Jhana & Awakening Retreat 2026 · Session 11 of 16

Wednesday, November 11 · Evening

Exertion (Sn 3:2), Before the Break-up (Sn 4:10) and The Cow (AN 9:35); Q&A on siddhis, purification, teachers and koan practice; Hakuin’s soft-butter method

Recorded November 11, 2026, 7:00 pm Mountain Time · Nameless Mountain, Boulder, Colorado · 1 hr 20 min

Three readings on resolve, peace and consolidating each stage before the next. The Q&A covered siddhis, purification, his teachers and a long thread on koan practice. It closed with Hakuin's soft-butter method, guided.

Topics and questions in this session

Talk

  • 0:00:00The five recollections. Final, capping instructions over the next two days.
  • 0:02:10Exertion (Sn 3:2): Mara's "Live, good sir!" (0:04), the Bodhisatta's resolve (0:05) and "Do I carry munja grass?" (0:06).
  • 0:08:10Mara gives up, like a crow pecking a stone that looked like fat.
  • 0:10:16Before the Break-up (Sn 4:10): the one at peace is secluded from the hindrances even amid sense contact (0:11). "No swellings of pride are his" (0:13).
  • 0:16:31The Cow (AN 9:35): the foolish mountain cow and the wise one, moving through the jhanas step by step (0:17), then the higher knowledges (0:20).
  • 0:23:03Only lift your hind leg when your foreleg is firmly placed.

Q&A

  • 0:24:36Advanced access: going back to the breath when it feels nicer.
  • 0:25:49The siddhis in the suttas. Are they real possibilities? No consensus experience of them (0:28).
  • 0:28:36Physical purification in intense practice. Not a boot camp: rest, eat more fatty food (0:31). His own experience with tummo (0:32).
  • 0:34:40Something like sleep paralysis after jhana.
  • 0:36:09Ping-ponging between sukha and piti. His teachers, Theravada and Zen (0:38–0:41).
  • 0:43:03It's the same practice all the way through. Is there any benefit to koans on top of Theravada?
  • 0:44:27Awakening without mastery of jhana, in the suttas and in modern Theravada (0:45).
  • 0:47:28Smiling as part of your posture. He's pro-smiling.
  • 0:49:04His experience with the koan Mu (Gateless Gate).
  • 0:54:28Could you answer it for us now? Each answer is different; the teacher judges where it comes from.
  • 0:54:28The Mahayana ideal. Why doesn't this retreat have a Mahayana flavor? "Not yet" (0:56).
  • 0:58:14What has to be realized to pass a koan? Is it stream entry, or a gold star?
  • 1:00:29Is there an end to koan practice? For Buddhahood, the final koan is "not yet."

Guided practice

  • 1:04:36Hakuin's soft-butter method: a ball of warm ghee at the crown, melting down through the body.
Wednesday, November 11 · Evening

Edited transcript. The time at the start of each paragraph is where it begins in the recording above; drag the player to that point to listen. Participants' names are omitted. [Square brackets] mark editorial insertions; [unclear] marks words that couldn't be made out.

0:00:00I am of the nature to age; I have not gone beyond aging. Still true: fingernails a little longer, hair a little longer, life a little shorter. Byadhi-dhammomhi byadhim anatito: I am of the nature to sicken; I have not gone beyond sickness. Marana-dhammomhi maranam anatito: I am of the nature to die; I have not gone beyond dying. Sabbehi me piyehi manapehi nanabhavo vinabhavo: all that is mine, beloved and pleasing, will become otherwise, will become separated from me. I am the owner of my action, heir to my action, born of my action, related to my action, and abide supported by my action. Whatever action I shall do, for good or for ill, of that I will be the heir. I am a man of the nature to die. Thus we should frequently recollect. And having recollected: just a few short readings and a little commentary, and then, again, no new instructions today, but I'll open it up for questions coming out of the practice, or doubts, or anything that's on your mind.1

0:02:10Then tomorrow and the next day, some final, capping instructions, and then we'll be just about done. Time flies. This is "Exertion," the Padhana Sutta. We're a little more than halfway through now. There's been some time for momentum and steam to build in practice, or for it to flag, or to go through many cycles of that. So here's hoping this may rouse some further balanced effort. This is the Buddha recounting how, while he was striving, Mara approached and attempted to dissuade him from pursuing his course. "To me, my mind resolute in exertion near the river Nerañjara, making a great effort, doing jhana to attain rest from the yoke..." That's a good phrase that shows up in a bunch of places. There are lots of agricultural metaphors in the suttas, of course: the yoke of becoming, as though we were beasts of burden, bound constantly in labor. "Namuci" (an epithet of Mara) "came, speaking words of compassion." Interesting: the tempter, speaking words of compassion. "'You are ashen, thin. Death is in your presence. Death has a thousand parts of you.2

0:04:16"'Only one part is your life. Live, good sir! Life is better. Alive, you can do acts of merit. Living the holy life and performing the fire sacrifice, you will heap up much merit. What use is exertion to you? Hard to follow, this path of exertion, hard to do, hard to sustain.' Saying these verses, Mara stood in the Awakened One's presence. And to that Mara, speaking thus, the Blessed One said this: 'Kinsman of the heedless, Evil One, come here for whatever purpose: I haven't, for merit, even the least bit of need. Those who have need of merit: those are the ones Mara is fit to address.'" Isn't that interesting? Those who have need of merit; "I haven't the least need for merit." Why? The Buddha's freedom, confidence and liberation don't depend on keeping up accumulated virtue and hoping for some reward from it. That's good: good acts lead to good consequences. But that in and of itself doesn't lead to freedom, doesn't lead to liberation. "In me are conviction, austerity, persistence, discernment. Why, when my mind is resolute, do you petition me to live?

0:05:36"This wind could burn up even river currents. Why, when my mind is resolute, shouldn't my blood dry away? As my blood dries up, gall and phlegm dry up. As muscles waste away, the mind grows clearer; mindfulness, discernment, concentration stand more firm. Staying in this way, attaining the ultimate feeling, the mind has no interest in sensuality. A being's purity, [unclear]. Sensual passions are your first army. Your second is called discontent. Your third is hunger and thirst. Your fourth is called craving. Fifth is sloth and torpor. Sixth is called cowardice. Your seventh is uncertainty; hypocrisy and stubbornness, your eighth. Gains, offerings, fame and status wrongly gained, and whoever would praise self and disparage others: that, Namuci, is your army, the Dark One's commando force. A coward can't defeat it, but one having defeated it gains bliss. Do I carry munja grass?" A footnote says this was a sign of surrender in ancient India. Apparently you would take this piece of grass in your mouth and lie down, and that would show you were ready to surrender in a battle. Interesting.

0:06:50"Do I carry munja grass? I spit on my life. Death in battle would be better for me than that I, defeated, survive." You get a sense sometimes of the Buddha's character: he's a proud, aristocratic warrior. "Sinking here, they don't appear, some brahmans and contemplatives. They don't know the path by which those with good practices go. Seeing the bannered force on all sides, the troops, Mara along with his mount, I go into battle. May they not budge me from my spot. That army of yours, that the world with its devas can't overcome, I will smash with discernment, as an unfired pot with a stone. Making my resolve mastered, mindfulness well established, I will go about from kingdom to kingdom, training many disciples. And they, heedful, resolute in mind, doing my bidding, despite your wishes, will go where, having gone, there's no grief." Quite the rebuke. And Mara replies: "For seven years I've dogged the Blessed One's steps, but haven't gained an opening in the One Self-awakened and glorious. A crow circled a stone the color of fat:

0:08:10"'Maybe I've found something tender here. Maybe there's something delicious.' But not getting anything delicious there, the crow went away. Like the crow attacking the rock, I weary myself with Gotama. As he was overcome with sorrow, his lute fell from under his arm." (Mara came with a lute, to share music and enticement.) "Then, dejected, the despondent spirit right there disappeared." So much drama in here. "Do I carry munja grass? I spit on my life. Death in battle would be better for me than that I, defeated, survive." You don't have to let your muscles waste away and spit on your life and let the blood, phlegm and mucus in your body dry up. If you're into that, go ahead; it's not necessary. It makes for good rhetorical effect, though. That kind of resolve, that determination, serves well: caring nothing for life, not fearing death, like a warrior standing alone against a raging horde of enemies charging in, fearless of death. That's a good spirit to go chasing after the deathless with. And this: a little on the goal again.

0:10:16This is "Before the Break-up of the Body": "Seeing how, behaving how, is one said to be at peace? Gotama, tell me about the ultimate person, when asked." And the Buddha replies: "Free from craving before the break-up of the body, independent of before and the end, not classified in between..." There's interesting wordplay going on here. "Before" could also mean behind, and "the end" could mean in front; they could also mean the past and the future. "Classified in between": both in terms of the present, and also in terms of spatial reference. Independent of space and time, not bound within space and time: behind, in front; before, after; here. All three: let go. "No preference is his. Unangered, unstartled, unboastful, unanxious..." Okay, the Buddha does sometimes boast, so perhaps even he had some residual thing to work through, given what we just saw. "Unangered, unstartled, unboastful" (most of the time, anyway, perhaps) "unanxious, giving counsel unruffled, he is a sage, his speech under control. Free from attachment with regard to the future, not sorrowing over the past, he sees seclusion in the midst of sensory contacts."3

0:11:52So even while there are sensory contacts, the mind is secluded from the hindrances, secluded from attachment and aversion. The mind isn't bound up in the arising and passing away of the senses, even while in full contact with them: in the world, but not of the world. "He can't be led on in terms of views." What usually puts people into attachment to ideas has nothing alluring there; there's no freedom, no [gain] to be had in holding on to views, ideas, theories, conjectures. "Withdrawn, undeceitful, not stingy, not miserly, not insolent, inoffensive, he doesn't engage in divisive speech." As from yesterday: quarrels and disputes. There's not much to quarrel about or dispute when one is free from the allure of sensory contact. "Not drunk on enticements, nor given to pride, gentle, quick-witted, beyond conviction and dispassion, not in hopes of material gain does he take on the training, and when without material gain he isn't upset. Unobstructed by craving, he doesn't, through craving, hunger for flavors. Equanimous, always mindful, he doesn't suppose himself equal, superior or inferior in the world.

0:13:19"No swellings of pride are his." This always cuts, interestingly, against a tendency some folks have and cling to, that no one's better or worse, we're all equal. Even that: if you're thinking in terms of oneself or others, taking a measure of self and other, even in terms of equality, there's a kind of projection, a kind of conceit, blatant in that. "Whose dependencies don't exist when, on knowing the Dhamma, he's independent; in whom no craving is found for becoming or not: he is said to be at peace, unintent on sensual pleasures, with nothing at all to tie him down: one who's crossed over attachment. He has no children, cattle, fields, land." In the suttas there aren't any lay arahants, interestingly. The highest attainment a layperson is said to have reached is the third stage, and there are some of those. But there's the idea that, immediately upon attaining arahantship, if one doesn't enter the order, one will starve within 10 days, because one won't be capable of feeding oneself, or something.

0:14:50But perhaps without giving up children, cattle, fields and land, or whatever today's equivalents are, one can't reach the fullest freedom. Who's to say? I wouldn't know. "In him you can't pin down what's embraced or rejected. He has no preference for that which people (run-of-the-mill, or brahmans or contemplatives) might claim, which is why he's unperturbed with regard to their words. His greed gone, not miserly, the sage doesn't speak of himself as among those who are higher, equal or lower. He, theory-free, goes to no theory, for whom nothing in the world is his own, who doesn't grieve over what is not, who doesn't enter into doctrines or phenomena: he is said to be at peace." So, to that end, if you can summon up that spirit, even if not so bombastically: "I spit on my life. Death in battle would be better for me than that I, defeated, survive." And then, relating to steady, sustainable progress on the path, the final thing I'll read tonight. This is "The Cow," with reference to jhana.

0:16:31"Suppose there were a mountain cow, foolish, incompetent, unfamiliar with her pasture, unskilled in roaming on rugged mountains, and she were to think, 'What if I were to go in a direction I've never gone before, to eat grass I've never eaten before, to drink water I've never drunk before?' She would lift her hind hoof without having placed her front hoof firmly and, as a result, would not get to go in a direction she had never gone before, to eat grass she had never eaten before, or to drink water she had never drunk before. And as for the place where she was standing when the thought occurred to her, 'What if I were to go where I've never been before... to drink water I've never drunk before?', she would not return there safely. Why is that? Because she is a foolish, incompetent mountain cow [unclear], unfamiliar with her pasture, unskilled in roaming on rugged mountains. In the same way, there are cases where a monk, foolish, incompetent, unfamiliar with his pasture, unskilled in being quite secluded from sensuality, secluded from unskillful qualities, entering and remaining in the first jhana (rapture and pleasure born of seclusion, accompanied by directed thought and evaluation), doesn't stick with that theme, doesn't develop it, pursue it, or establish himself firmly in it.4

0:17:43"The thought occurs to him, 'What if I, with the stilling of directed thoughts and evaluations, were to enter and remain in the second jhana: rapture and pleasure born of concentration, unification of awareness free from directed thought and evaluation, internal assurance?' He is not able to enter and remain in the second jhana. The thought occurs to him, 'What if I were to enter and remain in the first jhana?' And he is not able to enter and remain in the first jhana. This is called a monk who has slipped and fallen from both sides, like the mountain cow, foolish, incompetent, unfamiliar with her pasture, unskilled in roaming on rugged mountains. But suppose there were a mountain cow, wise, competent, familiar with her pasture, skilled in roaming on rugged mountains, and she were to think, 'What if I were to go in a direction I've never gone before, to eat grass I've never eaten before, to drink water I've never drunk before?' She would lift her hind hoof only after having placed her front hoof firmly and, as a result, would get to go in a direction she had never gone before... to drink water she had never drunk before.

0:18:41"And as for the place where she was standing when the thought occurred to her, 'What if I were to go in a direction I've never gone before... to drink water I've never drunk before?', she would return there safely. Why is that? Because she is a wise, competent mountain cow, familiar with her pasture, skilled in roaming on rugged mountains." You can see where this is going. "In the same way, there are some cases where a monk, wise, competent, familiar with his pasture, skilled in being quite secluded from sensuality, secluded from unskillful qualities, enters and remains in the first jhana (rapture and pleasure born of seclusion, accompanied by directed thought and evaluation), and sticks with that theme, develops it, pursues it, and establishes himself firmly in it. When the thought occurs to him, 'What if I, with the stilling of directed thoughts and evaluations, were to enter and remain in the second jhana: rapture and pleasure born of concentration, unification of awareness free from directed thought and evaluation, internal assurance?', then, without jumping at the second jhana, he, with the stilling of directed thoughts and evaluations, enters and remains in the second jhana..." (the formula).

0:19:45"He sticks with that theme, develops it, pursues it, and establishes himself firmly in it. The thought occurs to him, 'What if I, with the fading of rapture, were to enter and remain in the third jhana?' Without jumping at the third jhana, with the fading of rapture he remains equanimous, mindful and alert, senses pleasure with the body, and enters and remains in the third jhana, of which the noble ones declare, 'Equanimous and mindful, he has a pleasant abiding.' He sticks with that theme, develops it, pursues it, and establishes himself firmly in it." And so on. "The thought occurs to him, 'What if I were to enter and remain in the fourth jhana? What if I were to enter and remain in the dimension of the infinitude of space? What if I were to enter and remain in the dimension of the infinitude of consciousness? What if I were to enter and remain in the dimension of nothingness? What if I were to enter and remain in the dimension of neither perception nor non-perception? What if I, with the complete transcending of the dimension of neither perception nor non-perception, were to enter and remain in the cessation of perception and feeling?'

0:20:38"When a monk enters and emerges from that very attainment, his mind is pliant and malleable. With his pliant, malleable mind, limitless concentration is well developed. With his well-developed, limitless concentration, then whichever of the six higher knowledges he turns his mind to know and realize, he can witness them for himself whenever there is an opening." These six higher knowledges are: the supernormal powers. "Having been one, becoming many; being many, becoming one; appearing, vanishing; going unimpeded through walls, ramparts and mountains as if through space; diving in and out of the earth as if it were water; walking on water without sinking as if it were dry land; sitting cross-legged, flying through the air like a winged bird; with his hand touching and stroking even the sun and moon, so mighty and powerful; exercising influence with his body even as far as the Brahma worlds: witnessing this for himself whenever there is an opening." Sound fun? "If he wants, he hears, by means of the divine ear, purified and surpassing the human, both kinds of sounds, divine and human, whether near or far.

0:21:38"He can witness this for himself whenever there is an opening. If he wants, he can know the awareness of other beings, other individuals, encompassing them with his own awareness." It goes on. Recollection of past lives: "one birth, two births, three births, four, five, ten, twenty, thirty, forty, one hundred, one thousand, one hundred thousand, many aeons of cosmic contraction and expansion," and so on. "He can witness this for himself whenever there is an opening." The divine eye, surpassing the human: beings passing away and reappearing, the influence of karma. And then, finally, the one I assume is of most interest to us: "If he wants, then through the ending of the effluents he enters and remains in the effluent-free awareness-release and discernment-release, having directly known and realized them for himself right here and now. He can witness this for himself whenever there is an opening." Unbinding, awakening. This is only a ten-day retreat, and it's good to get some range, but just to reiterate: take your time. If you find yourself behaving like a foolish mountain cow, take your time.

0:23:03Enjoy the [unclear]. Only lift your hind leg when your foreleg is firmly placed, and then you'll be able to go and return with ease and certainty. No need to jump ahead. Nothing else. The floor is open for questions coming out of the practice, anything it would help to have resolved, and anything broader as well. Yeah. "So, my experience of access concentration today... in the middle of it, and I practiced this evening for a while with the intention just to sit as long as it took to see it again. I sat for about 60 minutes and got a little glimmer of it, and then a little more, but it never stabilized. And I'm noticing I'm now determined to understand what brings forth access concentration and the nimitta. I'll get to my question in a second. So far I'm seeing more subtle hindrances show up, little tensions where I realize, 'Oh, I don't have to give this my attention,' right?

0:24:36And I go back to the breath, and then the breath feels nicer, and that's as far as I've gotten. I'm wondering if there's a more advanced lesson about the nimitta and access concentration you can give. I'm trying to get the little bits. I don't know. I don't know what my question is." Okay, here's the most advanced lesson I can give on developing the strongest access concentration it's possible to have, and the full development of the nimitta. "Okay, great." Whatever your object is, stay with it at all times, in all situations, and when you notice that your mind has moved, let go of whatever it's moved to and bring it back to the object (with the breath, focus here). That's it. "Thank you." And when the nimitta arises, don't fuck with it. Don't touch it. Don't get interested in it. Don't get fascinated with it. Don't poke it. Don't play with it. Leave it alone. Leave everything else alone. "Heard.

0:25:49Got it." "I'm curious about the siddhis referenced in the suttas. I know they don't directly pertain to awakening, but it just seems so curious: we're on this path and we're basically taking what it says as truth. The jhanas are true; awakening is a well-trodden path. So what about the siddhis? I'm curious what you think about them, or your teachers, or people." Sure. "Are these real possibilities, like entering the jhanas is?" Yeah. Well, I'll start with some of my teachers. Most of the teachers who have been most important to me do, by conventional standards, hold a whole lot of supernatural beliefs, based on their own experiences or those of people they trust. Leigh Brasington is of the opinion that many of these things can be explained in terms of out-of-body experiences: entering a kind of wakeful, lucid-dream-like state in which one can perform these apparent miracles within the domain of one's own mind, but that they don't have an effect in consensus reality.5

0:27:25And that is definitely true; at least, I can confirm it from some personal experience, and from friends of mine who have much more extensive experience playing around in these territories. You can certainly do everything listed there within the boundaries of one's own mind, at least. With the mind made malleable, you can have perceptions exactly as described. Being one, you can become many; being many, you become one; you can polylocate; you can fly through solid objects; you can touch the sun and the moon; you can travel to other realms. You can have all these seemingly miraculous perceptions. You can appear to know the minds of others; you can see beings arising and passing away; you can apparently recollect past lives. Yes, all of that, for sure: at least within the boundaries of one's own mind, those are experiences one can have if one develops concentration and inclines the mind in certain ways. The reality status of all of that? You let me know. The question is: what is the reality status of this, right now, at the same time?

0:28:36"I'm curious: so there's no consensus experience, even from your teachers, of two people seeing somebody float or go through a wall?" I tend not to ask about these kinds of things. But I do know people directly who have witnessed some things that are pretty hard to explain, and I believe them that they witnessed those things. "Not like that?" [unclear] Yeah, sure. Anyone? I'm not sure who's next. [Participant], yeah. "I don't know if this question is appropriate for the setting, but I'm wondering if you could speak to the purification that happens, especially with jhana or [unclear], with intense practice. I know you spoke a little about things coming up, but I'm curious about physical purification, and whether there's any guidance or support. Or is it something you notice, but you stick to the practice and tax yourself, at the cost of what's happening physically?"

0:30:14Tax yourself? Is this like a boot camp? "Like, I don't care how I feel or that I need to sleep, or these other physical symptoms of purification I've been with. They're definitely happening. Other things were bubbling up before, but now it's physical, and I'm like, 'Oh, this is going to be purification.' So I found myself sleeping a little more today, because I needed it. Do I avoid that, because this is boot camp and I should be pushing? I just need guidance, because this is all new." Yeah, absolutely. This is not boot camp. If you want that, there are other retreats or monasteries you can go to. If you find that what's arising for you, psychologically, energetically, emotionally, however it's classed or categorized, is exhausting, and you need to sleep more, take naps. If you find that the intensity of practice, the intensity of concentration, is disrupting your sleep in a concerning way, you can ease off.

0:31:24Eat more fatty food. If something like that is coming up in a way that's concerning to you, let me know; there are things you can do. And also, sometimes, if it's all right, if it's within your window of tolerance, you might sleep a little less or sleep a little more. You have intense energetic and emotional stuff moving through and dissolving and being released, and that can be really intense, and it can be okay. It just depends on your window of tolerance, and what feels healthy. "So it's not like, 'I see that, but avoid it, stay focused'? What's the recommendation in those books?" Okay, yeah: the standard recommendation is just to stay the course with the practice. The failure mode of that is that when too much intensity comes up, you go outside your window of tolerance, and then you can become mentally or physically unstable, and actually cause yourself illness. There are contemporary and historical accounts of people becoming psychologically, energetically, physically ill as a result of doing too much intense practice, in a way that was too taxing too fast for their body, for their nervous system.

0:32:45"That's what I'm feeling. If I don't tend to my health, I'm fighting against it; I'm fighting my body, and my body's going to win." Yeah. Urgency is good, and if you want to be all hardcore and macho and spit on your life like Siddhartha, okay. But my recommendation is to take care of yourself. Go for a sustainable burn. "Thank you." You're welcome. The hairiest it ever got for me was when I had started doing tummo, a very intensely energetic practice. I was really excited by it and started doing it a whole bunch, and then it seemed to get into a loop of energetic intensification. Huge amounts of psychological and energetic stuff were coming up and blasting off all day, and that was really cool for about two days ("Great, this is all good things"), and then I stopped being able to sleep for more than two hours a night, and that went on for 10 days, even after I stopped the practice. That was not so fun. I was hypomanic. It was fine, but it was concerning, and the effects persisted for about 10 days even after I stopped the practice. I was able to bring myself down by easing off practice and making adjustments to my diet, to ground everything down.

0:34:40So take care of yourself, and let me know if things are going up, or otherwise. Yeah. "Here's another topic, hopefully not too much. I was coming out of a sit with deep jhana, and I experienced what I'd describe as sleep paralysis. I was trying to do the motion that moves the hand, and it just wouldn't; I was glued to the floor. I thought, 'Okay, I guess I'll wait,' and eventually I could. There was some fear: 'Ugh, what's going on here?' Is that a sign of pushing it too much, or is it fine?" Yeah, no, I've experienced that before. You can get so absorbed that when you emerge from the absorption, it takes a while for ordinary motor function to come back online. If you know that can happen, you can just go, "Okay, just a pulse. Okay, can I move my hand? Still no. Okay, how about now? Oh, okay, we're back." I haven't experienced that in a long time, and I've had deeper absorption since, so it might just be your nervous system adjusting. But let me know; it's a weird thing that can happen.

0:36:09"I don't know if this is a question, but for your reference, could you also say something about your teachers and so on, just so I don't forget? But the practice question: when I'm working with sukha, I'm tempted to bounce back to the piti to keep brightening it and softening it, and it's almost like a ping-pong thing that wants to happen. Would you lean into that? Is it helpful? Or would you recommend trying just to stay with the sukha, particularly the not-so-bright, kind of muddy sukha?"

0:37:08You have free rein to play around. If you're attempting to shift over into the second jhana, just give priority to the sukha and let the piti die down to a low hum in the background. And you'll get much more familiarity with both qualities, how they're distinct, how they overlap, how they interact, by moving backwards and forwards. That process of moving backwards and forwards is a kind of ping-pong thing, but at first it's just to get really acquainted with each. Was there another part of the question? The teachers I've been closest to and worked with mostly one-on-one: I owe a lot to Shinzen. We didn't and don't have a very close relationship, but the times we've interacted have been very impactful for me, very important. I received my formal teacher training through him and his organization, and then encouragement from him to teach, to get out there. And then Leigh Brasington as well, very important. I already had a samadhi practice and a jhana practice, but working with him on retreat really refined my understanding of my practice, and he likewise was like, "Yep, you know this well enough. Go."

0:38:46I asked if he thought it was a good idea, and he said yes, so here I am. Then, on the Zen side: I was at Zen Mountain Monastery for a little over a year, and most of that time I did koan practice with the abbot there, Shugen Roshi, although I also worked with the two other teachers in that institution, Hojin and Hogan, and I feel an immense debt of gratitude to all three. Their lineage is a kind of hybridized Soto-Rinzai blend, through Maezumi Roshi, Daido, and then Shugen, Hojin and Hogan. I should go back and visit. And then I'm continuing now with Mugen Roshi as well, Stephen Snyder. I met with him one-on-one, often at points where something big had shifted in my practice and I was like, "Who can I reach out to? Okay, I'm going to go talk to Stephen." And I went on retreat with him for the first time this past March, which was wonderful. His lineages are Theravada, and also, actually, a different branch of the same Soto-Rinzai hybrid lineage.

0:40:18And then there are the two teachers I'm primarily continuing to work with on an ongoing basis, though I'll still take any opportunity to study with Leigh, Shinzen, Shugen Roshi and all that. The two teachers I'm in it with for the remainder: as long as they're alive, I'll continue going to them and make it a priority. Meido Roshi at Korinji: I've been going on retreat at Korinji for a little more than two years now, and I spent three months there this past winter. His lineage is straight Rinzai. If you want a disciplined, boot-camp environment, go there. That's the kind of good stuff. And then Lama Justin von Bujdoss, whose lineages are Kagyu and Nyingma. The training I've done, and continue to do, in Vajrayana and Dzogchen is with him. "Lama Justin. Never heard of him. And you said Stephen Snyder has Theravada and Zen [unclear]? That's interesting." Yeah. His primary Theravada teacher is Pa Auk Sayadaw, and then there's his Soto-Rinzai line.67

0:41:40He trained with several teachers earlier in his practice career, but finished the Zen curriculum with Mark Minenberg Roshi, who's actually a Dharma brother of Shugen; they trained together under Daido. Small world. "Where does Stephen teach?" Online, and in person at retreats. He's kind of independent, not associated with a center as such. Yeah. And I go out of my way not to claim authorization or the lineage imprimatur, even though I don't think any of the people I've mentioned have any problem with what I'm doing. I'm off-brand, okay? "First of all: in Zen there's this koan practice after awakening, kind of like [unclear]. In Tibetan Buddhism, it's like you do it once, and then you keep doing it, keep [unclear], keep being there. Is there something I can do further, like a koan, something to do after awakening, so we keep going?" Yeah. There's this wonderful sutta in the canon that describes the practice for one prior to stream entry, after stream entry, and then all the way through arahantship and after arahantship.8

0:43:03Okay. And it's exactly the same practice all the way through: the four foundations of mindfulness, jhana, the brahmaviharas, meditation on the three characteristics, all the way through, including after arahantship. What does an arahant do in their spare time? They hang out in jhana. They play with the powers. They meditate on the three characteristics. They're mindful of the body, having a pleasant abiding in the here and now. "I have a follow-up question. Do you think that's equivalent in practice? If you were to do Theravada all the way to the end, is there any benefit to doing koans on top of that, or before it, if you had the choice of how to spend your time?" I wouldn't know. I haven't reached the end of the Theravada path, and I've done relatively little koan training, so I wouldn't know. Yeah. "I'm curious... I've just listened to a certain description of the path as set out in the Pali Canon, and with this centrality of jhana and cessation, it gives a certain impression of the level of mastery of samadhi that's required.

0:44:27And I'm curious how you think about that in terms of the extant Theravada schools that don't rely on jhana, and other branches. Everyone seems to agree that samadhi is important, but there's a different map. And awakening seems more or less attainable to me depending on who I talk to: one person says, 'Oh, just ask "Who am I?" all day for six months,' and another says, 'Master the eight jhanas.'" Yeah. Well, mastering the eight jhanas, or plowing deeper into samadhi, certainly won't hurt. It certainly won't hurt. Is it necessary? No. In the Pali Canon, and in the extant Theravada lineages, there are people who are deeply attained and don't have mastery of jhana to that level. The very orthodox answer, from the Abhidhamma and the Visuddhimagga, is that at the moment of a path attainment one needs a jhanic level of concentration, even if one isn't going through jhana. But there's a sutta that delineates arahants who are released through discernment, those released through the temporary attainments, and those who are released both ways.910

0:45:48So there are some who reach arahantship without mastery of the jhanas (which are considered temporary releases). And if one did attain release through discernment, through insight, in contemporary language we might say through a more dry approach, without that depth of samadhi, then it's recommended: why not be released both ways? But even in the Pali Canon it's not necessary to have that degree of mastery. Likewise, there are arahants who can attain the first four jhanas, but not the formless attainments, and some who can do all eight, but not the cessation of perception and feeling. "Yeah. And do you have any wild speculation about what's actually going on for someone who has a moment of awakening without a degree of mastery of jhana? There's the Abhidhamma explanation, but I'm curious whether that tracks for you, or koans, or..." Yeah. Whether a glimpse of awakening stabilizes, and how deeply it impacts and permeates, seems to have a lot to do with samadhi, both leading up to that moment and after. And if you're doing something like koan practice, or another method of inquiry, and taking it up all the time, day in, day out, moment after moment, you're building up real horsepower in samadhi.

0:47:28So, I don't know. Is that...? "Yeah, cool." You're welcome. Now, [one participant] and then [another]. "I've read a variety of books, practices and techniques around jhana that are about smiling, making a smile part of your posture. I'm wondering if I should throw that into my current practice. I guess, straightforwardly: what's your take on smiling?" In my own experience, I find it quite helpful. Just the bare... if you see statues of the Buddha, the smile. And often, as concentration deepens for me, it gets bigger, and if I'm not worried about looking really weird, it'll go to a full toothy smile as the concentration deepens and the factors increase. On the retreat with Stephen earlier this year, I did find that, up to a certain depth of access concentration, smiling was helpful, or at least not obtrusive, but then even that tiny bit of muscular facial tension got irritating and interfered with the concentration. So I went blank, completely neutral, no muscle tension, and then it could develop further.

0:49:04I found it to be an obstacle at a certain point, but that was pretty far along. So I'm pro-smiling. Yeah. "What was your experience of koan training like?" I spent the better part of a year working with the famous koan Mu: "Does a dog have Buddha nature or not?" Joshu answered "Mu," which means no, or does not have. And I absolutely fucking hated it for a long time. I'd done all this practice up to that point: some fluency and mastery of jhana and insight practice and other things, the ability to enter all these different states, and what I thought at the time, anyway, was a pretty decent grasp of emptiness and selflessness. But I was still impelled to go further into practice, because it was not quite there. And it was exactly as described: like a red-hot iron ball that one has swallowed and can't spit up. The method, as commonly instructed, is to yoke the key phrase or the word to the cycle of the breath.11

0:50:42If you do that kind of practice and stay with it, you become progressively and more continuously absorbed in the inquiry, in the question. (Or "Who am I?", or "What is this?"; it's all getting at the same thing, going straight to the source of the issue.) And that becomes ever more consuming, and at a certain point (this happened for me) you couldn't stop the practice even if you wanted to. It's as though you're a person possessed, and it doesn't stop until it's resolved. At a certain point, after, I don't know, about 10 days of really not being able to put it down even for a second (not that I wanted to, but I found I couldn't), there was a phase shift. There had been some deepening up to that point, but now everything I saw, everything I heard, all my bodily sensations, all the transient states and signs of concentration rising and passing away, absolutely everything, was wrapped up and entangled with this Mu that you can't... A large part of koan practice, if you're doing it traditionally (and if you want to do it, I'd recommend you actually work with a teacher), is going frequently to the teacher, who will ask you, "What is Mu?

0:52:30"Show me Mu." And that's not a question you can answer in any way except from awakening itself, so any answer you give that's not a direct manifestation of awakening will be rejected flatly. And that is maddening. Eventually it came to a point and broke open, and what I'd been looking for for seven years resolved. Not done, but the main issue was through. "Did you have answers that you thought would be accepted that were in fact rejected, or did you not submit any?" No, I knew, at that point. Sometimes I would try shit; I made jokes sometimes. More frequently, though, I'd just end up... The practice of meeting with the teacher when you're doing koan practice: you're holding it as best you can, 24/7, and while you're going in to the interview you're in the practice. Sanzen is "going for Zen"; dokusan is meeting with the abbot alone, but it's going for Zen with a realized teacher. The interview is not a chat about practice; it is practice, and you're being asked right there to resolve the great matter of life and death, now. Charged!

0:54:28For a long time, every time it was my turn to go in for an interview, I felt like I was waiting in line for the executioner's block. My heart would pound, and I'd sweat through my robes. So if that sounds appealing, go do koan practice. [Participant]. "Okay, I'm dying to hear: could you just answer it for us, right here, right now, from that place? Whether I understand or not, just say it?" No. "So there's a different answer for each person, based on their response?" It could be anything. And if the teacher is genuine, they'll know without you having to say anything. "Okay, so the teacher is judging whether your response is coming from that place." Yeah, and they know. It's not... "In Mahayana, the ideal seems pretty nice, right? You go around doing deeds for all beings, everyone gets enlightened, and it seems worse to get enlightened and then hang out in mastery than to be a bodhisattva. I guess the question is: the vibe and flavor of this retreat feels very far from that; it's going to a place where we probably don't want to go, living in our heads.

0:56:28"The bodhisattva vibe is better, and you're a Mahayana guy. Why doesn't this retreat have a Mahayana flavor? Not yet, anyway; that's the question." I started the retreat within the context and framing of bodhicitta, and I've been trying to frame it and point back to a non-dual view. But partly because of my own path and practice, these foundational elements, and the framing in the early texts, I've found so inspiring and invigorating, and the practice so valuable, that there's a part of me that wants to honor what's there and present it without my own spin. And in my own experience of practice, where these early practices lead is exactly the same place I glimpsed early on, reached through Zen practice, and have continued to refine and work through in Vajrayana and Dzogchen and a little Mahamudra instruction. It's all, in my own lived experience (not to abuse that often-invoked term), the same in essence. So I have full faith and confidence that if you follow the instructions I've given, which come out of these texts, and if you actually realize them, you'll have realized the point of Zen, you'll have realized the point of Dzogchen, you'll have realized the point of tantra.

0:58:14And yeah, that's extra heretical, but that's my experience. "Where do you recommend going after this?" Maybe one last question, if there is one; if not, we'll break and sit. "Just one clarifying question about the koan thing again. The thing that has to be achieved before a satisfactory answer can be given to the koan: is that stream entry, or what?" This is a little complicated, and it depends on the koan lineage. A little backroom gossip: different koan lineages have different standards, and within the Zen scene this is a known fact. Also, the same teacher may set different standards for different students, if they feel they can push a student further. Meido Roshi has said publicly that, given the response and the depth of awakening he had realized when he was passed on his initial koan, he's not sure he would pass himself. So it really is contextual. "Yeah. So the whole practice is: you get a gold star from the teacher, and they're like, 'You did it. Congratulations'?" No, you don't get a gold star.

1:00:29"But it seems like the subjective 'you did it' finish line is..." Nope, not a finish line. It's: "Okay, bucko, you've just started. Let's go." "Okay. So wait: is there an end to koan practice, or isn't there?" There's an end to the formal curriculum, which I wouldn't know anything about. But even then, again, there are different koan lineages, and at the completion of a curriculum it's sometimes customary for someone to take a koan to work on for the remainder of their life. Or they might go through the whole curriculum again at a deeper level; there are different things one might do, or be asked by one's teacher to do. But I know that in at least some koan lineages the final koan, either assigned or taken up oneself, is "not yet," because the end of the path for them is full and total Buddhahood, and in the traditional sense that's a high bar. No kudos until that point. And even then, what would you need kudos for?

1:01:55"Yeah, I mean, motivation, maybe. I don't know." Yeah. I did meet with Stephen Mugen shortly after the big pop for me. I don't even remember if I said anything, but he was like, "You did it. How did it feel?" Like a wet fart. It was just like, "Oh, yeah." It did nothing. Nothing anyone could say... Okay. Yeah. And part of what's so great about koan practice, and so terrible, is that you'll be absolutely shorn of your need for validation and confirmation, because you just won't get it. That's part of the point. Because what is it that's seeking confirmation? What is it that's seeking "You did it. Good boy, good job"? Okay, with that, let's take 10 minutes and then sit. Okay. Since some intensity has been coming up for a lot of folks (I know from interviews and from some of the questions that were asked), I'd like to offer a technique that can be used to bring too much rising energy down and to soothe and calm a system that may get stirred up and unbalanced through intensive practice. It has many touted benefits. It comes from Hakuin, who, in an obviously fabricated story (which he covertly admits to having made up), learned it from an immortal Taoist sage after he had made himself terribly, deathly ill by over-exerting himself in practice.12

1:04:36So get comfortable. You can do this lying down or sitting up. Okay. Thank you.

1:05:17Imagine that at the crown of your head (and you can use both visualization and felt sense; if visualization isn't so easy, you can lean more on the felt sense, and vice versa) there's a warm, fragrant, magically imbued ball of ghee, clarified butter, about the size of a duck's egg, infused with medicinal herbs, whatever scents are comforting to you, associated with healing and well-being. You can feel the heat from it on your scalp, the scent fragrant in the air. And from the heat of the ghee and the heat of your body, it begins to melt and drip over the outside of your scalp, and it also begins to seep down through the pores of your skin. And from here on it's dripping and coating and covering and saturating and suffusing, both externally along the skin and down through the interior of the body. Wherever it moves, the warmth pervades and permeates, and any tension, physical or energetic, any felt tension or obstacle, dissolves like dirty ice and runs down ahead of the dripping, warm, fragrant, healing ghee. It drips down through your head and over your brain (if you like to imagine that), through all your sinuses and mouth and nose and down through the throat, soothing and healing, melting everything away; dripping down through your throat, spreading internally and externally over and through your chest, your shoulders, down through your arms, your fingers; further down through the abdomen, completely coating and saturating, internally and externally, all the organs: along the heart, stomach and intestines, diaphragm, down through your bowels, through your hips and pelvis, melting down through your legs.

1:09:30And everything, all the accumulated tension, stress, illness, obscurations, whatever has melted away, runs out through the soles of your feet, and likewise the ghee drains out, leaving your body as pure and clear and light as a crystal vessel. You can do that once, very slowly (I ran through it rather quickly), or as many times as you like. Make it your own, and either continue with it a couple more times or transition to whatever your main practice is for the remainder of the session. At the end of this session I'll cue it, and we'll go through it again. It can be very good to do at the end of the day, or if you feel too elevated after a sit; it can bring you down. Or if you're too energized, buzzing, to go to sleep, it can help bring things down. You can carry on with whatever your practice has come to, or you can join in and imagine again that the crown of your head is this ball of clarified butter, fragrantly infused with medicinal herbs, aromatic spices, whatever signifies cleansing, health, purification to you. From the warmth of your own body and the warmth of the ghee, it begins to melt down on the outside and the inside of your body. Any obstruction, cause of illness, blockage melts like dirty ice, running down, draining away.

1:12:56The warm, fragrant ghee fills and saturates and suffuses wherever it goes, bringing ease and bliss and warmth, totally filling and soothing [unclear].

1:13:45Coating and filling and saturating all the organs, and smoothing and running down over the skin.

Sources

Translations are Thanissaro Bhikkhu's on dhammatalks.org unless noted.

  1. The five recollections. AN 5:57 Upajjhatthana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN5_57.html ↩
  2. Mara’s armies; “Do I carry muñja grass? I spit on my life”; the crow and the stone; the lute. Sn 3:2 Padhana Sutta (Exertion) dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/StNp/StNp3_2.html ↩
  3. “Seeing how, behaving how, is one said to be at peace?” Sn 4:10 Purabheda Sutta (Before the Break-up) dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/StNp/StNp4_10.html ↩
  4. The foolish and the wise mountain cow; the six higher knowledges. AN 9:35 Gavi Sutta (The Cow) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN9_35.html ↩
  5. Leigh Brasington on the powers as experiences within the mind. Leigh Brasington, Right Concentration (Shambhala, 2015) ↩
  6. Meido Moore Roshi and Korinji (Rinzai) korinji.org. korinji.org/ ↩
  7. Lama Justin von Bujdoss. Retreat Guru teacher page. retreat.guru/teachers/282-5320/lama-justin-von-bujdoss ↩
  8. The same practice before stream entry and after arahantship. SN 22:122 Silavant Sutta (Virtuous) dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN22_122.html ↩
  9. Arahants “released through discernment” without the formless attainments or powers. SN 12:70 Susima Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN12_70.html ↩
  10. Released both ways vs. released through discernment. MN 70 Kitagiri Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN70.html ↩
  11. Joshu’s Mu. Gateless Gate (Mumonkan), case 1. ↩
  12. The soft-butter (nanso) method and the hermit Hakuyu. Hakuin, Yasenkanna (Idle Talk on a Night Boat), trans. Norman Waddell in Hakuin’s Precious Mirror Cave (Counterpoint, 2009) ↩

← Wednesday, November 11 · Morning · All sessions · Thursday, November 12 · Morning →