Monday, November 9 · Morning
Feeding and starving the hindrances; Q&A; guided whole-body breathing
A practical talk on what feeds each hindrance and what starves it. The Q&A was mostly about desire, regret and the breath. It closed with a guided body scan and whole-body breathing.
Topics and questions in this session
Talk
- 0:00:00More detail on the hindrances, and how they sound in your head: "Maybe there's something wrong with that guy at the front."
- 0:03:44Feeding and starving the hindrances (SN 46:51).
- 0:03:44Sensual desire is fed by attention to beauty and starved by its opposite, such as the parts of the body (MN 10).
- 0:06:59Ill will is fed by irritation and starved by goodwill and compassion. Noises, earplugs, coughing and sneezing.
- 0:14:17Restlessness and anxiety are fed by non-stillness and starved by stillness.
- 0:17:15Uncertainty is fed and starved the same way.
Q&A
- 0:18:53Regret over unskillful living, when you can't go back and undo it (0:21).
- 0:22:43How to tell sensual desire from the rapture of jhana (MN 66).
- 0:24:33Lustful imaginings during practice. Can that energy move into piti (0:28)?
- 0:29:36Noticing the phases of the breath, versus just sensation.
- 0:31:53In whole-body breathing, should the breath or the body be in the foreground?
- 0:33:43Lights and images in the closed-eye visual field, with the breath or a mantra.
- 0:35:02A participant's share on holding frustration: "double dukkha" (SN 36:6).
Guided practice
0:00:00Namo tassa bhagavato arahato sammā-sambuddhassa (three times). I wanted to give a little more detail this morning on the hindrances. On a retreat of this length, with such a diverse group of people [unclear] with lots of varying levels of prior experience, I can't address everyone's situation all at once, which is why I'm glad we have the opportunity for interviews at least every other day and ample time for Q&A. But a little more on the hindrances. The five are, again: sensual desire; ill will; sloth and drowsiness; restlessness and anxiety (sometimes restlessness and remorse); and uncertainty, or skeptical doubt. Let's make it participatory: can someone give an example of distracting sensual desire that arises in meditation? "I'm really hungry. When's lunch going to be?" Really hungry, when's lunch going to be? Absolutely. It smells good, too. What are you guys doing? How about ill will? [Participant], [unclear].1
0:02:00Sloth and drowsiness? Sorry. How about restlessness, anxiety, remorse? "I'm getting a lot of that, a lot of things about my life." Yeah: "All this time and space; let's think about everything I've fucked up, or that I'm not doing but should be doing." I'm familiar with that one. Oops. And uncertainty, or doubt: a kind of wavering, not fully in, not out. "I feel like this isn't working. It's not working. I'm not working. Maybe this practice isn't for me. Maybe I'm not for this practice. Maybe there's something wrong with me. Maybe there's something wrong with that guy at the front. Or the Buddha: what a crock of shit, awakening, nonsense, wishful thinking." These are just examples. With anything I say or recite or read, or in your own studies, try always to relate it back to your own experience. Even if a specific example doesn't resonate, there should be a chord within your own experience where you can identify some similarity.
0:03:44This sutta talks about feeding and starving the hindrances. So what feeds sensual desire, sensory desire? (I'm not sure what Pali word they're translating.) "There is the theme of beauty. To foster inappropriate attention to it..." But we could generalize this to anything we find captivating. If we can smell the delicious food, we start to fasten on it. Our attention is drawn and fastened and proliferates on the basis of something we find desirable. Not that there's anything wrong with beauty or good, delicious food. To draw from the later tradition, Tilopa to Naropa: "It's not appearances that bind, but attachment." So there's nothing wrong with beauty, nothing wrong with delicious tastes or odors, or with your body. The Buddha once thought there was something wrong with all of those things, and nearly starved himself to death. He did live a pretty extreme and ascetic lifestyle by today's standards, but not one focused on forceful deprivation or punishing self-denial. So when you're trying to meditate and you notice that your mind is pulled and drawn by something you find attractive and endearing, in imagination or actually in your immediate sensory environment, okay, that's fine.234
0:05:28Let it go and bring it back. Especially if you're some ways in, if you've begun to proliferate around this endearing, attractive sensory event, let it go. And how does one starve the hindrance of sensual desire? Again, this isn't so popular in most Western meditation circles, but "there is the theme of unattractiveness. To foster appropriate attention to it: this is the lack of food for the arising of unarisen sensual desire, or for the growth and increase of sensual desire once it has arisen." So this is an antidotal approach to the hindrances. If you find you're drawn to the sensation of hunger or to food, and your mind is drifting to it as you attempt to come back to the breath or to metta, think for a moment about what's going to happen to that food. Where's it going to go? What does it turn into? Pasty mush in your mouth, not as appetizing. It's going to travel down your throat through saliva and mucus, be dissolved in bile and acid in your stomach, then move through your intestines and come out the other end.
0:06:59So you can bring in the opposite as a contemplation, which should allow some release from the sensory attraction and fixation. You can also meditate on your own body as a corpse, or as moving through the process of decay. I'm not going to give instruction on that right now, but if you're curious, we can talk about it in an interview. Feel free to be creative in your approach here. I'll reiterate that most of the time, for any and all of the hindrances, it's enough just to let it go and come back. Only if something persists across a long duration in a session, or over many sessions, do I recommend trying these more elaborate means of calming and stilling the hindrances. But they do work. What about ill will? "There is the theme of irritation. To foster inappropriate attention to it..." This is the inverse of sensual desire, attraction and fixation. Is there something in imagination, memory or our immediate sensory environment that we don't want (a person, a sound, a noise, a motion, whatever it is) that we're averse to, and that creates a tension and jitter in the mind that isn't conducive to samadhi?5
0:08:41And then engaging in perseverative thinking about it: "Oh, that noise, why does it keep happening? Oh, that person I can't stand; will they ever go away?" "And what is the lack of food for the arising of unarisen ill will, or for the growth and increase of ill will once it has arisen? There is the awareness-release through goodwill, compassion, empathetic joy or equanimity. To foster appropriate attention to that..." This is perhaps more appealing than meditating on the process of digestion, or on your body as a corpse, or some other equally unappealing thing to quell perseverative desire. If you're preoccupied with ill will, with irritation, with anger, whatever it is, tap into metta if it's available to you, or into compassion for yourself or for another, or actually direct those qualities to the sensory event itself. If there's pain or discomfort in the body and you can direct metta to it, that can zap, liquefy, neutralize an aversive reaction you may be experiencing. Likewise with something interpersonal, or in memory.
0:09:58If you're holding a resentment or a grudge that you're chewing over and over again, you can bring compassion to yourself, to the situation, to that person, likewise. If you're preoccupied with jealousy, you can somehow tap into sympathetic joy instead. Easier said than done, but these do work. "And what is the food for the arising of unarisen sloth and drowsiness, or for the growth and increase of sloth and drowsiness once it has arisen? There is boredom, weariness, yawning, drowsiness after a meal, and sluggishness of awareness. To foster inappropriate attention to them..." I'm sure you're familiar with this. It's not listed here, but it is in other places, and maybe you know this to be true from your own experience: if you overeat, you're going to be tired. If you don't get good sleep, you're going to be tired. If you hold your body in rigid tension, you're going to be tired. If you're over-efforting and straining in practice, that's going to be exhausting.6
0:11:13So if you find yourself doing those things, relax. And [a participant] has very kindly offered a whole bunch of earplugs, so if someone in your room is snoring and you'd benefit from them, they're on the counter. You're also welcome to bring earplugs into the hall if that would help you; use them at your convenience. Then, what is the lack of food? Well, with the yawning, the tiredness, the drowsiness, inappropriate attention to them is like a current: if you let yourself be sucked under, or actually relish the feeling of sleepiness, you'll slip and fall deeper into it. Again, on this retreat I'm pro-nap, so if you're really exhausted, take a 20-minute nap; it might be better than trying to fight through dullness and tiredness. But similarly to the urge to scratch an itch, you can allow these waves of tiredness to arise and pass away. You can notice the tendency of the mind to get sucked or pulled into the wave of sleepiness. You don't have to suppress a yawn if it's coming, but likewise, if the urge to yawn comes up and you don't allow it to propagate, you may find you're not actually as sleepy.
0:12:48Interestingly, you can also do the same thing with coughing and sneezing. A little less pleasant, but something to try. "And what is the lack of food for the arising of unarisen sloth and drowsiness, or for the growth and increase of sloth and drowsiness once it has arisen? There is the potential for effort, the potential for exertion, the potential for striving. To foster appropriate attention to them: this is the lack of food for the arising of unarisen sloth and drowsiness, or for the growth and increase of sloth and drowsiness once it has arisen." So: opening your eyes, reminding yourself what you're doing here, calling up a spirit of wholesome, joyful, well-balanced effort, rallying yourself again, establishing some urgency. There's no guarantee that this will be one of a long stretch of retreats you have the opportunity to attend. We don't know whether we're going to survive tonight. How do we want to use our time? "And what is the food for the arising of unarisen restlessness and anxiety, or for the growth and increase of restlessness and anxiety once it has arisen?
0:14:17"There is non-stillness of awareness. To foster inappropriate attention to that..." That's a little vague. Another cause, not listed here but elsewhere, for restlessness and anxiety is regret and remorse over our past actions. So for all the hindrances, but especially for this one, the best defense is living your life in a way that's blameless, so that you have no cause for regret, or to be restless or unresolved. Then there's physical restlessness. Some of us are taking quite a lot of caffeine; if you find you're jittery or buzzing and can't sit still, it might do to have a little less coffee or tea. But as with scratching an itch, if you indulge the mind's tendency to move, to be shaken, and follow it wherever it wants to go, it's like a stone dropped into a pond causing a whole bunch of ripples. Each time you attend to the moving mind, to where the ripples are going and how they're bouncing off everything, it's like slapping the water again and again, wherever the ripples have gone, just creating more and bigger waves.
0:15:59"And what is the lack of food for the arising of unarisen restlessness and anxiety, or for the growth and increase of restlessness and anxiety once it has arisen? There is stillness of awareness. To foster appropriate attention to that..." Okay, still kind of vague, but the principle is sound and true. These are feedback loops. Restlessness, with inappropriate attention fostered to it, gives way to more restlessness; anxiety, with inappropriate attention paid to it, fosters more anxiety. But if there's even a modicum of stillness, even a modicum of stability, even a small bit of contact with your meditation object, foster more attention to it: appreciate, savor, enjoy any stillness of awareness that's present. That way the mind can leap up, be glad, even collect, and be encouraged to continue on that path. "And what is the food for the arising of unarisen uncertainty, or for the growth and increase of uncertainty once it has arisen? There are phenomena that act as a foothold for uncertainty. To foster inappropriate attention to them:
0:17:15"this is the food for the arising of unarisen uncertainty, or for the growth and increase of uncertainty once it has arisen." Again, pretty general. But say you have a method you have traction with, you're plugging away at it, and you have a reasonable confidence that you can do it. If you then turn your attention to what other people are doing ("How's their meditation going? What about those books on the shelves? Are there other, better meditation techniques?"), comparing yourself to others, or to yourself at a prior moment or in an imagined future: all of these provoke a deep uncertainty and an inability to stay with the practice, to stay with whatever course you're on. "And what is the lack of food for the arising of unarisen uncertainty, or for the growth and increase of uncertainty once it has arisen? There are mental qualities that are skillful and unskillful, blameworthy and blameless, gross and refined, siding with darkness and with light. To foster appropriate attention to them: this is the lack of food for the arising of unarisen uncertainty, or for the growth and increase of uncertainty once it has arisen."
0:18:53There are skillful and wholesome mental qualities that we're all here developing, and that we have at least some acquaintance with. Remind yourself: "I've experienced some stability in practice, whatever depth that may have been. I've experienced some goodwill, some metta, some compassion, some joy, some equanimity. I know from my own experience that these are skillful and wholesome qualities. It's good; it's a good use of my time to cultivate these things, and the fact that they're able to arise at all is proof enough that I can continue to develop and cultivate them." However you can make it relevant to you, remind yourself of the factors and qualities of the path you're taking up and developing. If you find yourself wavering in uncertainty, it can help to take a little time to reflect, using the thinking mind skillfully to establish a firm resolve to move forward. And while it's not in this sutta, for establishing wholesome qualities and for the cessation of the hindrances, noble friends and good conversation are good for all of them.7
0:20:24Again, we're not talking too much here, and I leave it to you whether this skin bag is noble or not, but hopefully the talks and the opportunity to ask questions and have interviews help to resolve any uncertainty or doubt you may have about proceeding. That's all I have to say this morning. Are there any questions?
0:21:07"Okay, so let's say you have lived regretfully, and you can't just go back. I guess I'm not satisfied with the answer you gave for remorse and regret. I can't go back in time." No, you can't, not within the context of a retreat usually. But within the context of a retreat, while still maintaining the boundary and the container, you can make a resolve to make changes in the rest of your life, or to make amends if necessary. If it helps to write that stuff down and get it out, great. Also, I know for myself, when I've had majorly regretted actions I've done or habits I've engaged in, what has prevented me from accepting that and moving on is not wanting to feel the pain within myself of the harm I've caused, the harm I've caused someone else, or the harm I'm causing myself through my continued habit. So: some earnest, honest reflection on that, and a resolution to change, to make amends, to feel whatever needs to be felt, to see and look, even if you have to go through some self-disgust or feelings of shame, or "Oh, I can't believe I did that.
0:22:43Oh, no." Is that more helpful? "Yes, thank you." You're welcome. "How do you distinguish between sensual desire and the feeling of rapture in jhana?" Yeah, good question. Did that come through online? Yeah. So how do you distinguish between sensual desire as a hindrance and really savoring and enjoying and finding something beautiful and rapturous in the meditation object, which is something I've recommended doing if possible? There's a similarity in the quality of the attention. If you're captivated by a sunset or a beautiful piece of artwork or a person, it's as though you're being magnetized. So in some of the attentional dynamics they're quite similar. The difference, whether it's a hindrance or not, is more in the result. Sensual desire feeds on itself. In the form of a hindrance it just proliferates, and you get more fixation, more obsession, more grasping. Whereas working with a meditation object, through this process of settling the hindrances, your mind becomes more still, more absorbed. It doesn't stir and spin up thoughts and desires and plans and fantasies and all of these things.8
0:24:33We opened this can of worms last night: while most of the instructions here are oriented towards the renunciative mode of practice, at least for now, it's not appearances that bind, it's attachment. In experience there's nothing impure, nothing defiled, nothing inherently dangerous about any sensory event at all. But if our habit of fixating on objects of our desire, in a way that proliferates and causes fixation and obsession, is so ingrained, then turning away for a while, anyway, is a good call, so that we can come to have a wiser relationship to appearance. Is that helpful? "[unclear]" Yes: it's not an end in and of itself, and the result in the mind is greater collectedness, deepening into samadhi, and a reduction of fixation. Yes. Awesome. "[unclear] How do you work with charged, lustful imaginings? Is there a way to work with them without just repressing them, or acting on them?"
0:26:34Did that come through, the question? Yeah. So if that's arising, you can just go to (I did this when I wanted to be a monk, and it works) corpse contemplation. You can reflect on the icky, gross parts of human bodies, and suddenly it's, "Okay, no, I'm good, actually." That works. Or you can notice that when those feelings of fixation and arousal and lust arise, there's an energy coming up in the body that propagates into the space of thought and imagination. If you stay with it at the layer of embodiment, without that energy needing to go anywhere or transform into anything or fixate on anything, then it's just a flow of sensation, which can actually be enlivening, and some methods use that energy as a means to steady and stabilize the mind. So you don't need to suppress it. If it's really persistent, you can use an antidote. But (and this is harder at first for many people) you can just let that energy flow through without engaging any proliferation that may be coming up around it.
0:28:05Then it can pass through, and the mind can settle. "Would you say it's close to piti? Can you move it into...?" Yeah. If you can stay at the level of sensation and tune into it, there's an excited quality to it, and there's a pleasure in that itself. So if you can stop it there, without repressing, it can get reincorporated into the field of samadhi, staying established in the body, and it can transform in the direction of the jhanic factors. Yeah. "I have a question about the object; I'm still on the sensation at the nose. I've found myself oscillating, undecided, between two ways of attending to the sensations, which produce quite different kinds of object, and I'm wondering if one is perhaps more conducive to concentration than the other. The first is a perception of continuity, [unclear]...
0:29:36The other is not perceiving [that], and just sensation." Just sensation, yeah. It's a good one. Let me make sure I understand; I'm not sure that came through online. So there are two ways of modulating attention to the breath, which generate slightly different experiences of the breath at the nostrils. In one, you're tracking the phases of the breath: the arising sensation of the inhale, a little pause, then the exhale and the gap, and you're noticing all these different phases of the breath and the changes in the quality of sensation here. And the other (I'm not sure I fully understood): you're not noticing continuity in that way. Are you not discerning the phases of the breath, but there's a constant sensation, or...? "It feels to me as if I need to almost true my mind in a certain way to perceive continuity, or I need to put in some help. And if I let that tracking fall away, there's just sensation here.
0:30:50If I think about it, I'll notice there are changes, so I don't think it's just..." Yeah. Okay. So I think I understand: there's a way in which the tracking of the phases of the breath can fall away, and there's just sensation, without so much distinguishing of the phases. Something like that. At first, if you're working with the breath through the body or at the nostrils, it can be quite helpful, just to keep the mind on track and on task, to deliberately have touch points for the different phases of the breath, or just to notice, "Okay, there was the cessation of the inhale; okay, there was the beginning of the exhale," whether you're using mental notes or counting or not. That can be helpful. But as the concentration becomes more refined, you can let go of the part of the mind that's tracking ("This is an inhale, this is an exhale, the breath stopped, the breath started").
0:31:53As concentration deepens, you may find that it falls away naturally, and at a certain point you may just be able to tune in: "Okay, no, I'm just staying with the breath sensation, even if I'm not distinguishing in or out, beginning and end." And that is more conducive to deeper absorption. "When doing whole-body breathing, is the instruction to foreground the breath and background the body, or vice versa, or some combination? What are the general benefits of foregrounding the body versus the breath?" Foreground the breath until there's no felt distinction between the breath and the body. Eventually you perceive it as a unified field of sensation, of which the coming and going of the breath is a modulation. "Yes, thank you." "I haven't gotten into any states of very deep and stable concentration, but I've noticed that when my concentration seems better than usual, my closed-eye visual field naturally starts occupying more of my attention.
0:33:43Is it okay to just allow that to happen, or should I try to redirect my attention back to the meditation object?" What meditation object are you using? "This has happened with both the breath at the nostrils and a mantra." Yeah. All kinds of things might happen with your closed-eye visual field as concentration deepens. You might feel it's moving towards you, or that you're falling into it. It might seem to broaden or widen or brighten or dim, or all kinds of things. Stay with the meditation object, and let your visual field do whatever it's doing. If it seems to occupy a larger portion of your experience as you get more keyed into the meditation object, okay, great, let that happen. Don't push it away; don't hold on to it. If cool stuff is happening, great, but let it happen in the background. Is that clear? "Yeah." Okay. No need to try to repress it, but also don't switch the object to the visual field.
0:35:02Yeah. Okay. "I wanted to speak to [a participant] real quick. Can you hear me?" Yeah. "Okay, cool. I've also been dealing with, not regrets quite the same, but maybe just frustrations. I just had knee surgery, so I've been dealing with lots of frustration at being stuck here, the squirrels outside, whatever it is. I've always been more of a love-and-light person, and I've had a bit of trouble with that. People were always telling me, 'Oh, hold your emotions,' and I was quite confused about how to really do that. I've made a little bit of a breakthrough this week. Yesterday, say, I went through two hours of frustration leading into the meditation, and then finally found a practice that really helped me, and that might help you too. It goes with what Wystan was saying: hold it, don't push it away. Because first there's the suffering of the original frustration, and then there's the suffering of pushing it away.9
0:36:20So it's like double dukkha, you know what I mean? That's a funny phrase that stuck with me. What helped me yesterday is that I literally just took maybe 15 or 20 minutes just sitting with it: I'd say, 'I'm frustrated. I'm frustrated.' Or you'd say, 'I'm regretful. I'm regretful.' And just really holding that emotion. All emotions are like waves: they reach a peak, like Wystan was saying, and then they peak out and eventually go down. It surprised me how quickly it peaked out once I really sat with that emotion. And then I was able to go back to focusing more on the jhana meditation, because I wasn't dealing with so much of the hindrances. I don't know if that kind of practice would help you, but I just wanted to mention it, because it really helped me. I was always pushing everything away, and now I'm like, 'Oh, maybe I just needed to sit with it a little longer.'
0:37:16Just wanted to mention it." Thank you. Okay, that's it for a little bit. A 10-minute break, back here, and then a longer guided sit. Okay. For this guided session I'm going to give cues as I go along through my own practice. If my cues don't align with what's going on for you, or with the object you're working with (I'm going to guide through the breath, starting with the whole body), and you want to just carry on with what you're doing because you're in a good groove, just do that, and let my voice pass right through, in one ear and out the other.
0:39:34Feel the stability of the ground underneath, the points of contact with the floor.
0:39:57With each out-breath, as though you're sinking, getting steadier and stiller, more relaxed.
0:40:24Draw your attention up to the crown of the head, and scan down from there, over the scalp, down through the muscles of the face: forehead, temples, cheeks, down through the neck. Notice, relax and release any unnecessary tension. Moving down through the neck, shoulders, chest and back.
0:41:25Descending through the abdomen. Pause here and take an intentionally deep diaphragmatic breath, really expanding the abdomen. Exhale until there's absolutely no air left. Two more of those intentionally elongated breaths.
0:42:34And continue down through the hips and pelvis, passing through the thighs, the knees and calves, down to the tips of your toes and the soles of your feet. Drop the attention through the floor, letting the body completely soften and relax.
0:43:35And reorient to the whole space of the body, from the crown of the head to the tips of the toes and everywhere in between, front to back, side to side, sensitive to the whole body.
0:44:02Feel, on the inhale, a rise and intake of energy, some pressure and swelling in the bodily volume, not just in the abdomen but all throughout. And on the exhale, a settling, flowing down, calming. It can help to adopt a slight smile.
0:45:02With each in- and out-breath, remain sensitive through the whole body, enjoying and savoring the comfort, the relaxation, the influx of energy, whatever it is you notice.
0:47:20Any time you notice that your attention has collapsed down within the space of the body, or drifted to some sound or unrelated sensation, memory, fantasy, planning, relax and release it, and gently return, reorienting to the whole of the body and the breath moving through it.
0:49:50If any signs of concentration arise, or you're disturbed by any of the hindrances, treat them exactly the same. There's brightness in your visual field, piti beginning somewhere, or your mind is pulled and tugged by restless movement: exactly the same. Let go if your mind is drawn and pulled into them, and return and reorient to the whole space of the body.
0:50:37The breath and the whole body. It doesn't matter how often or for how long the mind may drift, or how wobbly it is on the object. Your mind and your body and all the conditions that contribute to samadhi cohere and collect in their own time. It's not a process you can force or rush. Just persistently, patiently, gently reorient and return, again and again.
0:51:44As the richness and stability of the contact with the object increase, savor and sink in and enjoy.
0:52:13Happiness feeds on happiness; concentration feeds on concentration.
0:55:13If there's a significant volume and stability of pleasant sensation or piti in your experience, it will sustain your attention if you turn to it. Let the breath go, and plunge in: immerse in and enjoy the rapture and pleasure born of seclusion from the hindrances, seclusion from disturbance.
0:56:01And for the last few minutes: if you've been using [unclear], you can broaden it out, if you haven't already. For the rest of us, take whatever momentum in samadhi you've gathered or regathered, and feel into the area in and around your heart. Generate sincere goodwill for yourself and for everyone here on this retreat.
0:56:35May we all be well. May we all be happy.
0:58:24Thank you, everyone. Those online, I'll be seeing some of you for interviews before too long; otherwise, back at 7. Practice well. Enjoy.
Sources
- The five hindrances. DN 2 Samaññaphala Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN02.html ↩
- Feeding and starving each hindrance (the passage read through the talk) SN 46:51 Ahara Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN46_51.html ↩
- “It’s not appearances that bind, but attachment” Tilopa, “Son, it is not appearances ...”, trans. Adam Pearcey (Lotsawa House) lotsawahouse.org/indian-masters/tilopa/not-appearances ↩
- The Bodhisatta’s near-starvation. MN 36 Mahasaccaka Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN36.html ↩
- Contemplating the body’s parts and the corpse. MN 10 Satipatthana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN10.html ↩
- Overeating and drowsiness; the remedies for nodding. AN 7:58 Capala Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN7_58.html ↩
- Noble friends and good conversation. SN 45:2 Upaddha Sutta (“admirable people as friends ... the whole of the holy life”) dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN45_2.html ↩
- Savoring meditative pleasure vs. sensual desire. MN 66 Latukikopama Sutta (jhana pleasure “is not to be feared”) dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN66.html ↩
- “Double dukkha”: the pain and the pushing away. SN 36:6 Sallatha Sutta (the second arrow) dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN36_6.html ↩