pali. AN 5:57 Upajjhatthana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN5_57.html ↩
- “This world is burning, afflicted by contact” Ud 3:10 Loka Sutta (Surveying the World) dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/Ud/ud3_10.html ↩
- Where do the four great elements cease without trace? “Consciousness without surface” DN 11 Kevaddha Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN11.html ↩
- “Consciousness without surface” elsewhere in the canon. MN 49 Brahmanimantanika Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN49.html ↩
- The unfabricated and its synonyms (the unbent, the surfaceless, non-objectification, the island ...) SN 43 Asankhata Samyutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN43.html ↩
- The near shore and the far. Sn 1:1 Uraga Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/StNp/StNp1_1.html ↩
- The path as fabricated, to be let go once crossed. MN 22 Alagaddupama Sutta (the raft simile) dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN22.html ↩
- Avalokiteshvara “reaching behind one’s head for a pillow in the dark” Blue Cliff Record, case 89 (Yunyan and Daowu) bluecliffrecord.ca/case-89-daowu-and-the-person-reaching-for-a-pillow/ ↩
- “I teach suffering and its cessation” MN 22: “Both formerly and now, monks, I declare only stress and the cessation of stress” dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN22.html ↩
- Helping others while walking the path. AN 4:95 Chalavata Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN4_95.html ↩