Jhana & Awakening Retreat 2026 · Session 4 of 16

Sunday, November 8 · Morning

The first four jhanas in context: lineages, the Anapanasati tetrads, transitions and similes; Q&A

Recorded November 8, 2026, 10:02 am Mountain Time · Nameless Mountain, Boulder, Colorado · 1 hr 49 min

This talk put the first four jhanas in context: the competing lineages, jhana inside breath and metta practice, and how to move from one jhana to the next. The Q&A was the longest yet and ranged from saliva to self-doubt.

Topics and questions in this session

Talk

  • 0:00:00Jhana lineages: Leigh Brasington and Ayya Khema's lighter jhanas; Pa Auk and the Visuddhimagga's deep absorptions (0:01).
  • 0:03:29What's realistic on a retreat of this length.
  • 0:04:59The jhana factors inside the Anapanasati tetrads (MN 118).
  • 0:07:17Jhana through metta and the other brahmaviharas (AN 8:63).
  • 0:09:49The point isn't notches on the meditative belt. It's enjoying the fruit and turning it to insight.
  • 0:10:19Instructions: riding access into the first jhana, then marinating there.
  • 0:13:59The jacuzzi metaphor for the transitions: jets on full blast, jets off, cooling water, a float-tank cover.
  • 0:15:32Moving into the second jhana. Jhanas and the heavenly realms (AN 4:123).
  • 0:20:04The third jhana.
  • 0:21:36The fourth jhana: fathomless stillness.
  • 0:23:45The DN 2 similes for all four.

Q&A

  • 0:26:44Saliva building up in deep stillness.
  • 0:30:09Are the formless attainments what later teachers call jhanas five to eight? Yes.
  • 0:31:41When piti is too strong to be pleasant.
  • 0:33:05How to tell how much time has passed, and mastery of the second jhana.
  • 0:34:31Setting a time resolve, and a timer.
  • 0:35:36Metta through abstract qualities such as color. Jhana synesthesia is a thing.
  • 0:38:50Strong piti during the talk. Don't fear giddiness, but it can signal over-efforting (0:42).
  • 0:43:57Dropping into darkness, a state like boundless space. Is it dissociation, or skipping steps (0:46)?
  • 0:48:49Jhana through visualizing emptiness.
  • 0:52:20A participant compares the lineages. How access works in Visuddhimagga-style jhana (0:55).
  • 0:58:52Working with self-doubt: warmth and acceptance toward your conditioning, and his own childhood phobias.
  • 1:05:25Pushing anxious thoughts away versus sliding into dullness.
  • 1:10:48Napping to relax into practice.
  • 1:12:34Posture and tension: where to rest the hands, and permission for imperfect posture.
  • 1:18:37Holding difficult emotion alongside the object. The Korinji story.
  • 1:25:05Emotional numbness, especially with metta, for the heady, conceptual type.
  • 1:28:01Where in the body jhana should sit. Aim for the whole body; let a local feeling spread.
  • 1:29:29Combining metta and breath.
  • 1:30:58Involuntary swaying and rocking. It usually settles over time.

Guided practice

  • 1:38:59A short sit at the nostrils, with the image of striking a bell and letting it ring (1:45).
Sunday, November 8 · Morning

Edited transcript. The time at the start of each paragraph is where it begins in the recording above; drag the player to that point to listen. Participants' names are omitted. [Square brackets] mark editorial insertions; [unclear] marks words that couldn't be made out.

0:00:00Namo tassa bhagavato arahato sammā-sambuddhassa (three times). This morning I'd like to give a little more context and perspective on the first four jhanas. As I'm sure many of us are well aware, there's quite a diversity of opinion in the contemporary Buddhist and Buddhist-influenced landscape about just what exactly these states are, how one reaches them, and where the bar is. Sometimes, especially online, people can get very angry about developing these wonderful, wholesome states of mind. That's funny. My own experience has been within more traditional Buddhist settings, and I've had the good fortune to learn from a couple of different sources. One is Leigh Brasington, whom some of you are familiar with (thanks); some of you have been on retreat with him. He learned from Ayya Khema, a German-born nun who first learned from the Visuddhimagga and the original suttas, and then also confirmed and dialogued with a Sri Lankan jhana master, who told her that she had to go and teach these things.12

0:01:48Then one of the other major jhana lineages represented in Western discourse at present comes from Pa Auk Sayadaw, a Burmese jhana master, familiar through Stephen Snyder, Tina Rasmussen, Nikki Mirghafori, Beth Upton and a bunch of other people. They're influenced by some later sources like the Visuddhimagga, The Path of Purification, which is fifth century AD, as opposed to the suttas, whose oral tradition, as best we can tell, goes back to the fifth century BC. So there's a gap of about a thousand years, and in that time it seems the bar for what constitutes jhana got higher and higher, until even by the first jhana one is so secluded and withdrawn from ordinary sensory consciousness that, by the time of deep access concentration and then the first jhana, there's no consciousness of the body and no self-structure. It's a non-dual state. You're completely withdrawn from the senses, with no contact at all, fused with a kind of jet-engine-intensity blissful light that shows up as a result of meditation. Already formless, already non-dual, completely withdrawn from the senses: really quite far from ordinary waking sensory consciousness.34

0:03:29Fingers crossed, but it's unlikely, on a retreat of this length under these conditions, that we'll all be reaching that kind of absorption. If you want to take the time, cool: those states are real. Go on a longer retreat with a teacher who specializes in them and you can experience them; they're wonderful. And for what jhana is good for within the larger structure of the path (seeing clearly, having collected, clear, stabilized, really piercing insight into the nature of phenomena), absorption like that is just stronger on all the relevant dimensions. So it's worth it if you have time, and it's also not entirely necessary. But if you go back to the sources I'm drawing from here, the suttas and some of these other jhana lineages, the first four jhanas are embodied states, unless you're really deep in them. There are variants of the first four jhanas, even without getting to the Pa Auk level, where the body fades or is absorbed into the factors; but except at the very far end, in these first four jhanas you're conscious of the body, and unless you're exceptionally absorbed you'll still be aware of sound and other external things.

0:04:59There's also some debate and dispute, and there are different approaches, as to whether these factors of jhana and the progression through these four levels are absorptions that stand alone from other practices, or whether these levels of concentration develop naturally while doing other practices. As it's presented in the Mindfulness of Breathing Sutta, the locus classicus for mindfulness of breathing, it's organized into four tetrads, four sets of four. We've gone over some of it already: breathing in long, you know you're breathing in long; breathing in short, you know you're breathing in short; breathing out short, and so on. Breathing in sensitive to the entire body; breathing out sensitive to the entire body. Breathing in calming bodily fabrication; breathing out calming bodily fabrication. That's the first four. In the second four (there's nothing about jhana here, but the relevant factors start showing up): "He trains himself, 'I will breathe in sensitive to rapture'" (that's piti) "'I will breathe out sensitive to rapture.'5

0:06:13"He trains himself, 'I will breathe in sensitive to pleasure'" (that's sukha) "'I will breathe out sensitive to pleasure.' He trains himself, 'I will breathe in sensitive to mental fabrication; I will breathe out sensitive to mental fabrication.' He trains himself, 'I will breathe in calming mental fabrication; I will breathe out calming mental fabrication.'" And then it goes on: sensitive to the mind (sorry), gladdening the mind, concentrating the mind and releasing the mind. So there's a way of reading that progression through mindfulness of breathing, without ever departing from the breath, as a progression through the levels of jhana. That's how some teachers teach it, and I can confirm from my own experience that if you just stay with mindfulness of breathing for longer and longer durations, those qualities and factors of jhana will arise. If you don't turn to those factors and make them the objects of your absorption, the state will be a bit different, but you can just stay with the breath all the way through, up to full awakening.

0:07:17So says the Mindfulness of Breathing Sutta, and I happen to think it's true. There are so many ways you could go. And this is also a point of some confusion: there are some teachers and lineages teaching jhana where, as just outlined, you stay with the breath through the levels of jhana. There are also some passages where you stay with metta or compassion or sympathetic joy or equanimity through the four levels. This is one such example: "You should train yourself thus: 'Goodwill, as my awareness-release, will be developed, pursued, given a means of transport, given a grounding, steadied, consolidated, and well-undertaken.' That's how you should train yourself. When you have developed this concentration in this way, you should develop this concentration with directed thought and evaluation" (there's vitakka and vicara, two of the jhana factors), "you should develop it with no directed thought and a modicum of evaluation, you should develop it with no directed thought and no evaluation." If those drop away, by sutta criteria, that's the second jhana.6

0:08:22"You should develop it accompanied by rapture" (okay, a first-jhana factor), "not accompanied by rapture" (okay, moving into the third jhana: the rapture is completely gone), "endowed with a sense of enjoyment" (sukha), "endowed with equanimity." You could read that as referring to the fourth jhana. So that's a lot [unclear], but I'm just trying to open up whatever conception you have of what jhana is: that there's a necessary progression, or that jhana only happens as a result of absorbing into the factors, or that these factors can't show up if you're staying with some other object. For the transmission of information, in some ways of teaching, for pedagogy, it's expedient to present this all as a very well-defined linear set and sequence. But as you may have discovered already within your own practice, during this retreat and off it, actual living experience doesn't fit so neatly into categories. So whatever idea you have of what jhana is, where it begins, where it ends, what the depth is, what the fixed criteria are: these are markers, these are guideposts.

0:09:49Let them go. The point is not to put notches on the meditative belt, but to enjoy the fruit of the practice and turn it to insight, for yourself, for your mind, for your heart.

0:10:19With all that said: I gave instructions last night on accessing the first jhana and then moving into the second, so I'll just reiterate for those who weren't able to join live, and as a reminder for those of us here. You stay with the breath at the nostrils or through the whole body, or with metta, or with anything else. The steps work for any object, so I'm just going to talk about it with the breath. You stay with the breath for longer and longer. Your attention becomes more and more stable. The hindrances and the wavering and wandering of the mind progressively settle. You feel calm and assured, at ease, and as a consequence of that coherence and collectedness and the abandoning of the hindrances, pleasant feeling arises in the body. It may already show up as piti, which is buzzy and effervescent, can be wavy, shows up in different ways for different people, and might come with heat or feel electric. Or there might just be a diffuse warmth, which might be more indicative of sukha. But you start to get the incipient signs of deepening samadhi, with piti and sukha independently or in combination. And when your mind has been steady and calm and collected for about 15 minutes at a bare minimum, without serious interruption, without the mind completely coming off and losing contact, then you can try turning the mind to pleasant sensation, whether that's already obviously identifiable piti and sukha or something more nebulous, not so strong. And that's it.

0:12:28You can just ride that up. No muss, no fuss; keep it very simple. Just turning the momentum of the concentration you've developed so far towards the pleasantness, towards the piti and sukha or a combination, will set up a feedback loop, and eventually you'll ride that up into the first jhana. The first jhana, with the relevant factors of piti and sukha, can show up more localized in the body; it's not uncommon for it to be shooting up in your chest, into your head. For some people, if your concentration is strong, it may be in your whole body at once from the beginning. But if it's more local, don't worry about it. Just stay with it where it is, and let it develop and strengthen and mature and refine locally for a while before trying to spread it. And a recommendation: before trying to move on to another jhana, take your time. Let yourself really enjoy and immerse and absorb in the first jhana, second jhana, third jhana, fourth jhana, however far you go, for at least 15 minutes. There's really a lot of work being done on your consciousness by hanging out and marinating.

0:13:59[unclear] in the room talks a lot about marination, right? It's very true. Like a nice juicy steak, let your mind completely marinate, totally saturated and suffused with these factors of piti and sukha. Just hanging out there for longer and longer can ease any disruption, any pain, any agitation in the body and mind. A metaphor I like to use: the first jhana is like a wonderfully warm, blissful jacuzzi with the jets on full blast. So hang out, enjoy it, let yourself get really relaxed and comfortable, and also energized and bright. If the first jhana is too uncomfortable, too intense, as I mentioned last night, you don't have to stay there long; you can shift down. Once you're really familiar with these states, just a movement of intention may be enough to shift, but there are some more mechanical things you can do to help move yourself along. From first to second: take a long inhale, then sweep the attention down from the crown of your head through the soles of your feet into the floor with a long exhale, through the mouth or the nose, up to you.

0:15:32You might need to do that a couple of times if the piti is really switched on. And shift your attention from the piti in the foreground, this buzzy electric feeling, to the warmer, more diffuse happiness and pleasure that is sukha. If you can do that, you'll still have piti in the background, buzzing and bubbling away at a much lower intensity, and your experience will be predominantly one of the warmth and pleasure and happiness that is sukha. To take the jacuzzi metaphor, most of the jets are off, and now you're appreciating the warmth and pleasure of it more. Not so excited. Here too, let yourself stay for a long time. Again, this differs by teacher and lineage and all of these things, but each jhana is almost a world unto itself, and the longer you stay in it, the more your perception conforms to the properties of the jhana. In fact, in traditional Buddhist cosmology, each of the four jhanas and the four formless attainments corresponds to a heavenly realm made up entirely of these qualities.7

0:16:58If you really spend time immersed in these states for long durations, you can understand why that might be. You can imagine, in fact, that if you're really immersed, your entire experience is like a realm made up of these qualities. You don't have to die to go to heaven; you can experience it here. So take your time; enjoy it. Teachers and lineages have different criteria for mastery, but if you're going to go for fluency and mastery of jhana in your career of practice, I really recommend being able to sustain each of these for at least an hour, if not more. And you may find (this was true in my experience) that your system has a preference or predilection for certain jhanas over others. It's good to be well-rounded. With the first jhana, if you're a shy and retiring kind of personality, you may find, "Oh, it's too loud, it's too intense." Actually habituating yourself to that volume and intensity of experience, gaining some tolerance for it, is good training in equanimity.

0:18:28If you do that, you may not mind loud sounds and lights as much in the rest of your life. Me, I have a really good time with the first, second and fourth jhanas, but for some reason my system doesn't want to hang out in the third jhana so much: just content, overwhelmingly content, everything's fine. Max pleasure, max bliss, or total peacefulness, sure; but that in-between, no. That's my work to get over: the third jhana. So the second jhana is characterized by a diminution of the bliss and rapture of piti and a foregrounding of the sukha. Moving into the third jhana, you can do the same move you did from first to second, exhaling and sweeping the attention down, once or as many times as you need to actually clear the piti. In the third jhana there's no piti at all; it's all gone. And the sukha refines into a much more even, cool, calm, contented feeling. If you had a big, toothy smile in the first jhana, by the second maybe your mouth is closed, and by the third you've just got a faint wisp of a smile.

0:20:04Continuing with the jacuzzi metaphor, the jets are off. It's still nice and warm (maybe the water has cooled down a bit), but there are no more jets, no more turbulence. It's a very still state compared to the second and the first. In the canonical description, by the second jhana all thought has ceased. It's very possible, and worth doing, to get to that level of absorption, but don't worry if you're still thinking a little through all of these jhanas; it's fine. Know that there's always more depth, more absorption, more sustain and more power you can reach in your practice, but don't count it against yourself. Moving into the fourth jhana, the same move can be done again. Maybe you don't need the exhale so much, but certainly sweep the attention down and let the last remnant of pleasurable contentment drain out of the body, so that all that's left is this pure stillness and calm and evenness.

0:21:36Really, a well-consolidated fourth jhana is an incredibly still, fathomlessly still state. If you're really well into it, you won't be feeling yourself breathing; that'll be gone. And the body may already start to be present as just a bare wisp. For the jacuzzi metaphor, imagine you're in the jacuzzi and suddenly a float-tank cover comes over, and it's completely dark and still, with no motion. Those are my descriptions, but the traditional similes are quite nice, so I'll run through them again. "Seeing that they have been abandoned" (the hindrances) "gladness is born. In one who is glad, rapture is born. Enraptured at heart, your body grows calm. Your body calm, you are sensitive to pleasure. Feeling pleasure, your mind becomes concentrated. Quite secluded from sensuality, secluded from unskillful qualities, you enter and remain in the first jhana: rapture and pleasure born of seclusion, accompanied by directed thought and evaluation. You permeate and pervade, suffuse and fill this very body with the rapture and pleasure born of seclusion. Just as if a dexterous bathman or bathman's apprentice would pour bath powder into a brass basin and knead it together, sprinkling it again and again with water, so that his ball of bath powder, saturated, moisture-laden, permeated within and without, would nevertheless not drip;8

0:23:45"even so, the monk permeates this very body with the rapture and pleasure born of seclusion. There is nothing of your entire body unpervaded by rapture and pleasure born of seclusion. This is a fruit of the contemplative life, visible here and now, more excellent than the previous ones and more sublime. And then, with the stilling of directed thoughts and evaluations, you enter and remain in the second jhana: rapture and pleasure born of concentration, unification of awareness free from directed thought and evaluation, internal assurance. You permeate and pervade, suffuse and fill this very body with the rapture and pleasure born of concentration. Just like a lake with spring water welling up from within, having no inflow from the east, west, north or south, and with the skies supplying abundant showers time and again, so that the cool fount of water welling up from within the lake would permeate and pervade, suffuse and fill it with cool waters, there being no part of the lake unpervaded by the cool waters; even so, the monk permeates this very body with the rapture and pleasure born of concentration.

0:24:42"There is nothing of your entire body unpervaded by rapture and pleasure born of concentration. This, too, is a fruit of the contemplative life, visible here and now, more excellent than the previous ones and more sublime. And then, with the fading of rapture, you remain equanimous, mindful and alert, and sense pleasure with the body. You enter and remain in the third jhana, of which the noble ones declare, 'Equanimous and mindful, you have a pleasant abiding.' You permeate and pervade, suffuse and fill this very body with the pleasure divested of rapture. Just as in a lotus pond, some of the lotuses, born and growing in the water, stay immersed in the water and flourish without standing up out of the water, so that they are permeated and pervaded, suffused and filled with cool water from their roots to their tips, and nothing of those lotuses would be unpervaded with cool water; even so, you permeate this very body with the pleasure divested of rapture, so that there is nothing of your entire body unpervaded with pleasure divested of rapture.

0:25:39"This, too, is a fruit of the contemplative life, visible here and now, more excellent than the previous ones and more sublime. And then, with the abandoning of pleasure and pain, as with the earlier disappearance of elation and distress, you enter and remain in the fourth jhana: purity of equanimity and mindfulness, neither pleasure nor pain. You sit, permeating the body with a pure, bright awareness. Just as if a man were sitting covered from head to foot with a white cloth, so that there would be no part of his body to which the white cloth did not extend; even so, you sit, permeating the body with a pure, bright awareness. There is nothing of your entire body unpervaded by pure, bright awareness. This, too, is a fruit of the contemplative life, visible here and now, more excellent than the previous ones and more sublime." If your concentration is exceptionally strong, this pure, bright awareness may manifest as bright white light. This may also happen in access concentration and through the first jhanas, but in the first three jhanas, if you do have this kind of light phenomenology, usually you're not paying attention to it, because the state is a bit more agitated, even in the third.

0:26:44But when your mind becomes so still, and all the agitation of the rapture and pleasure has gone out of the body, that bright white light might become prominent again. It can be as though your entire body is in a field of bright, white, perfectly pure and still, wakeful light. So whether you've come on this retreat already well familiar with four or more jhanas, or you've never tasted jhana, it's all good. These are all well within your grasp if you continue to practice and set up the conditions for them to manifest. They may feel magical, but they're not magic, and you don't need to be a special person to attain them. I might have a little more to say, but that was a lot of information, and I want to leave space for questions now. "I have a question. One of the things I've noticed is that a lot of saliva builds up, and sometimes I break my concentration trying to figure out what to do with it.

0:28:57I was wondering: do I tilt my head back? Do you have any suggestions?" Yeah, this came up earlier, and maybe you've already heard this advice. If you create a suction seal with your tongue on the roof of your mouth (place the tip of your tongue just behind your front teeth, suck the air back, then swallow), your tongue will stick to the roof of your mouth and you'll salivate less. You'll still occasionally need to swallow, and that might disrupt your meditation a bit, but if you need to swallow, just swallow. That should prevent so much buildup, if you're not already doing it. "What if I'm sort of doing that and it's still disruptive? Is there a way to work with the fact that maybe I just naturally salivate more?" Possibly. Odd things can also go on as a result of concentration. You can get bodily heat, you can get shaking. I've also experienced, as a consequence of the bliss, sometimes when the piti is really strong (I don't know, it's like a symptom of physiological arousal) a huge amount of salivation.

0:30:09[unclear] other people report the same. So you might just salivate a lot, in which case you can let it build up, or you can swallow it. "This is related to what you were saying at the beginning about the definition of jhana changing. Is it true that what the suttas call the four formless attainments are what later people call jhanas five through eight? And do you know the history of when and why that terminological shift happened?" No, I don't know exactly how that happened. In the Visuddhimagga, I'm not sure; I'd have to check whether they're referred to as jhanas there. In the suttas, the four formless attainments, which most of the time are referred to as jhanas five through eight (boundless space, boundless consciousness, nothingness, and neither perception nor non-perception), are just referred to as the formless attainments. There is a natural progression through them for some people. It's also true that some people, by the narrative in the suttas, the Buddha himself included, enter the formless attainments without going through the four jhanas first.9

0:31:41But in many places in the suttas they're presented as a full sequence, the fullest sequence being jhanas one, two, three and four, then the four formless attainments (boundless space, boundless consciousness, nothingness, neither perception nor non-perception), and then finally the cessation of perception and feeling, which, again, some people call the ninth jhana. That's kind of confusing. The terminology ultimately doesn't matter that much, but in the suttas there are four jhanas, four formless attainments, and then the cessation of perception and feeling, which is the big daddy of temporary attainments. Call them whatever you want; the important thing is to experience them. Yeah, [participant]. "You mentioned really steeping in these jhanas as much as possible. Part of my question (I think it was brought up last night) is that the piti is sometimes really not pleasant. It's a lot; it's pleasant in some parts of the body and really unpleasant in others. If there's also sukha there, do you recommend switching back and forth between them, or fully mastering absorption in the piti before moving to the sukha?"

0:33:05You could go back and forth. If the piti in the first jhana is too strong, too gross, too coarse, you can shift to the second jhana and hang out there for however long you want, then traverse backwards, back up into the first. If you do that, the piti will very likely be more refined, and you'll be able to stay in the first jhana longer, more comfortably and more stably. So if you have steady access to the second jhana, that's what I'd recommend if the first is too intense: hang out in the second jhana for a while, shift back, and master the first that way. "I don't know if I have mastery of the second. The first is more the playground, and then maybe I notice sukha, and I don't know whether that would destabilize it, because I haven't been able to play with the second." Find out; play around. I don't have a strong intuition. "Then, about time: you were saying to spend 15 minutes or so in access concentration, or in a jhana. But I'm not looking at my watch, and I don't know how time is going when I'm deep in there. So when we need to test the first jhana, how do we know how much time has passed? Other than a bell every half hour or something, what do we use?"

0:34:31You can just wing it: "I've been in here what seems like an awfully long time." You can also just quickly open your eyes and check, if you've got a watch. That's not so possible if you're sitting in a hall as we are, but on your own time you can set a time resolve and also set a timer. "And if you resolve to stay for 15 minutes, does that track with the actual time?" Yeah. A very traditional style of training, and an aspect of mastery, is to stay in any particular jhana as long as you determine to. The way that's done is you set the intention, "Okay, I'm going to stay in the first jhana for 30 minutes," and then you stay in the jhana for what you think is 30 minutes. At some point an internal alarm goes off ("Yep, that's about 30 minutes"), and then you look. You do that again and again until you're able to get it right at 30 minutes.

0:35:36"When you use the bell, it's different, right? If you use the bell, you don't have to..." Well, yeah, you can't really do that kind of training here. You could sit outside and set your own time, or play around. "My other question is about focusing on the metta with abstract qualities." When you say abstract qualities, what do you mean? "The color, or the smoothness, or the peacefulness." It will have a location within your experience. Is it shifting, or are you mostly staying with a particular color you associate with metta, or a particular picture? How do you know that it's metta? If you associate all of those things with metta, my bet is that you're doing it by some felt sense, and that will have a location in the body somewhere. That's something to check. This is another interesting thing: some people have very strong color phenomenology corresponding to the jhana factors or to particular jhanas.

0:37:18I don't get that, but some people do. Likewise with the brahmaviharas, some people get very strong color phenomenology. Jhana synesthesia is a thing. So if a color or a particular felt texture is really strongly coupled to the feeling of metta, great, use it, and look to see if there's a felt sense in the body. If it's a color, you can experiment with washing the body with that color; if it's a texture, can you invite that texture to move through the body? Does that give you something to go on? "Yes. I have another question. Sometimes there's confusion between feeling the excitement and feeling this... I'm not sure whether it's the same thing, or craving, or something like that." Is there craving in it? There can just be excitement, without the gripping and grasping at all. "It's sort of both of these." Yeah. So the feeling of giddiness: yes, that's right.

0:38:50Piti has that... maybe that's why I laugh so much; I spend too much time with piti. But it does have that levity, that lightness. So that's good; follow it, it's going in the right direction. And if you find you're clamping or latching or gripping, let that go. There's nothing in the sensation itself that you need to be wary of. After the Buddha realized the futility of his ascetic practices (after he almost starved himself to death, going without, denying himself all forms of pleasure), he recalled (this is the canonical story of his turn towards jhana, and how that led to his awakening) sitting as a young boy in the shade of a rose-apple tree and, spontaneously, just through relaxing and being contented, absorbing into this rapture and happiness. And then it occurred to him: why should I be afraid of this rapture and this pleasure, which has nothing to do with unskillful, unwholesome qualities? It's not pleasure that is wrong. It's not excitement or rapture that leads into further rounds of craving and clinging and becoming.10

0:40:42He followed that intuition all the way, and didn't come to a bad end. So don't be scared of feeling giddy and excited and happy. And if you can bring a sense of play as well (this goes for everyone)... This is a serious endeavor we're doing here, as serious as anything is, but if you can bring a sense of lightness and joy and play to it, you'll have a better time, and your mind will be more malleable. Yeah. "I notice that while you're giving this talk, I've had maybe the strongest piti of the whole retreat, and I'm curious about that. It makes me think of something I heard Rob say about happiness leading into jhana. I'm trying to figure out whether that implies I'm pushing too hard, since it seems easier to get into it in this less formal setting." Often, depending on our character, we have a lot of diligence and a lot of drive, and that's great. But there's a certain kind of pressure where it's as if we're pressing an inflatable underneath the water; then when we get tired or the circumstances change, we take our hands off and, poof, it pops off.

0:42:28So that might be a sign that you're over-efforting and could stand to relax and loosen and ease up a bit. "And ease up without fading into dullness?" Yeah. If you notice you're fading into dullness, ramp it up a bit. Often there's a kind of fear of losing our edge or slipping: "If I'm not tense, I'm going to miss it." That reaction, that feeling, that orientation is false, and it will often prevent us from relaxing and letting the state develop naturally. Does that make sense? And if you're anything like me, you'll have to go through lots and lots of cycles of incredible over-efforting: you get a little brittle concentration and samadhi, then you get exhausted, then you fall into dullness, and you just swing wildly back and forth until eventually you somehow figure out, "Oh, wait. Oh, there. Like that. Oh, okay." No verbal set of instructions will get you through that.

0:43:57"Thank you for this morning. When I experienced it, it was coming up, and I was just with the breath, and I sat with it for quite a while. Because it was so intense, I took a step back, and then I was in the darkness you described. I think it might be that, or I thought I was just dissociating. It's just pitch black, and it's everywhere, and it feels kind of lonely; there's really no feeling, it's just quiet and dark, and I know everything else is out there, but it's not, actually." Secluded from it, yeah. "Is that what you're talking about? Or is it just dissociating, or being too strong?" Let me ask another question: were you in contact with the body at all, or had the sense of it left? "No, but if I wanted to reach out, I could feel it."

0:44:59You could touch back into the body. "Yeah. But I wanted to stay there, so I didn't care. Is that part of this process?" Yeah, definitely related. And in that state, it doesn't sound like you were sleeping; it was just very still, very spacious. "I practice that state at home quite often, and I like it because it's quiet and still, and it actually brings more experience to me. But I didn't know if I was bypassing something. Is that part of this?" Yeah, 100% related. And were you able to feel any further... what would you say about its size? "Oh, it's all in. It's everything, everywhere. And I can touch back in if I want to, but it's pitch black and silent.

0:46:04It's stupid silent." Yeah. From just this basic report (and we can talk more in your interview, where it's scheduled), that sounds more like it's going towards the fifth jhana, boundless space. "So then my question is: am I skipping steps, and should I not skip steps? Should I force myself back into the piti?" This is another thing I'd like to relieve you of: worrying about skipping steps or getting the sequence right. Different people will find it easier to enter at different places. I do think it's good to get fluent with the whole range and learn to surf all these different frequencies of experience. But if the piti is too intense and you can go there, that's a good place to hang out. Did you try the transition I suggested, sweeping the attention down, calming the piti, and shifting to the soft happiness of sukha?

0:47:15"Yeah." Did that work? "It takes several tries, and then it just comes up again. After a long time I was like, okay, it's uncomfortable. It feels good, but some parts are uncomfortable, and then I just went there. You know what I'm saying?" Yeah. Do you think you could access that second state directly, without going through the first? Because this is common, and it may show up in your experience at some point as well: you try to shift down from the first to the second, but the concentration is strong and you just pop right back up into the first, and the piti can get kind of stuck. In that case, take a break, go for a walk; or you may just have to try sweeping and letting it drain out again and again. Or, if you can get in contact with a more spacious quality, the piti doesn't have to drain out through the floor; that's just one way. You could also orient more to space, and it might diffuse out that way. So one thing you could try is getting more in contact with that quality of stillness and spaciousness, and see if the piti can drain out that way. You may just have to tune and play around at the edges for it to fully go away; and in the second jhana it won't fully go away, but it will stabilize at a lower frequency. "Thank you." Thank you.

0:48:49"I have a question. Can you hear me?" Yep. "It's based on two of the other questions: first, what you were saying about jhana synesthesia, and then what the person before me asked about skipping steps. I know you said we don't have to worry about skipping steps, but the only way I've really been able to access what I'd consider a feeling of jhana is through a profound visualization of emptiness: everything dissolving, all fabrication dissolving, time dissolving, really tapping into that feeling of emptiness. And whenever I meditate now, since I know it's a way I can access it quicker, my brain almost jumps to wanting to let everything dissolve into emptiness. I think, 'Oh, it's so easy if I could just do that.' But I wonder if I'm not spending enough time with my breath or with metta or with simpler things; if I'm jumping to too much visualization, almost reifying the visualization a bit too much and attaching to it. But it also seems to be working.

0:50:13So I don't know if it's something I should keep following, because my brain wants to keep doing it (maybe I'm just a very visual learner), or whether I should really focus more on the thing that seems harder for me, simple breath and metta, if that makes sense." Yeah, for sure. If you have a strong visual sense, it may be quite expedient to use that sense to work creatively with the felt sense of the body. You can couple and interact between the visual and somatic fields, and some people have this going on naturally. Also, one of my teachers uses this phrase: "You might be a fast dissolver." Yeah. I'm not teaching these techniques on this retreat, but there are some techniques where, at the beginning of a practice, you dissolve the body from the bottom and from the top using a visualization.

0:51:16You dissolve from the top and the bottom until you're gone, and you're just abiding in a formless, boundless state. So if some visualization lets you effectively dissolve and get to a working basis from there, there's nothing wrong with that, and it can be good to fill in the middle. "Okay." So try going back and forth. If you can get to that state of dissolution and relative formlessness, bring the body back in and see if you can tune into the qualities we're talking about here. You can also try using elements, if you have a strong visual sense: imagine fireflies pervading the body, and see if that activates the kind of rapture we're talking about. "Oh, I like that. Okay." I leave it to you. "Okay, awesome. Thank you." And once you get a felt sense, if you're skilled with the visual, you can use the visual to spark the somatic and then key in more to the somatic.

0:52:20You're going to strengthen both sides. "Okay, thank you." You're welcome. [Participant], yeah, you're muted. "Thank you. First of all, a couple of people's questions in the room don't come through clearly online, maybe because of where they're sitting relative to the microphone, so if you're able to repeat some of them, that would be helpful." I can generally grok what's going on from the responses. "I have a three-part question. First: my understanding from the Brasington world is that there are four levels of jhana intensity and quality. At the top are the Visuddhimagga jhanas, which are on another planet and not really worth exploring in the context of a ten-day retreat other than intellectually; those use the concept of access concentration, but you just breathe through the whole thing. Then there's Leigh's, which is lower but still noticeably intense; here you still use access concentration, but you switch from the breath to the piti. Then maybe slightly below that is the Burbea area, where he's not using access concentration, but you also switch from your object to cultivating the piti.

0:54:13But maybe it's less of a switch, so it's more muddled. And then there's the [unclear] level, which Brasington thinks is so light as not to actually be jhana, where you don't use access concentration and, oddly, you're back to just staying with the breath and not switching..." Or metta, yeah. "Or metta. So, first question: is that also your experience, or your understanding of how these things go?" Yeah. If you put me up against the wall and I had to rank-order which of those methods are likely to deliver what depth of concentration, that's the order I'd put them in. But there's nothing saying you can't mix and match, or move from one to the other. I know from my own experience that I can get to an equal intensity of jhana without going through access concentration first, just building up piti as Rob teaches it. It'll take me longer in terms of time efficiency. If I ramp up access concentration really strongly first, I'll get a stronger intensity of jhana faster.

0:55:20But people differ. "Okay, that answered the main part of my question. Mostly out of intellectual curiosity: for the Visuddhimagga-level jhanas, how does access concentration come into play? For Leigh, you do access concentration, and after staying there for a little while, that's the point for switching. Why even bother having the idea of access concentration if you're just focusing on a disc or your breath or whatever for months straight?" I think I understand the question; we'll see from my answer whether I understood what you meant. Doing Pa Auk-style jhana, you just stay with the breath (or a color disc), and you stay with the object until jhana arises; you don't ever depart from the object. You never switch to the jhana factors deliberately, never. You just let them build, and eventually the entirety of your experience synchronizes with the breath. You go through a process of development where you get the visual counterpart sign, which can show up as diffuse white light or a disc of light, or can be different colors (different people get different light phenomenology), but you still just stay with the breath.

0:56:44Likewise, you're not paying any attention to the jhana factors; you're still with the breath or the color disc or whatever. You never switch off the object, and eventually, without your doing anything, the light and the breath sensation merge, and it's almost as though a gravitational well, an inescapable black hole of energized concentration, develops with this fused object, which is barely recognizable as anything corporeal. It becomes increasingly removed from any ordinary sense of breath or body; it's just this energized, luminous intensity. Then at a certain point you get completely absorbed and sucked in, and you're in it. At first you can't volitionally enter the jhana; it just happens. And once in it, you certainly can't volitionally exit; it just lasts as long as it lasts. Did that satisfy your [unclear]? "Yeah. So is it roughly correct to say that access concentration at that level is more descriptive than prescriptive?

0:57:54It's like, 'Just letting you know you're on the path here,' but there's nothing to do?" Yeah. And if you do eventually try for that, you'll be sitting and deepening access concentration day in and day out, hour after hour, for hours. If you really want to go for that depth of absorption, sitting uninterruptedly for hours is the way to go. For these other methods too, if you can sit or lie down uninterruptedly for hours and just keep it chugging, you'll get much stronger absorption; with that system you're just taking it to the maximum. "Got it. Okay. My main curiosity for this retreat was to try out the first three levels and mixing them, so you answered that with the question. Thank you." And with all this discussion of levels and depths and intensities, don't let it set up a value hierarchy in your mind.

0:58:52Descriptively, yes, these are different depths and dimensions of absorption and relative intensity, but it's all good. As much as you want to explore the wide and wonderful world of absorption in the rest of your life of practice, go for it. It's all for the good, but don't stress. Yeah, [participant]. "I wonder if you could speak about working with self-doubt. I notice it's such a strong part of me, such a strong story: I'm just not skilled at this. Some people are naturals at this, and I'm not. I've been on so many retreats, and I almost can't imagine having the facility to work in the ways being described, even if I can imagine them intellectually. It seems like a part I'm really going to have to learn to work with and fold into the practice." Yeah.

1:00:05On other retreats I've been on, asking questions in Q&A was expressly forbidden, to avoid the potential of bringing in a kind of comparison. It can help to remember that you, as who you are, with all your aggregates and conditioning, are different from everybody else here and everybody else in the entire world. Each person's process is a unique constellation of their causes and conditions, as is yours. No one is more apt, or better or worse. Setting up the comparison is an unfortunate habit. But bring to mind the larger context and the conditionality of any meditative state: if you're a "natural" at jhana, then, seen clearly, that's not a cause for pride, not a cause for anything; and if one finds difficulty with any aspect of the practice, then, seen clearly, that's not a cause for discouragement. I know you reasonably well, so if you can borrow some of my confidence: I have full faith in your ability to work with these instructions and reach these states if you want to.

1:02:06We bring whatever our conditioning is to any practice. So see if you can calm and soothe, and bring warmth and kindness and acceptance to, the parts of you that feel, "Am I behind? Am I not keeping up? Am I good enough? Will I ever?" That's an understandable manifestation of a kind of anxiety and concern, and you can meet it with warmth and kindness. It's good to work through. If you can work through that part, that tendency, in relation to samadhi, I promise you it will change how you relate to the entirety of the rest of your life. Does that address it? Is that helpful? [Participant]. "Yeah. An interesting segue: I have a very beginner question, since some of us are still at the very beginning. When I think I'm focusing on my breath, I sometimes can't tell whether I'm finally doing the right thing (only being with the breath, my mind no longer wandering) or whether I'm dissociated, zoned out, almost in a stupor, because it all just feels like low activation in the system.

1:04:00Relatedly, I had some childhood phobias (as a kid I used to be terrified I'd be abducted by aliens; it's a whole separate story, not worth getting into), and it means I have a lot of practice shoving my attention away from the scary thing so that I'm not thinking about it. I'm wondering if I'm doing that with my anxious thoughts. It feels like it's probably more forceful than what you're trying to aim me at, but I'm not sure, and I don't know how not to do it. That's the realm of the question, if you could just speak to it." Yeah, thank you for the question. With these instructions, with samadhi in general, with mindfulness of breathing, with metta, with anything, we can relate to it unskillfully. This shoving away of anxious feelings: when I started doing these kinds of practices and began to get traction, it was amazing. Like someone with a hammer, to whom everything looks like a nail: "If I'm ever sad, anxious, confused, angry, tired, horny, anything I don't want to feel, you know what I can do?

1:05:25Lock on and push everything else away!" There's a way of redirecting whatever energy is caught in feeling or distraction and reincorporating it back into the breath without pushing anything away; and there's a way of pushing, then rebounding and latching onto the object. If you're pushing and latching again and again, you may end up, as I did, bypassing a whole lot of material, and that will bite you in the ass later, even if it works for a given definition of "works." So if you're able to notice some aversion, some push, in how you're relating to things that aren't the primary object, that may be a sign to loosen and open up the aperture of your attention. Allow the disturbance, allow the anxiety, allow the doubt, allow whatever it is; you don't need to push it away. You can gently be with both, allowing the fear or doubt or confusion to be in the same field of experience while still gently resting with the object.

1:06:45As for moving into a kind of stupor: with any object, you can get into a very relaxed but quite dull state that almost borders on sleep, and you can get stuck there in the doldrums, and it can be quite comfortable. But you can discern a brightness and sharpness and vividness, to both the object and the quality of your mind, when you're progressing in the direction that leads to deeper samadhi, as opposed to a hazy, foggy, almost gauzy feeling when you're drifting in the direction of dullness. Does that resonate at all? "I suspected it enough to ask the question, so I'm not surprised by your answer. Maybe we should do this more one-on-one if it's too beginner to be helpful to the group. But what it feels like is happening is: I see a thought wandering across, and I think, 'Oh no, I'm not supposed to be thinking thoughts right now; move attention to the breath.'

1:08:07So that's the samadhi aggression. And then when I get there, I feel like I'm focusing on my breath, and it just feels drowsy and hazy. I suspect it shouldn't, but that's what it feels like when I get there, and I can't really just change it. So yes to your answers, but what do I actually do? I'm happy to talk more one-on-one if this isn't group material." No, this is great; thank you for the question. And a note on that: the principles and mechanics in the most basic question, the most beginner question, apply to everyone at all phases of the practice, regardless of where they're at or how long they've been doing this. So don't hesitate to ask what might feel like a simple or basic or beginner question. As for the reactivity to distraction you're mentioning, you may not be able to drop it directly. It may just be something you have to notice yourself doing, and each time you notice, gently soften and return.

1:09:35Let's talk more one-on-one, but until then, in the sessions coming up, try to put more attention on the way you relate to distractions and return to the object than on tightening around the object itself. Get really curious and interested in the mechanics of that process: of drifting, of how you react to whatever you drifted to, and of how you return. I don't know if you've ever gone canoeing, but let it be a nice smooth paddle in a smooth arc rather than thrashing in the water, if that analogy gives you something to work with. As for when you do settle with the object and it feels dull or hazy, you may just be tired, and that may clear up with time. Another thing you can do (and this goes for anyone experiencing drowsiness or tiredness) is just open your eyes. You can stare straight ahead, not engaging the visual field, just with an open, unfixated gaze, or down past the end of your nose; or, if you're really tired, you can angle your eyes upwards.11

1:10:48Nothing else changes about what you're doing with your attention or the instructions, but that should bring some energy up. You can think of it as a three-position throttle. Yeah, welcome. [Participant], yes. "One can veer wildly from the anxiety and fear to the total other side. The anxiety, fear and tightening around the breath can lead to that; I think I get tired from it. What I've been doing is getting drowsy, saying, 'Oh, this is nice,' and letting myself fall asleep, with the intention of continuing after I wake up, because then I'm in this nice, relaxed, I-took-a-nap state. That seems to be successful for me, but would you advise against it?" No. I don't remember whether this was online, but I'm pro-nap. There are some practice containers with no sleeping, no dozing off, and some sleep restriction involved. But for samadhi, if you're tired, often just taking a quick 20-minute nap will do more for your practice and benefit you more than slogging through dullness and tiredness.

1:12:34"I've got a two-part question about body posture and tension. This is my first jhana retreat where I'm attempting to sit upright like this for as much time as possible. What usually happens is that a tense frame starts to build around the outside edges of the upper half. I can feel it on the tops of the shoulders, down into my arms, and sometimes I'm like, 'Oh, fuck.' I've heard a lot of the instructions about letting everything relax without slumping, and I'm thinking, apparently I can't relax without slumping. So the first part of my question is: what can be done about that? And the second part is its relation to trying to get concentrated. Previously I would just be in a super comfy position the whole retreat,

1:13:54so the body was out of the equation and I could just focus on concentrating on whatever the object was. Now it's: object; okay, do this. There are lots of little tricks that can relieve tension, breathing through the shoulders and this and that, but it's object, okay, breathe through the shoulders; object, okay, breathe through the shoulders; object, relax. It's almost like I'm trying to do two things at once, and that feels unhelpful. I don't know how much of this is venting rather than a natural question, but I'm somewhat tempted to totally ignore the body and whatever it feels like, because I know what I'll find once I get sufficiently concentrated. Or should I keep doing this kind of thing?" Were you able to hear that question online? Yes? Okay. One: if you're just not used to sitting upright this much, you may simply experience a bunch of discomfort, even pain.

1:15:05Another thing: if you're sitting this much, even slight misalignments (in your pelvic tilt, in whether your head is this far forward or actually up, and also in the position of your hands) will cause pain over time. You talked about tension in the shoulders and neck. Where your hands are sitting matters: if they're drooping, a bunch of weight is pulling the shoulders down. "Actually, that reminds me of a mini sub-question. Almost every time I bring attention back to the whole body, I notice some slight misalignment has occurred: my head has jutted out a bit, my arms have gone up a bit, or the body has slumped a bit one way or another. So the sub-question is: when I notice that, do I correct it at the cost of [unclear]?" What you don't want to do is set up a loop of "Is the posture right?

1:16:11Check it." Don't do that, or if you catch yourself doing it, remember it's okay not to have perfect posture. But if you notice spontaneously, "Oh, I've shifted a little," sure, take a second. You may notice immediately the increase in clarity and alertness and energy that comes from bringing the posture back into alignment. So if you notice it spontaneously, it's worth correcting. And if you're experiencing a bunch of pain and discomfort, odds are there's something in the posture you could adjust, at least at the beginning, to remedy some of the pain and tension that's accumulating. The last thing I mentioned was the position of the hands. People's bodies are different, and you're going to have to find what works, but if they're too far forward and all this weight is pulling, you'll get a whole bunch of tension in your shoulders and neck. What you may need to do is wad up a sock, or if you've got a pocket like this... your hands might just need to be higher, so there isn't that downward strain on the shoulders and neck.

1:17:33It can take a bit of getting used to, but you can also just keep a little tension in your arms to hold your hands up just below the belly button, or something like that. That may feel awkward at first, but then you won't end up with shoulder and neck tension from it. As for the other part of the question, it's similar to the posture: if you're constantly going, "Ooh, I can be a little more comfortable if I just sweep through," if you're caught in a loop of doing that again and again, then you're not building as much momentum in samadhi as you could be. Also (I've given this advice to some folks in interviews already), if you have some access to piti, or there's a sense of the breath that you can move through the body to break up tension, that can be great, very skillful. Then you can reach a happy equilibrium where you do that a little bit, and then really plunge in once you're more relaxed.

1:18:37"Thank you. Something you said a couple of questions ago was very interesting: allowing your difficult emotions while also resting on the object at the same time. My personal conceptualization is that returning to the object is like the fatherly guidance of the mind: 'Hey, you can do it, buddy. Come back. Come back.' But there are times when the negative emotions are so negative or so strong that they kind of smack you, this cranky mind. So then I shift into a more motherly, feminine attunement: 'Okay, we're not going to do the object for now. Let's just hold space for this hurt, this energy, and just care about it.' Sometimes I get an insight, maybe tear up a bit, and then I understand, and come back to the fatherly guidance:

1:19:44'Let's go back to the object.' And the way you said it was like a balance between the two, and I wonder if you could say a bit more about it. What does that feel like? How do you go about it? Do you have a beautiful analogy or a story that shows it? Or not, that's okay. When you said that you can balance both, staying with the object and holding the negative emotion, I thought, 'Whoa, that's a whole new thing,' because I tend to do all of one or all of the other. So if you can do both, that sounds really interesting." Yeah. Usually, if we're attending to some object to the exclusion of the rest of experience, there's a little bit of aversion: you're pulling the mind apart, bunching up one aspect and shoving the stuff at the periphery out.

1:20:41That's not sustainable. It won't lead to really deep, sustainable absorption; it'll just result in a brittle concentration. Even with the bonkers concentration you get doing Pa Auk-style jhana, you're never pushing anything out of your experience. Things drop out of your experience as a function of the mind naturally collecting and cohering, with all the energy in the periphery flowing into the object like water downhill. So let's use the finger again. You can look at my finger and be aware of the whole rest of the visual field, just like that. If you're with the breath at the nostrils, your awareness is still present to the rest of the field of experience, without any shoving or pushing away. You asked for a story, so here's a story. Last winter I was at Korinji for three months, and for those whole three months the main practice I was doing was the Rinzai Zen style of mindfulness of breathing. About six months before, I'd gone through a major separation, and I had some complicated feelings, both from that relationship and from some other things going on.

1:22:13As I got into the monastery, three months of monastic residency, it was: "Okay, boom. Let's think about everything you've ever done wrong in every relationship you've ever had, for months." Yeah, this is how some people react to divorce. Sometimes the intensity of regret and feeling and grief and all of that would be arising extremely strongly in the various emotional centers, in my gut, in my brain, and often the way I processed it was just staying with the breath through the whole body on the exhale. Not blocking anything out: weeping, crying, tears streaming down my face, and still the breath was like a container, a holding space and a holding energy for all that intense emotion to arise and pass away within the field of the attention, within the field of the breath. The same can be true even with a narrower spatial focus, though in a way it's easier if you're working with the breath through the whole body,

1:23:40which includes the space of emotion more holistically. But you don't need to separate, to partition the space of your mind: "Okay, this is the object; nothing else is allowed." You're anchoring to the object, orienting again and again, holding and staying with the object, but everything else is welcome and allowed without your engaging it directly. And the more experience you get with that, the more you can hold any kind of intensity and kind of emotion. "Gotcha. So an example might be: some negative emotions come in, and you tear up. You can be crying, tearing up, but you notice that you're still at the tip of the nose. They're both happening." Yeah, and there can be no resistance to the grief, to the anger, to whatever. "Right. Both are paid attention." Yeah, or they're held within the same field. "They're held within the same field. I see." And if that doesn't feel accessible at first, or the emotion reaches a certain intensity, then, as with physical pain, the appropriate thing may be just: "Okay, letting the breath flow,

1:25:05I'm just going to be with this, whatever it is." "All right. Okay, that helps." "The last exchange got me thinking. What if, rather than strong negative emotions coming up, you have an issue with emotional dumbness, or numbness, or dullness? In particular, this has been a challenge for me with metta: I have trouble generating positive sensations through metta. And I think it's sometimes linked with a tendency to spin up conceptual analysis as things are going on, so my mind is doing that rather than producing any of the positive emotions associated with the good feelings I'm trying to cultivate. Any general remarks about that?" Yeah. If we're a heady, conceptual, intellectual type, a lot of our attentional and energetic resources can get captured, shrink-wrapped up here, and it can take a while to rebalance and redistribute all of that energy below the neck, into the heart, into the gut, into the rest of the body. It can be patient, painstaking work. This can happen for various reasons: it can be an intellectual fixation, or it can be the result of painful emotional experiences that cause a kind of retreat, so that it may not feel safe in the body to feel intense emotion. There are different causes, but in all these cases, gently, patiently, persistently bringing awareness back into the body with sensitivity and care is what does the trick. And notice (as you are, otherwise you wouldn't be asking the question) when you're more engaged in thought or reflection or analysis than in directly feeling the sensations, wherever they are in the body; and without recriminations or aversion or batting it away, just let it go, reorient, and come back into the body again and again.

1:28:01When I started practice, my band of experience was like a tight iron cage. I don't even know that I was aware of anything below here; it was like a tight prison here. So it can be done. "Typically I'm heart-centered, but when I made it to [unclear], I wanted to drop down here for jhana. Is that a good thing to do, or should I stay in my heart?" Well, I'm trying to orient people to whole-body jhana. If it starts out localized, let it build in intensity in whatever locality it's in, and then it may spread through the body naturally, or you can intentionally spread it, like using a rolling pin on dough. Some visualization may also help with that: you can imagine light spreading, or just spread your attention from the area of local intensity, and it may follow. So I wouldn't privilege a particular location, but over time, as concentration deepens, let it spread naturally, and if it's stable, you can encourage it along.

1:29:29Eventually it's really just equally distributed throughout the whole field of the body. "I know you spoke about metta and the breath, and experimenting between them. I'm curious about your thoughts, opinions and recommendations on combining them: sensing the breath as imbued with metta, or sending metta to sensations rather than people, or something like that." Yeah. Here's another case. Were you able to hear that question online? Yep. Categories are not rigid. It turns out you can add a drop of metta to the breath, and it's like, "Oh, the breath kind of feels like metta." You can do it as a fused practice. You can breathe metta through the body. You can breathe metta out into space. You can send metta towards bodily sensations. You can send metta towards emotions. All of these are live possibilities. If that's working for you, if you're familiar with it and want to play with it, great. Just a caution: you can end up playing with your food the whole time and not eating.

1:30:58But if that kind of fusion of metta and breath feels resonant and interesting, and you can move into greater depth with it, go for it. Yes. "I haven't been to one of these kinds of things before, and I'd heard that you have to sit still and not move. I just thought, okay, I've got to lock myself into a full-body cast and sit here. Then when you told me that the movements that come through are okay, that was very freeing. I'd been trying to contort myself not to do those things, almost punishing myself for moving. And I also don't want to disrupt anybody else's practice; that's important to me as well. But another thing I do, and I want to know if it's okay: my body has a natural swaying and rocking. Sometimes it just does it; it's not something I intentionally do. And sometimes in meditation (I did this in the last meditation, because it felt good)

1:32:03it just rocks and sways. Is that another thing that's acceptable without breaking the no-moving rule? Because it's something I don't really control, and when I try to control it, gripping myself like a body cast so as not to move, it's more stressful for me than focusing." Yeah. (I'm pretty close to the speaker, so I think that got through online.) This is for everybody, since many questions take the form "Is this okay?" Yeah. Whatever your experience is, it's okay. As for being conscientious with other people in the hall: if you were really violently swaying or shaking and making a lot of noise, and it were persistent, then you could set yourself up over there and just let it happen. But I don't think I noticed anything, so I don't think it bothered anybody. And if it's something spontaneous that's arising as part of the deepening of samadhi, usually the thing is just to let it happen and work itself out.

1:33:17In my own experience, and it seems to be true for many others, that kind of swaying and shaking settles over time. During that three-month stint, there was a resident who had a very persistent, entirely involuntary leg shake, and rather than spend every meditation period putting a lot of effort into inhibiting the motion, which is what she would have had to do to make it stop, she just sat at the other end of the hall. That's fine. So we don't need to be too rigid. Okay, we've been sitting here for a while, so let's break for 10 minutes and then have a very short and sweet sit together. [unclear] Okay, a short meditation together before we head off to lunch. Thank you all for joining; I'll be seeing you folks online, some of you for interviews, and then again at 7 p.m.

1:36:00Just as an exercise here at the end, let's try to feel into what one of the questions was about: gently settling on whatever your object is. For now let it be the breath at the tip of the nostrils, but this applies to anything. Gently orient your attention and settle it there, staying with whatever sensations are present, and let yourself be fully aware of the rest of your body, of sound, of anything and everything that arises in the field of experience: emotion, thought. There's no need to block any of that out. It will settle of itself, and the mind will collect around the object of itself. Our only job is to gently orient and rest the attention on the object without pushing anything away. Not trying to exclude anything; just orienting and resting, again and again.

1:38:59Let whatever arises arise, and let whatever passes away pass away, without any resistance, without any attempt to make something be that is not, or make something not be that is. When your mind drifts, notice, release whatever your mind has drifted to in a smooth curve, reorient, and return to the breath at the nostrils.

1:40:50There's nothing else you need to do. Resting stably on the breath at the nostrils, if there's some quality there that's a little smoother or more enjoyable, you can tune slightly to it, to make resting here more enjoyable. But over time, the enjoyment and the stability and steadiness of your attention feed on themselves: the enjoyment, the interest and the persistence come from the concentration itself, feeding back in on itself.

1:45:17This image may help. You can imagine that each time you return your attention to the object, it's like striking a bell, and all you have to do is savor the resounding sound, like that, but with the sensation of the breath or the sensation of metta: just receiving and appreciating, enjoying, savoring, and staying with the feeling. Unlike an actual bell, at a certain point it will just keep ringing, and the sound will get deeper and richer and more encompassing as your attention stabilizes, as your mind becomes absorbed.

1:48:18It will just keep ringing.

Sources

Translations are Thanissaro Bhikkhu's on dhammatalks.org unless noted.

  1. Homage chant. Namo tassa bhagavato arahato samma-sambuddhassa (“Homage to the Blessed One, the Worthy One, the Rightly Self-awakened One”) ↩
  2. Leigh Brasington and his teacher Ayya Khema. Leigh Brasington, Right Concentration: A Practical Guide to the Jhanas (Shambhala, 2015) ↩
  3. Pa Auk-style jhana in the West. Stephen Snyder and Tina Rasmussen, Practicing the Jhanas (Shambhala, 2009) ↩
  4. The Visuddhimagga (5th century CE) Buddhaghosa, The Path of Purification, trans. Bhikkhu Ñanamoli (BPS; free PDF via Access to Insight) accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/nanamoli/ ↩
  5. The four tetrads of mindfulness of breathing. MN 118 Anapanasati Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN118.html ↩
  6. Goodwill developed through the forms of concentration. AN 8:63 Sankhitta Sutta (Thanissaro, “In Brief”; Access to Insight) accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/an/an08/an08.063.than.html ↩
  7. Each jhana corresponding to a heavenly realm. AN 4:123 Jhana Sutta (rebirth with the Brahma’s Retinue, Abhassara, Subhakinha and Vehapphala devas) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN4_123.html ↩
  8. The hindrances abandoned; the four jhana similes (bathman, spring-fed lake, lotuses, white cloth) DN 2 Samaññaphala Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN02.html ↩
  9. The Bodhisatta’s formless attainments under Alara Kalama and Uddaka Ramaputta; the full sequence to cessation of perception and feeling. MN 26 Ariyapariyesana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN26.html ↩
  10. The rose-apple tree memory: “no longer afraid of that pleasure that has nothing to do with sensuality” MN 36 Mahasaccaka Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN36.html ↩
  11. Opening the eyes against drowsiness. AN 7:58 Capala Sutta (remedies for nodding) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN7_58.html ↩

← Saturday, November 7 · Evening · All sessions · Sunday, November 8 · Evening →