Jhana & Awakening Retreat 2026 · Session 9 of 16

Tuesday, November 10 · Evening

Quarrels and Disputes (Sn 4:11); Q&A on cessation, sukha, perception and consciousness, open-eye practice, dreams

Recorded November 10, 2026, 7:01 pm Mountain Time · Nameless Mountain, Boulder, Colorado · 59 min

A short reading of "Quarrels and Disputes" traced conflict back to contact and name-and-form. Most of the session was Q&A on cessation, the terms for mind, open-eye practice and sleep.

Topics and questions in this session

Talk

  • 0:00:34The five recollections: how will we use our time?
  • 0:02:55"Quarrels and Disputes" (Sn 4:11): disputes come from what is dear, desire, contact, and name-and-form (0:05).
  • 0:07:03When form disappears, contacts don't touch.
  • 0:08:49Some of the wise say this is the utmost purity. The sage ponders dependencies and doesn't dispute (0:09).

Q&A

  • 0:11:08Is cessation like getting whacked? Zen stories of teachers striking students, and Hakuin (0:14).
  • 0:16:19What you remember from deep jhana versus cessation.
  • 0:16:19Sukha feels dull next to piti. It comes in grades too (0:18).
  • 0:18:16Grounding the terms: perception, consciousness, name-and-form (MN 43).
  • 0:22:23Consciousness is also dependent, and empty, not a resting place.
  • 0:25:34The breath shifting and speeding up in the first jhana. "Have I been poisoned?" (0:27).
  • 0:28:52Modulating effort: high effort brings piti but tires you out.
  • 0:30:36Are there thoughts in access concentration? Echoes are fine.
  • 0:30:36Open-eye jhana with a visual object, such as a webcam light: how to hold the gaze (0:33, 0:34).
  • 0:36:21Pain, dullness and wandering.
  • 0:42:06Simplicity has its virtues. Which technique is best (0:43)?
  • 0:43:53Restless dreams, and practicing as you fall asleep (0:47).
  • 0:50:24How to orient to piti after a mind-blowing experience.
  • 0:55:36Without much body sensation, how can you tell the mind is unifying?
  • 0:57:07Staying with the object while eating.
Tuesday, November 10 · Evening

Edited transcript. The time at the start of each paragraph is where it begins in the recording above; drag the player to that point to listen. Participants' names are omitted. [Square brackets] mark editorial insertions; [unclear] marks words that couldn't be made out.

0:00:00I am of the nature to age; I have not gone beyond aging.

0:00:34The sun rises, the sun sets; we eat, sleep, repeat, and some other things happen in the middle. How will we use our time before we go to bed? How will we use what remains, and likewise after? Byadhi-dhammomhi byadhim anatito: I am of the nature to sicken; I have not gone beyond sickness. I have also certainly not gone beyond sleepiness; I don't know about you. Marana-dhammomhi maranam anatito: I am of the nature to die; I have not gone beyond dying. I am the owner of my action, heir to my action, born of my action, related to my action, and abide supported by my action. Whatever action I shall do, for good or for ill, of that I will be the heir. Thus we should frequently recollect. Here, from the Sutta Nipata, is "Quarrels and Disputes": "From where have there arisen quarrels, disputes, lamentations, sorrows, along with stinginess, conceit and pride, along with divisiveness? From where have they arisen? Please tell me." Someone asks the Buddha. "From what is dear there have arisen quarrels, disputes, lamentations, sorrows, along with stinginess, conceit and pride, along with divisiveness.12

0:02:55"Tied up with stinginess are quarrels and disputes. In the arising of disputes is divisiveness. And where is the cause of things dear in the world, along with the greeds that go about in the world? Where is the cause of the hopes and aims for the sake of a person's next life? Desires are the cause of things dear in the world, along with the greeds that go about in the world. And here, too, is the cause of the hopes and aims for the sake of a person's next life." It's a very common pattern in the suttas. It seems to have been, as much as it is today for many people, an issue of much concern: "What will happen to me on the breakup of the body, after death? What about those I love? Where have they gone? Where will I go? What will become of me?" So here is the root for both: the cause of things dear in the world, and the greeds that go about in the world, and the cause of the hopes and aims for the sake of someone's next life.

0:04:13All this speculation and hankering is rooted in desire, rooted in what is dear. "Now, where is the cause of desire in the world? And from where have there arisen decisions, anger, lies and perplexity, and all the qualities described by the Contemplative? What they call 'appealing' and 'unappealing' in the world..." Attractive and aversive in the world: "in dependence on that, desire arises." Desire to have, desire not to have. Get it closer; move it further away; I'd like to hold on to it; it can't go away. In dependence on that, desire arises. "Having seen becoming and not with regard to forms, a person gives rise to decisions in the world; anger, lies and perplexity: these qualities, too, when there exists that very pair. A person perplexed should train for the path of knowledge, for it's in having known that the Contemplative has spoken of qualities. And where is the cause of appealing and unappealing? When what isn't, do they not exist? And whatever is meant by becoming and not: tell me, where is their cause? Contact is the cause of appealing and not."

0:05:33Sensory contact: the eye and a form, the ear and a sound, the body and a sensation, the mind and an idea. When there's contact, there's appealing and not. "Contact is the cause of appealing and not. When contact isn't, they do not exist. Along with what's meant by becoming and not, I tell you: from here is their cause. Now, where is the cause of contact in the world, and from where have graspings, possessions, arisen? When what isn't, does there not exist mine-ness? When what has disappeared do contacts not touch? Conditioned by name and form is contact." Name and form, namarupa, shows up all over. Form is pretty straightforward: this is what you see here, smell, taste and touch. Namarupa is sometimes translated as mind and body. It's not a bad translation, though rupa also refers to everything that appears to be external, and nama is the naming function, the naming and labeling and classifying function of the mind. "Conditioned by name and form is contact. In longing do graspings, possessions, have their cause. When longing isn't, mine-ness doesn't exist."

0:07:03So when there isn't longing to hold on, to have, to acquire, to not have, that sense of me and mine doesn't exist. "When forms have disappeared, contacts don't touch. For one arriving how does form disappear? How do pleasure and pain disappear? Tell me this. [My heart is] set on knowing how they disappear. One not percipient of perceptions, not percipient of aberrant perceptions, not unpercipient, nor percipient of what's disappeared: for one thus arriving, form disappears." This relates to the topic of this morning's instructions. Not percipient of perceptions: the diversity of phenomena has faded away sufficiently in absorption. Not percipient of aberrant perceptions: nor is the mind taken up by all the odd things that can arise when we withdraw a bit from the senses and the usual forms. Not unpercipient: not unconscious. Nor percipient of what's disappeared: not hankering after or fixating on what isn't present. "For one thus arriving, form disappears, for objectification-classifications have their cause in perception. What we have asked you've expounded to us. We ask one thing more. Please tell it.

0:08:49"Do some of the wise say that just this much is the utmost, the purity of the spirit is here? Or do they say that it's other than this? Some of the wise say that just this much is the utmost, the purity of the spirit is here. But some of them, who say they are skilled, say it's the moment with no clinging remaining." There's something subtle going on here that might not be clear from reading it through once. The questioner is asking: "Okay, so there are these states where form disappears (appealing and unappealing, lies, perplexity, anger, all the things that have gone before), and there's this collapse of contact, of longing, of form, of decisions, all of that. Do some people say that's it?" And some do. And then some say that it's actually further than that: it's the moment where there's no clinging remaining, not even clinging to the disappearance of form, the disappearance of all these polarities the mind makes on the basis of attachment and aversion.

0:09:55But there's a little bit more. "Knowing, 'Having known, they are still dependent,' the sage ponders dependencies, and on knowing them is released. He doesn't get into disputes and doesn't meet with becoming and not. He's awakened." So: seeing as well that even in the statement "just here is the utmost," even in a moment of no clinging remaining, any statement you could make, any comparison, any judgment, any holding something up, or indeed holding oneself up: all of that is still dependent. There can be residual conceit, and clinging even to non-clinging.

0:11:08So with that said, I now invite any and all of your quarrels and disputes. More questions. "Earlier today you were talking about the cessation of mental activity, and you mentioned that when you get into that state, you're just in it for however long. It makes sense that you can't set a mental timer, because that would presumably require some sort of mental activity. But I was wondering: what if you were in that state and a monk whacked you with a stick? Would that snap you out of it?" You can get into such a state of absorption that you can't volitionally exit it, and likewise you can't quite volitionally enter it. Extremely deep down, it can be like this: your mind is just so fused there that there isn't room for navigation. But you can set a timed intention beforehand, and that may work out. Just as when you have something really important the next morning and have to get up early, and you end up waking at, or a few seconds before, the time you set for your alarm: there's some function of your system that, even without your conscious awareness, can rouse you out of a state.

0:12:59So I presume something similar is going on there. Whether with deep jhana or in the cessation of perception and feeling, people can set timed resolves and have them work out accurately. "Another question about that." Oh, I didn't answer the second part. "Oh, sure." I was going to come back to getting whacked by a stick. Thankfully that hasn't happened to me, but there's a pedagogical function to shattering the state of absorption that's talked about, and sometimes enacted, in both Zen and Dzogchen; that's really where I've seen this kind of thing discussed. Either for yourself, or with a friend or teacher around, you're in a state of absorption, or whatever state you can get yourself into, and then there's a sharp, sudden external stimulus that shatters that state. In your system's reaction, as it's jolted and startled out of that state, in that sudden re-arising of sensory contact and intensity, there can be a sharp clarity and the potential for insight.

0:14:32People love these stories in the Zen tradition of someone getting slapped. Or (I forget exactly who) one of the teachers in the lineage of Mahamudra woke up when his guru smacked him with a sandal. And Hakuin, the reviver of Rinzai Zen in Japan, in the 17th century, in the long phase of his post-awakening deepening practice, was boring away day and night in practice when a schizophrenic woman knocked him out with a frying pan, and when he came to he had a deeper realization. I don't suggest doing this; you'll just end up with brain damage. Or in Zen there's the katsu shout, or in Dzogchen someone might shout really loudly, or you can do that for yourself. They startle the mind and bring clarity to it. So yes, it can have an effect. But the second part of the question? "Yes. How would one know that one was in such a state, if there are no mental experiences that can form the basis of memories? Is it just a matter of time having passed, as if you were in a dreamless sleep?"

0:16:19We can distinguish. In deep jhana you're still conscious, and you have memories of it, though there's not much to say or describe in particular. It's different for the cessation of perception and feeling. There, yes, you can just recollect the entrance and the exit and the time that's elapsed, and there are aftereffects. "What sort of aftereffects?" Intense vividness and clarity and peace. Also, in the exit you can perceive with great clarity the re-arising of the different structures of consciousness coming back: form coming back, mental activity coming back. "I have a specific question and a practice question. I'm wondering if you can speak to sukha a little more. I'm a little confused about it, because my approximation of what it might be feels kind of dull, or blah. With the piti there's so much rapture, and it's so in your face, wow, and the sukha is satisfying, but I'm like, is this really moving towards the second jhana? So I'm wondering if you can speak to the different depths of it."3

0:18:16Much as with piti, sukha can come in grades. At a low hum, it's like a warm, pleasurable, happy glow, and at the stronger end, depending on concentration, it's break-your-face happy. It doesn't have the excited, electric, buzzing quality that piti does, but every pore and every tissue, down through the marrow of your bones (even if you're not feeling that kind of internal structure in the body), is totally saturated, suffused by radiant [unclear] and a complete happiness that just wipes out any perturbation in the mind or the body. So there's a range. Keep practicing; it'll clarify. "I was trying to ground some of these terms a bit, and also the part about dependence there felt interesting or important. I'm getting all these terms mixed up: perception, consciousness, nama-rupa, at least from how Rob and some Madhyamaka stuff talk about how consciousness and perception co-arise. Does that imply that perception is almost more like an object or something, and consciousness is the knowing of that thing, but they're also two sides of the same coin?" Yeah. This gets tricky, because we're not translating ourselves.45

0:20:37We're working with other people's translations of Pali terms, and often not being as precise or consistent in our use of language as we could be. Within the context of this, what's usually translated as perception is sañña, which refers to a kind of objectification that's still occurring. Even in the seventh jhana, sañña is still operating. In "neither perception nor non-perception," sañña is the word being translated as perception. So the seventh is the end of the perception attainments: in some places the list of perception attainments doesn't actually include neither perception nor non-perception, because in the seventh there's still perception, still a slight objectification of nothing, somehow (that's possible). So perception and consciousness here are not synonymous. Perception is also one of the aggregates, and viññana, the fifth aggregate, is what's usually translated as consciousness. You're definitely conscious in the eighth. So if we pry those two terms apart, you can have consciousness without that kind of objectification and labeling. Is that helpful?6

0:22:23"Yeah, I think so. Well, I guess one more." Resolve your doubts through practice. That'll do it. Then you won't worry so much about the language. "Yeah. I guess I'm just curious. It lands as really exciting: whoa, what is this? For so long when I was practicing, it was just 'rest in awareness,' and then hearing someone say that consciousness is also [dependent]... something about that is like, hope, that it'd be empty. Is it only through deepening experience that you see the emptiness of consciousness? How do the suttas talk about it: because it's dependent? I'm just trying to grapple with it." Yeah.

0:23:29Through practice you do come to see that all five aggregates, including consciousness, are empty. There's nothing substantial, nothing independent, in consciousness. It arises dependently, along with everything else. And you can see this process through to the temporary cessation of the five aggregates, in an experience of cessation.

0:24:06And at first blush this kind of spooks [laughs] some people, sometimes even more so if they're coming from a tradition (even some traditions of Buddhism) that posits awareness as, or talks about it in terms of, a kind of ultimate ground from which all appearance arises and from which it's inseparable. That's true as far as it goes, and it's also the mistake. Even in Dzogchen, Mahamudra and Zen, places where that kind of language features more prominently than in the suttas, it's stressed again and again that rigpa, ordinary mind, whatever, is not a thing: that it, too, is empty.

0:25:04And how exactly that is, in some sense, is literally inconceivable. It is experienceable, though. I don't know if that's helpful.

0:25:34"For my practice, getting into and resting in the first jhana: as you predicted, I was really efforting, and then over the hours there was almost a natural fading, and I hit this place where the breath definitely seems to shift, and the concentration seems to match the breath when it shifts. All of a sudden I can focus so much more, with more clarity, on the breath, actually. But it feels very coarse. The piti feels more sustained; it's still very wavy, but it's definitely more sustained, and the focus is much clearer. But the breath is kind of agitated, I guess you could say. The breath is hard to sustain, the state is hard to sustain, because the breath is agitated. So even though it feels pleasant, and I feel I'm on the right track, that this is what I should be going for, it doesn't feel very pleasant, in a sense. It feels short and shallow." Rapid or slow? "More rapid than it was previously."

0:27:11That's not too uncommon in deep access concentration, or when popping over the threshold into the first, for the breath to become shallow. As with hot sweats or an elevated heart rate, or salivation, there can also be a physiological response of breathing more quickly, just as a consequence of arousal in the nervous system. In my experience that goes away; it's part of the learning process of your body adapting to sustaining this kind of very high-arousal, high-intensity state without... I mean, it's a weird thing we're doing; we're rather outside the range of what evolution primed our bodies to sustain. It's like: "Okay, we're just in outrageous, otherworldly bliss for minutes, or longer. This can't be right. Have I been poisoned? What's going on?" "So I'm assuming I just stay with that. I don't really have a choice, I guess, but any tips for how to work with it?" Yeah. You could try taking a long exhale and see if that calms the breathing, and if it calms the coarse sense of the piti as well. Otherwise, just stay with it, and check back in.

0:28:52Yes. "I've been experiencing modulating effort. On the one hand, higher effort is when I experience the most rapture and attention within that path, and that's when I also experience piti. But that tends to fatigue me, so I can't sustain it for long. And lower effort is more peaceful; the mind is still, almost unified with the object, but I haven't experienced so much piti, or any piti, in that state. I'm wondering which direction I should go. What is it supposed to do?" Both descriptions sound good, as if they're headed in the right direction. It may just be a matter of finding the middle between them, or indeed of leaning in a bit more and experiencing some more intensity. This is also partly a stamina thing: you learn to sustain a certain intensity of engagement with the meditation object, and to sustain more intense states for longer and longer without getting fatigued, as you build capacity. So when you have the energy and the enthusiasm, lean in a bit more and relish the intensity. And when you feel like it, okay, you can cool off and rest back into a still, progressively deepening state.

0:30:36Did that stay with you? Okay, is that helpful? "Yeah. And in access concentration, are there no thoughts whatsoever? Are there echoes of thoughts?" Oh, could you hear that? The question was: in access concentration, are there some thoughts, or no thoughts? In very deep access concentration there will be no thoughts, but that's not necessary. You can be well into access concentration, you can have the jhanic factors going or their incipient stirrings, and there can still be plenty of mental activity going on. So that's not a criterion for being in or out. Likewise, in the first jhana there's much more mental activity going on than in the successive jhanas, and it's not a problem. [Participant], yeah. "Would you go over open-eye jhana meditation some more? For example, say I wanted to sit in my computer chair, and my computer camera has a blue light. If I just look at that blue light, is there an optimal way to hold my gaze, my eyes? Because there are several ways I could look at that blue light, if you know what I'm saying. What would be the best way?"

0:32:19Yeah. Oh, I want to make a distinction here. Building access concentration with an external visual object is one thing. Doing jhana meditation, in terms of the first four, is the same as you'd do it with closed eyes: you're just getting progressively immersed in the bodily experience of the jhanic factors, the same as you would with your eyes closed. But if you're using an external visual object to generate concentration, you want to avoid eye strain. If you find you're squinting or over-focusing, you're going to tire your eyes out. You may also find (and this is also partly a stamina issue) that your vision becomes blurry or unfocused; it's hard to hold an unwavering focus for minutes at a time, and that just comes with repetition. But don't over-focus.

0:33:28Yeah: a relaxed focus. "Maybe you could say a bit more about the different ways. What about what they call the Dzogchen gaze, where you put your two fingers over here and one eye tries to look over here and the other over there, to have the widest field of view? That's not exactly focused, so it doesn't feel like access concentration, you know what I'm saying? It does feel kind of like jhana 3. But if I'm trying to get into access concentration, wouldn't I just be focused on that?" Yeah. Unlike going for that panoramic engagement with the whole visual field at once, that experience of unfixated visual awareness, you're engaging focal vision if you're doing shamatha on an external visual object. So it's different from that. "So it would be not exactly super strained, but kind of focused?"

0:34:57Yeah. There's a little tightness to it. "Okay. If I'm doing it right now, it's almost as if, when you focus on something for long enough, you get kind of double vision, or it gets a bit hazy. Are we trying not to do that? Are we trying to maintain this very alert focus?" Yes. Different things may happen if you're engaging an external visual object. The object itself might start to fade or break up, or the periphery may blur or fade or wobble. All of these things may happen. If that starts to happen so much that you actually lose track of the object, just blink; that should reset the visual field, and you can get back to it. But if it happens a little, and you can still get the felt sense of homing in and settling and stabilizing the mind, then all good. The visual field can be doing weird things and it's fine. But if it gets to the point where you're more absorbed in the odd visual phenomena than in homing in on the object, however weird the stuff going on with it, then blink and start again.

0:36:21"Okay, cool. Thank you." You're welcome. "About twice a day I'm able to go pretty effortlessly into access concentration and play around with it. The rest of the time I'm in the trenches: either in a lot of pain, which makes me brain-dead, or just brain-dead. I'm wondering how to make use of that time. I can feel that it would be possible to just white-knuckle through it ('All right, I'm just going to withstand the pain and not move and really grasp onto the object'), but that feels kind of counterproductive for me. It doesn't feel like the right way to go about it. But the way that works those two times a day just isn't really available the rest of the time. So how can I make use of the time when I'm kind of brain-dead?" When you say brain-dead, do you mean hazy? What is it? Are you preoccupied with the pain, or a mixture of both? "A mixture of dullness and wandering. I'll attend to the object for a bit and then just sort of disappear, or wander off, get distracted and come back. But often it's associated with intense pain, and it's like: I can attend to it, but this is too much.

0:38:04I potentially have to move around." For the haziness and the wandering, you may find it happens less if you practice with your eyes open, staying oriented to where you are; there are more cues, even subconscious ones, about where you are and what you're doing. As for the pain: if there's no way to get your body comfortable (lying down, a palace of cushions, I don't know, whatever you need to do), if there's no way for your body to be comfortable and it's just pain, then, as we discussed two days ago or so, you can take the pain as the object: massaging the breath through the pain, or taking the pain itself as the object, if you remember when I went over that. "Yeah. Can you say more about orienting? I've found the most useful thing has been to widen the aperture, or to attend to the sense of being here in a room, which kind of grounds me more, or even just to do a body scan, breathing.

0:39:17That all seems to push me in the right direction. Do you have any more things like that I can play around with? Or maybe speak more about widening the aperture and attending to the breath throughout the entire body? More details." A good way to set that up can be with a body scan. Go from the crown of the head slowly down through all the parts of the body, as luxuriously and for as long as you want, in as much detail as you want. That can sensitize your awareness to the whole field of bodily sensation, so that when you then open up to the whole body, there's more vividness and clarity in the sensation. Likewise with the breath. It can also help to have an anchor: even if you're mainly attending to the whole breath, the breath through the whole body, if it helps, have a touch point in the abdomen, or even at the nostrils, as a kind of home base, and split your attention. If it's hard to focus on the whole body, a light anchor, a 20-80 split or something, can be helpful.

0:40:52Something else you can play with, working up to feeling the breath through the whole body, is imagining and feeling the breath coming in at different places. I don't know if you've tried playing with this, but instead of feeling the breath coming in through the nostrils, can you imagine the stream of breath entering through the bottom of your spine? Or, if you've got pain, can you imagine breathing into the pain, with an actual, ghostly sensation of breath flowing in there? These are all things you can play with that give you more. "Another problem is that I have all these tools now, and it's like: which one is most amenable to me right now? Sometimes attending to my entire body with the breath, and then focusing on it, works. Great, I'll do that. And other times it doesn't really stick, so okay, I flip through the different things. That doesn't seem that good. So I almost want you to say, 'Just focus right here and white-knuckle it; it'll be okay.'"

0:42:06Yeah. Simplicity has its virtues. It's all right to be dull and hazy, and not to white-knuckle it, but no matter how dull or hazy you are, just keep coming back to whatever your base practice is, again and again. Sleepy? Okay: I'm familiarizing myself with the object in a sleepy state. Dull? Great: familiarizing myself with it in a dull state. My body is wracked with pain? Okay. And you can develop a real sense of comfort across all the different states: falling asleep, waking up, all the different moods (hungry, sore, sad, tired). Developing continuity with a single practice, with a single object: it's informative to stay with the same practice through all of those. You see the way the mind reacts and wavers, with the main object as a foil, and keeping that steady can allow a little more clarity in seeing, rather than conceding to "Oh, what about this? What about this now?", going through the Rolodex of techniques. It's good to have a variety of techniques for different situations, and to have range, and it's fun; why not? But this goes for everybody.

0:43:53We're coming to the end of the fourth day. [unclear]. If you've been trying a whole bunch of things, really prune it down and settle in. "Last one: all things being equal, which one's the best?" No. Yeah. "Does any of this translate into the dream world? For example, there's quiet and stillness during the day, and I've noticed that in my dreams it's intense: I'm thrashing around in the bed, and I wake up and I'm not getting any sleep because I'm so active. I don't know if that's just material coming through because I'm not present with it, or what it means, but I was curious how this practice might affect the dream world. And another question on top of that: if you're a lucid dreamer, can you meditate in a dream? And would you want to? Because that sounds terrifying, like it could get deep somewhere and... I don't know, isn't that what nightmares are made of? My dreams aren't nightmares, they're just so intense, and then I'm waking, and my covers are thrown all over. Thank goodness no one's on the top bunk." Did you hear the question online? Yeah. So, continuous practice, deepening into samadhi, can churn up a whole bunch of material and bring it to the surface, just as in the waking state, and that will likely carry over into the dreaming and sleeping states.

0:45:57That might mean you get deeper and more profound rest during sleep. It might also mean that a whole bunch of material is shaken loose and comes up, and you have very vivid, intense dreams, both positive and negative, as stuff comes up. That's normal. As for taking practice into the lucidity of a dream: yes, you sure can.

0:46:29If you find yourself lucid in a dream... Or, as I recommend to everyone again: maintain your practice as you're falling asleep, and that may transition naturally into lucidity in any dreams that arise. You can also set the intention to become lucid in sleep, and that may happen. There are also reality-checking techniques. This isn't a dream yoga retreat, but it's very...

0:47:03The mind in the dreaming state is already quite malleable, and in some ways it's a more optimal state to meditate in than the waking world. The dreamlike nature of appearance is a bit more evident in dreams. And if you're able to bring that lucidity into the dream state and meditate, meditation within the dream state can be immensely powerful.

0:47:39At first, if you're not used to it, it might be a little spooky, a little weird, disorienting. Follow-up questions? Is that...? Yeah. There are specific techniques and all kinds of prescriptive things you can do. But for now, you can do any meditation in a dreaming state that you do in a waking state. You can do jhana in a dream; you can follow your breath. Start there and see what happens. "Could you say a little about whether you have any tips for continuing practice as you're falling asleep? Is it something you have to be pretty good at while awake before you can do it? Because I notice that when I'm falling asleep, the transition stage is often characterized by uncontrolled mind-wandering." Yeah. You'll likely have more success maintaining awareness through hypnagogia and into lucid dreaming and sleep the stronger your practice is while waking. And it's well worth doing anyway, even if it's mostly characterized by mind-wandering and completely losing it.

0:49:23It's still worth doing, and you never know. You never know. My advice for now would just be to carry on with whatever your main practice is as you're falling asleep, and see what happens. "What is hypnagogia?" Oh yeah. Hypnagogia is going into sleep, and hypnopompia is coming out of sleep. It's just the word for that odd transitional state where you might see or hear things, or feel your body sinking, or all kinds of things. "I just wanted to offer, since I've been using my Theragun in my car: I know you're feeling a lot of pain, so if you want to use it, or anyone else here wants to..."

0:50:24Thanks. Yeah. "I have a question about piti. I don't know if I'm biased towards 'more is better' or something [unclear], after having a mind-blowing experience. I guess I'm struggling to decide how to orient when it's going. For example, doing the whole body, I'm able to relax the body and feel the piti coming in with the in-breath and then maintaining on the out-breath. But I'll go half an hour without it intensifying; it'll just stay there, and I'm like, 'So when is this going to kick up?' And sometimes (it's kind of weird) there's a little bit of dukkha, localized in the sternum, and there's piti in the rest of the body, and I'll try to relax into it, and it just stays: piti in the body, a little localized dukkha. So I wonder if you can speak to how to orient when that's happening. Is it always better to intensify it?"

0:51:40No, it's not always better to intensify piti if it's present, even if you have the ability to lean in or ramp it up. And piti can co-occur with pain or discomfort in the body, for sure. One thing you can do is draw the attention through the area where there's pain; the piti might follow and break it up. It's also worth refining your palate for piti. Even if it's not blow-your-head-off intense, can you instead amp up the savoring of its texture? There's a spectrum of refinement in the texture of piti, which can co-vary with the intensity. So see if you can appreciate the subtlety of piti. Become a piti sommelier. And as with anything (and I'm repeating this a whole lot on this retreat), for any and all of these questions, more time with the base object, deeper access concentration, will work wonders. "I have a question about practice while not formally practicing. When I'm eating, for example, my attention is mostly on my body, my object, but the next step is to include the dish and the forks and those things, so I'm breaking the practice there.

0:53:40And then when I'm eating something, at some point I'm dissolving the flavor: 'Whoa, food. This is flavor consciousness; it's just flavor.' I could choose not to enjoy a flavor at all; it's meaningless. I could do that. Should I? For example, I just like the flavor." Yeah. Someone else had a similar question in an interview today. If you're really gunning for maximum continuity of concentration and you want to send it, then yes, just stay with the object at all times. Even when you're eating, don't pay any attention to the food. Let's go; it could be cardboard; let's go. You can do that if you want to, and if you're really going for concentration, you'll gain more momentum that way, carrying it through even activities like eating. You can become a bit of a samadhi zombie this way, staying with the object all the time: you've got this thousand-yard stare, you're walking kind of robotically, you're eating... It's not the most functional thing to be doing outside a retreat environment, but you're on retreat. If you want to do that, send it, stay with the object. Likewise during these talks: if I'm tired and saying a lot, or it's just not pertinent to you, stay with the object. Catherine, yeah.

0:55:36I think maybe this one or one more question, and then we'll break. "Sorry, my laptop died; I'm on my phone. I was wondering: if you're trying to get to jhana via concentration and not having much experience with the body (it's like nothing, and then eventually, apparently, maybe there will be something), aside from indicators like how many times you've gotten distracted in the last 10 minutes, how can you tell that you're getting more unified, if you're not really feeling things in the body?"

0:56:30There's a stability in the attention itself: not just the duration you're staying with the object, but the quality of contact, whether there's wobble or jitter, and you become more sensitized to that over time. The clarity and vividness of the object are also likely to increase, as is the ability to discern subtlety in it.

0:57:07"So the texture of it will change?" Yeah. It's an odd thing to say, but the texture of your attention and of the object will both change as concentration deepens. "Okay, thanks." Yeah. Last one. "Just on the point of eating: I once heard, imagine that while eating you were only eating to taste the salt in it and nothing else. In a similar vein, can you stay with your meditation object while eating, or anything else, to the exclusion of all else?" Yeah. You can pick out the strand in your experience that you're trying to home in on, and stay with it. I might quibble with "to the exclusion of all else." You can, and it's good, to get so absorbed that everything else falls away, but that doesn't come from pushing anything. It's just all the energy of the mind cohering and unifying and pooling in, until everything else drops off on its own. Okay, let's take ten, come back, and practice a bit.

Sources

Translations are Thanissaro Bhikkhu's on dhammatalks.org unless noted.

  1. The five recollections. AN 5:57 Upajjhatthana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN5_57.html ↩
  2. “From where have there arisen quarrels, disputes ...” Sn 4:11 Kalahavivada Sutta (Quarrels and Disputes) dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/StNp/StNp4_11.html ↩
  3. Recollecting entry into and exit from cessation; the order in which fabrications return. MN 44 Culavedalla Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN44.html ↩
  4. Degrees of sukha; pleasure suffusing the body. DN 2 Samaññaphala Sutta (the jhana similes) dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN02.html ↩
  5. Perception and consciousness arising together. MN 43 Mahavedalla Sutta: “feeling, perception, and consciousness are conjoined, not disjoined” dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN43.html ↩
  6. Neither-perception-nor-non-perception set apart from the “perception attainments” AN 9:36 Jhana Sutta (“as far as the perception-attainments go, that is as far as gnosis-penetration goes”) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN9_36.html ↩

← Tuesday, November 10 · Morning · All sessions · Wednesday, November 11 · Morning →