Jhana & Awakening Retreat 2026 · Session 14 of 16

Friday, November 13 · Morning

Renunciation, transformation, recognition; Bahiya (Ud 1:10) and Tilopa’s Ganges Mahamudra; nature of mind; Q&A

Recorded November 13, 2026, 10:01 am Mountain Time · Nameless Mountain, Boulder, Colorado · 1 hr 7 min

Three kinds of path, renunciation, transformation and recognition, served as a bridge from the early texts to Mahamudra and Dzogchen. Bahiya's teaching and Tilopa's song led into an eyes-open pointing-out exercise.

Topics and questions in this session

Talk

  • 0:00:00Three kinds of path: renunciation, transformation and recognition. Outer and inner renunciation (0:01).
  • 0:03:14Paths of recognition, typified by Zen and Dzogchen. His regard for the early Dharma (0:05).
  • 0:06:38Bahiya (Ud 1:10): the deva's prompt, and the urgent request on the alms round (0:09–0:10).
  • 0:11:08"In reference to the seen, only the seen." Bahiya's awakening and death (0:12–0:13).
  • 0:14:35A bridge to the later traditions: Naropa meets Tilopa by the river (0:16).
  • 0:18:13Tilopa's Ganges Mahamudra: mind without a focal point (0:19), and non-meditation (0:21).
  • 0:23:09Studying this won't bring you an inch closer.
  • 0:24:23The torrent, the Ganges and the sea. For those of lesser ability, the winds and a consort (0:25), and the tantric "carrots" (0:26).
  • 0:28:27With recognition, the defilements transform into the five wisdoms.
  • 0:29:16His advice: persist in gradual practice. Mipham on gaining stability (0:30–0:31).
  • 0:33:31Eyes-open exercise: is there a boundary between inside and outside (0:34)? Your mind is already empty and awake (0:36).
  • 0:38:05"Just this" is what's meant by Buddha, and by bodhicitta.

Q&A

  • 0:39:05The subject–object split persists. Open awareness before recognition, and Longchenpa on ordinary mind versus awareness (0:41–0:43).
  • 0:47:04Looking for the looker feels like derealization; samadhi feels more real.
  • 0:50:46From the second jhana to the third: letting go of the remnants of agitation (0:53).
  • 0:53:15How body and space change from the second to the third. Does the body disappearing mean stronger concentration (0:55)?
  • 0:55:44Is there a place here for ritual, offering and ceremony? Are they necessary (0:58), and where can you learn more (0:59)?
  • 0:59:46What that object is: a vajra, and what it symbolizes (1:01).
  • 1:01:51How the jhanas relate to enlightenment, and the "ninth jhana" (SN 38:1, SN 43).
Friday, November 13 · Morning

Edited transcript. The time at the start of each paragraph is where it begins in the recording above; drag the player to that point to listen. Participants' names are omitted. [Square brackets] mark editorial insertions; [unclear] marks words that couldn't be made out.

0:00:00Namo tassa bhagavato arahato sammā-sambuddhassa (three times). This might have been a useful frame (I've referenced it at least once in the talks so far), and it might have been useful to introduce it at the beginning: among Buddhist paths, we could class them into three types, three methods. There's renunciation, which is typified quite beautifully in the early tradition, in what you'll find in the Pali Canon and in extant Theravadan schools, which really emphasize a monastic, renunciate mode of life and an at least provisional relationship to phenomena, to attenuate and then completely release the craving and aversion that prop up ignorance. And I think it's safe to say that all of us could do with renunciation to some extent. Not necessarily putting on robes and shaving your head, but at least letting go of those things that keep us locked into habituated patterning that isn't bringing us any closer into alignment with our goals, whether that's deeper samadhi, some degree of awakening, or even conventional secular aims.1

0:01:48How often do we find that we're not using our time in a way we reflectively endorse? So outer and inner renunciation of habits and patterns and activities and all these things is very helpful. Very helpful. I know I wouldn't have gotten along (I'm just not that disciplined) without pretty strict training containers and a good bit of outer renunciation, at least for a time, and I still find it very useful, hence my going back to [unclear] boot camp in a couple of weeks. So there are paths of renunciation, or paths that emphasize renunciation. Then there are paths of transformation, where you work with the raw material of the body and psyche and energy. These would be typified by something like tantric methods and approaches, where you take all the latent energy bound up in afflictive tendencies and use methods of visualization and of manipulating energies within the body to purify and transform it into wisdom. The same kind of realization of emptiness and selflessness will result, but the outer expression and the method will differ.

0:03:14And then there are paths of recognition. This might be typified more by Zen, in many presentations, and by Dzogchen and Mahamudra, these more immediate, direct paths (or at least that's how they're advertised). This is recognition of the mind's empty, selfless nature, and returning to that recognition, letting the afflictions, the craving and aversion, unbind as a result of that recognition. Not through abandoning anything, outer or inner, or transforming anything: simply by recognition, like snowflakes hitting a hot surface, they dissolve on contact. That's how craving and aversion, the afflictions, are liberated. If you actually look at the biographies of most of the people held up within these various traditions, you'll find that most people end up practicing some mixture, and it's rare to find a pure type expressed. And while the flashier transformational path, or the apparently more immediate path, may appear more appealing, you'll remember the simile of the mountain cow who leaps ahead without firmly placing her feet, loses her way, and is unable to return. All of that to say: because of my own wandering and wavering tendencies, I've had the occasion and opportunity to practice all these different paths, and I've found that the emptiness and selflessness and the freedom that results have the same taste, even as the methods, the aesthetic outer expression, or the norms of conduct might differ.

0:05:27And I really value and treasure the path and the perspective in the early Dharma. It has been so vital and useful in my own life, and continues to be, and it's mostly what I've been sharing from. But today we're going to take a bit of a turn, and you'll find that kind of recognitional (if that's a word) frame in the early tradition as well. So I'll be making a bit of a bridge this morning. This will be the last of the instructions, and tonight (maybe I'll say some words) it'll be more open for any lingering questions about jhana, about vipassana, about what I'll introduce this morning. Then tomorrow I don't think there'll be a morning session. I want to leave the last full day for you all, here and at home. Pretty soon this retreat is going to be over, and you'll not be on your own (I mean, keep in touch), but take whatever you've learned and put into practice so far, and just keep going with it.

0:06:38You don't need any more words from me. Then we'll have a final send-off tomorrow evening, with an opportunity for questions and some parting words and advice about leaving retreat, and we'll really finish and wrap up on Sunday. So, picking up from yesterday: "Where do water, earth, fire and wind have no footing? Where are long and short, coarse and fine, fair and foul, name and form brought to a stop without trace? The answer to that is: consciousness without surface, without end, luminous all around. Here water, earth, fire and wind have no footing. Here long and short, coarse and fine, fair and foul, here name and form are all brought to a stop without trace. With the cessation of the aggregate of consciousness, each is here brought to a stop." And then the Bahiya Sutta, very famous. This is the student of the Buddha who was the quickest, the most apt. There are cues within the sutta: we can tell that Bahiya was already a very well-practiced yogi, probably quite skilled in meditation of various types, and was of the opinion that he had attained some degree of awakening, some degree of liberation.23

0:08:12But, the story goes, a deva who had been a relative of his sees him confused (a mighty meditator, a powerful renunciate yogi, but actually just very confused), and the deva comes down and says to him: "You, Bahiya, are neither an arahant nor have you entered the path of arahantship. You don't even have the practice whereby you would become an arahant or enter the path of arahantship." Ass-backwards: you don't know what the hell is going on. And Bahiya replies: "Then who in this world with its devas are arahants, or have entered the path to arahantship?" "Bahiya, there is a city in the northern country called Savatthi. There the Blessed One, an arahant, rightly self-awakened, is living now. He truly is an arahant, and teaches the Dhamma leading to arahantship." And then Bahiya, deeply chastened by the devata, "left right then and, in the space of one night, went all the way to where the Blessed One was staying near Savatthi, at Jeta's Grove." So, a great and powerful yogi, though unrealized: you can infer he uses his psychic power to disappear and reappear halfway up the subcontinent.

0:09:20"Now on that occasion a large number of monks were doing walking meditation in the open air. He went to them and, on arrival, said, 'Where, venerable sirs, is the Blessed One, the arahant, rightly self-awakened, now staying? We want to see that Blessed One.'" He uses the royal "we." Interesting. "'We want to see that Blessed One, the arahant, rightly self-awakened.' 'The Blessed One has gone into town for alms.' Then Bahiya, hurriedly leaving Jeta's Grove and entering Savatthi, saw the Blessed One going for alms in Savatthi: serene and inspiring serene confidence, calming, his senses at peace, his mind at peace, having attained the utmost tranquility and poise, tamed, guarded, his senses restrained, a Great One. Seeing him, he approached him and, on reaching him, threw himself down, with his head at the Blessed One's feet: 'Teach me the Dhamma, O Blessed One! Teach me the Dhamma, O One Well-Gone, that will be for my long-term welfare and bliss.' When this was said, the Blessed One said to him, 'This is not the time, Bahiya. We have entered the town for alms.'"

0:10:16"I'm trying to get my meal here. Later." "A second time, Bahiya said to the Blessed One, 'But it is hard to know for sure what dangers there may be for your life, or what dangers there may be for mine. Teach me the Dhamma, O Blessed One! Teach me the Dhamma, O One Well-Gone, that will be for my long-term welfare and bliss.' A second time, the Blessed One said to him, 'This is not the time, Bahiya. We have entered the town for alms.' A third time, Bahiya said to the Blessed One, 'But it is hard to know for sure what dangers there may be for the Blessed One's life, or what dangers there may be for mine. Teach me the Dhamma, O Blessed One! Teach me the Dhamma, O One Well-Gone, that will be for my long-term welfare and bliss.'" And so, having been asked sincerely for the Dhamma three times, the Buddha can't refuse. It's just a rule, I don't know. "'Then, Bahiya, you should train yourself thus: In reference to the seen, there will be only the seen.

0:11:08"'In reference to the heard, only the heard. In reference to the sensed, only the sensed. In reference to the cognized, only the cognized. That is how you should train yourself. When for you there will be only the seen in reference to the seen, only the heard in reference to the heard, only the sensed in reference to the sensed, only the cognized in reference to the cognized, then, Bahiya, there is no you in connection with that. When there is no you in connection with that, there is no you there. When there is no you there, you are neither here nor yonder nor between the two. This, just this, is the end of dukkha.'" The end of stress, the end of suffering. "Through hearing this brief explanation of the Dhamma from the Blessed One, the mind of Bahiya of the Bark-cloth right then and there was released from effluents through lack of clinging. Having exhorted Bahiya of the Bark-cloth with this brief explanation of the Dhamma, the Blessed One left. Not long after the Blessed One's departure, Bahiya was attacked and killed by a cow with a young calf."

0:12:12Turned out he was right to be so urgent: a full awakening, and then, who knows how long, minutes or a couple of hours later, gored by a cow. Whoops. "Then the Blessed One, having gone for alms in Savatthi, after the meal, returning from his alms round with a large number of monks, saw that Bahiya had died. On seeing him, he said to the monks, 'Take Bahiya's body, monks, and placing it on a litter and carrying it away, cremate it and build him a memorial. Your companion in the holy life has died.' Responding, 'As you say, lord,' to the Blessed One, the monks, placing Bahiya's body on a litter, carrying it away, cremating it and building him a memorial, went to the Blessed One. On arrival, having bowed down to him, they sat to one side. As they were sitting there, they said to him, 'Bahiya's body has been cremated, lord, and his memorial has been built. What is his destination? What is his future state?' 'Monks, Bahiya of the Bark-cloth was wise. He practiced the Dhamma in accordance with the Dhamma, and did not pester me with issues related to the Dhamma.

0:13:11"'Bahiya of the Bark-cloth, monks, is totally unbound.' Then, on realizing the significance of that, the Blessed One on that occasion exclaimed: 'Where water, earth, fire and wind have no footing...'" (the same as the last verse from the other sutta) "'Where water, earth, fire and wind have no footing: there the stars don't shine, the sun is invisible, there the moon doesn't appear, there darkness is not found.'" Again, these paired opposites: the elements and the paired dualities. "'There the moon doesn't appear, there darkness is not found. And when a sage, a brahman through sagacity, has realized this for himself, then from form and formless, from bliss and pain, he is freed.'" In the seen, only the seen; in the heard, only the heard; in the sensed, in the cognized, only the cognized, without a you in connection with that. Neither here nor there. So again, this collapse, this breakage of the duality of perceiver and perceived, of supposing a self within the aggregates, within the senses: that comes to a halt. When there's no you, there's no here nor there,

0:14:35and one's unbound from space and time, distance and duality. So I'll use this as a bridge to the later tradition. The characterizations you'll find in Zen and in various tantric traditions, Mahamudra, Dzogchen, are often more positive, perhaps sounding a little more appealing, or a little less puzzling. These are the Ganges Mahamudra instructions that Tilopa gave to Naropa. Some of you may be familiar with the story of Naropa; there's a university here in Boulder named for the great mahasiddha. By some accounts he was a renowned and learned scholar, who had risen to a high position at the foremost Buddhist university of the time, Nalanda, and he was quite proud of his knowledge and his learning. One day a dakini, a female spirit of wisdom, appeared to him and asked whether he knew the heart and essence of the Dharma. He replied confidently that he did, and then she began to weep, because in fact it was only a conceptual knowledge he held, and she wept for him and his confusion.4

0:16:29But she told him of Tilopa, this shady character who hung out by the river, who could help him out. And, depending on the story, Naropa went through many hardships and practiced quite a bit, and at some point, so it's said, Tilopa gave Naropa these instructions: "Wise Naropa, you have accepted suffering and endured hardships with devotion to the guru, so take this to heart, you fortunate one. Mahamudra..." (that's the great seal; the seal here is usually explained as emptiness, or as mind, and actually the unity of the two: mind, emptiness and appearance) "Mahamudra cannot be explained." And yet here we are. "Yet in space, what depends on what? Likewise, your own mind, Mahamudra, has no supporting ground. When you relax..." That's all of you: when you relax. "When you relax in an unaltered, natural state, the bonds are released, and you are undoubtedly freed. When you gaze into the midst of the sky, fixed concepts of center and boundary will cease. Likewise, when mind looks at mind, thoughts will cease, and you see the nature of mind. When mist and clouds disperse into the sky, they neither go nor remain anywhere.

0:18:13"Likewise, the waves of thoughts arising in the mind subside when mind sees itself. As space transcends color and form, it is changeless, not tinted black or white. So too, your own mind is beyond color and shape, untainted by the light and dark phenomena of good and evil. Just as the brilliant essence of the sun is not obscured by the darkness of a thousand eons, so too the luminous essence of mind cannot be darkened by eons of samsara. Though space may be described as empty, space itself cannot be expressed in this way. Likewise, although mind's nature may be pointed out as luminous, there is no basis for labeling it through any such expression. Thus the nature of mind is like space: there is no phenomenon not included in it. Abandon all physical activities and rest at ease. Be silent, and let words be like an echo. Without a single thought, look at the definitive experience that lies beyond the mind. The body has no essence, just like a hollow bamboo reed. Mind, like open space, transcends the realm of thought.

0:19:28"Place your mind within this state, neither confining it nor allowing it to roam. Mind without a focal point is Mahamudra. By habituating yourself to this, you will attain supreme awakening. Proponents of the secret mantra" (that's another name for Vajrayana, tantric Buddhism) "and the paramita vehicle" (that's the bodhisattva path), "the vinaya" (that's the discipline, the rules upheld by renunciate practitioners) "and the other scriptural authorities will not reveal the luminosity of Mahamudra by expounding on their texts in philosophical traditions. [unclear] luminosity cannot be seen. Observing vows conceptually..." (on an outer level, following the letter but not the spirit) "Observing vows conceptually, you betray the point of actual vows. In a mind without engagement, free of wanting anything, thoughts arise and subside on their own, like ripples on water. Neither focused on an object nor abiding anywhere, if you do not wander from the actual truth, the unimpaired vow is a light in the darkness. If, free of any wish, you do not dwell in the extremes, you will see the meaning of the Buddha's teachings, all without exception.

0:20:48"If you heed this truth, you will be liberated from the prison of samsara. If you settle in it evenly, the veils of negativity and ignorance will be burnt away. Thus it is referred to as the torch of the teachings. Foolish people who lack interest in this truth are forever being carried off by the torrents of samsara, and their misery will never end. How sad that they experience the intolerable pains of evil states! If you want release from these sorrows, rely on a wise teacher, and when the blessings infuse you, your mind will be freed. Kye ho! Because engagement in worldly affairs is a meaningless cause of suffering and is without essence, look at the essence of the ultimate truth. Transcending every dualistic notion of perceiver and perceived is the king of views. Being undistracted is the king of meditation. Making no deliberate effort is the king of conduct. Having neither hope nor fear is to realize the fruition. Mind is luminous by nature, devoid of any reference point. Without a path to tread, you enter the path of the buddhas.

0:21:48"When you become habituated to non-meditation, you will attain unsurpassed awakening. Alas! Look closely at worldly phenomena. Like dreams and illusions, they cannot last." Until this is clear to you within your own experience, keep meditating on those three characteristics. "Look closely at worldly phenomena. Like dreams and illusions, they cannot last. Dreams and illusions do not actually exist. Therefore develop disenchantment, and abandon worldly activities. When you cut through the bonds of attachment and aversion to people and places, meditate alone in forests and mountain retreats" (or in Gabe's house). "Remain there in a natural state of non-meditation. When you attain non-attainment, you attain Mahamudra. Cut the root of a living tree, and its hundreds of thousands of branches and leaves will wither. Likewise, by severing the root of the mind, the foliage of samsara will perish. The darkness of a thousand eons is dispelled by the light of a single lamp. Likewise, the luminous clarity of mind instantly dispels the negativities and obscurations amassed over eons. Kye ho! The intellect cannot see the truth that transcends the intellect." Right?

0:23:09Thinking about this, studying, talking about it, won't bring you an inch closer, ever. It might induce you to practice, and that might do some good. But "the intellect cannot see the truth that transcends the intellect. You will not discover the truth beyond action by means of deliberate action." As we were talking about last night: the path, all these practices, are fabricated, and they bring you to the brink, the brink of letting go. But for that final leap, on the edge of a ledge, you have to let go of the branch you're clinging to. "If you want to attain the truth transcending mind and effort, cut through the root of the mind and rest in naked awareness. Allow the water, muddied by discursive thoughts, to settle naturally. Without affirming or negating what arises, leave it as it is. When there is no acceptance or rejection, appearances are liberated into Mahamudra. The unborn ground of all is free from the obscuring veils of karmic imprints. But in the unborn essence, without discriminating between meditation and post-meditation..." This means all the time,

0:24:23every moment. "When you recognize appearances as self-projections, the phenomena produced by the conceptual mind will cease to be." When we don't recognize appearances as self-projections, attraction and aversion occur, and on that basis the mind proliferates, and there's no end. When appearances are recognized as empty self-projections: hands off, and the proliferation winds down and ceases on its own. "Release from all extremes is the foremost king of views. Boundless, deep and vast is the foremost king of meditation. Natural and effortless abiding is the foremost king of conduct. Natural abiding, free of any hope, is the foremost king of fruition. In the beginning, mind is like a torrent rushing down a gorge." Sound familiar? The stream of thoughts and emotions and hindrances and annoyances and irritation and wanting and wishing and not wanting and pushing away. "In the beginning, mind is like a torrent rushing down a gorge. In the middle, it flows gently, like the river Ganges." When there's some stability in practice, it's steady, powerful, like a broad, deep river. "In the end, it's like a stream returning to the sea, its mother."

0:25:48Coming home. "If those of lesser ability cannot abide in this state, they should hold the key points of the winds and cast awareness into the essence." This refers to tantric methods: if one can't attain some recognition and then begin to rest in it, there are the more engaged paths of transformation or renunciation. (He doesn't say that here; I'm adding it.) "Through various gazes and ways of focusing the mind, persevere until you abide in awareness." I'm not going to go into this on this retreat. "When you rely on a consort, the wisdom of empty bliss will arise. So enter into union, the blessing of method and wisdom. Bring it down slowly, hold it, reverse it, draw it back up, bring it to the places in the body, and let it spread throughout." Hey, does that sound familiar? Piti practice, anyone? Spreading empty bliss through the body: there's some similarity. "When you remain free of desire, the wisdom of empty bliss will appear. Like the waxing moon, your life will expand, without graying hair."

0:26:50Funny: these tantric texts also include these carrots. If you do these practices, you'll live long and be hot: "like the waxing moon, your life will expand, without graying hair. You will have a radiant presence and the strength of a lion. You will swiftly achieve the common attainments and enter the ultimate city" (the ultimate accomplishment). "May this essential advice on Mahamudra dwell within the hearts of fortunate ones." That's you: if you're here and you heard that, you're fortunate. So, as was brought up last night, letting defilements be liberated by defilement: when there's some recognition and stability in the nature of mind, there's no need for transformation, no need for an antidote, like a snake uncoiling itself, like ripples in water left to settle on their own. Here are some passages that get at that: "The essence of an angry mind is clear awareness, empty yet luminous the moment you recognize it. This nature is called mirror-like wisdom." In the later tradition the three root afflictions are sometimes expanded to five, and their converse are the five wisdoms.5

0:28:27So when you recognize the nature of mind, through transformation or recognition, the defilements transform into a wisdom display. "The essence of a confused mind is luminous natural awareness, wide awake the moment you gaze into its face. This vital nature is called the wisdom of the dharmadhatu. The essence of a proud mind is the expression of natural awareness, naturally empty the moment you leave it in its place. This state is called the wisdom of evenness. The essence of a desirous mind is lustful attachment, but sustained without clinging it is empty bliss. This nature is called the wisdom of discernment. The essence of a jealous mind is dualistic grasping, but when left in its place it is nakedly free. This nature is called the all-accomplishing wisdom."

0:29:16So my sincere, heartfelt advice: through whatever means, persist in systematic, diligent, gradual practice until everything that just came out of my mouth is as clear to you as the palm of your hand. And until that point, keep going; don't stop; it's worth it. I'm concluding. This is from Mipham Rinpoche, referring to the nature of mind: "Once you have familiarized yourself with this again and again, the waves of thought will weaken, and the face of rigpa..." (rigpa means knowing one's own state, knowing the nature of mind) "...the face of rigpa that you are sustaining will grow clearer. During meditation, remain in this experience for as long as you can, and in post-meditation, maintain the mindfulness of recalling the face of rigpa. If you can familiarize yourself with this, the strength of rigpa will increase. Thoughts will continue to arise at first, but without your having to resort to any other remedy in order to stop them, they will be freed by themselves in an instant, simply by leaving them as they are, like a snake uncoiling its own knots by itself.6

0:30:50"Then, with further familiarity, rising thoughts will continue to bring some slight disturbance, but will dissolve immediately by themselves, like writing on water. As you become still more familiar with this state, you will reach a point at which rising thoughts no longer have any effect at all, and you have no hope or fear about their arising or non-arising. This experience beyond benefit and harm is likened to a thief entering an empty house. By continuing to familiarize yourself with this, you will reach the level of perfect strength, at which thoughts and the alaya..." (the storehouse consciousness, out of which karmic impressions form into the various afflictions and mental activities) "...together with any tendency to produce movement in the mind, all dissolve into unaltered dharmakaya" (the body of Dharma, the body of absolute reality, emptiness). "When rigpa is secure in its own place, then, just as you might search for ordinary earthen stones on an island of gold without ever finding them, the whole of appearance and existence, without exception, arises as a dharmakaya realm in which purity is all-encompassing.

0:31:50"This is known as gaining stability, the point at which any hopes and anxieties about samsara and nirvana, or birth and death, are eradicated entirely. As in this way daytime perceptions and thoughts are gradually brought into rigpa's domain, during the nighttime too there is no need to rely on any other instruction, as this can be applied to dreams and to the recognition of the clear light of sleep. Having understood this, you must persist in the practice until you gain stability, with unflagging diligence like the continuous flow of a river." I might have been a little too ambitious with my slate of topics for this retreat, tracing the course through the early samadhi and insight practices and culminating in the non-dual view you'll find in the later tradition, but here we are. I'll leave a little time for questions, but for now I recommend we all do a little exercise, and then we can have time for questions and then sit. Most of us have been meditating most of the week with eyes closed. But now open your eyes and gaze straight ahead.

0:33:31If someone is directly in your field of vision and that's disturbing, you could move slightly to the side, so that you can just stare as though gazing at a far-distant horizon, as though staring through the world without any obstruction, without the gaze or the mind or attention fixing on anything within the field of vision: relaxed, unfixated, unfocused, clear, side to side, top to bottom. Let whatever bodily sensations there are arise and pass away without any interference, and likewise emotions or thoughts. If you find your mind landing, fixating, finding a footing anywhere, drop it, let it go, and reorient back to this wide-open gaze and experience of awareness.

0:34:56And as you rest, free from grasping internally or externally, do you find that there's a boundary between inside and outside? Does your awareness discriminate between "here I am" and "there that is"?

0:36:19Your own mind is already empty, already entirely awake, and all the light and color and sound and movement that appears is your own mind's insubstantial, magical display. When you neither embrace nor reject phenomena as they appear, they lose their concreteness. The elements find no footing, duality collapses, and mind is without center, without edge, without inside, without outside, without near or far, then or now: unbound, unrestricted, empty and awake. And all the forms, in movement and stillness, are the mirror-like play of the face of your own mind.

0:38:05"Just this" is what is meant by the word "Buddha," "awake." "Just this" is what is meant by "bodhicitta." If you recognize and remain in this, there's nothing else to do.

0:39:05All right, that's it. Any questions? "Yeah. During that exercise, when you asked whether there seems to be a separation between in here and out there: the answer for me is definitely yes. And I'm fully bought in to the idea that all these appearances are mental projections; what else could they be? But even believing that's the case, unfocusing my eyes so there aren't distinct external objects, trying my best not to bring any conceptual analysis to bear, I still get the very clear sense that this appearance in my mind represents things such that the stuff in the visual field is out there, and I, observing it, am in here." Yeah. So carry on with the gradual practice. Make your mind malleable, wieldy, bright, attained to imperturbability. Take up the three characteristics, if it's helpful, and keep looking until it's clear. "Sure. Okay. The way I learned this style of meditation was that you sit in this open awareness, and it's just going to take a while until you have that recognition.

0:41:42You do that, and then you have the recognition, and then you try to stabilize it. But my sense of what you're saying is: no, not so much; you recognize this, and then you do this. Do you think there's something harmful, or just downright useless, about doing this until you've had a recognition? I'll pause there." Yeah. That does work for some people. Resting in a looser or more open state of awareness, reification and self-play can just diminish over time, and one may arrive at a genuine recognition of the nature of mind that way. So, let's see. This is from a different text, quoting, I believe, Longchenpa. (The oxen, poor beasts of burden: they get a lot of blame laid at their feet in Buddhist texts.) "These days, the oxen who consider themselves followers of Ati" (another name for Dzogchen) "claim that discursive thought is awakened mind. Such fools are lost in the realm of darkness, far from the meaning of the natural great perfection."7

0:43:14And then a comment on that quote from Longchenpa: "If you fail to discern between ordinary mind and awareness, you will develop erroneous views concerning cause and effect and so on, as you stray from the correct path, on which conduct and views are in harmony. While abiding within the naturally settled and undistracted state, awareness is without fixation, like the sky, and no matter what circumstances arise, be they good or bad, there is not the slightest benefit or harm from hope and fear, joy and sorrow. However, should you become distracted even slightly when the conditions mentioned above are met, thoughts of desiring happiness and avoiding sadness will occur, and karma will accumulate. This is the ordinary mind. The metaphor of clouds in the sky will serve us well. Awareness needs to be stable, like a perfectly clear sky, and the aspects of mind must be dispersible, like clouds within the sky. Through this, you will be able to discern between awareness and the ordinary mind." So the risk of doing that is... and, sad to say, I've met practitioners in Zen and other contexts who are decades and decades into their practice,

0:44:19and, by their own admission, when they sit they're experiencing the ordinary mind, and not the "ordinary mind" that refers to recognizing the natural state. They're just distracted and oscillating between hope and fear, fixation, desire, aversion: just circling in muddy water. Partly because of that potential tragedy (honestly, that someone could be motivated to practice, could have encountered the Dharma, could have put in decades of continuous engagement, and then realize that), I really strongly recommend, rather than this, that you develop exceptionally strong samadhi, so that when there's recognition it will be doubtless, and one can actually remain in it. And the likelihood that recognition may occur as a function of doing these more gradual practices is much greater. So I suppose this is my opinion; you're on my retreat, so that's what you're getting. If you don't have a doubtless recognition, in which the nature of your mind is as clear as the palm of your hand, at least in a way you can begin to access regularly;

0:45:45if there's any doubt whatsoever, it's better to stick to gradual practices. "Okay, thank you." [Participant]? I'm not sure who was first. "Doing Dzogchen practice like that can make the world feel less real for me; I kind of derealize. Whereas when I come out of jhana it feels like, 'Oh wow, things are really here.' It feels almost as if I can see things in a lot more detail, as if the signal-to-noise ratio is boosted, but it's kind of empty: I can see there's nothing beyond it, but I can see it all. Whereas the other states were like everything's just kind of cloud, and it doesn't matter as much; I can see my body and sensations and the world, but they're sort of [unclear] and not really grabbing. Those feel like very different states, and maybe they turn around and become the same thing, but I certainly prefer the one where things feel bright and luminous, and maybe also empty. Does that make sense?"

0:47:04I lost track of which you were referring to in your description. So there's a slight derealization flavor when you go with something like open awareness [unclear], and then things feel bright, but somehow more real or substantial, coming out of samadhi? Or what's...? "Yeah. With looking for the looker, the staring sort of stuff, it tends more towards derealization, which doesn't feel great. And then with samadhi it's like, 'Oh wow, bam,' it's almost like I'm really here too, and the world is really here, and it's all bright and I can see it all, but maybe I'm not attached to it necessarily, or maybe I see it as empty; I can see the emptiness around all of it. Does that make sense? It takes longer to explain than it is, but they feel like opposite directions. Is that confused in some way?" I don't think you're confused. The experience is just oscillating; it's maturing. Also, if you begin to have some partial perception of emptiness (in which the apparent external world, or the body, comes up; in insight practice working with the characteristics as well), if there's still a trace of duality, if subject and object haven't collapsed, it may feel freaky: "The ground, the world, is falling out, and here I am, and I feel like, oh, I don't..." So there may be some discomfort with that. And with instructions like these, you can also move in an unhealthy and unhelpful dissociative direction, where you lose contact with bodily sensation and emotionality, and people can space out in a quasi-unitive or quasi-non-dual trance, but they're actually just dissociating really hard.

0:49:13So: "By their fruits ye shall know them." Genuine experience doesn't result in emotional numbness, or in things that have recognizable markers of clinical dissociation. I don't have any particular comment beyond that. Something that might be interesting to try is to go deeply into samadhi and then, with that as a basis, open up. That can be a very powerful combination. And a note about shamatha and vipassana: these are two aspects of meditation training, categorizations of different practices. But the practices of shamatha and the practices of vipassana are both brought to their culmination, find their culmination, in recognition of the nature of mind. So recognition of the nature of mind, and familiarizing and stabilizing in it, also fulfills shamatha and vipassana. You're just coming at it from different angles, with different methods. The nature of mind, when it's recognized and rested within, is immovable, vast, unshakable, imperturbable, clear and bright: all the characteristics we associate with shamatha, with deepening samadhi.

0:50:46And the nature of all phenomena is vividly clear and empty, all fabrications being impermanent, and any clinging and aversion is shown up in sharp relief as stressful, unsatisfactory. So there's convergence. "I have a practice question. I'd love for you to speak more about the transition between the second and third jhanas, as far as whether I'm on the right track or not. There are sukha fields, a little fuzzy. And then it seems, in the second, it kind of feels like... I don't know. Here are a couple of things; I don't know if this is the transition, or if you can speak to it. The breath almost starts breathing itself a little, and it almost feels more like a toddler starts to [unclear]... I don't know. But I guess I'm also curious: if you were to try to push it over intentionally, how would you do it?" Yeah.

0:52:11In the second jhana there's still piti, but it's calmed way down; it's like a warm seltzer with just a little carbonation left. In transitioning down to the third, all that fizz, all that buzz, goes away, and the sukha calms down to a more refined texture of deep contentment. "But no piti?" No piti at all. If there's any piti left, you're at the bottom of the second, or slowly transitioning to the third. As for making that transition voluntarily, there are different things you can do, but much the same as from the first to the second: you may find it helpful to sweep your attention down through the body, to invite the piti to come down, at the same time as switching the attention from the piti to the sukha; except in this case you're just sweeping, letting the piti go down.

0:53:15A long out-breath, an extended out-breath, might also help settle the energy in the body. "So it's almost like letting go of the remnants of agitation." Yeah, exactly. "And do you find insight helps with that?" Yeah. You also mentioned the breath breathing itself. That's just a characteristic: if you're bringing in an anatta way of looking, in Rob's frame, that might help deepen the samadhi, might calm the state. But it's also just characteristic of moving into deeper absorption: the sense of doing anything goes. And the... no, sorry, I lost the train. Was there another part to the question? "I guess I'm curious about the sense of body and space. Do those transform from the second to the third?" They can. Generally, through the whole jhanic arc, the slide, you're moving in the direction of de-reification. So you may find there are bodily changes.

0:54:37But (not that these are real, but as an ideal type of the first four jhanas) what's mostly changing is just the ratio and intensity of the factors: strong piti and sukha in the first; piti way down, sukha more refined and more predominant, in the second; then piti gone and sukha refined in the third; and then that has drained away too in the fourth. So you may find the body de-reifying more and more. If you're feeling boundaries to the body, internal and external, then as samadhi deepens the body may come to have no clearly defined edges. That's characteristic both of deep access concentration and of moving into further depth of jhana: you may feel like a field, or an egg, or just an ill-defined blob of the jhanic factors. If the concentration is really strong, there may just not be a felt sense of the body at all, only the sense of factors in the field.

0:55:44"Yeah. Awesome. So if the body is disappearing, or de-reifying more, that means your concentration is stronger?" Yeah, that's it. "In this space, is there any place for ritual, offering, ceremony [unclear]? Those are things that are part of my being alive, very normal, and maybe some odd things come up in those spaces. Here, for so many days, I haven't done some of those things, or maybe I encounter something in the meditation and I think [unclear], and I'm like, 'Wow, I don't know if maybe I'm too into those things. Maybe there's a disparate [unclear], and I just need to let them go.' I thought no, because there's a thing that happens, an opening happens, with those. So I'm conflicted about that. You might say something about it; I haven't studied these traditions. Is there such a thing?"

0:57:07"[unclear] a little incense going on." Yeah, absolutely. You're on a retreat in a cultural context in which the kinds of Buddhadharma that have flourished are what's sometimes referred to as Protestant Buddhism: kind of de-traditionalized, de-ritualized, so that a lot of those more traditional elements often aren't presented. And there's a mixture of people on this retreat, and if I bring in too heavy a ritual and religious element, I might scare some folks away. I like all that stuff. The places where I go on retreat have rich ritual, offering, chanting, all these things, which serve as very supportive conditions for samadhi, for insight, for the raising of bodhicitta, for the sense of devotion, all of these things. We don't want to cling to the rituals, but they're incredibly powerful and useful. Just like the path and all the practices, they're fabricated, indeed like everything, and they're incredibly powerful and useful and amazing and beautiful.

0:58:23I mean, I like my ritual objects and toys. "Yeah. [unclear]. Do we need to think those things are necessary?" No. They're not necessary. "It's like a double channel. There are many parts of it, life experiences and things that sparked from so many places, and now I'm like, wow, I need that piece." Yeah. Bring it back in. If you want to do some... I don't know if you have what you need here to do stuff, but feel free. "I did a little stuff with what I have, and the land outside [unclear]." Yeah. That goes for everybody. If you find ritual and more devotional elements helpful, or if that calls you, do it. Go for it. It's a rich vein in my own life and practice, but not something I usually bring out in teaching contexts, because most people aren't that into it, or [unclear]; that might change.

0:59:46Who knows? I promise not ever to wear a funny hat, but... Yes, well, I ran out of other clean clothes, and technically this is the monastic work wear you'd wear while cleaning or working outdoors, so it's not even that formal. "Sorry, I just have a smaller question: if I wanted to learn more about what these traditions might say about that kind of thing?" Yeah, we can talk afterwards. So many. So many. Okay, and I can give you recommendations, for sure. "I was just going to ask what that object is." Yeah, this is a vajra, a symbol coming from the god Indra: his vajra. That deity, in Indo-European mythological traditions, is kind of cognate with Zeus and the Nordic gods of thunder and lightning. If you look at just this part, you can see it's like a fork, like forked lightning, and it's double-headed here.

1:01:10So it represents the lightning, the power of realization. Another meaning of vajra is diamond, so it's indestructible, like the nature of mind. Lots and lots of meanings. The five prongs can represent the five wisdoms, the five Buddha families, the five aggregates, the five elements. If you like symbolic correspondences and rituals, if you enjoy that stuff, there are spades you can get into.

1:01:51"Could you describe more of how the jhanas relate to enlightenment? And what is the ninth jhana, and how does that relate to enlightenment? Because my understanding is that the ninth one is enlightenment, right? Or just a taste of it still? But the jhanas are an important step on the path, and helpful for becoming enlightened, but you don't need to go through all the jhanas to become enlightened. Is that correct?" Yeah. There are differences of opinion here. What's clear is that the jhanas are not awakening. Again, some people refer to the cessation of perception and feeling as the ninth jhana: much as the formless attainments are referred to as jhanas 5, 6, 7 and 8, if you add the cessation of perception and feeling, you could refer to these as nine jhanas. But no, they're not awakening, and the cessation of perception and feeling likewise isn't. Depending on whom you ask or what text you read, one already has to be relatively far along in the awakening process to attain it, but there are variant opinions even on that.

1:03:16What's obvious is that attainment of, mastery of, fluency in these states certainly makes the insight that does lead to awakening (to unbinding, to the release of clinging and craving and becoming, and everything else we've been talking about) much more likely, much easier. Does that answer the question? "Yeah, totally. Thank you." There's also this (and I'm wading into controversial waters here): there are some extant Theravada schools, lineages and lines of interpretation that understand nibbana to be a kind of ultimate dhamma, an ultimate phenomenon. They take the cessation of nama-rupa, name and form, very literally, to mean that at the moment of a path attainment there's necessarily a cessation of name and form, a cessation of consciousness entirely. And some will say that immersion in the cessation of perception and feeling is a foretaste of the state of a fully awakened being after death. You can find readings and interpretations to support that.

1:04:42I like (and it's my retreat, my opinion, my bias) the passages in the canon where it's very clean: nibbana is not an object, not a phenomenon, not a thing. It is the ending of passion, aversion and delusion. And you can characterize that positively as the deathless, as the unafflicted, as peace, as the ending of all fabrications, as consciousness without surface, because without passion, aversion and delusion there's no reification; there's no way for the mind to land, fix and proliferate. See for yourself. Make up your own mind. "Okay, thank you." Okay. If you do want to practice this kind of open style in concert with the deep samadhi we've been cultivating all retreat, I'd recommend sequencing them. Get as deeply concentrated as you can, and then, coming out of that, you could carry on with the three characteristics. You could practice eyes open and see what that brings. If there was some experience, some recognition, see if you can return to it and remain and rest in it. And may we all practice well, and realize what there is to realize.89

1:06:30Let's take ten, and come back and sit.

Sources

Translations are Thanissaro Bhikkhu's on dhammatalks.org unless noted.

  1. Paths of renunciation, transformation and recognition (self-liberation) The sutra / tantra / Dzogchen triad, e.g. Chögyal Namkhai Norbu, The Crystal and the Way of Light. ↩
  2. “Consciousness without surface ...” (from the night before) DN 11 Kevaddha Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN11.html ↩
  3. “In reference to the seen, there will be only the seen ...” Ud 1:10 Bahiya Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/Ud/ud1_10.html ↩
  4. Tilopa to Naropa: “Wise Naropa, you have accepted suffering ...” Tilopa, The Ganges Mahamudra Instructions, trans. Ina Bieler (Lotsawa House) lotsawahouse.org/indian-masters/tilopa/ganges-mahamudra-instruction ↩
  5. The five afflictions as the five wisdoms. Source not named in the talk. ↩
  6. Mipham Rinpoche on sustaining the face of rigpa: “like a snake uncoiling its own knots” Mipham Rinpoche (text not named in the talk) ↩
  7. “These days, the oxen who consider themselves followers of Ati ...” Attributed in the talk to Longchenpa, with a later commentary (sources not named) ↩
  8. Nibbana as “the ending of passion, the ending of aversion, the ending of delusion” SN 38:1 Nibbana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN38_1.html ↩
  9. The unfabricated and its synonyms. SN 43 Asankhata Samyutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN43.html ↩

← Thursday, November 12 · Evening · All sessions · Friday, November 13 · Evening →