Jhana & Awakening Retreat 2026 · Session 10 of 16

Wednesday, November 11 · Morning

Four modes of practice, four ways to arahantship, defilements of concentration (MN 128) and the thorns (AN 10:72); Q&A

Recorded November 11, 2026, 10:01 am Mountain Time · Nameless Mountain, Boulder, Colorado · 52 min

No new instructions this morning. Instead, four short texts gave a more nuanced map of how practice unfolds and what disturbs concentration. The Q&A was mostly about excitement and piti.

Topics and questions in this session

Talk

  • 0:00:00The four modes of practice (AN 4:162): painful or pleasant, with slow or quick intuition. There's no fifth category where it doesn't work (0:02).
  • 0:06:45His own path: for a while, practice was the only relief from intense aversion.
  • 0:07:15Four ways to arahantship (AN 4:170): insight preceded by tranquility, tranquility preceded by insight, the two in tandem, and restlessness about the Dhamma brought under control.
  • 0:09:58The defilements of concentration (MN 128): Anuruddha's lights and forms, and what made them fall away, including excitement (0:13).
  • 0:17:40The thorns (AN 10:72): noise is a thorn to the first jhana. Earplugs help (0:20).
  • 0:22:15Perception and feeling are a thorn to cessation.

Q&A

  • 0:24:05How to define passion, aversion and delusion, with examples.
  • 0:28:17A new hindrance: deep joy and gratitude, "as if someone gave me MDMA."
  • 0:32:48Piti that resonates with every sound and sensation.
  • 0:34:11How to be less excited when piti arises.
  • 0:36:51The five grades of piti (Visuddhimagga IV.94–99).
  • 0:41:46Slow walking can sustain concentration better than sitting. If so, walk more (0:44).
  • 0:45:37Experiences like LSD. Are they still within the possible kind of weird (0:46)?
  • 0:48:22Why not follow the breath inside from the nostrils?
Wednesday, November 11 · Morning

Edited transcript. The time at the start of each paragraph is where it begins in the recording above; drag the player to that point to listen. Participants' names are omitted. [Square brackets] mark editorial insertions; [unclear] marks words that couldn't be made out.

0:00:00Namo tassa bhagavato arahato sammā-sambuddhassa (three times). No real new instructions to give this morning, but some things following on from what's been present all through the retreat. This is a nice sutta, on the modes of practice in detail: "Monks, there are these four modes of practice. Which four? Painful practice with slow intuition, painful practice with quick intuition, pleasant practice with slow intuition, and pleasant practice with quick intuition." Which of the four would you like to be shown? There's more detail here, but it's right there in that first line: there's a way forward for us all. We don't get to choose which of these types of practitioner we are; how the path progresses depends on us and our unique causes and conditions up to this time. It's all relative, of course: how painful, how pleasant, how quick, how slow. I've experienced a lot of pain and a lot of pleasantness. Sometimes it seems to be going quickly, and sometimes it seems to be going agonizingly slowly.1

0:02:03I don't know which of these I fall into, but note that, for those who practice, there isn't a fifth category where it just doesn't work. "And which is painful practice with slow intuition? There is the case where a certain individual is normally of an intensely passionate nature, perpetually experiencing pain and distress born of passion; or normally of an intensely aversive nature, perpetually experiencing pain and distress born of aversion; or of an intensely deluded nature, perpetually experiencing pain and distress born of delusion. These five faculties (the faculty of conviction, of persistence, of mindfulness, of concentration, of discernment) appear weakly. Because of their weakness, he attains only slowly the immediacy that leads to the ending of the effluents." The effluents, again, show up all over the Pali Canon, but for some reason don't get talked about that much in contemporary sutta-based or Theravada-based discourse: the effluents of sensuality, of becoming and of ignorance, if I'm remembering correctly. "This is called painful practice with slow intuition." But it still works. And as those faculties increase and the hindrances decrease, the pain turns to pleasantness.

0:03:33"And which is painful practice with quick intuition? There is the case where a certain individual is normally of an intensely passionate nature, perpetually experiencing pain and distress born of passion," and likewise with aversion, "perpetually experiencing pain and distress born of aversion; or of an intensely deluded nature," experiencing "pain and distress born of delusion. But these five faculties of his (the faculty of conviction, of persistence, of mindfulness, of concentration, of discernment) appear intensely. Because of their intensity, he attains quickly the immediacy that leads to the ending of the effluents. This is called painful practice with quick intuition." So if you're of an intensely passionate, intensely aversive or intensely deluded nature, and yet, through where you begin the path, or because you quickly strive to develop these faculties, they're strong, then even if your passion, your aversion, your ignorance are very strong, progress can nonetheless be swift. "And which is pleasant practice with slow intuition?" You can see the pattern here: the pain and distress born of passion and aversion and delusion are not so strong, and yet the five faculties are weak, so progress is slow even as the practice is pleasant.

0:04:55And then, finally, pleasant practice with quick intuition: not terribly passionate, not terribly aversive, not prone to so much delusion, but with strong faculties of conviction, persistence, mindfulness, concentration and discernment, and therefore the path is attained quickly and pleasantly. One of the reasons I try to encourage people to work on satipatthana, on anapanasati, on the brahmaviharas, and on jhana as a fruition (potentially all of those) is that whichever of those four types of practitioner you are, if you master those foundations, those fundamentals, your practice can quickly become more pleasant than painful. We don't get to choose how practice unfolds, or what we've got to start with. I was intensely full of aversion, and still am sometimes. I struggle with all three, as everyone does, but of those three the strongest in me was definitely aversion: real disgust and hatred for myself, for the world, for everything. And I think I was strongly motivated to practice because I was in such distress from how intense my aversion was.

0:06:45For a while, the only relief I got from the really deep suffering caused by my intense aversion was through practice. So my early practice, I can tell you, was quite painful, but I was very motivated.

0:07:15So there are these four modes of practice: pleasant and quick, pleasant and slow, painful and quick, painful and slow. There are also different ways the path can develop. This is "In Tandem": "On one occasion Venerable Ananda was staying in Kosambi, at Ghosita's monastery. There he addressed the monks, 'Friends!' 'Yes, friend,' the monks responded to him." Venerable Ananda is the Buddha's cousin and attendant, renowned for having the best memory of all the Buddha's disciples; he memorized the whole canon (who knows if this is true) and thus helped in its transmission. [unclear]. "'Friends, whoever, monk or nun, declares the attainment of arahantship in my presence...'" (the complete fruition of the path): they all do it by means of one or another of four paths. The canon really likes fours; easy to remember, I suppose. Which four? "There is the case where a practitioner has developed insight preceded by tranquility. As they develop insight preceded by tranquility, the path is born. They follow that path, develop it and pursue it, and as they follow the path, developing it and pursuing it, the fetters are abandoned and obsessions are destroyed."2

0:08:37And likewise the grid is filled out: "tranquility preceded by insight." So you could have strong discernment and then use that as a basis for developing tranquility, or your tranquility can be strong and then insight can come after. Then there's developing tranquility in tandem with insight, a yoked approach, not leaning too far in either direction. And then there's actually a fourth here: "Then there is the case where a monk's mind has its restlessness concerning the Dhamma well under control. There comes a time when his mind grows steady inwardly, settles down, and becomes unified and concentrated. In him the path is born. He follows that path, develops it, pursues it. As he follows the path, developing it and pursuing it, his fetters are abandoned, his obsessions destroyed." Interesting: it doesn't mention either tranquility or insight here, just that the restlessness concerning the Dhamma is resolved; "he becomes settled." Maybe one of you will follow that path and can tell me what it means. But again, if we have an inclination or a choice, why not develop the path so that it's pleasant rather than unpleasant?

0:09:58Why not develop tranquility and use that as a basis for insight? Or do it in tandem; it's up to you and your inclinations. If there's a pleasant path, why not take it? Okay. And a little more on the signs of concentration and their causes. This is from another sutta, and some elements of it should strike a chord for some of you, with what you've been bringing up in interviews or in the Q&As. The Buddha is addressing an assembly of people practicing meditation who are perplexed; they don't really understand the causality of what's occurring in their practice. "'Lord, as we remain heedful, ardent and resolute in this way, we perceive both light and a vision of forms. But not long afterward the light and the vision of forms disappear, and we haven't ferreted out the reason for that.'" So, then as now: you get very concentrated, and for some people, as a sign of that concentration, you may perceive light, internally or externally. You may perceive forms with eyes closed, or you may experience visual stuff with your eyes open.3

0:11:28But everything that follows goes not only for visions of light and forms but for all the signs of concentration. "'Anuruddhas,'" the people the Buddha is speaking to, "'you should ferret out the reason for that. Even I, before my self-awakening, when I was still an unawakened bodhisattva, perceived both light and a vision of forms. But not long afterward the light and the vision of forms disappeared. The thought occurred to me: "What is the cause, what is the reason, why the light and the vision of forms have disappeared?" Then the thought occurred to me: "Doubt has arisen in me, and on account of the doubt my concentration fell away. With the falling away of concentration, the light and the vision of forms disappeared. I will act in such a way that doubt doesn't arise in me again." So, staying heedful, ardent and resolute, I perceived both light and a vision of forms. But not long afterward the light and the vision of forms disappeared.'" [unclear], it goes into a pattern.

0:12:19These provide a more nuanced picture than just the standard list of five hindrances, of issues that can arise in developing samadhi. "'Inattention has arisen in me... sloth and drowsiness have arisen in me... panic has arisen in me...'" So even for the Buddha, as his concentration started to get strong: doubt, inattention... "'Panic has arisen in me, and on account of the panic my concentration fell away. With the falling away of concentration, the light and the vision of forms disappeared. Suppose, Anuruddhas, that a man was traveling along a road and murderers appeared on both sides. He would, for that reason, feel panic. In the same way, panic arose in me, and on account of the panic my concentration fell away. With the falling away of concentration, the light and the vision of forms disappeared. I will act in such a way that doubt, inattention, sloth and drowsiness, and panic don't arise in me again.'" And it keeps going: light and the vision of forms; okay, no more doubt, no more inattention, no more sloth and drowsiness, no more panic.

0:13:28And then what? Excitement! "'And on account of the excitement my concentration fell away. Suppose, Anuruddhas, that a man searching for portals to hidden treasure suddenly came across five portals to hidden treasure. He would, for that reason, feel excitement. In the same way, excitement arose in me...'" Lights, colors, ooh! "'I will act in such a way that doubt, inattention, sloth and drowsiness, panic, and excitement don't arise in me again.'" So he gets it going again, ramps it back up, and the light and the vision of forms appear, and then they disappear. "Okay, why now? What gives?" "'Boredom has arisen in me...'" Or "'excess persistence has arisen in me, and on account of the excess persistence my concentration fell away'"; and thus the light and the vision of forms fall away. "'Suppose, Anuruddhas, that a man was grasping a baby quail tightly with both hands. It would die right there. In the same way, excess persistence arose in me.'" If you're squeezing or pushing too much in the practice, it's like killing a baby bird in your hands.

0:14:48So, staying heedful, ardent and resolute again, he perceives light and the vision of forms, but not long afterward they disappear. Okay, what now? "'Slack persistence has arisen in me.'" Shit. Too tight; oh, too loose. "'Suppose, Anuruddhas, that a man was holding a baby quail loosely. It would fly out of his hand. In the same way, slack persistence arose in me.'" So don't kill the baby bird, and don't let it fly out of your hands. "'With the falling away of concentration, the light and the vision of forms disappeared. I will act in such a way that doubt, inattention, sloth and drowsiness, panic, excitement, boredom, excess persistence, and slack persistence don't arise in me again.'" So the light and the vision of forms come back. Oh, then they disappear again. Okay, what now? "'The thought occurred to me: "A perception of multiplicity has arisen in me... Excessive absorption in forms has arisen in me, and on account of the excessive absorption in forms my concentration fell away"'"; and thus the vision of forms falls away. So if you're getting signs of concentration, of deepening absorption, and they're multiple, and your mind becomes dispersed, either in the signs of concentration or in external sensory input or internal sensory experience; if the mind moves into multiplicity rather than unification and collectedness, the concentration will fall away.

0:16:25Or if you get absorbed in any of the forms that may begin to appear, the concentration will weaken. There's a parallel, not with light and forms here, but if some of the jhanic factors are arising, piti and sukha, and yet the concentration isn't strong enough yet, and you get fascinated with the details, or play around with it too much, or get absorbed in multiplicity, or start thinking, "Oh my goodness, is this piti and sukha?", and then start thinking about all the wonderful things you're going to do once you've mastered the first jhana: okay, the concentration will fall away. So he resolves: "'I will act in such a way that doubt, inattention, sloth and drowsiness, panic, excitement, boredom, excess persistence, slack persistence, a perception of multiplicity, and excessive absorption in forms don't arise in me again.' So, understanding that doubt is a defilement of the mind, I abandoned doubt. Understanding that inattention..." (sloth and drowsiness, panic, excitement, boredom, excess persistence, slack persistence, a perception of multiplicity, excessive absorption in forms) "...is a defilement of the mind, I abandoned it."

0:17:40"I abandoned them. Then, staying heedful, ardent and resolute, I perceived light but didn't see forms, or saw forms but didn't perceive light, for an entire night, for an entire day and night." It goes on a little; at first the light is limited and then it becomes limitless, the forms are limited and then become limitless, and he uses this intense, malleable concentration to move through and, as anyone can, attain awakening on that basis. And a last reading and commentary before moving into questions, if there are any (if not, we'll just practice): more on some obstacles to developing samadhi and progressing through jhana. "'For the jhanas have been said by me to be thorned by noise. There are these ten thorns. Which ten? For one who loves seclusion, love of entanglement is a thorn.'" So if you're attempting to bring the mind and body and attention into seclusion, into withdrawal, into absorption, being preoccupied with entanglement in motion, in activity, in all the busyness we usually are in, is going to slow you down, at least.4

0:19:32And some of these are more relevant to the monks. "'For one committed to the theme of the unattractive, commitment to the theme of the attractive is a thorn.'" So if you're using the antidote to the hindrance of sensual desire, contemplating the unattractiveness of the body, and you're committed to fantasizing about and longing after food and odors and whatever else, it's going to be hard to detach. "'For one guarding the sense doors, watching a show is a thorn.'" Imagine monks sneaking off to watch puppet shows or magicians, dances, music. Not that there's anything wrong with any of those, in my opinion, but for the development of deep samadhi, yes: all of that, listening to music, any form of entertainment, anything that's not continuing the practice, will slow the development of samadhi. "'For one practicing celibacy, nearness to those one finds attractive is a thorn.'" They take a kind of blunt-force approach in the early texts: "Oh, you're distracted by these things? Just stay the hell away." "'For the first jhana, noise is a thorn.'"

0:20:55So if it helps, put in earplugs or noise-canceling headphones, if an abandoned hut, the foot of a tree or an empty wilderness isn't immediately accessible to you, or if you're like us, in, let's call them, cozy retreat quarters, with a lot of noise. It can be good to work with that and learn that you can become more and more deeply concentrated even with slight disturbances and noises, but if you can find some way to eliminate that barrier for yourself, do go for it. "'For the second jhana, directed thought and evaluation are thorns.'" Any residual perturbation in mental space will prevent fuller settling into the second jhana. "'For the third jhana, rapture is a thorn.'" That intense rush of rapture is actually agitating past a certain point, and the deeper settling and unification of the third jhana isn't accessible as long as there's rapture remaining. "'For the fourth jhana, in-and-out breaths are thorns.'" Even that much disturbance, feeling the passage of breath, prevents the mind from settling into that deepest stillness.

0:22:15"'For the attainment of the cessation of perception and feeling...'" (it just skips over the formless attainments) "'...perception and feeling are thorns.'" Okay, yeah. And then the three root defilements, or root afflictions: "'Passion is a thorn. Aversion is a thorn. Delusion is a thorn.'" These are also referred to as the three fires, the extinguishing of which is nirvana. "'Dwell unthorned, monks. Dwell unthorned and dethorned.'" It's interesting: a lot of the things listed here as thorns, someone attempting to enter deep samadhi, or acquainted with deep samadhi, would think of as thorns. In-and-out breaths, a thorn: an irritation, a puncture in the skin, like that. "No, I like reading; it's nice, thank you. Entertainment, sound: I like sound." But for accessing these more refined, more secluded, more collected states, all of these agitations and sensory disturbances slow down or prohibit the deeper, more subtle, more refined, more pleasurable (no, more than pleasurable: more sublime) states. And then it would be an error, on the basis of acquaintance with these states, to form an aversion to all of these things.5

0:24:05That often happens in the course of training, and if it does, that's fine. You can get attached to jhana or deep samadhi; it's okay. And if you find you're temporarily more irritated by light and noise and movement, that's all right. But eventually, through making the transition in and out of deep samadhi, and learning to sustain samadhi in motion and in contact with sensory events, it's not a problem: eyes open, eyes closed, in motion, in stillness, sensorially withdrawn or in full contact. You can dwell unthorned, without passion, without aversion, without delusion, and all the other thorns cease to be thorns. Okay, that's all I have to yap about this morning. Are there any questions? Okay, you spoke first, so you go first. "I'm curious: how would you define passion, aversion and delusion, ideally with examples as well?" Sure. "I really want pizza right now." My mind is obsessed with this image of cheesy perfection, of salty deliciousness, and because of that there's an embodied tug and pull and clenching around the mental formation of this idea of pizza. I'm longing, and my mind is inclining towards it.

0:26:16And because of that, I'm not comfortable. There's something out there that I've got to get. Broaden that to any experience, any sense object. "Aversion is a thorn": I'm trying to get deeply concentrated, and there's all this fucking noise. Water running through the house, footsteps, the creaking of wooden floors, birds outside. "Get it to stop. Go away. No, not right now. Stop." That's aversion; broaden that out. "Delusion is a thorn": delusion is what actually underlies both of those, the pushing and the pulling, "I want this, I don't want this." It's the confusion, the bifurcation into I and not-I, the identification: "This is me, this is myself, this is mine." On the basis of that split in consciousness between here and there, this and that, me and not me, the world is split into what's good for me and what's bad for me. And then you've got the wave machine going, which will just push and pull and tug, and there's no end to that unless it's resolved at the source.

0:28:17And if you let go of passion or aversion completely... the delusion, in a sense, is nothing but that kind of splitting. These aren't actually three separate things. It's a way the mind relates to experience that shows up as splitting and pushing and pulling. And if one of those three is completely undone, then it's all undone, because the split collapses. "I have more questions, but I think they'd take a lot of time. So thank you." Yeah. Okay, I'm not sure whose hand went up first, but this time it was you. "Okay. I guess there's a new hindrance in my mind. I feel this deep joy and gratitude, and I feel like someone gave me an MDMA [unclear]. I'm like, 'Oh, everything is awesome. And the prairie dogs, and you're a great teacher,' and I want to tell my friends how much [unclear], and so forth. This is a new one. With the other ones I kind of know how to deal with them, but this one I haven't been able to get [past], even in the meditation today."

0:29:35Yeah. It's a kind of excess joy, excess proliferation on the basis of a positive feeling. "It's so wholesome. These ones feel so nice." Yeah. When I started to practice, my mind was so constantly ruminating in such a horribly negative way that, likewise, when I started to get more concentrated more regularly and started to think happy thoughts, I was like, "Oh my goodness, everyone is so beautiful and wonderful, and we're all walking this path together, and I want to tell everybody how amazing..." And that's lovely; that's wonderful. But, as with negative thinking and proliferation, you just leave it in the background and let it run, without engaging it or pushing it away. If you're feeling glad, great, feel glad; don't suppress that. If you're feeling grateful, wonderful. But whatever proliferation arises on that basis, if you love it, let it go. Come back and re-engage, and it may just tire itself out.

0:31:04"The other ones have specific antidotes. Is there something specific for this one? Because my mind is very reluctant to let this one go." Yeah, at least [unclear]: an excess of levity, or inattention resulting from a positive state, right? Mindfulness of death is always good for me. If you're familiar with formal ways of practicing it, you can go through the stages of illness, death and decay of your own body, everything you feel that you are. You think I'm such a great teacher? Okay: do the stages of decay on me, and see that there's nothing there. Within and without, there's nothing lasting to form the basis of this kind of proliferation. "Yes, that's a good one. Thank you." Yeah. "I want to double-click on the sense-contact hindrance, because I guess it doesn't make sense to me. I've been experimenting throughout the day: say there's a beautiful sunset or something, and the piti is going strong, and it just magnifies the piti. It almost seems like there's a way to interpret every perception as piti-inducing.6

0:32:48The bell rings: 'That's nice.' Or someone coughs: 'Oh, more piti.' So should I lean into that? Is that sense contact in a way? Because it seems helpful." Yeah, I'm familiar with what you're talking about. When you've got a strong enough momentum of concentration, it's almost as if you've got a resonant chamber set up in the body-mind, and when any ordinary sense contact makes contact, a sound or some sensory contact touches it and it just goes boom: it resonates at the frequency of what's set up in the body, and it can spark it, spike it. That's great. See for yourself, but in my experience, if that's happening, great; you don't have to resist it. But I'd recommend against seeking out sensory contacts to spike the internal absorption, or the spurts of pleasure arising from the concentration. You'll actually develop much deeper and much more intense absorption just staying with it.

0:34:11And then, when you open your eyes and everything is a pure land of vibrating bliss and light, okay, great, that's nice. But you'll go further if you keep it grounded within. [Participant], yeah. "I'm just wondering how we can get less excited, as in the story, when he was seeing these beautiful lights and colors, or forms. When I feel a lot of piti, I get a really excited feeling, and I'm trying to separate the two, because being really excited almost feels like some of the energy of piti. So how can I separate those two things? How can I become more neutral to it when those feelings come up? Neutral is the wrong word; maybe more equanimous. (I can't say that one.)" Yeah. You don't have to be neutral. The kind of excitement that's problematic for deepening samadhi here is the kind that agitates the mind, that diverts it from the object.

0:35:41If you're taking pleasure and delight and joy in the meditation, in the object, in the jhanic factors if they're arising, that's good; that will help you stabilize and plunge deeper into it. It's more the kind that starts sparking commentary, excess analysis ("Wow, this is really great. Oh wow, this is really intense"), or a kind of jitteriness. Then taking a deep breath out might help, or just noticing that it's happening, letting it go, and reorienting to deeper contact with the object or the jhanic factor. "Okay. So just try not to get... I don't know, I'm just such an excitable person all the time, normally. So when the piti comes, I'm like, 'Oh my God, it's here! Woo!' So I guess I just need to really focus on the breath a lot more, and not put my attention into the piti too much, or into whatever I'm concentrating on in that moment, and really hone in on that.

0:36:51My second question: some of the piti I've felt is very intense, and that's probably when I get super excited; it almost scares me out of it because I'm so excited. But yesterday you were talking about becoming a connoisseur of piti, or whatever it was, paying attention to its more delicate parts. And I know there are five stages, or forms, of piti. Are all of those forms still considered part of the first jhana? Or is there a certain level of piti and excitement you have to build to before it's really considered jhana? Or is this super-gentle form still a part of it?" Yeah. There are five grades. I don't have them memorized, but thankfully, with the internet, I can look at them here. Yay. They all count.7

0:37:54It depends on who you ask, but for a stable, mature, strong version of the first jhana, it's the fifth you're going for. You can read the descriptions: it's all-pervasive, completely filling and suffusing and saturating the whole body. Then you're at the fifth grade. But in access concentration, and in lighter or less absorbed versions of the first jhana, you'll get more of the first four. Minor joy: goosebumps, the hair on the body standing on end, tears, quiet satisfaction. Momentary joy: intermittent flashes; this stage is often the first thing people notice. You might get sparks, or currents running through the body. Then flooding, or wave-like joy, if it's undulating or washing or waving through, but still inconstant, not so stable. And then transporting, or uplifting, joy: welling up intensely, more constant, almost like a geyser coming up. This can cause involuntary movements, shaking.

0:39:13You might feel like you're floating up off your seat, different kinds of things. And then finally, all-pervading piti. When you're at all-pervading piti, you can sustain it for a very long time, comfortably and stably, in the first jhana. The body is just evenly flooded and saturated and suffused with piti. It's not coming or going; it's not fluctuating so wildly in intensity. It's just a very stable, very strong, even hum or buzz. "I see. Okay. So that's why it's definitely important to keep exploring the first jhana a lot: to go through all these different stages and let it grow up to the fifth stage. Okay, cool. Thank you." You're welcome. Just a little note on what you said earlier: there's practically always no harm in just staying with the base object more and letting access concentration develop deeper.

0:40:14But if whatever piti or pleasurable sensation you're experiencing can sustain your attention, you can also switch to that, and you may find success either way. "Yeah, thank you." And for everyone: you can just stay with deepening access concentration until, when you switch, it turns on to this fifth stage of piti, where it's all-pervasive; or you can build up piti more gradually, until it widens and stabilizes and intensifies into that all-pervasive stage. Yeah. "I have a question [unclear], specifically between postures. In your instructions, there's this sitting still, and the idea was that being still is more conducive to deeper concentration. I've found that to be true in my own experience when I'm already in jhana: when there's sufficient absorption, it takes very little effort to just stay and deepen in it, and staying in the same posture is very helpful.

0:41:46But what I've been noticing these last couple of days, while I'm still working with access concentration, the kind where there's more volitional moving and returning of attention to the object, is that slow, mindful walking seems to be better for sustaining that involvement. My suspicion is that it takes a little mental activity to keep walking, avoid obstacles and so on, and that somehow reminds the mind to check in, or something like that. So I'm wondering if, while I'm still developing access concentration, it might be helpful to do a lot more walking meditation than I otherwise would, and then switch over as, yeah, as I think." I suspect that may not have come through online. The question was about the pros and cons of keeping complete stillness, or alternating with more motion, working with the breath.

0:43:08It will vary between people. It seems likely to me that you can't get to the same depth of concentration, and certainly not full absorption, while engaging in motor activity, but it's still useful for developing access concentration. Your experience matches my own. I can remember, in the first weeks when I started trying to stay with the breath constantly, all the time, my walking meditation periods were much more concentrated than my sitting. I think it's exactly because of what you were describing: there are just enough cues while walking to keep you on task, to remind you, "Oh, what am I doing? I'm walking. What am I doing? I'm supposed to be meditating. Okay, back to the breath." Whereas if you're just sitting or lying completely motionless, especially with eyes closed, you might drift for much longer without some external cue to bring you back.

0:44:13So if you're finding that walking is allowing you to gain more momentum, do more walking [unclear]. On retreats, earlier on, I generally feel like I want to move around more. Alternating with walking meditation is also very good for balancing all these different factors. If you have excess energy, too much excitement, a walk might bring you down and stabilize you. If you're feeling sloth and torpor, drowsiness, or just a slackening of resolve, a brisk walk will bring you up, and may aid the development of concentration more than stacking on another motionless period. Okay, maybe two more questions. Yep. "Okay, so whenever you talk about how it can eventually get weird: I just saw what you were saying, with [unclear], where suddenly this battering ram showed up next to me with my breath, going back and forth to the gates of a castle, and I thought, 'Okay, that's kind of weird.'

0:45:37I'll just keep with the breath. And then also I couldn't tell where the breath was, or I thought my right eye was over here and my left eye was down here, and my breath was like a sphere, and I was like, 'Okay, that's weird.' And this morning it reached a point (I was easily past your 15-minute suggestion of not moving from the breath, [unclear], maybe a small thought and right back to the breath) where I had a peak-LSD-trip-level, psychedelic, incredible experience, just with the breath, not even going to jhana or the piti. I did not expect that at all." Wow. "So I was in a possibility space. When you say weird, is this still within the realm of possible weird?" Yeah. Okay. If you have prior experience with psychedelic drugs: in terms of the intensity and oddness and weirdness you've experienced through that,

0:46:53similar, if not more, can happen through meditation. Yep. "So that's my question for you. And is that also a sign... maybe it has a technical benefit? Is there a way to keep going through that? Is it valid?" Yeah. If your concentration is getting strong enough that you're getting those kinds of intense sensory distortions, and lights and forms (we don't need to go into details), then your concentration is probably strong enough to switch, if you want to. Or you can keep plugging away at access concentration, or switch; up to you. "Well, that's my thing: if I keep plugging away and get to that space again, what do I do then?" You just stay with the breath. "Okay." Yeah. If you just stay with the breath, and stay with the breath, and stay with the breath, you'll just get more and more concentrated, and the terminus of that is something like what you'll find in Pa Auk Sayadaw's lineage. But on the way, most people getting to that depth of concentration will experience really radical sensory distortions, odd things: visions, lights, all kinds of things.

0:48:22So yeah, up to you. Okay, one more question. [Participant]. "Yeah. For breath at the nostrils, Leigh and you both, I believe, instruct keeping the attention here and not following it inside. I realized I've never understood, never even thought about, why that is. Can you say why, and then how one would translate that to whole-body breathing?" Sure. If you're keeping the mindfulness established just at the entrance of the nostrils... Some people can get into a pattern where, with each in- and out-breath, they're following the track of the breath in and out, and even subtly, that will disrupt the stabilizing, energization and absorption that can develop on a spatially stable object, if you're following it up or following it down. Also, you can have a kind of fuzzy, larger object that includes the interior of the nasal passages, as opposed to just the exterior here. In some ways it's a bit harder to maintain attention just at the entrance,

0:49:44and for that reason, because it's a spatially smaller, more precise object, it's better for developing really fine, stable attention. Again, as with everything else, if you're aware of sensation up in your nasal passages and sinuses, okay, that's perfectly fine, but keep the focal point of your attention just at the entrance. Then for whole-body breathing, likewise: if you're following the breath as it moves through the body, swaying or, I don't know, making a serpentine motion as the breath passes through the body, the same dynamic is at play as here, where you're following it around, and the energy of the mind can't quite cohere and stabilize to the same extent. Whereas if you're just holding the whole space of the body and experiencing the breath throughout that whole volume, stably, a greater coherence and unification of mind can take place. And if that isn't accessible or isn't working, it's fine to work more flexibly with the breath than that.

0:51:12In fact, you'll see that folks like Thanissaro Bhikkhu and other teachers instruct methods that are more mobile. But in my experience, and it seems conserved across everybody I know, you'll get stronger concentration if you're working with a spatially stable object, whether it's small or large. "That makes sense. Thank you." Okay: 10 minutes, and then we'll sit.

Sources

Translations are Thanissaro Bhikkhu's on dhammatalks.org unless noted.

  1. Four modes of practice: painful/pleasant, slow/quick intuition. AN 4:162 Vitthara Sutta (Modes of Practice in Detail) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN4_162.html ↩
  2. Ananda’s four ways to arahantship: insight preceded by tranquility, and so on. AN 4:170 Yuganaddha Sutta (In Tandem) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN4_170.html ↩
  3. Light and vision of forms; the defilements that make concentration fall away; the quail similes. MN 128 Upakkilesa Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN128.html ↩
  4. “The jhanas have been said by me to be thorned by noise” AN 10:72 Kanthaka Sutta (Thorns) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN10_72.html ↩
  5. Passion, aversion and delusion as the three fires. SN 35:28 Adittapariyaya Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN35_28.html ↩
  6. Contemplating the stages of a corpse’s decay. MN 10 Satipatthana Sutta (the cemetery contemplations) dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN10.html ↩
  7. The five grades of piti. Visuddhimagga IV.94–99, trans. Ñanamoli, The Path of Purification. accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/nanamoli/ ↩

← Tuesday, November 10 · Evening · All sessions · Wednesday, November 11 · Evening →