Sunday, November 8 · Evening
The Snake and the two viewpoints: becoming, non-becoming and the fruits of the contemplative life; Q&A; the four brahmaviharas
The talk turned from concentration to what it's for: the Snake Sutta, the two wrong viewpoints of becoming and non-becoming, and the higher fruits of the contemplative life. The Q&A went deep into awakening, emptiness and the two truths. It closed with the four brahmaviharas.
Topics and questions in this session
Talk
- 0:00:00The five recollections (AN 5:57).
- 0:04:10The Snake Sutta (Sn 1:1): sloughing off the near shore and far, as a snake its old skin.
- 0:07:24Two viewpoints (Iti 49): some hold back, delighting in becoming; some slip past, seeking non-becoming. Seeing what has come to be as it is.
- 0:18:06The fruits of the contemplative life after the jhanas (DN 2): knowledge and vision, then the ending of the effluents (0:23).
- 0:27:01The king's question to the contemplatives, retold: what's in it for you?
Q&A
- 0:29:13What are the effluents (asavas)?
- 0:34:15Should we hold off on insight and stay with jhana for now?
- 0:34:15Relative and ultimate bodhicitta during the retreat.
- 0:37:08Evenings on Twitter and Star Wars: how to become more disenchanted with all of it.
- 0:44:24A compassion mantra (Om mani padme hum) as the object.
- 0:47:12Is this Pali Canon awakening, and how does it compare with other schools?
- 0:52:02The non-duality of samsara and nirvana. Both empty, yet the path still points one way (Iti 44).
- 0:55:27Madhyamaka analysis: beautiful, and possibly a total waste of time.
- 0:58:53Does non-becoming mean more than permanent death?
- 1:04:03The recollections speak of persons and death, yet the awakened have no birth or death. The two truths (AN 2:25).
- 1:07:43When metta feels slippery and nothing seems to be happening.
- 1:11:29Pain and hunger as signals, versus craving and aversion.
- 1:16:34Insight versus concentration at this stage.
- 1:17:57"Leigh" is Leigh Brasington, not Ajahn Lee. The shaken-up bottle method (1:19).
- 1:20:25Working with the fear of death. Charnel grounds, and the body as one (MN 10).
Closing
- 1:26:22The four brahmaviharas, chanted and guided.
0:00:00I am of the nature to age; I have not gone beyond aging. Just about 24 hours have passed: one step closer to death, not getting any younger. I am of the nature to sicken; I have not gone beyond sickness. Use whatever good health I've got, for as long as I've got it, for good. I am of the nature to die; I have not gone beyond dying. Sooner or later this skin bag will cease to function, whether through old age or sickness or accident. This life is limited; we don't know how long it will last. Sabbehi me piyehi manapehi nanabhavo vinabhavo: all that is mine, beloved and pleasing, will become otherwise, will become separated from me. Possessions, relationships, ideas, things I cherish outside myself (art, music, government, whatever it is), whatever I'm attached to will become other than as it is, and at death, if not before, will be parted from me. And I am the owner of my action, heir to my action, born of my action, related to my action, and abide supported by my action. Whatever action I shall do, for good or for ill, of that I will be the heir.1
0:02:03Reflect on this one: is it true? In your own life, in your own ongoing experience, do you reap the fruit of each action you sow? Thus we should frequently recollect, and now we've recollected it. I think I've given enough jhana talk and instruction for today. If there are any more questions there'll be time for them, but I'd like to give a little more context on the larger scope of the endeavor. As time has gone on, I've come to appreciate the texts in the Sutta Nipata, a collection of mostly poems and verse in the Pali Canon; I recommend you check it out after the retreat. On that: I don't know what you at home are up to, but I've seen some people here dipping into books and reading, and while I'm not going to police that, I do recommend against it. There are only so many days when we have the conditions we have here, where, apart from the chore you've got to do, showing up, eating, meditating, and talking to me if you want to, there's really nothing you have to do other than practice.2
0:04:10And I know from my own experience that engaging in reflection mediated by the written word can often be an escape, an unhelpful escape from my immediate embodied experience. So again, I'm not going to tell anyone off or absolutely forbid it, but I really recommend using the time solely for practice. Let study and reflection and reading come later. So this is from the... [Zoom pop-up: "AI wants to record this meeting"] No, not for now, I think. Yeah, that was [a participant's]; it got auto-added. Okay, sorry about that, we can kick it out. No, the AI can hang out; it just can't record. Oh, so this is the Snake Sutta: "The monk who subdues his arisen anger, as with herbs, snake venom once it has spread, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin." Evocative imagery here. We're going to go through it, and this formula is repeated again and again. Arisen anger, or arisen obsessive [unclear] desire or aversion, is like old skin, dry and cracked, ready to come off.3
0:06:16And by meditating, by persevering with practice, we can wriggle and shake it off. There's another bit here as well: "sloughs off the near shore and far." I thought we were trying to get to the far shore. What's this about sloughing that off too? We'll get there. "The monk who has cut off passion without leaving a trace, as he would, plunging into a lake, a lotus, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk who has cut off craving without leaving a trace, drying up the swift-flowing flood, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk who has uprooted conceit without leaving a trace, as a great flood, a very weak bridge made of reeds, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk, seeing in states of becoming no essence, as he would when examining fig trees and finding no flowers, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin.
0:07:24"The monk with no inner anger, who has thus gone beyond becoming and not, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk whose discursive thoughts are dispersed, well dealt with inside without leaving a trace, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk who hasn't slipped past or held back, transcending all this objectification, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin." I'll stop there for now. This phrase, "hasn't slipped past or held back": what does it mean? There's something at the core, the heart of the Buddha's realization, the Buddhadharma, the awake truth, whatever you want to call it, that you see if you see very clearly. Most of us, most of the time, slip past or hold back. We're leaning towards or leaning away. The meaning of this slipping past or holding back is clarified in another place: "This was said by the Blessed One... Overcome by two viewpoints,4
0:08:54"some human and divine beings adhere, and some slip right past, while those with vision see. And how do some adhere?" Like glue: they get stuck. "Human and divine beings enjoy becoming, delight in becoming, are satisfied with becoming. When the Dhamma is taught for the sake of the cessation of becoming, their minds do not take to it, are not calmed by it, do not settle on it or become resolved on it. This is how some adhere." So, all this talk of the cessation of becoming, the cessation of objectification, the cessation of identification with our minds and our bodies and even our awareness: some people, when they hear talk like that, think, "Absolutely not, no thank you. I quite like what I see and hear and smell and taste and touch, in my mind and my body. I wouldn't like to let go of those things and stop identifying with them. Absolutely not. What are you talking about? That sounds like death.
0:09:56"No thanks." Or that somehow they won't be able to enjoy what they enjoy. They fall into a nihilistic misconception about what the end of becoming means. "And how do some slip right past? Some, feeling horrified, humiliated and disgusted with that very becoming, relish non-becoming." Some of us have this problem. We look at the world, at our bodies, at our minds, at the situation, and think, "Oh, you're telling me there's a way out? Oh my goodness, this can all stop? Absolutely, let's go. I'm ready." They relish non-becoming. They think there's something here that will cease: "'When this self, at the breakup of the body, after death, perishes and is destroyed and does not exist after death, that is peaceful, that is exquisite, that is sufficiency.' This is how some slip right past." These two ways of conceiving of and relating to experience, trying to hold on or trying to push away, and all the views that can develop on their basis, are two roots from the same confusion, the same dualistic confusion: attraction and fixation, or aversion and pushing away. They result in conceiving either that the end of a certain kind of becoming is tantamount to annihilation, which is frightening ("Absolutely not, I don't want to go there"), or that there's something really, truly existing here in a substantial way, and when that ceases we'll have some peace. And the Buddha says no.
0:12:19Both of those are mistaken. "And how do those with vision see? There is the case where a monk sees what's come to be as what's come to be. Seeing what's come to be as what's come to be, he practices for disenchantment with what's come to be, for dispassion towards what's come to be, for the cessation of what's come to be. This is how those with vision see." A little cryptic, perhaps. But there are the patterns of identification and craving and clinging and becoming, the cycling of thoughts and feelings and cravings and obsessions and fixations that continually reinforce the sense that here I am, there's the world, and there are some things that are good for me, which I want more of and want to hold on to, and things that are bad for me, which I've got to keep well away from, in that constant cyclic tension. By starving that process of fuel, by seeing sight and sound and sensation without indulging the fixation or the aversion, we can wean ourselves off that continual process of re-becoming, and off the confused identification that lies at its root.
0:13:41Something like jhana allows us to become so satisfied, so contented and so clear within ourselves that we're able to let go. Those of us more inclined to relishing non-becoming, to relishing the cessation of name and form, may find, "Oh goodness, I can hang out in states of formless absorption, or even the cessation of perception and feeling, lights out," and adhere to that. If ignorance isn't cut at its root, you can go through all the jhanas, you can even enter cessation, but if you emerge from those states without having cut the root, you'll continue to slip right past, or you'll continue to adhere. So jhana is a means to an end. It's not liberation; it's not awakening. But it's very expedient for bringing the mind and body into alignment and coherence, so as to see the nature of mind and body and of phenomena, and then to let go and be released. "Those, having seen what's come to be as what's come to be, and what's gone beyond what's come to be, are released in line with what's come to be, through the exhaustion of craving for becoming.
0:15:23"If they've comprehended what's come to be and are free from the craving for becoming and non-, with the non-becoming of what's come to be, monks come to no further becoming." I imagine that just rolls right off the tongue in Pali; there's some wordplay and repetition. And then back to the first text: "The monk who hasn't slipped past or held back, knowing with regard to the world..." If we're not obsessed and fixated on becoming or non-becoming, the one who hasn't slipped past or held back knows with regard to the world "that all this is unreal, and sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk who hasn't slipped past or held back, without greed, as all this is unreal, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk who hasn't slipped past or held back, without aversion, as all this is unreal, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk who hasn't slipped past or held back, without delusion, as all this is unreal, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin.
0:16:44"The monk in whom there are no obsessions, the roots of unskillfulness totally destroyed, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk in whom there's nothing born of disturbance that would lead him back to this shore sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk in whom there's nothing born of the underbrush that would act as a cause for binding him to becoming sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin. The monk who has abandoned the five hindrances, who, untroubled and de-arrowed, has crossed over doubt, sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake, its decrepit old skin." This play of attraction and aversion, and the confusion that undergirds it: the good news is that it's something we've done, and it's something we can undo if we see it clearly, and see the inconstancy, selflessness and stress of it all. If the mind sees what it's doing clearly enough, then, like the involuntary reflex of a hand grasping a hot coal, it will instantly let go.
0:18:06Release, unbinding, awakening is the inevitable result. So, picking up from this morning: "With a mind thus concentrated, purified, bright, unblemished, free from defects, pliant, malleable, steady, and attained to imperturbability" (a mind brought to a kind of peak of clarity and coherence through jhana), what do you do with it? How do you slough off the near shore and the far? How do you wriggle out of your decrepit old skin of attraction and aversion and ignorance? "You incline it and direct it to knowledge and vision, discerning that this body of mine, endowed with form, composed of the four primary elements, born from mother and father, nourished with rice and porridge" (or soup and tacos), "is subject to inconstancy, rubbing, pressing, dissolution and dispersion. This consciousness of mine likewise is supported here and bound up here. Just as if there were a beautiful beryl gem of the purest water, eight-faceted, well polished, clear, limpid, consummate in all of its aspects, and going through the middle of it was a blue, yellow, red, white or brown thread, and someone with good eyesight, taking it in their hand, were to reflect on it thus:5
0:19:48"'This is a beautiful beryl gem of the purest water, eight-faceted, well polished, clear, limpid, consummate in all of its aspects, and this, going through the middle of it, is a blue, yellow, red, white or brown thread.' In the same way, with your mind thus concentrated, purified, bright, unblemished, free from defects, pliant, malleable, steady, and attained to imperturbability, you direct and incline it to knowledge and vision, discerning that this body of mine is endowed with form, composed of the four primary elements, born from mother and father, nourished with rice and porridge, subject to inconstancy, rubbing, pressing, dissolution and dispersion, and this consciousness of mine is supported here and bound up here. This is a fruit of the contemplative life, visible here and now, more excellent than the previous ones and more sublime." If you do go back and read the Pali literature, you'll find many more, and much more varied and rich, analogies and similes describing the process of insight, much more so than the formulaic presentation you'll find in a lot of commentaries or modern sources.
0:21:04It's really an organic process, one that has shared features across people, because we're not that different as the mammals we are. Still, the knowledge and release that is awakening comes through your own discernment, your own vision, and it's an organic process arising from the clarity of a clear, calm, collected mind. There are themes you can turn to that are liable to provoke insight, and we'll talk a little more about that towards the end of the retreat. If you're able to see, in any moment (and it only takes a single moment), completely and thoroughly, all the way through, side to side, top to bottom, front to back, if you're able to see through one moment of your experience in its entirety, then you'll know the nature of all experience. If you know the nature of your mind, if you see emptiness, see all the way through it at least once, then you won't be in any doubt any longer. And there are some other things you can do with a mind made malleable and pliant.
0:23:00There's talk here in this sutta of the mind-made body and other supernormal powers. You can create another body; some people have this capacity. You can trigger an out-of-body experience and go wandering through realms and have visionary experiences, if that's of interest to you. I'm not going to encourage that on this retreat, and you usually have to be really concentrated for it to work, unless you have a knack for it. But neat: you can do that. Then the other supernormal powers; some people find these things fascinating. Again, I really recommend just going gunning for insight. This other stuff you can do on your own time. And then the ending of the effluents (the cankers, the influxes; there are different translations), one way of describing awakening that's all throughout the canon: "With the mind thus concentrated, purified, bright, unblemished, free from defects, pliant, malleable, steady, attained to imperturbability, you direct and incline it to the knowledge of the ending of the effluents, discerning, as it has come to be" (there's that phrase again),
0:24:17"'This is dukkha'" (stress, suffering, dis-ease) "'this is the origination of dukkha.'" Not through conceptually mediated analysis, but through direct sensory encounter, you see clearly and without doubt the mechanics of stress, of tension, of dis-ease, of the dualistic bifurcation that sets up existence and non-existence and the craving for either side of that polarity. You see that without doubt. "'This is the origination of dukkha. This is the cessation of dukkha. This is the way leading to the cessation of dukkha. These are the effluents. This is the origination of effluents. This is the cessation of effluents. This is the way leading to the cessation of effluents.' Your heart, thus knowing, thus seeing..." I like that it talks about the heart here. It's as much something you feel through your whole embodied existence as something you see or know. It's not non-cognitive, but it is an embodied knowing that permeates the whole of your being. "Your heart, thus knowing, thus seeing, is released from the effluent of sensuality, the effluent of becoming, the effluent of ignorance.
0:25:55"With release, there is the knowledge, 'Released.' You discern that 'Birth has ended, the holy life fulfilled, the task done. There is nothing further for this world.' Just as if there were a pool of water in a mountain glen, clear, limpid and unsullied, where someone with good eyesight standing on the bank could see shells, gravel and pebbles, and also shoals of fish swimming about and resting, and it would occur to them, 'This pool of water is clear, limpid and unsullied. Here are these shells, gravel and pebbles, and also these shoals of fish swimming about and resting'; in the same way, with your mind thus concentrated, purified, bright, unblemished, free from defects, pliant, malleable, steady and attained to imperturbability, the monk directs and inclines it to the knowledge of the ending of the effluents. This, too, is a fruit of the contemplative life, visible here and now, more excellent than the previous ones and more sublime. And as for another visible fruit of the contemplative life, higher and more sublime than this, there is none." This is part of a sutta called the Samaññaphala Sutta, The Fruits of the Contemplative Life, where the Buddha is in dialogue with a king, someone who has everything the world can offer.
0:27:01The king wants to know: "Okay, you homeless guys in the woods outside my palace, what are you up to? Are you feeling any good? Pitch me." The Buddha goes through a really thorough rendition, from the very basic fruits of living a life that's ethical and upright and free from disturbance and involvement in unpleasant things, all the way to final release and complete awakening. It's a good one. Sometimes, when I reference the canon, on or off retreat, it can feel distant, not that relevant to our current circumstances or your own life. I hope that in my commentary I'm able to bridge a little of that gap, but I promise that what's being talked about here is as close to you as your own skin; in fact, closer. Though this comes from 2,500 years ago, the condition and nature of human life, and of consciousness and its mechanics, haven't changed that much in 2,500 years. I share it in the hope that it's as inspiring to you as it has been to me, and maybe as a jumping-off point for reflection and questions.
0:29:13I think that's all I had to say this evening. I'll open it to questions now; I just wanted to keep the long view and the goal in mind. If you're not undertaking this as part of a larger project, you may just be here because you want to gain some facility with the jhanas, and that's great. If you are undertaking this as part of a larger project of waking up, then it's good to keep the goal in mind and understand that it is possible, it's doable, and it's not far. Okay, I wasn't sure whose hand went up first. [Participant]. "Yeah, two questions. One: in the sutta it said 'inconstancy of the effluents' or something, and I'm struggling to understand what that refers to." It said a lot of things. Inconstancy was in there: impermanence. "And then effluents?" No, a different word. The Pali, if I'm remembering right, is asava. It doesn't show up much in most modern texts, but it's actually all over the canon. It's a bit of an interesting word. It means outflow; "effluent" is a funny English word, but it means something flowing out.
0:31:01One way of interpreting it: at the time of the Buddha there seems to have been a way of making alcohol where you would ferment fruits, and flowing out of them would be this intoxicating substance. That's a very natural reading of what these things are. We get drunk, intoxicated into a deeper state of ignorance, when we engage on the basis of ignorance with sensuality, with states of becoming. With the cessation of the effluents, we're no longer intoxicated. Leigh likes to translate them as "intoxicants" for that reason, which isn't a literal translation, but it may be closer to what was actually meant. "That's helpful. The second one: you said deep jhanic absorption doesn't necessarily lead to insight. I'm curious, if the intention is towards insight, is there any question or something you can drop in when you're in a jhanic state to move in that direction?" There are lots of things you can do, and I'll talk more about this in a couple of nights. If your mind is really, truly, deeply absorbed, there isn't the maneuverability to do analysis, which is why in the later tradition there can be a split between shamatha and vipassana.
0:32:40If you really go hard into shamatha, there's no ability to analyze or comprehend in that moment of absorption. But most of us aren't going to be getting that absorbed. I'll talk more about it when I get to it. You can take up, in Rob's phrasing, insight ways of looking. You can take the themes of impermanence and not-self and actually look at the jhanic factors themselves. In the midst of the first, second, third or fourth jhana, you can take them up and realize, "Whoa, okay, even this incredible, sublime state is actually constantly changing. Any clinging to it, any craving for it, is unsatisfactory." Because the mind is so well prepared, malleable and pliant, it doesn't mind letting go and opening so much. You can see that these sublime states likewise aren't me or mine; they're dependently arisen, and they're empty of any essence. So you can apply that to the state itself while you're in it, if it's not too absorbed. Or you can come out slightly into a shallower absorption and conduct insight from there.6
0:34:15"Would you recommend that at this stage of the retreat we not do insight and just do jhana for a few more days?" Yes. While I'm keeping the long view and the goal in mind here, what I actually recommend is to just plow away and deepen into concentration, honestly even for the whole of this retreat, and otherwise let insight arise as it will. On the... not the second-to-last night, the third-to-last night, I'll talk in more detail about insight practices, and on the second-to-last night I'll go into more direct, non-dual, nature-of-mind-type insight pointing. But until then, even as I'm trying to keep the goal in mind here, and hopefully motivate you all, just stay with the practice of deepening into samadhi. "Could you talk more about the difference between relative and absolute [bodhicitta] and how to use it or relate to it during the retreat? Do we just set an intention in the evening? Do we keep it in mind all the time?"
0:35:39Yeah. For the folks online, are you able to hear the questions? Yeah? Okay. So, the relative and absolute bodhicitta I mentioned on the first night. As a way to whip up your motivation and enthusiasm for practice, at the beginning of a formal session you can sincerely aspire to awakening. Refresh it; set the intention. It could just be something heartfelt; it doesn't have to be verbal. But if it helps, you can refresh the intention with a phrase: "May I attain awakening for the benefit of all beings," something like that. There are more elaborate ways of doing it. And at the conclusion of every formal session, you can dedicate any merit to the benefit of all. That's a very simple way to refresh it and keep it going. Then ultimate bodhicitta, as I pointed to at the beginning, is from a certain perspective the motivating force behind all of this. The sensitivity of the heart to its own suffering is what draws in the curiosity and the investigation: "Wait a second. Ouch.
0:37:08What's going on here?" That sensitivity, and the response that draws someone into practice, is itself, from a certain perspective, a function of compassion, of the awake mind noticing a misalignment and beginning to clear and bring itself back into knowledge and vision. Is that helpful? Good. If it's confusing, that's fine too. Is that helpful? "Yeah. I'm practicing here at home, and there are plenty of gross distractions to draw me out of it. I'm trying to figure out the question here. I had a really peaceful first half of the day. My attention got really stable on the breath. I experienced a peace in my mind that I'm so not used to experiencing. But still, in the second half, as the evening rolled in, I found myself on Twitter. I found myself watching Star Wars. So what's the question? The question is: how can I get more disenchanted with all of this? How can I be more enchanted by the very subtle beauty I experienced earlier than by the very gross and easy-to-rest-in distractions of the evening?"
0:39:08Thank you for the question, and for your honesty. Actually, after this, go back on Twitter, start scrolling, and feel in your body what it feels like. Make it a deliberate practice: in your throat, in your heart, in your gut. Notice what it does to your attention, and let that be the practice. I think I said at the beginning that genuine renunciation, the kind that lasts, is effortless. It's like feeling the hot coal in your grasp, and then you're ready to let it go. The reason we keep doing things that are bad for us, that hurt and contribute to our dis-ease, the reason we perpetuate cyclic behaviors we don't reflectively endorse, is a lack of awareness in that habit pattern. An ineffective way to deal with it is: "Motherfucker, I did it again," and then getting into contortions of shame and recrimination and anger and all these kinds of compensations. Much more effective is to deliberately bring awareness to the pattern in the moment. Notice how it feels; notice what it... notice the texture.
0:40:48Sound good? "Yeah, thank you." Be open and honest and curious. Don't come in with, "Okay, I'm going to see this, and it's going to suck, and I'm going to hate it, and I'm never going to do it again." Actually look at it, and see what's good about it too. See where the bait is. Feel the bait and how tasty it is, and then also notice the hook, so that you know through direct experience what it is that's grabbing you there and how it feels, and then see what happens. "I'll do my best, Captain." That actually is the highest fruit of the contemplative life, visible here and now: not scrolling on social media. One I unfortunately haven't mastered, I'm sad to say. "Do you have any suggestions for... sometimes when I'm using a visual object I'm locked in, but it's not really... maybe I'm a bit zonked out or something. It's not very vivid. I don't know how to describe it, except a bit zonked out on the object.
0:42:32Does that make sense? How do I cultivate more vividness with it?" When you say zonked out, do you mean spacey or hazy, or what? Distant from it? "Yeah. I don't really have tunnel vision on it, but it's just a bit... it's not really vivid; there's just nothing going on." Yeah. With an external object, a visual focus (this may be what's going on, or it may not), as with the breath, we can just let our attention settle on it, and then most of our mind is actually drifty and hazy, even if our eyes aren't moving. Our attention is totally out to lunch. When you notice that you're zonked out, what do you do? What have you tried? "I think I've tried a bit of body scan to bring things back together. It doesn't quite feel like I'm looking at it while my mind is elsewhere. It's more like I'm looking at it and nothing else is online, but not in a way that's cultivating any general... It's just a bit spacey.
0:44:24It might sound stupid, but try blinking a couple of times, taking a deep breath in and out, looking around the room, and then refocusing on the object. That's the best I've got as a first guess. You might just need a refresher. I'm not sure what the duration of your sessions is, but you can get into a kind of, I don't know, concentration fatigue. If you're not used to doing extended sessions, you might be better served by doing more, shorter sessions. If you find you're zonking out more towards the back half of a session, maybe break the time you've set aside into two shorter sessions with a refresh in between. And when you notice you're zonked out, do smaller refreshes, shaking things off. "Thanks." "Earlier today we were talking about using a mantra as a meditation object, and you suggested one that had to do with compassion, and mentioned that it's best not to focus just on the auditory component, but also to be reflecting on compassion.
0:45:52I was wondering to what extent that's similar to metta practice. Should I be thinking about one particular being I'm directing compassion toward, or is it more abstract than that?" Yeah. For context, [this participant] finds it easier to focus on something auditory. We've got some people working with visual objects, even though what I've mostly presented so far has been the breath and metta. Any object will do. If you're working with a mantra, this one, Om mani padme hum, the mantra of Avalokiteshvara, the bodhisattva of compassion, there are many ways to work with it. There's an aspect of the practice where you just focus on the sound and its reverb within your experience, and it might be best at this point to focus mostly on that. But in the heart, it's very much like metta practice: one of the brahmaviharas is compassion. So if you can have a heartfelt sense of compassion radiating out from the heart as you work with the mantra, great. In some versions of this practice, you also imagine a visual component:
0:47:12there's a moon disk in your heart, the syllables of the mantra are rotating on it, and rays of light are bursting out from them to all beings, spreading and radiating compassion. That might be a bit too busy. So what I'd recommend for now... well, a clarifying question: can you touch into a felt sense of compassion in here? "Not on demand, consistently." Then generate the intention for compassion, and that could just be an abstract sense. It could be repeating the phrase "May all beings be free from suffering" once, then going into the mantra. At some point you may start to feel compassion arising, and in that case you can incorporate it as part of the feeling of the mantra as you recite it internally. But for now I'd just focus more on the sound, and not fall into too much conceptual reflection on it. "Sounds good." "I have so many really deep questions about this notion of what awakening is or can be. Just so I get the frame right: this is Theravada, Pali Canon awakening?"
0:48:44Yeah. Okay, we're opening a can of worms here. Hot take, despite what doctrinaire partisans of the different schools that have emerged in the history of the Dharma say: I don't think the awakening talked about in the Pali Canon is different from what folks in Zen or Dzogchen or Mahamudra or Vajrayana are talking about. There's a difference in method and a difference in expression. I don't think the historical Buddha would be well pleased with tantrikas. But the essential core (the realization of emptiness, the realization of selflessness, and the collapse of the bifurcated subject-object relationship and of the craving that arises in dependence on it) is, from my own practice and my own study, conserved across all Buddhist traditions, and it's at the heart of what awakening is. Because I'm mostly teaching early Buddhist methods here, though ensconced within a more non-dual, later Buddhist view, don't let the language trip you up too much. "Yeah. So, understanding the mechanisms: what I gather is that basically, letting go of desire opens you up to something way better than the craving and the suffering and the desire.
0:50:35So then we're using jhana as a tool to let go of worldly, out-there, or emotional, whatever, desire. Is that correct? This is the tool we're using?" Yeah. Within the early Buddhist path of practice, jhana is a mechanism. Most of us are so habituated to this dualistic way of seeing, where sense objects are something external to us that we crave and cling to, and on that basis become and fashion identities for ourselves over and over again, that the path is one of renunciation and disengagement. And what makes that not totally miserable is: wait a second, when you disengage, when you drop engagement with your ordinary sensory environment, you can withdraw the senses into these sublime states of absorption, which in terms of raw hedonic tone far surpass any ordinary dualistic mode of sensory engagement, and which allow you to release the craving and clinging to sense objects, and the identity we form on the basis of that push and pull.
0:52:02So yes, it's a process of weaning you off the addiction to sensory objects, and then releasing even that more refined pleasure for something beyond pleasure and pain and beyond the confines of identity. Later Buddhist tradition takes for granted the emptiness of the senses and the absence of a duality of subject and object, and has more sensorially engaged methods for attaining the same realization of emptiness, which results in different standards of conduct. "I'm so curious, and I know it's a whole big thing we can talk about later, but then there's the whole non-duality of awakening and, I guess you could say, delusion, or samsara and nirvana." I'll just put this out there: what later Buddhist tradition is really reacting against is (I'm going to use some seminar words here) a reified ontology of bondage and liberation, where samsara is something ontologically real, like a realm, made up, in Abhidhamma terms, of real dhammas,
0:53:52and nibbana, or nirvana, is some separate realm or domain or phenomenon or property that's radically ontologically distinct. If you hold that view, it's consequential for practice. In those terms you're liable to slip right past, to relish non-becoming, to delight in non-becoming, to think that nirvana only happens at the breakup of these aggregates and the cessation of something really existing. No: that's falling to one side of the polarity. If that were the case... but the Buddha, upon attaining full awakening, was cognizant and conscious, walking around teaching for 45 years and enjoying the peace of nirvana, not just when he entered the cessation of perception and feeling. Nirvana in the suttas isn't given a separate ontological status, and samsara is not a place. It's a way we mistake experience and bind ourselves up in it. "So the emphasis is that they're both empty states that are dependently arisen, and thus we still strive for the nirvanic, I guess, side of that polarity?"7
0:55:27Sure. But then it's tricky. But yes: there's no ontological difference, no ultimate ontological difference, between samsara and nirvana. There's no heaven we're trying to get to; nirvana is not a heaven for our hearts. But there is a massive difference between experiencing samsara and experiencing nirvana. Even though it's not a radically different mode of being, it is a radically different way of experiencing. "Okay. Thank you so much. I'm sorry." No, it's a good question. Good question. "What's your opinion on Madhyamaka analytical approaches to this? Did that come through?" Yeah: Madhyamaka analytical approaches. So, Madhyamaka, the middle way. All Buddhist schools claim to be the middle way, but Madhyamaka literally means that, and it comes from Nagarjuna, a second-century Indian philosopher and, as far as anyone can tell at this historical distance, quite a realized being. His seminal text is the Mulamadhyamakakarika, the Root Verses on the Middle Way.8
0:57:18An excellent text, and part of what drew me onto the path. Madhyamaka is beautiful, and it can be a total waste of time. Styles of meditation did develop where, from a state of shamatha (quite consolidated shamatha, maybe not to the level of jhana, but with your mind well collected and cohered and concentrated), you bring in more conceptually mediated reflections and bring them to bear on your experience. For some people that can alter the mode of seeing in the moment and release craving and clinging, using the power of the analytical mind and of concepts to break through to, in the technical language, a non-conceptual, direct and valid cognition of emptiness. To be quite honest, I don't know that it works very well for the vast majority of people. Maybe this is just my bias, in the Tibetan Buddhist scheme, from the lineages I've engaged: my Kagyu and Nyingma bias showing, if those words mean anything to anybody. But it hasn't formed a major part of my own path, and I honestly don't know many people for whom it has proved critical.
0:58:53I know Rob was quite a fan and interested in it, but in the Western Dharma sphere that I'm aware of, unless someone is in the Gelugpa school, where it's most prized, I don't see many people taking it up. So if you want to work more on that, and hear an argument for its utility, I'd recommend you find a learned and realized Gelugpa geshe who could help you. I'm not that guy. I love Madhyamaka (it was really crucial in my formation), but I go for the direct yogic methods, the non-conceptual stuff. That's my advice. Yeah. Bad thinking. [Participant], you had your hand up first. You're muted. "Non-becoming: is it meant to be read as something, a range of things, beyond just permanent death? Could you expand? I don't think I understood a word of that sutta. You kept saying you want to keep the long goal in mind, but I don't understand what that sutta said about the long goal. It referenced becoming and not becoming.
1:00:32I have no idea what becoming means, so I wanted to start with not becoming, because I get that it means something like: okay, life is terrible, so death would be a nice way out of this, or meditating my way into some state of..." Yeah, or cessation or whatever. "But does it mean something besides just death, and 'Okay, I'm ready, I would delight in death'?" Yes, it does. That would be falling to the annihilationist extreme here. That would be slipping past (I'm remembering how it's ordered here): feeling horror and disgust at becoming, one relishes non-becoming, and conceives of nirvana as a kind of eternal death. It might seem like splitting hairs, but it's really not. If your conception of liberation is that there's some existing being here that at some point will cease, and that's the release from suffering, that's entirely mistaken. "Okay, let me drop that and ask from another angle. How does this square with the five remembrances: I'm going to die, I'm going to be parted from everything I love?
1:02:15That motivates practice, but this seems to be saying the opposite. I am going to die; I am going to be separated from everything I love. Is it just leveraging my own mistaken view of life? You see my confusion, right?" Yeah, 100%. And yes, basically: the five remembrances are the stick; awakening is the carrot. For one who sees the aggregates in terms of a self, as long as that's true, yes, you're going to die, you're going to get old, you're going to get sick, and you're going to be parted from everything you cherish and hold dear, and that's going to suck. But (this is going to be a paraphrase) a sage at peace, who doesn't suppose a self in any of the aggregates, is not born, does not age, does not sicken, does not die. Because the conception, and more than that, the moment-to-moment perception, of there being some existing being here that was born, that is aging, that will get sick, that will die, is uprooted, even in the midst of aging, sickness and death. The root of that misperception of self is uprooted, and that's the freedom. And within the literal cosmological picture of early Buddhism, yes, that also leads to a cessation of literal rebirth on a cosmological scale.9
1:04:03I'm less concerned with that, and if you are concerned with it, you can talk to me afterwards. "Yeah, that makes some sense to me. I'm curious; I've never read the actual sutta the five remembrances come from. Does that sutta admit of that interpretation? Does it say something like, 'This is what I'm going to give you ignorant people to practice with, so you can realize that these five remembrances are nonsense'?" I don't know if that's there in the sutta they come from, but there are a number of places where the Buddha plainly states that when dealing with conventions he speaks conventionally. As one must, to be understood and to communicate: the grammatical structure of language actually requires that we speak in a way that isn't in accord with how things are, because things aren't. And this is how the later doctrine of the two truths developed, because the people receiving this canon thought: "Okay, in some places he seems to talk very clearly about persons and birth and aging and sickness and death, and then he says that for one who's realized there is no birth or sickness or old age or death. That's slightly contradictory. How do you make sense of this interpretive quandary?"10
1:05:42The hermeneutical problems are terrible. Okay, so we have two categories: discourses of definitive meaning and discourses of provisional meaning. Then some people harden that into ultimate dhammas and provisional dhammas, and it just gets really ontologically messy and confused. Don't go there; it bites. Is that clarifying? You're muted again. "Yes. It sounds like a good interpretation. It would be nice if, when the Buddha or his disciples were speaking, they'd say, 'Here's a conventional teaching.' When I go on Twitter, I say things ironically 80% of the time and earnestly 20% of the time, and then I'm like, 'Why did you take that ironically?' That's my complaint, but I get it. Thank you." Okay, I'll let the Buddha know you have some notes. No, but this is something that's lost. These were all oral teachings, and the best teachings are all oral, because they're given at a particular time and place to a certain set of people, or even to one person, with the speaker sensitive to the condition of the listener and pitching whatever is being communicated to what they can discern of that person's understanding, how it will be received, what they have to work with. So of course a lot gets lost, not only in translation but because of that decontextualization.11
1:07:43And commentators did make the effort, exactly as you say: "Okay, this wasn't so clear; let's neaten it up." And then you get the Abhidhamma. I'm not sure who had their hand up first; I think it might have been [a participant]. Okay, both of you. "I'm curious what you'd say about times on retreat when, working with metta, the sense of metta is very slippery, not really coming into focus, and the mind is unruly, and the idea can arise that absolutely nothing is getting accomplished here. I could tell a story about what is actually getting accomplished, but in the middle of it that can be tricky. So I'm curious what you'd say about those times on retreat." Yeah. When you find yourself in that moment where you're just rowing and rowing, and it seems there's a current you're rowing against and you can't gain ground, here's a suggestion: open your eyes if they're closed, touch the floor, take 10 seconds.
1:09:47That feeling of stagnation has taken hold and propagated into thought. There's a lack of contact with the situation, and if you can re-establish it very practically by reorienting to where you are in time and space, you can be reassured. Where am I? I'm on retreat. What am I doing? I'm meditating. Why am I doing it? For my long-term welfare and happiness, and for the welfare and happiness of other beings. Is it going according to my wristwatch? Who cares? And you can refresh and gladden the mind with wholesome aspiration, because I know that feeling well: "Oh my God, fucking breath. Here we go. Just keep... yep. Okay. It's stale, boring dinner food. I had bliss an hour ago, a little bit. Can we come back? I'm tired. When is this retreat going to be over?" Or even worse (and this is just my pathology): on retreat I get bored and start thinking about other retreats I can go on. "Okay, you get it. When meditating, I think of medicine retreats, but in medicine, I think I should really be meditating."
1:11:29Yeah, the tangled webs we weave. Shake yourself out of it. Refresh yourself: if it's not one of the group periods, change your posture, go for a walk, refresh your aspiration, bring wholesome thoughts to mind, recollection of the Buddha, or some similar inspiring practice, to re-establish faith and confidence and orientation. All these things can be very helpful. Enough for now? "So there is something to do about that state, rather than [unclear]." Yeah. "Thank you." You're welcome. "I'm wondering if you can help me differentiate clinging and aversion from pain and desire. If I have pain, it's signaling that I should shift my body when I'm in posture. How do I respect that without being averse to it? Or if I'm hungry and drawn towards food, how do I eat without [unclear]?" Well, there's the uncomfortable physical sensation, and then there's everything the mind does in reaction to it. If your mindfulness is sharp enough, you can see that these are two things, not one.
1:13:15Likewise with sensations of hunger. There's nothing wrong with sensations of hunger. There's nothing wrong with pain signaling; it's useful. It's telling you, "Hey, embodied being, do something different; this isn't good for you." And responding to it isn't wrong either. Taking your hand off a hot stove, feeding yourself: that's not clinging or desire in a bad way. You can tell the difference both by the sharpness of mindfulness (you can see clearly, like dominoes, what's the primary sensation and what's the reaction to it) and by whether it persists and proliferates in thought and yearning, following on in a chain. Persisting pain, when not resisted, doesn't occupy a great percentage of your field of awareness. Likewise with a hunger sensation: if it seems to blow up, and you fasten on it, and a bunch of thoughts begin to spark and chain, then there's some clinging and craving involved. Or, likewise with pain, the same process in the opposite direction.
1:15:08But that is released naturally. You can't say to a reaction to pain that wants the pain to go away, "Okay, stop wanting it to stop," by force of will; then you get the same thing. "Can you connect that to becoming? There's the becoming that's just sustaining my body and letting all this continue, and then there's the becoming that's something else." Yeah. Where the liberation occurs is on the level of phenomenology. The Buddha continued to eat. Leigh likes this point: even though he wasn't confused by reification within his perception, he didn't confuse his hand for a spoon; he didn't start munching his hand. Perception continued to work just fine. But there was no becoming in the sense of objectifying some sensory phenomenon as a concrete, substantial thing that I then have a polarized, attractive or aversive relationship to, which creates me as a subject split between inside and out, pulling or pushing on experience.
1:16:34That's the becoming that comes to an end, not the mammal. "So it's still seeing [unclear], but seeing it as empty." "I want to clarify what you were saying earlier about insight and concentration. You were talking about focusing on concentration in the body. Were you saying that we shouldn't also be using insight, or just that we shouldn't use insight in a jhanic state yet? Or were you saying we should really focus on just access concentration first, right now?" My recommendation is just to focus on access concentration, samadhi, and jhana if that's accessible. I have a sense of where the question is coming from, because of the interview earlier today. Some of us here have experience with Rob Burbea's methods, where you can weave in some insight: if you have an insight, you can incorporate it into the practice. Say you find that if you drop in viewing your hindrances as not-self, the hindrances subside a bit and you're able to collect the mind more readily.
1:17:57Great. Technically you're dropping in insight, or at least invoking it, and that may help the development of concentration. I just wouldn't suggest spending a lot of time on it at this point. If you're using drops of insight, invoking it to help develop concentration, great; if that's working for you, do it. But keep your focus on concentration. "Okay. So if some insight brings more samadhi, that's a good thing, but I shouldn't let my brain run with loops of more and more insight; I should keep focusing on the concentration. I had another question too. When you talk about Leigh, are you talking about Ajahn Lee?" Oh, no. Who are you talking about? That is how you say his name: Ajahn Lee Dhammadharo, one of Thanissaro Bhikkhu's teachers. Great stuff from him. But no, I'm talking about Leigh Brasington. "Yeah. Okay. And yesterday you mentioned some method involving a bottle being shaken up.
1:19:06I'd like a little more detail about what you meant by that. My understanding was that Rob's method is a bit more like a positive feedback loop, where you keep focusing on the good feeling and let it fill you, and that with the shaken-up bottle you keep the concentration on the breath and let it build on its own. But I'm not sure I understood it quite right. What exactly do you mean, and what's the difference between the methods?" Well, they both set up feedback loops. The major difference is that Leigh, the way he teaches, wants you to develop stronger concentration before you turn your attention to the jhanic factors, so that when you do, a more rapid and powerful feedback loop happens. If you really stay with access concentration for a while, the jhanic factors can get very strong in the background while you're still in access concentration, and it's almost as though all the energy you've accumulated in access concentration gets transferred into the factors all at once, and they can erupt in a more dramatic fashion.
1:20:25If you have the experience, you'll see why it's apropos: like shaking up a Coke bottle, or champagne, and it pops off. "Okay. Cool. That helps a lot." Okay, one last question (or not), and then we'll take a little break, meditate, and go to bed. "Would you say that the path is to overturn the fear of death? And if so, are there certain facets of the path that work on it more directly?" I would say yes. One of my favorite pithy lines, from Hakuin, a nice short poem: "Young people of the world, if you fear death, die while still young, and you'll never have to die again." That refers to the great death, the death of the subject. So yes, it does lead to the absence of the fear of death, because you see that there isn't some thing here. There isn't someone who was born or will die, literally. What a load off. Working directly with mindfulness of death, if fear of death is something that bothers you: directly confronting it, meditating on death in an imaginative sense.
1:22:17At the time of the Buddha it was also recommended to go to a charnel ground and meditate with corpses. That's a little intense. But if you really want to work directly with the fear of death, that does get at the core. From an evolutionary perspective, why do we have this instilled sense that here I am, this separate thing that needs to maintain homeostasis and reproduce? There are evolutionary reasons why it's adaptive for biological organisms like us to feel that there's something in here that I have to protect at all costs. Then you come directly up against death and drop the resistance, and you see... Again, this is going to be a bit of a paraphrase (I think this might be [unclear]; forgive me for not remembering the reference): "When you awaken, you will see what a worthless notion life and death truly is." "Wait, one more question. On that note, do you know the nearest charnel ground from here?" Yeah: you're in it.12
1:24:06This whole world is a charnel ground. Your own body, constantly living and dying, arising and passing away. How many bacteria in your mouth just died? You don't have to go far. Okay, let's make it quick: five minutes, come back, and we'll meditate. Okay. I'll open with a little chanting, and then we'll move into a short period here to end the day. "Now thus make the four boundless qualities shine forth. I will abide pervading one quarter with a heart imbued with loving-kindness; likewise the second, likewise the third, likewise the fourth; so above and below, around and everywhere, and to all as to myself. I will abide pervading the all-encompassing world with a heart imbued with loving-kindness, abundant, exalted, immeasurable, without hostility and without ill will. I will abide pervading one quarter with a heart imbued with compassion; likewise the second, likewise the third, likewise the fourth; so above and below, around and everywhere, and to all as to myself. I will abide pervading the all-encompassing world with a heart imbued with compassion, abundant, exalted, immeasurable, without hostility and without ill will.13
1:26:22"I will abide pervading one quarter with a heart imbued with gladness; likewise the second, likewise the third, likewise the fourth; so above and below, around and everywhere, and to all as to myself. I will abide pervading the all-encompassing world with a heart imbued with gladness, abundant, exalted, immeasurable, without hostility and without ill will. I will abide pervading one quarter with a heart imbued with equanimity; likewise the second, likewise the third, likewise the fourth; so above and below, around and everywhere, and to all as to myself. I will abide pervading the all-encompassing world with a heart imbued with equanimity, abundant, exalted, immeasurable, without hostility and without ill will." There are all four: the brahmaviharas, the divine abidings, the "boundless qualities," as the translation in the chant has it. We're all familiar with metta by now, or can have some sense of it at least. So touch into that quality in the heart if it's available. Intend for it to arise; use a phrase or an image, some support, as needed; and imagine it, and feel it if possible, spreading outwards, unbounded, immeasurable, embracing you, embracing this room, spreading out and blanketing the city of Boulder, or wherever you are online, opening up and embracing the entire world and all its inhabitants.
1:28:56May you be happy. May you be well.
1:30:14Let that feeling of goodwill permeate your whole body and the space around you, to all as to yourself. May we all be happy. May we all be well.
1:31:51When you feel your own suffering, it doesn't take much to want to relieve it. It's a natural impulse arising from care and concern for your own well-being. Likewise, when you see someone in distress, in need of help (a lost child, a grieving friend), the impulse naturally arises in the heart to help, to relieve suffering wherever it is. With that intention also radiating from the heart: may you be free from suffering. May we all be free from suffering.
1:33:07Feel your own way into it. For me, the embodied felt sense of compassion is a little cooler than the warmth of goodwill in metta, like a soothing balm. But find your own way in.
1:34:59May all beings be free from suffering. May all beings be safe.
1:38:23And then sympathetic joy, mudita. When a friend lights up with happiness, you have a fellow feeling for it; likewise, spontaneously, naturally, their joy is your joy. When a baby laughs or smiles, there's a feeling in you; or when a golden retriever runs up wagging its tail, so happy to see you.
1:39:23Let your joy and others' joy be boundless. People on this retreat taking time out of their lives to cultivate wholesome, skillful qualities of mind and heart: how wonderful, how amazing that we have this opportunity.
1:40:23All over the world at this very moment, there are people rejoicing, having the best moment of their day, of their week, right now. Someone's watching a sunset somewhere, or a sunrise.
1:41:15Let others' joy be your own.
1:43:02And upekkha, equanimity: maybe even an imperturbable peace and stillness, knowing that everything has come to be due to causes and conditions, due to the force of intention and all the other natural causes, and reflecting on the scope of our influence and our action. There's so much we hang on to that we can let go of, that we don't need to be concerned over, towards which we can have a kind of dispassion, an evenness with regard to circumstances entirely out of our control. So the felt sense can be one of stillness, of calm, even of peace.
1:46:04Amen.
1:48:04All right, good night, everyone. Sleep well. See you tomorrow.
Sources
- The five recollections (Pali line on separation from all that is dear) AN 5:57 Upajjhatthana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN5_57.html ↩
- The Sutta Nipata. Thanissaro’s complete translation, dhammatalks.org. dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/StNp/ ↩
- “Sloughs off the near shore and far, as a snake its decrepit old skin” Sn 1:1 Uraga Sutta (The Snake) dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/StNp/StNp1_1.html ↩
- “Overcome by two viewpoints”: adhering, slipping past, and those with vision. Iti 49 Ditthigata Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/Iti/iti49.html ↩
- Knowledge and vision; the beryl gem; the mind-made body; the ending of the effluents; the mountain pool. DN 2 Samaññaphala Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN02.html ↩
- “Ways of looking” Rob Burbea, Seeing That Frees (Hermes Amara, 2014) ↩
- The Buddha teaching for 45 years having realized nirvana. Iti 44 (unbinding with fuel remaining and with no fuel remaining) dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/Iti/iti44.html ↩
- Nagarjuna and the Root Verses on the Middle Way. Mulamadhyamakakarika, e.g. trans. Jay Garfield, The Fundamental Wisdom of the Middle Way (Oxford, 1995) ↩
- “A sage at peace ... is not born, does not age, does not die” MN 140 Dhatuvibhanga Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN140.html ↩
- The Buddha speaking in conventional terms. DN 9 Potthapada Sutta (“the world’s designations ... which the Tathagata uses without grasping”) dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN09.html ↩
- Discourses of definitive and provisional meaning. AN 2:25 Neyyattha Sutta (Thanissaro; Access to Insight) accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/an/an02/an02.025.than.html ↩
- Meditating in the charnel ground. MN 10, the cemetery contemplations. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN10.html ↩
- The four boundless qualities (pervading the four quarters) The sutta formula, e.g. MN 7 Vatthupama Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN7.html ↩