Tuesday, November 10 · Morning
The formless attainments and cessation; the Foam Sutta (SN 22:95); Q&A
The talk mapped the formless attainments, jhanas five to eight, and cessation, then read the Foam Sutta in full. The Q&A was mostly about effort, the slog and how long things take.
Topics and questions in this session
Talk
- 0:00:00Starting from a well-consolidated fourth jhana: unspeakably still, perhaps with bright white light.
- 0:05:00Boundless space. Nothing bad will happen; the fear passes with acclimatization (0:07).
- 0:09:00Boundless consciousness: only a boundless mind can know boundless space (0:10). Rob Burbea on using the aftereffects for insight.
- 0:13:16Nothingness.
- 0:15:39Neither perception nor non-perception: like a television tuned away from all the channels.
- 0:17:46The cessation of perception and feeling (MN 44). Hard to be fooled by the magic show once you've seen it taken apart.
- 0:19:56The Foam Sutta (SN 22:95): form as foam, feeling a bubble, perception a mirage, fabrications a banana tree, consciousness a magic trick.
- 0:24:48Disenchantment with the aggregates (SN 35:28).
Q&A
- 0:27:13When piti feels clamped or held in place.
- 0:29:56How long to sit. Three or four hours at a stretch is fine.
- 0:31:32Strain and fatigue. Sometimes drop it, do something else and come back fresh (AN 6:55).
- 0:32:47Is getting from the fourth jhana to the fifth a bigger hurdle than the first four? Is reaching access the hardest part?
- 0:39:11Slogging and tantrums: a participant's technique of getting angry at the inner critic.
- 0:41:17Playing with a wider or narrower aperture while balancing effort.
- 0:43:56Refining the breath. Does the breath disappearing count? Shortening it a little (0:45)?
- 0:46:45Quantifying the slog: if an hour a day for a year hasn't worked, is something off (0:48)? Building a container and a checklist (0:51).
- 0:53:09When to adjust for hip discomfort versus fidgeting.
- 0:55:24From the seventh jhana to the eighth: releasing clinging to nothingness (0:56).
- 0:57:34Lying down for hypnagogic relaxation, and conceptual elaboration (0:59). How long does it take (1:01)?
- 1:02:10Open-eye practice and the formless states.
0:00:00Namo tassa bhagavato arahato sammā-sambuddhassa (three times). Good morning. I'm going to talk a little about the formless jhanas, the formless attainments, the big spaces, whatever you want to call them. Again, I want to provide a large scope on this retreat: hopefully material and inspiration and information that will be helpful and supportive for the rest of your whole life of practice. So wherever you are right now (in the midst of a fit of awful hindrances, plugging away at deepening access concentration, tipping over into one of the form jhanas, or hating this retreat, hating me, hating yourself and wishing you weren't here), wherever you're at, take what's useful for now from this talk and leave what's for later. I'll just go through the instructions, state by state. You have a really (emphasis on really) settled, mature, deep fourth jhana. The piti disappeared in the third, and the sukha has drained away completely in the fourth. There's just pure calm, perfect stillness and peace. If you're really well absorbed, you move beyond perceptions of pleasure and pain, as the text says; at a certain depth you won't be able to feel yourself breathing, and bodily sensation will be barely present.12
0:02:44You may have bright white light appearing, or you might not. So still: really, unspeakably still. You've been hanging out there for a while (15 minutes, 30 minutes; the longer the better). From there, if you want to try, you can extend your awareness out in front or a little above. Any direction will work, but most folks I know, myself included, have found success in front or a little above. Everything so far requires some trial and error, some experimentation. So extend your awareness out in front of you, as though shooting out a beam or a wave of your attention. If you encounter any resistance, any felt, quasi-visual, quasi-tactile resistance to the passage of your awareness, you can pass through it or hop over it or move around it, until you just get the sense of your awareness expanding outward without limit. And you can ride that sense of your awareness, your attention. At this point it could feel more like a beam or more like a wave; either is fine. The point is that you're able to extend your mind past or around any felt sense of resistance, however it's showing up, until the body drops away, until any sense of solidity drops out. And even that sense of expansion will at some point peak and drop away.
0:05:00All that will be left is (you might see it, you might feel it, you might both feel and see it) a boundless, vast expanse. It might be pure black; there might be a little fizz in it. But it's pretty unmistakable: there's no limit to the space, and it's now formless. There's nothing going on in it. If you're not quite so absorbed, you can still get in contact with the quality of boundless space while a little remnant of the body is left. If that's happening, I encourage you to hang out longer in the fourth, until you can make contact with boundless space with enough depth of absorption that the body can completely disappear. As with moving into access concentration or the first jhana, this is a time, leaving behind any perception of form, when quite a lot of physiological, and also mental, anxiety and fear can rear their heads. You may gasp, or find yourself snapping back into your felt sense of the body; different things. You may have a sense of imminent annihilation: "Uh-oh. I don't know where I'm going. I don't know if I can come back. Hold on." As with moving through that kind of fear barrier into deeper access concentration, the first jhana and so on, you can reassure yourself, maybe sit with metta a little. But it really is that your body, as much as your mind, needs to learn that it's safe.
0:07:09Nothing bad will happen, and that comes through acclimatization. So you're in this boundless space. If you're really well absorbed, it won't feel as though you, as an observer, are in the space; you become the boundless space. At first, if you're not as absorbed, if there's still a sense of "I'm an observer in this massive space," it might feel like it's in front but not behind. Even with the sense of the body gone, that kind of directionality might still be there. If that's the case, you can just get more concentrated, and it might fall off on its own. Or, when you're able to get into and sustain that state, you can start spreading it, almost as you'd spread piti, the jhana factor, through the body. You can sweep your attention so that the space's sense of boundless extent moves 360 degrees, up and around, left, right, down, until the sense of orientation in the boundless space falls away completely, and it's just space without center or edge, border or boundary. Really amazing.
0:09:00Moving into this state and coming back out of it (and I quite like what Rob has to say about using the aftereffects of each jhana, the first four but also the formless attainments), seeing how form disappears and then how it reappears, you get a sense of how, in more ordinary moments of conscious sensory perception, the sense of form, of solidity, of borders is actually constructed: that resistance, the reification of space, the orientation of direction. You get a visceral understanding of how that's put together, how it comes apart, and what it depends on. Then boundless consciousness. As with the other jhanas, once you're able to stay in the fifth jhana for 15 minutes, 30 minutes (longer is better; no rush, really, don't rush), whatever the depth of absorption you're in, in the fifth you can, with a slight shift, tune to the knowing quality. "Okay, there's this boundless space. But how is it that I know this space is boundless? Well, there's this alertness, this wakefulness, this non-sensory brightness and lucidity. Oh, it's everywhere. It fills the space."3
0:10:43Only a boundless mind can know a boundless space. Only a boundless mind can become boundless space. And you become absorbed in this sense of boundless, limitless, borderless, formless consciousness or awareness. This state might feel brighter, even though visually it's probably still black: like dissolving into a sea of mind without form, without resistance. There's a strong sense of knowing without any particular object known. Really incredible. And as with the disappearance of spatial boundaries, in the sixth jhana you see: "Oh, that sense I have of wakefulness or consciousness being localized in a particular space within the body, behind the eyes? Nope, that can go away." As the structures of consciousness dissolve and relax and release, it becomes apparent that the knowing, which is actually the fabric of the whole field of experience even in ordinary moments of consciousness, is boundless: it doesn't inevitably have divisions or boundaries, or even a location. You're able to hang out in boundless consciousness for 15 minutes, 30 minutes, longer, however long you want. Then again, with a slight tuning of your attention, you notice: "Wait a second, there's nothing here. Really, there's nothing. Actually nothing." It's like, I don't know, striking a bell and expecting to hear a sound, and it just doesn't compute.
0:13:16There's just: nope, nothing. And you get absorbed in that sense of nothing. At this point the sense of boundless spatial extent can kind of collapse. It's almost as if your mind just gets... it's hard to speak about. When you get really well settled into this jhana, in my experience anyway, the sense of extent, of vastness, goes. It doesn't feel small, but it also doesn't feel vast. Your mind is just submerged in this perception of nothing at all, the most refined perception you can have. So you hang out there for 15 minutes, 30 minutes, longer, you and nothing getting really well acquainted. And then it's like swimming in a lake, pushing off a dock with your feet, and then letting go and seeing where the current takes you. Even here there's a very subtle way in which the mind is adhering and gripping and orienting to nothing, to this sense of nothing. If you can feel that (and if your mind is this refined and concentrated, it's hard to describe, but maybe not as hard as it seems) and let it go, you may tip over into a state in which even that refined perception of nothing has gone away. But you're not unconscious.
0:15:39There's still lucidity present, but you're not aware of anything, not even of nothing. It's as if you've tuned the television set away from all the channels, and it's just that. That's about as refined and subtle as the mind can get while still maintaining any form of consciousness. Oh, I missed a step. Going back to nothingness for a second, I'll get to the insights that can come from absorbing into and moving in and out of nothingness. You see that not only borders and boundaries and the localizability of awareness, of phenomena, of form, but thingness itself, the compactification of the mind into things, is optional. And then even that duality between something and nothing, the mind forming any kind of perception it can adhere to at all: that can be let go.
0:17:46And if everything is just right, and you set an intention beforehand (or it might just happen), then, as if you were standing in relatively shallow but swift-flowing water, felt a current, and let yourself fall in and be tugged away, you might fall into the cessation of perception and feeling from there. That's lights out: gone. It lasts for however long it lasts, and then consciousness comes back bit by bit on the other side. In that process you can see the whole stack, from zero all the way up: how it's taken apart and how it comes back together. For that reason, because you're really stripping consciousness structure by structure all the way down to not even nothing, and then lights out, it's among the most catalytic events for insight into the nature of phenomena. It's hard to be fooled by the magic show when you've seen the dolls taken apart and the magician disappear. So the formless attainments, the formless jhanas, and the cessation of perception and feeling round out the early Buddhist concentration attainments. I'll close here, before opening up to Q&A, with one of my favorite suttas, if not my favorite, from the entire canon. It's up there.4
0:19:56It's not that long, so I'll read it in full. This is "Foam," the Phena Sutta. "On one occasion the Blessed One was staying among the Ayujjhans on the banks of the Ganges River. There he addressed the monks: 'Monks, suppose that a large glob of foam were floating down this Ganges River, and a man with good eyesight were to see it, observe it, and appropriately examine it. To him, seeing it, observing it, and appropriately examining it, it would appear empty, void, without substance: for what substance would there be in a glob of foam? In the same way, a monk sees, observes, and appropriately examines any form that is past, future, or present; internal or external; blatant or subtle; common or sublime; far or near. To him, seeing it, observing it, and appropriately examining it, it would appear empty, void, without substance: for what substance would there be in form? Now suppose that in the autumn, when it's raining in fat, heavy drops, a water bubble were to appear and disappear on the water, and a man with good eyesight were to see it, observe it, and appropriately examine it. To him, seeing it, observing it, and appropriately examining it, it would appear empty, void, without substance: for what substance would there be in a water bubble?5
0:21:02"'In the same way, a monk sees, observes, and appropriately examines any feeling that is past, future, or present; internal or external; blatant or subtle; common or sublime; far or near. To him, seeing it, observing it, and appropriately examining it, it would appear empty, void, without substance: for what substance would there be in feeling? Now suppose that in the last month of the hot season a mirage were shimmering, and a man with good eyesight were to see it, observe it, and appropriately examine it. To him, seeing it, observing it, and appropriately examining it, it would appear empty, void, without substance: for what substance would there be in a mirage? In the same way, a monk sees, observes, and appropriately examines any perception that is past, future, or present; internal or external; blatant or subtle; common or sublime; far or near. To him, seeing it, observing it, and appropriately examining it, it would appear empty, void, without substance: for what substance would there be in perception? Now suppose that a man desiring heartwood, in quest of heartwood, seeking heartwood, were to go into a forest carrying a sharp ax. There he would see a large banana tree: straight, young, of enormous height. He would cut it at the root and, having cut it at the root, would chop off the top. Having chopped off the top, he would peel away the outer skin.
0:22:16"'Peeling away the outer skin, he wouldn't even find sapwood, to say nothing of heartwood. Then a man with good eyesight would see it, observe it, and appropriately examine it. To him, seeing it, observing it, and appropriately examining it, it would appear empty, void, without substance: for what substance would there be in a banana tree? In the same way, a monk sees, observes, and appropriately examines any fabrications that are past, future, or present; internal or external; blatant or subtle; common or sublime; far or near. To him, seeing them, observing them, and appropriately examining them, they would appear empty, void, without substance: for what substance would there be in fabrications? Now suppose that a magician or magician's apprentice were to display a magic trick at a major intersection, and a man with good eyesight were to see it, observe it, and appropriately examine it. To him, seeing it, observing it, and appropriately examining it, it would appear empty, void, without substance: for what substance would there be in a magic trick? In the same way, a monk sees, observes, and appropriately examines any consciousness that is past, future, or present; internal or external; blatant or subtle; common or sublime; far or near. To him, seeing it, observing it, and appropriately examining it, it would appear empty, void, without substance: for what substance would there be in consciousness?
0:23:29"'Seeing thus, the well-instructed disciple of the noble ones'" (that's all of you, if you want to be) "'grows disenchanted with form, disenchanted with feeling, disenchanted with perception, disenchanted with fabrications, disenchanted with consciousness. Disenchanted, you become dispassionate. Through dispassion, you are released. With release, there is the knowledge, "Released." You discern that "Birth is ended, the holy life fulfilled, the task done. There is nothing further for this world."' That is what the Blessed One said. Having said that, the One Well-Gone, the Teacher, said further, in a summary in verse: 'Form is like a glob of foam; feeling, a bubble; perception, a mirage; fabrications, a banana tree; consciousness, a magic trick: this has been taught by the Kinsman of the Sun.'" (The Sakyan clan were known as that; maybe they were sun worshippers. It's a little unclear.) "'However you observe them, appropriately examine them, they're empty, void to whoever sees them appropriately. Beginning with the body as taught by the One with profound discernment: when abandoned by three things (life, warmth and consciousness), form is rejected, cast aside. When bereft of these it lies thrown away, senseless, a meal for others. That's the way it goes: it's a magic trick, an idiot's babbling. It's said to be a murderer.'" Very grim. "'No substance here is found. Thus a monk'" (or you, lay people),
0:24:48thus anyone who wants to practice and realize this for themselves, "'persistence aroused, should view the aggregates'" (form, feeling, perception, fabrications and consciousness) "'by day and by night'" (all the time), "'mindful, alert; should discard all fetters; should make themself their own refuge; and should live as if your head were on fire, in hopes of the state with no falling away.'" A little commentary on the fire that's burning on your head: in other places the three root afflictions are referred to as the three fires, ignorance, attraction and aversion. Your hair's burning: uncomfortable. And nirvana literally means the blowing out of that fire. The four jhanas, the four formless attainments, cessation: all very helpful in seeing the fire and what it depends on, how you can stop fueling it, and in enjoying the release, the unbinding of the fire. All right, quick: any questions? "Do you have a... a practice question. I think it actually relates to this as well. I'm curious, with [unclear], I'm trying to understand whether it would be helpful to add insight ways of looking in. My sense is that with the intention for the piti, it can come on really strong, but it can feel a bit clamped or something.6
0:27:13I can hold the intention, and it maintains. I almost have a curiosity, as you're moving through the jhanas... I'm almost trying to understand how they work. If you [unclear], for example, does the piti push you into another jhana? I'm trying to understand which pedals I can press so that it's not just this really constricted piti for a long time." Did you hear the question? Yeah. So I encourage you to experiment; find out. But even if you're not bringing in one of the characteristics, or some other way of loosening the mind's grip on the experience, there's something in the subtlety of the attention as well that can modulate the intensity and coarseness of the piti. If we think in terms of grip: if you're gripping the piti harder, it's likely to show up as more coarse and more agitated, whereas if you have a softer, lighter touch, it might be just as intense, if not more intense, actually, and more stable, but the texture will become more refined.
0:28:45So, to use your analogy of the pedal, ease up a little and you can lean in. Also, the active and the receptive: play with those levers and see what happens. Yeah. "[unclear] practice iterations. I typically sit for up to an hour, but you're saying [to stay] 15 minutes or half an hour in the previous jhana, which seems to imply that to go from J1 to cessation, you have to sit for a very long time." Yeah, potentially. "Especially for most of us, sitting on the floor for three or four hours." Or lying down. Yeah. Right. So if you can do a single session of three or four hours, that's recommended. The retreat format we've got right now is my best compromise, to provide some balance between structure and giving you time in the afternoons to really go for it.
0:29:56So yeah, if you want to go for three or four hours at a stretch, do that. Also, once you've gained fluency with the prior jhanas, you can just run them, especially on a retreat where your concentration is deepening day after day. If you're working on the formless attainments at some point, you can run through J1 to J4 relatively quickly, in maybe a couple of minutes. So no, you don't have to; that's really just for the process of learning. It is good, and I recommend going through the whole sequence at a slow and luxurious pace, letting everything take its own time. But you don't have to do that every time. Yes. Did you hear the question? Strain versus relaxation, and fatigue from bringing the mind back to the object again and again. There might be a couple of things. There might be something in the approach that you can relax, despite the encouragement here to live as if one's head were on fire.
0:31:32If you're straining, that's not the kind of effort that's needed. So, as I was recommending to [a participant], if you can find a way to ease up and still maintain the continuity, do that. Over the whole life of practice really, but especially on retreat and when getting familiar with deeper states of samadhi, a lot of the learning curve is finding the minimum viable effort to sustain contact, and then riding that with continuity more than with force. Often what that looks like is over-efforting, letting go, slackening too much ("Okay, too much"), and then eventually, through trial and error, you find: "Okay, this is a sustainable pace. I can work with this." And moving between more active and more receptive modes, with the balance turning more receptive as concentration deepens and gains momentum. If you're also just grinding away and feeling, "Oh my God, I can't, I don't...": forget about it. Take a walk. Don't meditate. Intentionally don't meditate, and see what that's like for a little bit.7
0:32:47Sometimes it can be good to really just drop it and do something else for a little while, and then you come back fresh. "In your experience, is progressing from the fourth jhana to J5 for the first time a larger hurdle than getting from the first jhana to two, three, four?" It depends on the person, really. But for the majority of people, yes, moving from J4 to J5 is a bigger jump than from access concentration to J1, or from J1 to J4. "And what about developing the minimum adequate access concentration in the first place, versus getting from there to J1?" I don't think I understand the question. "I guess: is it more difficult to first cultivate the minimum required amount of access concentration than to move from access concentration to J1 for the first time?" Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah, I'd say that's true. Once you have good access concentration, if you know roughly what to do, it's just a matter of trying it enough times. If the concentration is strong enough, it will happen.
0:34:17But by far the most frustrating, difficult and annoying phase of practice, in my own experience, was developing consistently strong access concentration, so that it became the working basis rather than something I had to slog to redevelop all the time.
0:34:43"Yes, slogger here." I'm going to change your name in my phone. "I'm doing some great slogging this morning. This morning the state of my mind reminded me of being off retreat again: the number of thoughts, how much pull they have, and how easy it was to get lost in them. So I was working in that territory.
0:35:28I was trying to apply just this: 'My business is fine; not a problem.' And I found it was taking more and more intention and willpower to do that. So I got lighter and lighter, because too much intention sort of backfires.
0:35:57I got lighter and lighter, to the point where it felt like there was nothing I could do here. I had to turn more directly towards the state of the heart. I brought in some attachment-healing techniques, like ideal parents or something like that, because that just seemed to be what was needed more. I don't know, maybe this is just a report. I think I'd endorse my actions. It's just frustrating. I guess that's how you practice." There's nothing wrong in what you're reporting. Progress on a retreat, or even in a single sit, is just not linear: sit to sit, moment to moment, day to day, it's not a straight line, as you well know. If you're finding that you're getting sore and chafed and burnt out, then lean back more into ease, incorporate other modalities, and when you feel more resourced and refreshed, get back into it. "There's something I'm noticing about the container you're setting: 'This is what we're doing.'8
0:37:33As I do more of that, it's surfacing the 'you can't make me' part. Compared to years ago, I'm much more aware of that, and I know how to be gentle with it and meet it where it's at. But to get incredibly spacious and gentle, to meet it where it actually is... I feel like the deeper I go, the more subtly attuned to it I have to become somehow." Sure. Parts of the mind will rebel; they'll throw tantrums: "No, I would like to be doing anything else right now, please. Thank you." There are times when meeting that with warmth and openness and receptivity will soothe it, and then you can get back into practice. And there are other times when it's just like with a child: "No, I'm doing something really important, and you're actually fine." You just wait out the waves, and then the regulation can happen. And the habit of throwing up "No": okay, "No,"
0:39:11as many times as you like, and this is the direction we're going. Then eventually (you've seen this process with kids throwing a tantrum: "No, we're not going to the store, I'm staying right here," and you just walk out the door, and the kid goes, "Oh, I don't want to be left behind. Actually, I'd like to go. Can we...?") that can also happen. "Yeah. Here's a technique that's been working for me for this problem." Sure. "When that happens, imagine someone yelling at you, 'You [can't] do it, you're a piece of shit, you [can't] do it,' and just get angry at that thing, really angry: 'Yes, I can do it. Yes, I can do it.' It works for me." Yeah. Different personalities; whatever works. "Sorry, I've taken too much time, but as I keep going back to... I sort of gave up the game for a moment. It's like constantly going back to, 'Hey, just the breath.'
0:40:28It's like there's someone whose trust I need not to run over, or something. I just don't want to want it." Okay. Yeah, you can try different things. You can take a sterner approach, or you can take a gentle approach, and see what works. But folks online, I think they've had their hands up for a little bit here. [Participant], were you up first? I'm not sure. We'll get to you: [one participant] and then [another].
0:41:17"You were speaking a moment ago about playing with a more passive or a more active stance, and being responsive in efforting and relaxing to find that balance. Two questions. One: is it okay to also be playing with a wider versus a narrower aperture, if I'm using the breath, to find what's right in that moment? And also to move around where the breath goes, to find more pleasurable, easy spots to start with?" Yeah, at the beginning that might be skillful. As you gain momentum and concentration deepens, you'll get better results if you just stay with the breath through the whole body, or just stay with it, without changing the aperture so much. Or, if you are changing it within a session, start with one and then spend most of the time with the other. I wouldn't recommend following the breath around the body too much during a sit. That will disperse the energy that's building with the object.
0:42:47Not to say never do it. "Yeah, I am talking about quite early on. Okay, great, that answers that question. Thank you. And then: sometimes a feeling locks on, like, 'Yes, I'm now in balance; this is the right spot. This is where I want to be; I want to glide on this.' But it still tends to be binary for me: I'm off it, and then I've accidentally discovered it, and then I might fall off it again. Are there any words you can say about that in-between space, about what you're looking for, some clue that says, 'Okay, this is the right track; pay attention to this'?" In terms of whether a wide or narrow aperture is better, or more generally, down the road? "Okay, let's just talk about efforting."
0:43:56This is moving towards access concentration: you're finding that balance a little more than before. The length of time your mind actually stays with the object is increasing. There are signs in the body of increased relaxation, of pleasure; the signs of concentration we've talked about are beginning to arise. There may be some refinement in the object as well. What does that mean? At first the breath sensation, either at the nostrils or through the whole body, can be kind of coarse, and it can get brighter and more energized, smoother. These are all refinements of the object you might notice as concentration deepens. "Is the disappearing of the breath part of that too? Does that count as refinement? It gets quieter." Yeah, the breath getting softer. Also, deeper in access concentration it can get rather shallow, and at some point, if you're getting quite deep in, you may completely lose track of the sensation of the breath, say at the nostrils, or there might not be any perceptible fluctuation at all. If that's happening, you're probably well concentrated enough to try for the first jhana.
0:45:24"Last question: I think I've found that purposely shortening the breath just a little can move things towards that. Do you think that's accurate?" Move things towards access concentration? You tell me: does it work? "Well, it's really hard to say, because there are so many confounding variables. For sure, as things get more concentrated, my breath shortens. And there have been times when shortening the breath was followed by concentration." In my experience: the less fiddling and futzing ("What about a little bit of this? Or how about a little bit of this? A little to the left, a little to the right? How about up or down? Side to side?"), all those little minor adjustments... As your concentration deepens and you get more familiar with the object, the more you can let all of that go and just stay with it. [unclear]
0:46:45"Okay, thank you." Nice use of the Yiddish there, making "futz" a verb. Yeah, [participant]. "Extending the bit about slogging, as a fellow person who's still in the slog: I know everybody likes to say comparison is the thief of joy, and you're welcome not to tell me the answer if you don't think it's good for me. But I'm here to posit that for me it's actually been really helpful to get median, 80th-percentile, 20th-percentile-type numbers. I was one of those clever kids things came easily to in school, and therefore I get really impatient really fast. It would actually be really helpful to hear, 'It'll probably take something like 20 to 88 hours.' I know there's variability, but some quantification of what that slog is would, I think, actually be helpful to me. And I wouldn't be surprised if you told me I shouldn't know it." I don't know. I don't take those kinds of quantitative measurements. Perhaps somebody has; I haven't. It takes as long as it takes.
0:48:16"Are we talking, like, if somebody's tried an hour a day for a year, something's off?" No. It really depends. Someone can sit for an hour a day for a year, and during that hour their technique can be sloppy, so they're not actually getting many of the relevant reps in for each hour of that year. And likewise, someone can never have meditated before in their entire life and come on a 10-day retreat. This happens with some regularity on vipassana retreats in the Goenka tradition: "Never meditated before, but I hear it's good. I'm going to dive into the deep end and go for a 10-day." That's a lot of sitting they do, and they hit very deep access concentration, and, though they don't talk about it on those retreats, they hit jhana within 10 [days], 80 hours. Or further: I know people who hit formless attainments on their first vipassana retreat, without knowing what they were, never having meditated before. "But the fast end doesn't help me with the numbers on the slow end. Okay. Where this naturally leads me is something I've found in my system: apparently my system likes to throw up resistance in the form of confusion, which is really tricky, because I know that doing a year's worth of poor-quality practice isn't going to get you anywhere.9
0:50:07But I also know that I'll worry about the quality of my attempt as a way to just not do the thing. So is there a practical guideline? For example: pick your thing, do it for 45 minutes, just deal, and then iterate after 45. Something like that, to help contain that cycle in my mind, where within three minutes of sitting I'll have four questions I want to ask you and want to iterate." Yeah. This might not be helpful, but you're thinking about it too much. "Yes, every teacher has ever told me that. So did my stress instructor." Yep. "Go on. Are you going to tell me to feel the wave? We can feel the wave." No. So take a step back and look at what's driving these questions. It's the desire (this is a guess; tell me if it's correct) for certainty, for predictability, for something clear that I can set expectations around and have be 100% binary: "Yes, no, I'm doing it right, I'm doing it wrong." And constantly seeking verification and certainty at the level of thought will just slow this process down.
0:51:50So no, I don't have anything of that variety to give you, if what you want is "Just give me the checklist; give me the clear outline." "I think it's less about the checklist. It's more: can we build a container? I'll sometimes say, 'I'm not going to worry about whether this is working. I'll do this amount and check in on it after,' as a way to contain this tendency. Are you saying that's not the right way to contain the tendency?" It might help. For this retreat, just throw yourself in; I encourage you to let go and do as much as you can. But after this retreat, you could say to yourself, "Okay, if I want to keep working on this, I'm going to practice an hour a day for the next two weeks. Here are the signs that access concentration is deepening (that's a pretty standard list), and here are the signs that it's not." And then assess.
0:53:09You could do something like that. But it sounds like you want to get a lot more granular than that. "Yeah. The level of resolution I'm working at is within three minutes: should I try this as the object? Should I...? At what level of hip discomfort is it a valid move to adjust, so I can deepen concentration, versus just fidgeting? I go there very quickly, with all of that." Right. Yeah.
0:53:41You're hitting a wall that many people first hit when they start to practice a lot: the mind produces any and all questions, concerns, comments, small adjustments, variations on just bringing the mind back to the object again and again. And it really is just that simple. And it can take a while to relax enough for it to be that simple. "Okay. I won't push it in the big group setting." Yeah. If you want an interview, we can go over this again. [Participant]. "Yeah. First off, I'm just so giddy hearing you talk about all these big spaces. In fact, it makes me want not to focus on access concentration so much. So I wondered about the exact reasons to really focus on access concentration. It would be slowing the mind to build energy with an object, right? (Correct me if I'm wrong on any of these.) Then tapping into the subtleties of piti and sukha, so we can understand more of the subtleties in our body. And I guess the key element I can find connecting these formless jhanas with access concentration is less fabrication.
0:55:24As we're focusing on one thing, there's less fabrication of everything else around us. And then, I guess, the reps, almost like an athlete: the reps of our mind to build that access concentration. So the point of this (or not the point; there are many points) is that when we then go into the formless jhanas, we can have a deeper, more stable concentration to maintain them. Is that correct?" Yeah. "Okay. My one other question: could you describe the transition from the seventh to the eighth jhana one more time? What would the steps be, in our body or mind, to go from nothingness into the eighth jhana, where perception is gone but a slight amount of awareness is remaining? Maybe you could go into a little more detail on the seventh, and then a tiny bit on what the eighth is." Yeah, sure. It's neither perception nor non-perception. In terms of subtleties of body and mind: at that point, all the structures of your body and mind aren't there.
0:56:48So it's the most difficult of the transitions to describe. But, as I think I said in my description, if you are there, it's not that difficult a transition to make. You can feel a subtle tensing in the field of experience, on or around this can't-quite-pinpoint-it sense of nothingness. Then you loosen and release that, and you just fall in. If your concentration is strong enough, you'll just fall into the state. "Okay. So you're almost releasing clinging to nothingness." Yes. "Okay, awesome. Thank you." You're welcome. Okay, [unclear].
0:57:34"I know we're all anti-sloth and dullness, and I would never do that. But I've noticed that the most reliable, really the only, way to get my body to come online a bit more is to lie down and, as long as I can keep enough grasp on my attention, otherwise let my body get a bit hypnagogic, almost, and then it will sort of get something. So I'm wondering if you feel this is sloth-like or endorsable, or how you feel about that." Yeah. As with the balance of effort, the balance between alertness and sloth and torpor, sleepiness: it takes some time for your system to be able to maintain complete relaxation along with alertness. Just as with over- or under-efforting, too tight, too loose, you might find that, in finding that balance, you slip a little into being relaxed but actually a bit dull or sleepy, and then you bring it back up a bit. Likewise you might be, "Okay, alert, but too tense. Okay, relax a little." You swing back and forth until you find the middle. And that's fine.
0:59:07"So would you endorse this strategy overall?" Yeah. If you find it helpful to completely relax and get a little dull, without actually falling asleep, and then bring yourself up a bit, yeah. And at some point you may no longer need to do that; you may be able to settle right into the goal state. But yeah. "The sort of tendencies Quan was describing are very familiar to me, so I wanted to share one piece of advice I got. It hasn't cured me of that sort of thing, but I think it's been helpful. When you're sitting, what you're trying to do is rest your attention on the meditation object and just perceive it without engaging in conceptual elaboration. And all the questions that might come up (am I doing this right, should I maybe try a different object, should I do such-and-such) are just forms of conceptual elaboration.
1:00:22So if that's bubbling up during a sit, it's best just to remind yourself that this isn't the time for that sort of thought, and try to get on with it." And that may not work; it may come up anyway, and that's fine. You let it play, like (I think I said this yesterday) a radio on in the room. You're probably not going to be able to turn it off right away, and that's fine. You let it go. I know when I started to meditate, because I was reading a huge amount of meditation manuals and literature and suttas and all these things, I was more with thinking about what I'd read about meditation (all the different ways and theories and terms) than with my breath. It took some time for that to wind down, so that I could actually just be with the breath without the elaboration. It's not something you can turn off by force of will.
1:01:39But you can stop feeding it so much. "I know you're going to hate this question, but is it on the order of minutes, days, weeks, months? Can I get any sense?"
1:02:10I don't know anyone who's really put themselves into a container like a 10-day retreat, for example, and really done their best, and not experienced some significant diminution, a quieting. "Yeah, that's helpful. Thanks." Okay, one last question. Yes. "I'm just learning all this now. Here I'm closing my eyes for the meditation. At home I'd be able to do closed-eye and open-eye. With closed eyes, I can easily get to a still space. It's quiet, and obviously it's dark, and then there's light. But when I've done open-eye meditation at home (which I haven't done much), I noticed that it all becomes white, and then there'll be a few objects, and they slowly disappear: some white, and then maybe some light. So I'm curious: can the practice you're teaching be done open-eyed? Because it seems the lightness, or the stillness, is there with my eyes open or closed, maybe. But I'm wondering about the states you just spoke of: what happens with them? Because there's something different when the eyes are open. So I'm curious if there's a difference, if you can explain that."
1:03:56Yeah. You can go through these levels of absorption with your eyes open, and the experience will be different. If your concentration is exceptionally strong, and the pull of the visual field isn't so strong, your visual field might black out or white out even with your eyes open. You'll have the same progression in terms of bodily experience if you're doing jhana practice eyes open. Then, if you move on to boundless space, weird things may happen with your visual field, or the substantiality of the external world may just disappear, and you'll have the same felt sense of limitless extent, which you can get progressively absorbed into with your eyes open. This is harder for most people. Likewise with the boundlessness of awareness, and likewise with nothingness. Again, I recommend doing this with eyes closed first; it's easier for almost everybody to tune into it that way. But once you're really comfortable and fluent with these states, it can be very informative to tap back into these qualities with your eyes open and see what that does.
1:05:25"It's a weirdness... [unclear]?" Sure. The objects may fade and disappear. You may get ripples in space. Things may get larger or smaller. Your visual field may black out or white out, even with eyes open. You may get spots and speckles, dissolving and fading away, fading back in.
1:05:58These are some things I've personally experienced; I'm sure the range is quite large. If you're staring at the sky or a blank wall, you may also get a kind of Ganzfeld effect, and see patterns or colors in things. Okay. A spicy one, this one. Let's take 10 minutes and come back briefly for some sitting.
1:06:36Okay. Coming back, we'll sit for about 40 minutes. I don't like rules, but here's a new rule: only if someone asks for comments on their question, then, if you have something to say, go for it. But no more unsolicited commentary on others' questions.
1:07:06Okay. Thank you, everybody. I'll see some of you online for interviews. Enjoy the rest of the day. Practice well.
Sources
- Fourth jhana: “with the abandoning of pleasure and pain” DN 2 Samaññaphala Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN02.html ↩
- The formless attainments in sequence. MN 121 Cula Suññata Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN121.html ↩
- Using the after-effects of each jhana to see how form is fabricated. Rob Burbea, Seeing That Frees (Hermes Amara, 2014) ↩
- Entering and emerging from cessation of perception and feeling. MN 44 Culavedalla Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN44.html ↩
- Form like foam, feeling a bubble, perception a mirage, fabrications a banana tree, consciousness a magic trick. SN 22:95 Phena Sutta (Foam) dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN22_95.html ↩
- The three fires. SN 35:28 Adittapariyaya Sutta (Aflame) dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN35_28.html ↩
- Effort neither too tight nor too loose. AN 6:55 Sona Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN6_55.html ↩
- “Ideal parents” attachment repair. Daniel P. Brown and David S. Elliott, Attachment Disturbances in Adults (Norton, 2016): the Ideal Parent Figure protocol. ↩
- Ten-day vipassana courses in the Goenka tradition. dhamma.org. dhamma.org ↩