Friday, November 13 · Evening
Shido Bunan’s old man and Hakuin’s Song of Zazen; Q&A on impermanence, Nagarjuna, practice after retreat, Zen and jhana, Dzogchen, vitakka and vicara
Two short Zen readings opened the penultimate evening. The long Q&A ranged from Nagarjuna and Dzogchen to practical advice for keeping practice going after the retreat.
Topics and questions in this session
Talk
- 0:00:00The penultimate night: thoughts turn to home. The five recollections.
- 0:04:37Shido Bunan's old man, reciting the nembutsu. What is at the origin of mind? "Nothing" (0:06–0:07).
- 0:08:42"If one has no self, one is the Buddha."
- 0:10:24Hakuin's Song of Zazen: "All beings by nature are Buddha, as ice by nature is water."
Q&A
- 0:13:11Why impermanence matters, and seeing it at subtler levels (0:14).
- 0:16:15Is awareness always at objects?
- 0:17:56"If one has no self, one is the Buddha": do you believe it?
- 0:19:44The Song of Zazen as poetry that opens something. Conventional designations (DN 9).
- 0:21:18Not hardening the three characteristics into new views (SN 22:122). Nagarjuna's dedicatory verse (0:23).
- 0:25:33How to get into deeper absorption.
- 0:30:07"Fifteen minutes on the object" doesn't mean fifteen minutes without thoughts (0:31).
- 0:32:01After the retreat: how much to sit to keep the momentum.
- 0:34:15Can insight help you into samadhi?
- 0:36:06How to "look for the observer." Is there an origin point to attention (0:37)?
- 0:39:28Is there anything jhana-like in Zen? Is it frowned upon (0:40)?
- 0:42:34Open-eye practice: start in access, or with eyes open? Tilopa's six nails (0:44).
- 0:44:34Samsara has no discernible beginning (SN 15:3). Dzogchen's origin myth of Samantabhadra (0:46–0:47).
- 0:49:09Recognition versus stability: consolidating blips into longer stretches.
- 0:52:20What it means to exhaust one's karma.
- 0:54:06Is trekchö a preliminary before recognition? No.
- 0:55:14How concentration practice carries over into the rest of the day (0:56).
- 0:58:16An online question about thinking playfully, with space as the object.
- 1:02:47Getting dull and trancey. A standing practice; you can enter the four jhanas standing (1:04).
- 1:04:43An online follow-up. Vitakka, vicara and ekaggata: earlier and later meanings (1:06, MN 44).
- 1:09:23To let piti expand, feel it rather than think about it.
0:00:00Good evening, everyone. The penultimate night. Around this time in a retreat, people's thoughts often turn towards what comes next: the journey home, the time afterwards, the resumption of our usual routines, maybe some shifts, some new inspirations. But there's still a little more to go, so let's stay in it as best we can. As we have all retreat, we begin with these five subjects for frequent recollection. I am of the nature to age; I have not gone beyond aging. Days and nights passing by, all of us drawing closer (we don't know when) to sickness, to death. I am of the nature to sicken; I have not gone beyond sickness. Nourished by good food and meditation, I hope everybody's feeling well, and may they continue to; but again, we don't know how long it will last, or, when we do become ill, whether that illness will be the one that ultimately ends our life. I am of the nature to die; I have not gone beyond dying. Like Bahiya of the Bark-cloth. There aren't too many cows wandering around here in Boulder, or, I assume, wherever you all are, but there's an equivalent hazard every time we get on the highway or move through traffic.12
0:02:17You never know. All that is mine, beloved and pleasing, will become otherwise, will become separated from me: our aggregates, our meditation experiences, our joys and sorrows, our possessions and relationships. None of it can be kept; none of it can be held. I am the owner of my action, heir to my action, born of my action, related to my action, and abide supported by my action. Whatever action I shall do, for good or for ill, of that I will be the heir. You can see, I hope, the accumulated power of intention to condition your mind, moment after moment, day after day. It's often easier to see that with the clarity and context, the container, of a retreat. And also the ripening of all our past action: in the absence of more stimulation and diversion, we can see the ripening of our past intentions, our habits. So let that inform how we choose and intend, moment to moment, from here on. We should frequently recollect. I'll just share a little tonight and then open it up for an open Q&A: whatever questions are lingering, about practice, about anything at all.
0:04:37But first, this is a story from Shido Bunan Zenji, Hakuin's grandfather teacher. "An old man told me the following story, which I cannot relate without a sense of deep sympathy. He said, 'These long autumn nights, I cannot sleep for thinking of things that will never come again, and for hoping for peace in a still uncertain future. Now all my friends have passed away, and the people of today with whom I should like to be acquainted look on me as a vile old man. The young ones, finding it unpleasant to be with me, walk out of the room. How miserable is this world of transmigration, where I must move constantly between the realms of hell, hungry spirits, beasts and fighting demons.' Being eager to follow the way of Buddha, he came in tears to ask what he should do. I felt very sorry for him. I asked the name of the sect to which he belonged. 'The Zen sect,' was his reply. 'Since my youth,' he continued, 'I have been deeply interested in the way of Buddha.'3
0:05:38"'What is the great way?' I asked. Working a rosary in his hands as he repeated the words, he recited the nembutsu, 'Namu Amida Butsu,' with great sincerity. Then I asked, 'From what sort of man did you seek to learn of the way?'" For those who don't know, a little more context: in some sects of East Asian Buddhism, recitation of the name of Amitabha, the Buddha of limitless light, is said to assure one's rebirth in a pure land in which the attainment of awakening is swift, easy and pleasurable. "Working the rosary in his hands as he repeated the words, he recited the nembutsu, 'Namu Amida Butsu,' with great sincerity. And then I asked, 'From what sort of man did you seek to learn of the way?' He replied, 'I studied something of Buddhist doctrine in the past, but finally, fifteen years ago, I happened to reflect that however much I might study the doctrine, it would be a great mistake not to know what my destination would be if I were to die that very moment.
0:06:40"'I asked a priest where I would go after I died. He told me that if I gained awakening, I would know the answer to my question. In order to be enlightened, he said, I would have to exhaust my karma, and in order to exhaust my karma I should chant sutras and recite the name of Buddha, and that is why I am following these practices now.' 'Tell me, then,' I asked, 'if you died now, where do you think you would go, and what would happen to you?' 'Why, I shall go to the land of bliss and become a Buddha,' he replied. 'The priest told me that when my karma was exhausted, the land of bliss would reveal itself to me.' And again I asked, 'What would happen if you died with your karma still unexhausted?' There was nothing he could say. Putting his hands together, he entreated me tearfully to give him instruction. I felt great pity for him. When I said, 'Everything is produced by the mind,' he replied, 'I suppose that's so.' When I asked, 'And what is at the origin of mind?'
0:07:36"he answered, 'Nothing.' 'It is precisely that nothing,' I said, 'that is the land of bliss. It is the Buddha, and indeed it is Zen awakening as well. You should always keep it with you.' He was delighted, and put his hands together in thanks to me, saying that in him there was neither birth nor death, and not a single thing existed in the world, not even the thought of thinking there is nothing. Perhaps this was the result of his constant earnestness in the pursuit of the Buddha way." So this is someone like Bahiya: quite ripe, and earnest, and practiced. The right moment, the right word, the right turning phrase, and he sees what there is to see. "Zen places awakening first. If you practice in accordance with this awakening, you will have peace day after day, night after night. You should never doubt this. Teaching that you will reach awakening only after you have exhausted your karma may seem reasonable, but is difficult to actualize. It is easier first to gain awakening and then to exhaust your karma.
0:08:42"This is why I said before that the Japanese are people who think little of their own selves, and are thus near to Buddha. The reason for this is: if one has no self, one is the Buddha." I don't know how true that was of the Japanese people when he wrote this; a matter of historical record, I suppose. In the 21st-century United States, where I think most of us are, people who think little of their own selves? I can't say that's true. So while all beings are by nature Buddha, some, I suppose, are further than others. And one more from Shido Bunan, who has a lovely sense of humor. (All this flapping of lips I've been doing all week long...) "The teachings of Buddhism are greatly in error. How much more in error it is to learn them." What a waste of time. "See directly, hear directly. In direct seeing, there is no one who sees. In direct hearing, there is no one who hears." And, I promise, the last text I'll share, and then I'll shut up.
0:10:24This is Hakuin's "Song of Zazen": "All beings by nature are Buddha, as ice by nature is water." We're just frozen Buddhas. "Apart from water, there is no ice; apart from beings, no Buddha. How sad that people ignore the near and search for truth afar, like someone in the midst of water crying out in thirst, like the child of a wealthy home wandering among the poor. Lost on dark paths of ignorance, we wander through the six worlds. From dark path to dark path, when shall we be freed from birth and death? Oh, the zazen of the Great Vehicle" (the Mahayana)! "To this the highest praise! Devotion, repentance, training, the many perfections: all have their source in zazen" (in meditation practice). "Those who try zazen even once wipe away beginningless crimes. Where are all the dark paths then? The Pure Land itself is near. Those who hear this truth even once and listen with a grateful heart, treasuring it, revering it, gain blessings without end. Much more, those who turn about and bear witness to self-nature that is no nature4
0:11:33"go far beyond mere doctrine. Here effect and cause are the same; the way is neither two nor three. With form that is no form, going and coming, we are never astray. With thought that is no thought, singing and dancing are the voice of the Dharma. Endless and free is the sky of samadhi, bright the full moon of wisdom! Truly, is anything missing now? Nirvana is right here, before our eyes. This very place is the Lotus Land; this very body, the Buddha." Okay. Tomorrow night I'll have some more to say on continuing the practice and transitioning out of retreat. But for now, the floor is open for any questions arising out of the practice. Any doubts? "We were speaking about this a little in my interview, but I'm curious why impermanence is important, and how we can see it. We're going to go through the aggregates to see the impermanence of each one: consciousness, and I want to say perception. How can we see the impermanence of those?" Did the question come through? Can you hear?
0:13:11Why is impermanence important? We impute a kind of substantiality and solidity and lastingness, if not actual permanence, to things, and that serves as a ground for our craving, our clinging, and then for the formation of identity on the basis of something we assume to be solid, lasting and real in a way that it isn't. So seeing through that directly, in all the senses, in all the aggregates, frees us from that craving and clinging and from that mistaken formation of substantial identity. So it's one route to the deathless. And how you work that through the aggregates, through the sense bases, however you want to slice the pie of experience, is through direct observation. The stronger the concentration the better; it makes this much easier. You discern the fluctuation in body and mind. This may show up as waviness and vibration, increase and decrease, expansion and contraction, all kinds of flavors and subtleties of impermanence. Anyway, as I think I mentioned, there's gross impermanence that isn't subtle at all. Okay, I'm waving my hands:
0:14:32this is the manifestation of impermanence. But seeing it at subtler and subtler levels, through direct meditative perception, undermines this pre-verbal, pre-conceptual, mistaken craving and clinging. And for perceptions, mental formations and consciousness: once you have a perception of impermanence well established where it's easier to see (say, with bodily sensations, or, for some people, in the visual field or with sound), then these very subtle aspects of the mind, of attention, of orientation, of the subtle way the mind uses angles, kind of lenses, become much clearer and directly observable, and you can see them arising and passing. And consciousness itself: anything that seems to be the observer, anything that seems to be an awareness apart, or somehow standing in relation to objects, you can likewise see as fluctuation. If you're taking impermanence all the way through, you may perceive the entirety of your experience, all the senses, flickering and fluctuating in such a complete and total way that the mind releases clinging to such an extent that there is, in fact, a cessation of consciousness, which may be momentary or can be extended.
0:16:15It's different from the cessation of perception and feeling we've talked about in the progression through these deep states of concentration, but it can be experienced, and it can be an immensely catalytic event for insight. And likewise, that can happen with any of the characteristics, impermanence, dukkha, not-self: bringing those perceptions to maturity throughout the whole of one's experience unbinds the mind. "With angles, perceiving from angles: are you almost saying that awareness is always at objects, and that you see the impermanence by noticing that?" Yeah. Dualistic awareness is always bent with respect to what it's objectifying, and there's a kind of... You know how you have distorting lenses? You can perceive that. And likewise the subtle operation of craving and clinging, and the stress in it: with a finely honed perception of impermanence established, you can discern, at a very micro scale, the tiny mental motions that make up the formation of identity, that make up the formation of objectification.
0:17:56"I'm really struck by a line in the passages you read: 'If one has no self, one is the Buddha.'" Yeah, it's a good line, right? I'll read it again: "The reason for this is: if one has no self, one is the Buddha." Okay, here's another one: "When one's karma is exhausted, there is nothing at all. This is what, for expediency, we give the name Buddha." With awakening and the full exhaustion of karma, there's nothing at all: the tendency to reify, to thingify, is completely exhausted. This, for expediency, is what we call Buddha. "Okay, that makes sense to me. The question I wanted to ask, and I feel so shy asking this: do you believe it?" Yeah. "Okay." Yes, I believe... I mean, in more detail: I could guess at what exactly you mean, but believe what, exactly? "For some reason, when I hear those words in that order, something inside me goes, 'What the fuck does that mean?' This thing inside me is like, 'That can't be true.'
0:19:44It seems... okay. That's what I'm doing. Unbelievable to me." Yeah, no. I believe that. I have confidence in that, even. "Okay, that's all I had." "For me, the passages, specifically the 'Song of Zazen' (I remember that one from other Zen centers), always hit me in the soul. And I see that as a practice in itself: it's almost like poetry that opens something up in the being. Every morning, hearing 'This very place is the Lotus Land' right before sitting for two hours: I see that as so useful. And then I hear the other passage, degrading words, and he's obviously speaking out of both sides of his mouth here." Because here he is saying, in many different ways, what's classic, all through the Pali Canon as well: all of these are conventional designations. There's a famous passage where, speaking of himself, he says that the Tathagata uses the world's designations.5
0:21:18He uses the conventions that are lying around, recombining them, putting them together to communicate something, but he uses designations without being caught in them, without being bound by them. So yes: the free play of form, the free play of language, in the service of expression and compassion and inspiration. It's funny: for how much the Zen tradition degrades and derides the use of language, the Zen canon is actually the largest of any tradition. They've written the most; in sheer volume of literary production, they've got the most. "On the three characteristics: can you speak to not solidifying those three into views, seeing them as skillful ways of seeing through our usual delusion, but not thinking, 'Oh, everything is impermanent,' as if that becomes a new fixation, you know what I mean?" If you're walking around constantly imposing a conceptual label on appearances ("impermanent, not-self, suffering"), that's not what you're going for. There's a sutta from the canon, which I referenced earlier, that describes the path of practice leading to stream entry, and then, for a stream-enterer, all the way up through arahantship and after arahantship, the same practice is recommended: seeing the aggregates in terms of the three characteristics, because it leads to the release of clinging and the progressive loss of the fetters through to full awakening, and also results in a pleasant abiding here and now. But it's useful not to regard the views and the practices as statements about ultimate reality in a way that would cause one to form a new view, and certainly not an identity around that view.6
0:23:44They're skillful perceptions to engage in, to develop, to realize, insofar as they allow the release of clinging and craving and of the formation of identity. And if you work through the perception of impermanence, what does it lead to? It leads to something beyond impermanence and permanence: no arising, no passing away. But until that's your living realization, it's good to develop the perception of impermanence. "That's so helpful, though, because I've heard 'everything arises and passes away' a million times, and you just said the opposite. That was actually a good thing." Yeah. It'll take me a second to bring this up, but it's worth it. Oh, wait, too quick. This is the dedicatory verse from Nagarjuna's (I should really learn where the emphasis goes in some of these words) Root Verses on the Middle Way: "I prostrate to the perfect Buddha, the best of all teachers, who taught that that which is dependent origination is without cessation, without arising, without annihilation, without permanence, without coming, without going, without distinction, without identity, and peaceful, free from fabrication."7
0:25:33So all of those polarities, all of those dependencies that result from reification (arising, cessation, annihilation, permanence, coming, going, distinction, identity): when all of those collapse, there's peace, freedom from fabrication, freedom from views, freedom from arising and passing away. "I have a question. I've been experimenting with how to get into deeper absorption, and it's not obvious sometimes. For example, with trying to get deeper absorption in the second: in your experience, do you try to build concentration gradually straight into it, or build a really deep absorption in the first and then click it over?" In my own experience, the best return on investment you'll get is just from developing maximally strong access concentration before moving into jhana. So if you want stronger jhana, from my own experience: just stay with the base object for longer, in a more refined way. If you're staying with the breath, or metta, or whatever else you're using, for 15 or 30 minutes, stay with it for an hour, stay with it for two hours, stay with it for four hours, and see what kind of absorption you get as a result.
0:27:20You can also deepen just by staying in a particular jhana. And there's some navigation there too: if you have some navigation, you can move forward into the second and then back into the first, and you'll probably get a stronger, more stable or more refined version of the first by progressing and then traversing backwards. But again, if you really just want stronger versions of the states, spend a whole lot more time getting as absorbed as you can with the base object, and you'll see the results. "And do you find, as you're trying to build fluency in a new state, that it's harder to get absorption in it, but that it gets easier pretty quickly?" Yeah. If you're moving through the jhanas for the first time, then the attainment of one you haven't breached before, or gained fluency with, is going to be more unstable than the previous ones you have experience with. Likewise, if your playground has been one to two, or one to three or something, and you're going for the fourth, or especially if you're trying to make the transition from four to five, it really pays just to get as concentrated as you can. Once you have familiarity with the transitions, you can sneak by with less strong concentration.
0:28:55But if you aren't familiar with them, if your mind isn't used to making those transitions or stabilizing in these states, you're going to have a much better shot at it if you're as concentrated as you can be. "So, with building access concentration, to stabilize, say, the second... I guess part one: there's this suspicion I have that, for me, intending for piti, the absorption comes pretty quickly in the first, but it's so much more gross, and the second seems more subtle. Does the piti almost overpower it? Would you rather stay with the breath, and then, once there's a lot of concentration, go for the sukha? Or get really absorbed in the piti and then go?" If you're looking to spend time and work on the second jhana, you could just get really concentrated with the base object, hang out in the first for 10 seconds, a minute, a couple of minutes, whatever, and then move on to the second.
0:30:07"All right, that makes sense." Yeah, go on. "This is following up on our interview earlier today. I'm realizing that part of the reason for my misunderstanding is this: when you say a phrase like 'when you focus on the meditation object for 15 minutes,' I took that to mean that for those 15 minutes you're only focusing on the meditation object and don't have any thoughts. It sounds like that's not the case. Can you elaborate on that a little more?" Yeah. The working minimum viable threshold, on average, for people to start to gain access to jhana of the kind of depth we're mostly talking about on this retreat is 15 minutes without serious interruption. What that doesn't mean is that there are no thoughts whatsoever. It doesn't even mean that there's no wobbling of your attention. It means that if there are thoughts, they're in the background; they're not pulling you off the object. And while your attention might drift slightly away from the object, it never completely loses contact.
0:31:32So: 15 minutes of steady contact, sure, with a little wobbling. There may still be gross thought activity happening, but it's not pulling you away. "So you could be thinking for all of those 15 minutes, as long as you're not getting grabbed by it?" "Oh, that's really helpful. Thank you." Yeah, that's what I meant.
0:32:01"For after the retreat: I hear the emphasis being access concentration, basically, for jhana practice, right? So, first, what do you think is a good way to keep the momentum going from this retreat: a one-hour sit, a 90-minute sit? And of that, how much, in your opinion, would be best dedicated to access concentration, and then maybe to playing with jhana?" Yeah. If you got access to jhana on the retreat, and you keep up practicing for a good amount of time... The traditional recommendation is two hours a day, if you want to maintain the level of concentration you had, and the access you had on retreat. More will yield better, more stable results, and if you want to continue progressing, then more is better. As for the division: 15 to 30 minutes of access concentration, and if you want a stronger version, just stay longer. Also, people differ. And some days it will just take longer to get reasonably stabilized, depending on what's going on, on your conditions.
0:33:26So be sensitive to the causes and conditions; you can use your own discernment. "But would you recommend an hour in the morning and one in the evening? Is there a benefit to doing it at the same time?" Yeah. There's a nice rounding-out to the day if you do a morning practice session before you do anything else, and then one before you wind down. Right. And I find personally that if I can get an hour-and-a-half or two-hour uninterrupted block (even if I'm just switching posture in there, if I get sore), you can build up real steam, even in the midst of a very busy life, by getting a 90-minute or two-hour block in. "So, yeah, thanks."
0:34:15"[unclear], or is it better to have one where there's a single thing you're attending to deliberately?" It depends: on the mind, on the person. Try both; see what works. [unclear] The jumping-off point is whatever gets you to samadhi; that's fine. Whatever gets you to samadhi is a good jumping-off point. "Yeah, thank you. I've heard sometimes that [insight] can help you get into samadhi. If we did [unclear] beforehand, how could that help?"
0:35:02Yeah. If you're doing insight practice, there's a kind of... the canonical terms for the difference are momentary concentration and sustained concentration. If you're doing insight practice, your attention is usually working with changing objects, so there isn't the thorough sustain with a relatively unchanging object, which tends to make it less useful for developing the kind of concentration that's apt to let you get into jhana, which are more consolidated states. Still, if you work with impermanence, or with the theme of stress or not-self, you may find yourself getting exceptionally concentrated, to the extent that, if you wanted to, you could shift into jhana.
0:36:06Is that clear? "Yeah." Just play with it. Yeah. "I've done some guided meditations before where the instructions were something along the lines of 'look for the observer, look for what's looking,' and I never know how the hell I'm supposed to go about doing that. I was wondering if you had any explanation of the mental action being suggested there. But also whether it's worth worrying about this before having cultivated very much concentration ability in the first place." Yeah. As with every other technique, the more samadhi you're working with, the better things will go, the more easily insights will come, the more valuable and perceptive they'll be. With that said, those kinds of instructions (turn the light around, take the backward step, the unfindability of the mind, the unfindability of the observer) are pointing more directly, in early Buddhist terms, towards the not-self characteristic.
0:37:27You can't actually find anything that's solidly, unchangeably me or mine, or even localizable: "Okay, here's the seat of awareness; here's the seat of the self." It's like grasping a wet, slippery bar of soap: as soon as you grab it, it slips out.
0:37:50And the mental motion being asked of you is this. In our dualistic frame, attention is usually felt to be moving outwards towards objects: bodily sensations, sounds. So follow my finger. Does it feel as if there's an origin point to your attention? Does it feel as if there's some kind of directedness towards the object of perception? "Yes, I suppose so." Okay. So what we're going to do is turn it 180 degrees: turn your attention back. Yeah, that's the point. "I guess at that point I just start mentally protesting: why would I be able to do that? It doesn't seem like..." Yeah. With more concentration and malleability of mind, the protesting will likely not come up, and you'll have the flexibility to actually make that move. "Okay." But also, try it right now. Why not? What is that, actually, this looking out of your eyes? Haven't you ever been curious just what that thing is?
0:39:17Thinking about it won't help. Yeah.
0:39:28Okay. Any other questions? Yeah. "I'm curious: is there anything jhana-flavored in the Zen tradition?" Well, okay, a fun etymology for all of us etymology nerds. Zen is a Japanese word that comes from the Chinese Chan, which comes from an earlier, more antique Chinese word, chan-na, which is a kind of corruption of the Sanskrit dhyana, which is the same as the Pali word jhana. So the Zen school is quite literally the jhana school. And yet, funnily, in the transmission from India to China with Bodhidharma, the same kind of systematic jhana practice didn't really seem to make it over in quite the same way. You'll find them talked about in Chinese meditation texts (it's not as if the scriptures didn't make it over, and they have meditation manuals that go through them), but as far as I'm aware, nothing quite like the systematic practice lineage made it over, and it certainly didn't survive into the later Chan period or into Japan. So how and why that happened historically,
0:40:54I couldn't tell you. That would be a good doctoral thesis, if anyone here is from scholarship; a good research project. But deep samadhi certainly was, and has always been, part of the tradition. And the states and levels of absorption, including piti, contentment, the peace, formless states: if you do Zen practices, I can affirm from personal experience, you'll go through the same territory, but not in the same systematic, necessarily progressive or linear, well-staged manner. "Is it almost frowned upon in Zen to try to conceive of it that way, if you're going for a straight shot?" Yeah. You'll find literature that derides more fabricated meditations, or derides getting stuck in, or attached to, blissful or formless states of meditation. It's a common thing in Zen texts: meditators just getting stuck, checking out in formless absorptions. You'll see similar admonitions in the Vajrayana tradition, in Dzogchen and Mahamudra, pointing out again and again that this is not liberation. To which: yeah, but it's really useful.
0:42:34Why not? [Participant], yeah. "One question about the open-eye meditation. I don't know if I got it right, but you said one way would be to first get into access concentration and then do a little with eyes open? Or just start with eyes open? What's your suggestion for how to structure this with eyes open?" Are you asking about what I was pointing to this morning, or generally about developing samadhi with eyes open versus closed? "No, the instruction you gave this morning." So for that, I'd recommend getting as deeply concentrated as you can, moving through jhana if that's accessible, and then transitioning from that into a nature-of-mind practice. If you have some familiarity, or some degree of recognition, that can be a wonderful combination. "And then after that, you start this with eyes open?" Yeah. You let your awareness remain open, unfixated, unrestricted, without any deliberate focal object. I like this instruction: body like a corpse, speech like a mute, mind like a simpleton. "And how long in this phase?"
0:44:34As long as you want, as long as you can go. "Okay." This morning there was Tilopa's Ganges Mahamudra instruction. These are also some famous instructions from the same master, Tilopa: the six nails. So, coming out of samadhi. Here are the six nails; if you nail these, you've got it. "Don't recall": let go of what's past. "Don't imagine": let go of what may come. "Don't think": let go of what's happening now. "Don't examine": don't try to figure anything out. "Don't control": don't try to make anything happen. "And rest": relax, right now. With the mind well prepared, coming out of deep absorption, instructions like that, so simple, so direct... the mind may actually open and unbind, and you can see what there is to see. "Thank you." "[unclear]" Yeah, so this is one of the questions the Buddha famously would not answer: one of the classic imponderables, the beginning of samsara. It has no discernible beginning. If you try to trace that out, you'll go crazy.89
0:46:13Entertaining that question isn't conducive to the end of the path, the goal. "I feel like I received a similar answer [before]." Dzogchen is interesting in that it does provide a cosmological and mythic, as well as didactic, origin myth for delusion. Okay: there's the undifferentiated basis, before there were Buddhas and sentient beings. And depending on how persnickety you want to be, the basis is your own non-dual basis; it isn't in the same way a transpersonal ground, as you might find in other religious systems. But anyway, the details: in terms of practice, don't worry about that.
0:47:17So there's this basis, undifferentiated into samsara and nirvana, into Buddhas and sentient beings. And a subtle stirring in the winds of the basis causes light to shine forth. If the mind that arises as a function of the basis recognizes the display of the lights as its own projection, no duality arises: there's no reification, no objectification, clinging, craving, and so on. And right there one is liberated as a Buddha, without falling into samsara. Within Dzogchen, Samantabhadra, the primordial Buddha, All Good, is one such being who never fell into samsara, and is a representation of our own potential, of your own originally awake mind. This is a kind of didactic cosmology, but it also refers to a process that's happening in every instant of consciousness. There's a display, and a split into samsara and nirvana. If you don't recognize everything that appears as your own mind's display, and you don't fall into dualistic fixation, you're liberated: Buddhahood is that, nothing else. But as soon as there's even a smidge of objectification, of reification, and then craving and clinging on that gap, the gap widens and the whole show spins:
0:48:57the six realms, transmigration, birth and death.
0:49:09And in that way, the process of liberation is one of reversing that chain: the undoing of ignorance, the basic error of not recognizing. "So from that lens, you can have those blips, those moments of recognition, and then it's about consolidating those blips into bigger chunks of time?" Yeah. The difference between a Buddha and a sentient being in Dzogchen, much as in Zen, is recognition or non-recognition, and the difference between a part-time Buddha and a full-time Buddha is the constancy of that recognition and the exhaustion of karma. So from that angle, you can actually oscillate moment to moment between recognition and non-recognition, and also between depths of recognition. This gets into Zen as well: different depths and profundities of kensho, of seeing the nature, or recognition. And that depends on concentration; it seems to be one of the major factors in the stability, and also in whether, in a moment of insight, it becomes something abiding, or really penetrates, or cuts off delusion more deeply. Yeah. I'm not sure whose hand went up first, but we haven't heard from you yet. "A question about this morning's open-eye meditation. I've recognized some degree of similarity with various [practices], with different names:
0:50:54Dzogchen and Mahamudra-type stuff, open awareness, Michael Taft's [unclear], Shinzen Young's Do Nothing. Are these fundamentally the same practice, just slightly differently worded? Are they pointing at the same thing, or are they actually different flavors?" Yeah. In terms of the technique instructions, these are all pretty similar. If you wanted to be a Dzogchen hardliner, or a Mahamudra hardliner, you could say that you actually can't do the practice being instructed there until you have a genuine recognition of the nature of your own mind, and until then you're doing something like objectless shamatha, just a gradual release of fixation, but not actually arriving. The name for the Dzogchen practice is trekchö, "cutting through solidity." And what are you cutting through to? Direct recognition of the nature of mind. So if you can't do that, or if that's not clear, then that's not what's being done. The mind is certainly in a more open, less reactive state, but it's not yet awakening.
0:52:20Because, again, if you want to be a hard-ass about it, that practice is an awakening and post-awakening practice. "It sounds from your description like we're trying to bestow it even before awakening. It's something that [unclear]." It may result in an actual recognition, yeah. But, partly because of my bias, I think you're more likely to have that recognition, and for it to stabilize when it dawns, if you just crank the concentration. But you never know. [Participant], yeah. "You mentioned that exhausting karma is what a full-time Buddha has achieved. Would you share your understanding of what it means to have exhausted all one's karma?" Yeah. The tendency to reify is gone. Any subtle residual substantiality of the body, of the external world, of sense objects, of mental proliferation, all the tendency for the mind to objectify on the basis of past habituated confusion, attraction and aversion, has been cut off at its roots, such that no more is produced. It's like, I don't know, pond scum: it's all been cleared away. No more is produced, and what had been produced but had not yet ripened is burnt, or shed, in different metaphors.
0:54:06Yeah. And Zen and Dzogchen both talk about the post-awakening path and practice in these terms: exhausting the residual karma. "Okay. And one quick follow-up: you mentioned trekchö just now. Is that a preliminary, before you've had recognition of mind?" In some ways it's taught, you practice trekchö, and that might result in recognition, and then your trekchö just becomes deeper, in an arc. And some would take a stricter definition and say, "Okay, you're not actually practicing trekchö until you have an actual awakening and are deepening it with that practice." It depends on whom you ask. "All right, thank you."
0:55:14"Can you speak to this (and it might be one of those things you have to experience), for those of us who are still in the slog: the thing you gain by doing concentration meditation and getting better at it, how does it carry over when you're off the mat, to the day-to-day of what your brain feels like? Is it more that it resets the condition, and then your brain feels different? Or is it more that you've developed a move, and you can do that move when you remember? How does it translate?" Yeah, both of those things. One: if you're doing concentration practice actively... Samadhi is temporary, it's conditional, but if you're immersing in it regularly and deepening into it, it affects your baseline state. You'll feel more spacious; your body might feel lighter; much less mental proliferation may be produced than otherwise would be; your senses may be brighter and more vivid; you may have more access to emotion and sensory sensitivity. And you just have much more access, on demand, to really powerful attentional stability and clarity, and you can bring that to any other domain of life.
0:56:43"Okay. Something I've said before, and it sounds like you'd agree with me: I don't feel I'm doing meditation right, because if you surgically removed the hour I was sitting from my memory, and I went through the rest of my day, and you asked me, based on how I feel, whether I'd sat in that hour, I wouldn't be able to tell the difference. It sounds like the goal is for the answer to be yes." Yeah, no. As a beginner, you may not notice much of a difference. But the gains are cumulative, and there certainly is a difference. Especially as practice matures, the ability to enter samadhi increases, and so does the depth one is able to enter at relative speed. So it may not seem like much now, but the further you go, the difference is not subtle. "Right. No, I believe the skills are built. Another way to say this: a friend of mine who's done more meditation than me (not my most hardcore friend) and I have this joke that we're not sure whether meditation is a leading or a trailing indicator. In the weeks we meditate more, is it making us feel better?
0:58:16Or is it that, in the version of life where we can prioritize sitting for an hour a day, we have enough executive functioning to be doing that at all?" Sure, yeah. "It sounds like neither of us is in it deep enough. Once you're wherever some of you are, the answer is very obvious, and you can really tell that there's a causal link between the time you spend meditating and what life looks like the rest of the time." Yes. "Okay, thanks." You're welcome. Okay, let's just go through these two questions, unless there's a burning one here. Okay, [participant]? "I apologize if it's really scratchy. Can you hear me? There's a snowstorm and the power's out." Yeah, we can hear you. "Can you hear me? Okay, cool. Awesome. My question is based on this. Earlier this week I was going through a practice where, when thoughts come in, you just label them as thoughts and almost send them away like a little bird, or label an emotion as emotion, or a sound as sound, so it can't distract from the focus. And I shifted and played with this: instead of labeling thoughts as thoughts... My question also goes with what you were saying earlier about thinking: is thinking really a bad thing, if we apply it to the point of awareness, thinking playfully with the object? What happened is I was taking space as my object, and then I playfully thought 'surfing in space,' and then the piti came on so strong.
1:00:32And I think it was because I was almost playing with it a bit more, and I also..." Okay, you're cutting out a little more now. We just lost you there. "Oh." Okay. The snowstorm might have kicked her out.
1:01:00Okay. Well, I'm going to answer the question, or what I could discern of it, and maybe you'll catch this on the recording. Thought: there's nothing wrong with thought. The kind of perturbation in the mind that the arising of thought creates will prevent deepening into certain levels of samadhi. But that's not to say we shouldn't ever think, or that you can't use thought skillfully in meditation; not true. For deepening into samadhi, though, disengagement from verbal and visual and most other forms of thought is usually the most expedient, and it does have to be let go of to get to certain depths. But if you're able to use thought creatively, to remind or inspire or encourage yourself along, then great. And you may get to a point where, with the arising of an intention, or with the formation of a thought, you can incline the mind to certain properties. You can say verbally, "May piti arise," and boom, it shows up. "May the first jhana arise," boom. So, a bit of a complicated answer, but I hope it's clear. And [participant]: this will be the last one, and then we'll break.
1:02:47"My biggest problem with meditation is that I get into a dull, trancey state very easily. I've gotten to the point where I can accept thought, and maybe work with it a bit more comfortably than before, but I get so dull, and I'm just nodding off. So, and I guess my question is asking either for a kind of permission, or for you to say 'Don't do that': I'm also doing Chinese energy-cultivation arts, and one of them is a standing exercise where you're doing concentration exercises within your body while standing up. That helps me, the same way keeping my eyes open keeps me from going into trance or dullness. Now I'm standing up, with my eyes open, doing that cultivation exercise. But there's something in me that asks: am I mixing up traditions so much that it's getting super messy? Am I messing up the access concentration? Because how can I feel steady standing, when there's going to be a point where the jhanas may not feel quite so bodily? So am I just shooting myself in the foot? Should I just practice harder sitting down, or in a more stable position?"
1:04:05Yeah. Let your own experience be the guide; I'm not going to say one way or the other. But what I will say is that you can certainly enter the four jhanas while standing. You can develop access concentration and go through the first four jhanas standing. It may be a little harder, but you can do it; I can confirm. Likewise, while not as full absorptions, you can tap into the qualities of the formless attainments while standing.
1:04:43As far as mixing traditions or techniques, again, your own experience is the judge here, not any concern for propriety or purity; you're not going to get that from me. "Okay, thank you." Yeah. "Hi, I don't know if you can still hear me. I totally missed your answer. You don't have to go over it again; you could go over it tomorrow in class, or in the meeting, if you want. But the second part of my question was this, and it's maybe controversial: some Pali professors say that two of the five jhana factors, vitakka and vicara, just mean thinking, as the Buddha used them in those times, apparently. So if they mean thinking, that's two of the factors. And another of the jhana factors is ekaggata (sorry if I'm pronouncing it wrong)." Yeah, all good. "And that means one-pointedness. So, with just a one-pointed awareness and thinking, do we really need an object, an actual object to focus on?"
1:06:05Oh, okay, you're cutting out a bit, but I think I got it. Oh, did we lose her again? Okay. "Oh, no, it might be gone. You can tell me in our meeting tomorrow, or maybe I'll hear a little." Yeah. Well, I'll try to answer what I was able to hear of the question, and maybe you'll hear it, and if not, watch the recording. In the early discourses, the suttas, vitakka and vicara, two of the five jhana factors, do appear, in their usage throughout the rest of the canon, to mean just thinking: directed thought and evaluation, thinking as we'd think of it. You can tell that from context, from the way the terms are used elsewhere in the canon. In the later tradition, in specialized meditation terminology, they came to mean (and I referred to this in some talks earlier) initial and sustained attention, something like that; initial and applied attention. What this means practically is that in some later meditative pedagogy and tradition and manuals, the definition of the first jhana, and indeed even of deep access concentration, is that there's already no thought whatsoever. None. Zero. Zilch. Instead, what you have is an initial contact with the meditation object, and then vicara is the sustain, the hold.10
1:07:43Both senses of the term are helpful. The later understanding of the terms, as initial and sustained attention to the meditation object, makes sense as an element of experience, and it's useful to read them that way. But in the early discourses they do just seem to mean thinking. So you can be in a jhana as described in the early texts and there can still be thought occurring. And in the early discourses, by the second jhana the thinking has completely subsided. The other factor you mentioned, ekaggata: a very literal translation would be one-pointedness. But that has led some commentators, some meditators and some lineages of meditation instruction to think that you need a very spatially narrow range of attention, and that just doesn't follow from, well, one, the way jhana is described in the suttas, as involving the whole body. One-pointed, spatially restricted, and involving the whole body: those two things don't make sense together. So a less literal-minded approach to the term, where it means occupied with one theme, or collected or cohered around a single subject, rather than literally a very small spatial region, makes more sense. Though you can develop very powerful concentration with a spatially restricted focus, right?
1:09:23If you're focusing on the breath at the nostrils, that's a pretty pinpoint spot, and you can develop intensely strong concentration through that. So. "Okay. And when we get into piti, to stay in piti and let it expand within us, should we be thinking about it, or just really trying to feel it? Expanding in our body, you know what I mean?" Okay, I see. Yeah. "Thank you. Glad I could hear the answers. Thank you." For sure. Okay, with that, we conclude the Q&A.
Sources
- The five recollections. AN 5:57 Upajjhatthana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN5_57.html ↩
- Bahiya of the Bark-cloth, killed by a cow. Ud 1:10 Bahiya Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/Ud/ud1_10.html ↩
- Shido Bunan (Munan) Zenji’s old man and the nembutsu. Shido Bunan, Sokushin-ki; English in Kobori Sohaku and Norman Waddell, The Eastern Buddhist (1970–71). Please confirm the edition you read from. ↩
- “All beings by nature are Buddha, as ice by nature is water” Hakuin, Zazen Wasan (Song of Zazen) ↩
- The Tathagata uses the world’s designations without being caught in them. DN 9 Potthapada Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN09.html ↩
- The same contemplation of the aggregates before stream entry and after arahantship. SN 22:122 Silavant Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN22_122.html ↩
- “... dependent origination is without cessation, without arising ...” Nagarjuna, Mulamadhyamakakarika, dedicatory verse; e.g. trans. Jay Garfield, The Fundamental Wisdom of the Middle Way (Oxford, 1995) ↩
- Tilopa’s six nails: don’t recall, don’t imagine, don’t think, don’t examine, don’t control, rest. Tilopa’s Six Words, trans. Ken McLeod (Unfettered Mind) unfetteredmind.org/tilopas-advice/ ↩
- The beginning of samsara as unknowable. SN 15:3 Assu Sutta: “From an inconceivable beginning comes transmigration” dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN15_3.html ↩
- Vitakka and vicara as thinking (“verbal fabrication”) MN 44 Culavedalla Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN44.html ↩