Jhana & Awakening Retreat 2026 · Session 7 of 16

Monday, November 9 · Evening

The Rod Embraced; Q&A on awakening, stream entry and kensho, jhana and ethics, karma and purification

Recorded November 9, 2026, 7:00 pm Mountain Time · Nameless Mountain, Boulder, Colorado · 56 min

A short reading from "The Rod Embraced" opened onto a long Q&A about awakening: how it's mapped, what stream entry is, and how jhana relates to ethics and karma.

Topics and questions in this session

Talk

  • 0:00:00The five recollections (AN 5:57).
  • 0:03:20Day three: the first days of a retreat are often a kind of clearing.
  • 0:05:26"The Rod Embraced" (Sn 4:15): the Buddha's terror at people floundering like fish in small puddles.
  • 0:10:43"I call greed a great flood." Burning up what's before and having nothing for after (0:12).
  • 0:14:04"For one unperturbed, who knows, there's no accumulating." Taking inspiration from this for the rest of our lives.

Q&A

  • 0:16:19How do you define awakening? Different lineages map it differently. The ten fetters and the four paths (0:19, AN 3:88).
  • 0:21:28Kensho, seeing the nature of mind, compared with stream entry.
  • 0:23:10What "stream" refers to in stream entry (SN 56:11). Different routes to it (0:24).
  • 0:26:11Jhana and ethics. Some misconduct makes jhana hard to reach (0:28).
  • 0:29:44Marinating in one jhana versus climbing the ladder.
  • 0:33:23If you're on the path to awakening, why engage the world or help others?
  • 0:36:48What karma is, and whether jhana purifies it (AN 6:63). Neural annealing (0:38).
  • 0:42:59How much practice it takes: retreat versus daily life.
  • 0:45:04Rob Burbea's model of awakening and soulmaking. Is there a single endpoint (0:49)?
  • 0:51:06When the nostrils become unpleasantly sensitive.

Closing

  • 0:54:05Chanted reflections on universal well-being.
Monday, November 9 · Evening

Edited transcript. The time at the start of each paragraph is where it begins in the recording above; drag the player to that point to listen. Participants' names are omitted. [Square brackets] mark editorial insertions; [unclear] marks words that couldn't be made out.

0:00:00I am of the nature to age; I have not gone beyond aging. What can happen in 24 hours? Here we are: sunset, the sun risen again. So many experiences have come and gone. So many breaths, so many thoughts, so many hindrances have risen and passed away, [days].

0:00:54We're all a little older, hopefully a little wiser. Byadhi-dhammomhi byadhim anatito: I am of the nature to sicken; I have not gone beyond sickness. Hopefully we make it through this retreat without anybody catching a cold; so far so good. So let's make good use of the health we've got. Marana-dhammomhi maranam anatito: I am of the nature to die; I have not gone beyond dying. Even if we do realize the unborn, undying nature of all phenomena, of mind itself, this is still an impermanent assemblage of hair, skin, organs, teeth, mucus, phlegm, [unclear] (make a fuller inventory if you like), and it will pass away. None of this lasts. Sabbehi me piyehi manapehi nanabhavo vinabhavo: all that is mine, beloved and pleasing, will become otherwise, will become separated from me. Not only my own body, not only my own health, not only my youth: in fact everything is constantly passing away. We are all the owners of our actions, heirs to our actions, born of our actions, related to our actions, and abide supported by our actions. Whatever actions we shall do, for good or for ill, of those we shall be the heirs.1

0:03:20It's day three of the retreat. The first couple of days on a retreat like this can often be a kind of clearing ground for whatever is lingering in our body, our mind, our psyche, and we can see how we've been living. In the clear mirror, regrets, worries, anticipations, hopes, fears, the condition of our practice, the condition of our body and our mind: all of that is reflected, when we look, as a fruit of our past action and of the condition of our mind moment to moment. On retreat, when we're not so caught up and busy, we can see very clearly how the mind bends and swerves this way and that depending on how we intend, moment to moment: collecting the mind more into samadhi, or dispersing, engaging the hindrances, responding skillfully or unskillfully to what arises internally and externally. All of this conditions our experience. And thus we should frequently recollect. I don't have a subject for this evening's talk, and again, as this morning, I'll try to talk less, but there's a very brief text I'd like to share, a poem.

0:05:26This is also from the Sutta Nipata. It's "The Rod Embraced," speaking of what drew him onto the path and talking a little about its fruition as well. When we've gone through it, maybe I'll have some things to say, and then we can open it up to any questions related to the subject of this retreat, to anything that's happened so far, any lingering questions about practice, anything at all. So this is "The Rod Embraced": "When embraced, the rod of violence breeds danger and fear. Look at people in strife. I will tell of how I experienced terror: seeing people floundering like fish in small puddles, competing with one another, as I saw this, fear came into me." I'll pause there. It's interesting that in the later tradition the figure of the Buddha becomes more and more inhuman, more and more cosmic. In some traditions the appearance and display of the form body of the historical Buddha, Shakyamuni, is considered a kind of emanation of a cosmic Buddha, and the appearance of the path, the progression and then the realization of enlightenment is just a kind of mirage for our benefit.2

0:06:58Interesting that it went that way. But here, this is very plainly him, seeing North India 2,500 years ago: an urbanizing and agrarian society in which different political systems, small kingdoms and republics and [unclear] peoples were all warring and competing over land and resources and property. Killing, lots of war, famine, death. "Look at people in strife: seeing people floundering like fish in small puddles, competing with one another, as I saw this, fear came into me. The world was entirely without substance. All the directions were knocked out of line. Wanting a haven for myself, I saw nothing that wasn't laid claim to. Seeing nothing in the end but competition, I felt discontent." Again, in later narratives of the Buddha's life he's presented as a prince, the heir to a kingdom. From the early material, as best we can tell, he was definitely a member of an aristocratic class, but probably in more of an oligarchic republic, of the same kind you might see in Greece around the same time. So not the sole heir to a kingdom, but a member of a hereditary aristocracy. But even so,

0:08:43wanting a haven for himself, he didn't feel secure even in that position. He saw nothing that wasn't laid claim to. "Seeing nothing in the end but competition, I felt discontent. And then I saw an arrow here, so very hard to see, embedded in the heart." You know what he's talking about? Does that ring a bell? "Overcome by this arrow, you run in all directions. But simply on pulling it out, you don't run and you don't sink. Whatever things are tied down in the world, you shouldn't be set on them. Having totally penetrated sensual pleasures and sensual passions, you should train for your own unbinding. Being truthful, not insolent, not deceptive, and remote from divisiveness, without anger, the sage should cross over the evil of greed and avarice; should conquer drowsiness, weariness, sloth; shouldn't consort with heedlessness; shouldn't stand firm in his pride: the person with their heart set on unbinding. They shouldn't create affection for form, and should fully fathom conceit; should live refraining from impulsiveness; shouldn't delight in what's old, prefer what's new, grieve over decline, or get entangled with what's dazzling and bright."

0:10:08I don't know about you, but when he goes through that list and I look at how I spend a lot of my time: ugh, uh-oh. An awful lot of running around with an arrow stuck in the heart. Grieving over decline. Preferring what's new: "Oh, shiny." Delighting in what's old: "Oh, antique, traditional. It says so right in the Pali Canon. Check it out: authentic."

0:10:43"I call greed a great flood; hunger, a swift current; preoccupations, ripples; sensuality, a bog hard to cross over. Not deviating from truth, a sage stands on high ground, a brahman." (Using the word, in a sense, for just a noble, accomplished, learned one.) "Being relinquished in every way, they are said to be a sage at peace; having clearly known, they are an attainer of knowledge; knowing the Dhamma, independent, moving rightly through the world, and not envying anyone here." Isn't that interesting? Not envying anyone here. What would that be like: to survey the whole world and find there's nothing you lack, nothing at all, and nothing anyone else has or could possibly have that you would long for? "Whoever here has gone beyond sensual passions, an attachment hard to transcend in the world, doesn't sorrow, doesn't fret. Their stream cut, they are free from bonds. Burn up what's before..." You can look at all our efforts in practice that way. Here we are, rubbing and pressing our attention against meditation objects, creating a little friction, a little heat, burning up all our habituation.

0:12:27"Burn up what's before, and have nothing for after" (not holding on to what may come in the next moment, or tomorrow). "If you don't grasp at what's in between" (now), "you'll go about calm." Letting go of what's past, not grasping at the future, and releasing even the present: going beyond time. "For whom, in name and form, in every way, there's no sense of mine, and who doesn't grieve over what is not: they, in the world, aren't defeated; they suffer no loss. To whom there doesn't occur 'This is mine,' and for whom nothing is others': they, feeling no sense of mine-ness, don't grieve at the thought 'I have nothing.' Not harsh, not greedy, not perturbed, everywhere concordant: this is the reward, I say when asked, for those who are free from theorizing." All our tendency to conjecture, to ponder, to project, to speculate is really an expression of our agitation, our discontent, our dis-ease. To be free from theorizing: to know the arising and passing away of experience just as it is, without forming any conception about it.

0:14:04"For one unperturbed, who knows, there's no accumulating. Abstaining, unaroused, they everywhere see security." The tendency of the mind is to seek refuge and security in phenomena, internally and externally, and inevitably that falls away, and we feel the need to reach out and grasp and shore up conditions or ourselves, bracing, collecting. But if you let go completely, there's nothing to lose, and everywhere you see security. There's nothing to protect, nothing to hold on to: safe everywhere. "The sage doesn't speak of themselves as among those who are higher, equal or lower." The tendency to compare is also based on conceit, on a sense of I and mine and other, better and worse. "At peace, free from stinginess, they don't embrace, they don't reject. This is what the Blessed One said."

0:15:49So in our practice together here, and for the remainder of our lives, I hope you're able to take some inspiration from what's being pointed at there. It really is possible.

0:16:19All right, the floor is open: any questions about practice, any questions about Dharma, anything I can help anyone with. The floor is open, and as soon as we're done with questions, we'll just move into practice for the rest of the evening. "How do you define awakening in your system?" Did that come through? I don't have a system. How do I define awakening? In the history of jurisprudence, in the early 20th century, there was an issue about defining obscenity. I think it came about when James Joyce published his great novel Ulysses, and there was a furor in the courts over whether it should be banned because it contained explicit language, still not fit for publication. I may be misremembering, but I believe the judge who looked over the case, when trying to define obscenity, quipped, "I know it when I see it." A bit of a [unclear]. "Well, I wanted to ask a big question. In Zen you have kensho, which you could call awakening, but you can have many kenshos, whereas in Theravada supposedly you have it once and you're done."

0:18:13Yeah. In different Buddhist lineages there are different ways of mapping awakening, corresponding to the different ways this process has unfolded for different people, to how it's been languaged in different cultures, and to the different methods and how they choose to subdivide it into stages and progressions. I think the traditional maps are good as far as they go. If you take what's in the canon at its word, the definitions of stream-enterer, once-returner, non-returner and arahant are pretty straightforward. Then, of course, everything is contested. In my own opinion, and when I examine my own experience, having trained across these different lineages, I think what's meant in the Pali Canon by stream entry is actually a much higher bar than what most people are talking about in some lineages, or some teachers, or in contemporary discourse. It's like: "Okay, if you've had a little blip, a blank-out, if you've seen consciousness disappear once or something, a stream-enterer you are. You've reached the deathless." They define nirvana as the cessation of mentality and materiality, and if the mind has landed on that, touched on that unconditioned dhamma of nirvana once, then a stream-enterer you are.

0:19:49I don't think so. There are ten fetters, and the four paths within the early canon are defined by the progressive severance of these fetters. One of the fetters, the most consequential one to be cut at stream entry, is self-view, sakkaya-ditthi. In my opinion (take it for what it is, my opinion), the severing of sakkaya-ditthi, of self-view, is something irreversible, such that you can never again in the same way construe any of the five aggregates (form, feeling, perception, mental formations, or consciousness itself) as a self or as what belongs to a self. It's an irreversible transition that issues in a radically different way of experiencing, forever after, which isn't bound in the same way to the sense of identity. Then, progressively from there, all the further fetters (sense desire, ill will, conceit, the last veil of ignorance, passion for form and formlessness) are a progressive attenuation of the residual cruft, until it's finally all blown out. So that's my interpretation and understanding of the four-path model, and I think it's diagnostic as far as it goes. Then within Zen, like you said, kensho literally means seeing nature. Seeing the nature of what?3

0:21:28Seeing the nature of your mind, which is empty, which is selfless: the same thing as what's being gotten at with stream entry. But you can have little glimpses, little openings that are nonetheless not abiding, and that's acknowledged within the Zen tradition, and also within later traditions like Mahamudra, Dzogchen, Vajrayana. There are fleeting glimpses that don't overturn the mind in such a way that it can't fall back into the previous mode of misperception, and there are different modes and methods for stabilizing that glimpse so that it becomes the abiding mode of experiencing and not just a flash. My own experience was that I had a really radical glimpse early on that left me in zero doubt that awakening was real and possible, and yet it was very fleeting. So then I threw myself into practice, through many openings and experiences, until it finally flipped over and didn't revert to the prior way of seeing. And I can tell you in all honesty that there's much further to go.

0:23:10Does that answer the question in some way? "Yeah." "What does the word 'stream' refer to in stream entry?" You've entered the stream of the Dhamma, which inevitably flows to the ocean. "And what's required for stream entry, other than this lasting dissolution of the sense of being a self?" As recorded in the suttas, and by contemporary accounts, it really varies. You can't say anything deterministic. For some, an experience of cessation may issue in it, or a bunch of experiences of cessation, shorter or longer, may be involved, or they may not. This is another point of contemporary orthodoxy that I vehemently disagree with. In the suttas, if every time someone attained a level of awakening they had entered into the cessation of perception and feeling, you'd think they might mention it, but they don't. Sometimes, yes, but not always, and it would have been pretty easy to include. So you can't really say. And some people will have an awakening just by being in conversation; that happens plenty in the Pali Canon.4

0:24:48Some through exhaustive cultivation of samadhi, moving through the jhanas and then turning the mind to insight; some through contemplating the impermanence of the body; tons and tons of different ways. You can't say for sure. There's no minimum viable checklist I can hand you: "Okay, do these things in this order." That would be convenient, but it just doesn't seem to work that way. "And what are a once-returner and a non-returner?" Yeah. This refers to the scheme within early Buddhism. A stream-enterer has at most seven more lifetimes to go through before complete and full awakening and the cessation of the cycle of birth and death. A once-returner means literally that, if they don't complete the process in this lifetime, they'll come back at most once. A non-returner is not going to come back: either at the moment of death, or shortly after reappearing in a heavenly realm, they will attain full awakening. And an arahant is done while alive.

0:26:11You can make up your own mind about that, or, better, see for yourself. "I'm curious to hear you elaborate on the connection between jhana and ethics. I almost want to say I have some doubts. Sometimes I'm like, this is really cool stuff, but why are we doing this? I see how it's becoming popularized, with Jhourney and some new retreats, and I have some concerns about people just dipping into jhanas without potentially having a larger framework for what to do after. I'm curious if you could speak to that." Yeah. Deep states of absorption in meditation don't necessarily lead to liberation. They don't necessarily lead to awakening. They're powerful tools on the way. I would say that awakening is inherently ethical. If it's not changing your ethical conduct, then the seeing through self hasn't gone very deep, hasn't percolated or permeated through your body-mind, because it will inevitably affect your behavior. Not that that doesn't come in degrees. But I have little doubt that a sociopath could be quite adept at jhana and misuse it.5

0:28:02There are certain kinds of misconduct that will make jhana inaccessible or difficult if you have a normal conscience. But no, there isn't as tight a connection as we might wish. For the vast majority of people, I think, if you immerse yourself in jhana, really become skilled in it and bring it to some depth, you'll realize pretty quickly: "Oh, gosh, a lot of what I've been looking for in life, and a lot of the ways I've gone about getting it, which may have been more or less ethical... maybe I don't need to do all that." Maybe your behavior will change as a result. And, as I've tried to point out many times, being within the container of sila makes the whole process go as smoothly as it can. But there's nothing inherently Buddhist, or inherently one-to-one ethical, about deep absorption. It's an archetype in some contemplative traditions: the immensely powerful yogi who's like an evil wizard. There are such characters. Watch out.

0:29:44"One of the benefits of spending time in jhana is going up the ladder [unclear], but another is marinating in the jhana. You could spend one hour in the first jhana, or one hour in the fourth, or whatever. Are there benefits to being in jhana in general, separate from the benefits of being in the first versus the fourth? If you choose one to marinate in, which one? Do you gain different things? Is there any point in doing that, or should I be training depth?" Yeah. In my own experience, I've found that certain parts of my being are satiated by each of the four jhanas. There's a kind of deep emotional restlessness that the third jhana just completely balms and soothes and soaks and saturates and eases. There's almost an itch for a kind of deep, pleasurable happiness that the second addresses. Likewise, the first jhana satisfies what gets going after high-intensity stimulation. And deep rest, deep peace, deep clarity, deep contentment: the fourth takes care of those.

0:31:32That's on the level of what I can notice in terms of my psychology and how I react to spending so much time in the jhanas. It's as though different layers or levels of the mind-body system are soothed and dissolved by each of the jhanas in turn, and it's a progressive dissolution all the way home. What I'd recommend (and I recommended this to someone in an interview today) is that if you've got the time, if you've got the runway, you marinate in the first jhana for as long as you can, unless it's unreasonably intense, in which case move on and maybe come back up. Marinate in the first as long as possible, until you're absolutely full to the brim and the state naturally tips your system over: your nervous system reaches a point of total saturation and satiation, and it just tips over into the next jhana without deliberate intention. However long that takes. You might spend a day or days just hanging out in the first jhana before you reach a saturation point and tip over into the next.

0:33:23Or that might happen within a sit, or over several hours, or however long it takes. Doing it that way, you'll also learn the territory very well, and I think there's some deep, abiding benefit in letting your system just bask for as long as it wants to, as long as it can take. "Going off the ethics question: if one is on the path to awakening, what would be the motivation for engaging with the external world, or pursuing goals, or helping others?" Did everybody hear that? No, not so much. So: for someone on the path of awakening, what's the purpose of engaging other goals, or helping others? If you read what's in the canon: not much point; best just to go straight for it. Why bother with other things? And certainly at an earlier phase of my life, in a very prideful, conceited and kind of angry way, I was very much like that: "Why would you do anything else? Go." But sooner or later, at awakening if not before, you see that there's no difference between the worldly and the unworldly, the spiritual and the mundane.

0:35:18So do what you can to help yourself, those close to you, those around you. If you have a keen interest in art, in music, in creation, that's a part of who you are. (Here I'm departing from Theravada orthodoxy; they would definitely not be all for that.) But whatever your natural talents, capacities and skills are, as your practice deepens they'll emerge from you as a function of the depth of your practice, and will come into line with it. And for periods of time it may make sense, if, like me for a while, you really don't care about anything else. Great. It won't do wonders for your career or your social life. But if you're drawn to that... I don't know, it's like falling madly in love with somebody. Everybody around you may say, "Oh my God, that person? No." And you may run headlong anyway. It could be like that. [Participant], I think you had your hand up first.

0:36:48"My question is about karma, purifying karma, and perhaps jhanas, if they intersect. I know karma is a very complicated topic, so I was very curious to know, first of all, what karma is to you. Can we purify karma, and to what extent? What sorts of practices, including or maybe not including jhanas, help us purify karma? And what happens when the karma is purified even a little bit more? I know I'm asking about four questions at once." Sure. Karma is just intentional action, and it can be positively, neutrally or negatively balanced in terms of conditioning your future mental horizons. And I'm going to depart from the scholastic answer (okay, you just moved on the screen). Marinating in deep samadhi, developing access concentration and moving through jhana, as I'm sure some of you well know, can bring up scads of memories and impressions, can trigger old habits, and can cause you to see different formations in your personality and your behavior, even the way your motor activity is habituated. All of that can get surfaced, seen and released, and your mind and your body and your energetic system can all get reconfigured as all that gets massaged, or sandblasted, into a more pliable, less grooved state.6

0:38:45I could say something hand-wavy about neural annealing if you want; you could look up that term and you might find some interesting stuff. It's not talked about quite this way in the early canon, but in Zen, and certainly in Vajrayana and Dzogchen, karmic imprints are considered to be lodged within the subtle energetic structure of the body, within the channel system for instance. In Zen they don't map it out in quite so detailed or prescriptive a manner. But all those little knots or bindings come undone through practice, through a mixture of purifying absorption and insight. Then you pass a critical threshold in the awakening process, and you're no longer forming any new karmic impressions; you're just exhausting what remains. One way of looking at the theoretical end point is that you've exhausted it all: fresh as a newborn baby. You've cleaned out the basement; it's all undone. Is that helpful? "So what I'm hearing is: if we're really deep into, I'm going to say, especially the formless jhanas, when we go there (or maybe not, I'm not sure)... basically, are there certain jhana states that are especially helpful for getting the purification going, or is it all good for purification?"7

0:40:49In my experience it's all good, and the deeper the absorption, the better. And just the process of getting to that depth of absorption is, I think, where a lot of the work happens, along the way. Then there's also the quality of marinating. I noticed when I started getting into formless territory and then moving back into embodiment that the way I moved, the way my body articulated in space, changed. Certain patterns of facial tension didn't come back. Odd, interesting. Likewise, moving through and hanging out in the form jhanas, which are more corporeal and embodied and energetic and can have quite an emotional tenor, certain emotional patterns can get cleared or released or seen. Yeah. "I have some kind of question; I'm not sure exactly what. Something about hearing you talk about this process: does most of it tend to happen, for you or for most people you've seen, solely in retreat conditions? I'm trying to get my head around progress. I've only deepened in this practice in retreat conditions, and I only go on a few retreats a year, so it's slow going, and it has me thinking: can I get there with a ten-day jhana practice period once or twice a year, or should I go on a multi-month retreat again some day?

0:42:59What's the prognosis for how much... I know everyone's different, and there's no one-size-fits-all, but that's the kind of thing I'm thinking about, hearing this." Yeah. My own experience, and that of many people I know, is that you can absolutely continue and go deeply through this process in daily life. It's just a matter of prioritizing and using time, and retreat is expedient. "Probably not different from how I'd answer that question. That's one of those questions where I'd have an answer if someone asked me, so I needed to hear it from you." This also came up in one of the interviews earlier today. You can, and I've seen this (I've experienced it a little myself, but know it more from friends who've done an awful lot more retreat than I have): you can get stuck in a good place. You can be so comfortable in your routine of deep absorption and relatively stress-free living in a monastic enclosure or long-term retreat environment that whole layers and levels and triggers in your consciousness just aren't being accessed, aren't being touched. Then you might come out of a three-year retreat, walk into a Walmart and collapse crying because you can't handle anything; it's just too much. You may not have worked on huge reams and realms of your being that just weren't getting touched. So the monastery or intensive retreat enclosure is not in fact always the best for practice, at least past a certain point.

0:45:04"I have an inspired question, around the notion of awakening. In the model you're presenting, the goal (this is the image I got) is almost zooming out to see the coding of experience: to see the aggregates and disidentify and de-reify. I wonder whether that's objectively the place to stay. Something that really spoke to me from [Rob's] teachings is the ability to, I guess you could say, honor and sense the sacredness of the self, as a means of not pushing against it, and the same with suffering. That had the effect for me of really letting me embrace the self and the suffering, which had the weird effect of making them really fade. So it almost seems ingrained in the Pali Canon path, from what I'm hearing, that there's a pushing against these things that aren't actually even there, which seems to make them appear real. Do you see what I'm saying? So is that the goal? Is this an incremental path we're walking, and at the end of it we look back from that bird's-eye view and can then honor the self and the suffering? Do you see what I'm saying?"

0:46:34I think so. Let's see if this lands. The early teachings (with major exceptions, which I've tried to highlight a couple of times) are within a kind of dualistic frame, as an expedient pedagogical means. If you see emptiness, if you see not-self clearly, you see that there isn't actually anything here to push against. There never was, nor could there ever be. And yet, until that is a realization, it makes sense to think and practice in terms of these conventional categories. And seeing the sacred in everything: you won't find that language so much in the Pali Canon, but certainly in later Dharma, in other streams, the whole world is revealed as the face and form of Buddha. It's not just poetic language. When you realize the non-duality of your mind and appearance, and the emptiness of everything, there's a kind of equalization across all experience: everything is luminous, empty, clear, radiant, perfect, absolutely perfect just as it is, without any need to transform or disappear. And you can also engage in creative play with form and with appearance, as a method for realizing emptiness: working with energy.

0:48:32"Can you say that again? Working with what?" Energy. Manipulating somatic flows of energy. I'm thinking of creation and completion stage practice in Vajrayana, where you're engaging forms of deity and generating yourself [as the deity], or in completion stage manipulating winds and drops and colors and spinning wheels and lights. Whoa! "So that's from the solid ground of emptiness, you could say: you're creating intentionally, knowing that it's fully empty, just as everything always has been." Yeah. And even without having realized emptiness, if the mind is malleable enough, you can work with appearance, with the body and energy, in that way as a means to further that realization and deepen it. "So it's like Rob's way of seeing the model." As far as I can tell, Rob was deeply influenced by Vajrayana and quotes a whole bunch from it at certain points, although he doesn't draw as explicitly on a lot of the method that's there. But in Soulmaking Dharma and other places, it seems he's drawing a lot of inspiration from there, and from James Hillman and other places.8

0:49:47"Yeah. I'm trying to extract a question from this energy in my being. I guess the question, then, is: is there a solid, singular endpoint?" That's an open question. Certainly in terms of manifestation and expression, and the methods and means by which awakening can happen and how it can express itself, no, it doesn't really seem so, judging by the historical record and the diversity of practitioners currently living. In terms of method and expression, a realized Burmese Theravadin monastic and a realized tantric yogi hanging out in a charnel ground drinking alcohol: okay, these are different. But I'll reiterate what I think I said last night: what's conserved is the core realization of emptiness, of selflessness through all experience, and freedom being the [unclear]. Yeah.

0:51:06"Cool. Thank you." You're welcome. "I have a very down-to-earth question." Love those. "Is this just entertainment? Sometimes, as I was doing the sensations at the nostrils, the nostrils became increasingly sensitive in an unpleasant way, kind of like [unclear], that sort of thing. And it made me want to escape those sensations into something vaguer, or energetic or whatever, something other than those. Do you have any advice on this?" Yeah, I know what you're talking about. When you're focusing there, you can get these pinprick, needle-like or sharp sensations, something like that, as if you're breathing in air that's way too cold or dry. If you can volitionally tune your attention in that area to a smoother texture, if you can discern even a little of a smoother texture that's still obviously breath-related in that area, and preferentially focus on that, I'd go for it.

0:52:35It may also just pass. The meditation object can manifest all kinds of different frequencies and textures, and can transiently be unpleasant. But if you find it's getting rougher or coarser, and you can tune it to something more pleasant, go for it. Yeah.

0:53:18Well, let's take 10, and we'll come back and sit. Okay. After a brief chant, no more words from me tonight. We all know what we're doing here.

0:54:05Now let us chant the reflections on universal well-being. "May I abide in well-being, in freedom from affliction, in freedom from hostility, in freedom from ill will, in freedom from anxiety, and may I maintain well-being in myself. May everyone abide in well-being, in freedom from hostility, in freedom from ill will, in freedom from anxiety, and may they maintain well-being in themselves. May all beings be released from all suffering, and may they not be parted from the good fortune they have attained. When they act upon intention, all beings are the owners of their action and inherit its results. Their future is born from such action, companion to such action, and its results will be their home. All actions with intention, be they skillful or harmful, of such acts they will be the heirs." Hey, everyone: good night. See you tomorrow.9

Sources

Translations are Thanissaro Bhikkhu's on dhammatalks.org unless noted.

  1. The five recollections, with their Pali. AN 5:57 Upajjhatthana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN5_57.html ↩
  2. “When embraced, the rod of violence breeds danger and fear” Sn 4:15 Attadanda Sutta (The Rod Embraced) dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/StNp/StNp4_15.html ↩
  3. The fetters abandoned at each stage; “seven times at most” AN 3:88 Sekhin Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN3_88.html ↩
  4. Awakening on hearing a talk, without any mention of cessation. SN 56:11 Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta (Kondañña’s stream entry) dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN56_11.html ↩
  5. Right concentration and its requisites in the other path factors. MN 117 Maha Cattarisaka Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN117.html ↩
  6. “Intention, I tell you, is kamma” AN 6:63 Nibbedhika Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN6_63.html ↩
  7. “Neural annealing” Michael Edward Johnson, “Neural Annealing: Toward a Neural Theory of Everything” (Opentheory.net, 2019) ↩
  8. Rob Burbea’s imaginal practice and James Hillman. Rob Burbea’s Soulmaking Dharma talks (Gaia House, 2014–2020), archived at hermesamara.org. ↩
  9. Chant: reflections on universal well-being. Amaravati / Abhayagiri chanting book. ↩

← Monday, November 9 · Morning · All sessions · Tuesday, November 10 · Morning →