Saturday, November 7 · Evening
Five recollections, access concentration and the first jhana; guided metta
This talk covered access concentration and the first jhana, dipping into the second. The long Q&A was mostly about piti: how to ride it, calm it and keep it from becoming a goal. It ended with a guided metta practice.
Topics and questions in this session
Talk
- 0:00:00The five recollections (AN 5:57).
- 0:09:36Access concentration. The term is commentarial; its far end can be deeper than what many call jhana. Signs to look for.
- 0:13:20The signs of piti: electric, fizzing, sometimes heat and shaking.
- 0:14:54Riding a pleasant sensation up into piti, and piti up into the first jhana.
- 0:16:20The first jhana and the bathman simile (DN 2).
- 0:19:07Leigh Brasington's approach (build strong access first) versus Rob Burbea's (stay with piti as soon as it appears).
- 0:21:47Right effort and striving, without the hype.
- 0:23:38Shifting from the buzz of piti to the warmth of sukha: dipping into the second jhana.
- 0:25:31The jhana factors (MN 43).
- 0:28:34Appreciative attention: attend to the breath as you would to the eyes of someone you love.
Q&A
- 0:30:40Between formal sits, keep the nostril object or broaden to the body?
- 0:33:43When savoring piti, the sense of the body gets less clear.
- 0:36:26Piti alongside sleepiness: sloth and torpor can coexist with piti.
- 0:36:26Bouncing between the breath and pain. Moving piti into the pain.
- 0:39:23Leigh's method versus Rob's when piti is present.
- 0:43:35Shades of metta: learning what metta is over hours of practice.
- 0:46:40Heat, sweating and jolts. Calming excess piti with a long out-breath, moving attention down the body, or a foreground–background switch.
- 0:51:29Working with expectation after early piti.
- 0:54:26The "quick and dirty" route to access concentration, demonstrated on the tip of a finger.
- 0:59:48Eyes open: keep a relaxed, unfocused gaze.
- 0:59:48Pain as an object, and the old Vietnamese monk who found that pain isn't solid.
- 1:04:00Fear and vertigo in deep access. Reassure yourself and bring in metta (MN 128).
Closing
- 1:10:19The Bhaddekaratta verses (MN 131) and the Metta Sutta, then guided metta, sending and receiving.
0:00:00Before we get on to the exciting topic of tonight's talk (access concentration and the first jhana, dipping into the second), I thought I'd give a little more context and framing. A bit of a downer before the upper. Some of you will be familiar with these: the five subjects for frequent recollection, a set of contemplations that the Buddha advised everyone, monastic and lay, to recollect frequently. I'll chant the lines in Pali, then go through them a little and invite you to reflect on them, likewise to provide more context for what we're doing here and why we might want to be doing it. Maybe it'll resonate, maybe not.1
0:01:07I am of the nature to age; I have not gone beyond aging. I'm not as spry as I used to be. Sometimes I have less energy. There are wrinkles in my face that weren't there before. My skin is getting weathered. My teeth don't look quite as good as they did. I'm not that old, but I can still notice these things. True of everyone here, I assume. Today has nearly passed us by. We were born, or so it seems, and the days and nights are relentlessly passing by. Older, not younger. Is this true? How often do we stop to think? I am of the nature to sicken; I have not gone beyond sickness. A couple of weeks ago (I didn't bother testing, because it wouldn't have made much difference to how I'd treat it) I think I got either the flu or COVID, and it knocked me right out for five days or so. Just bedridden, congested, feverish and terrible. Aches and pains, moans and groans. Phlegm coming out of my orifices. Terrible.
0:03:20We don't know how long we may enjoy the good health we all have. We're all in good enough health to get here, anyway. How do we want to use what health and youth we have? How do we want to care for ourselves and those around us, in sickness and in health? I am of the nature to die; I have not gone beyond dying. I am of the nature to die. Skin, bones, nails, teeth, organs: all of it will decay and come apart, no longer animated by vitality. By that time, looking back, will I be happy with how I've spent my life? Will you? And will I know just what it is that's dragged this corpse around all these many years? Or will I die still wondering? All that is mine, beloved and pleasing, will become otherwise, will become separated from me. At the time of death, if not before, everything I cling to, everything I cherish, everyone I know and love, any possessions I may accumulate, each and every one will change or be parted from me somehow.
0:06:16There's nothing we can hold on to, not permanently. Even if we try to cling, it will fall apart in our grasp. I am the owner of my action, heir to my action, born of my action, related to my action, and abide supported by my action. Whatever action I shall do, for good or for ill, of that I will be the heir. Moment after moment, with each intentional, volitional action, we condition our bodies and our minds and our future experience, and the primary determinant of our happiness and suffering is our own action, for good and for ill. Circumstances have a lot of influence, but whether we meet old age, sickness and death, and the inevitable loss of everything, with peace and understanding or with regret and confusion depends on us: on what we choose to do, moment after moment, with our time and our lives.
0:08:02Thus we should frequently recollect. So, depending on my whim, in the mornings or evenings for the rest of the retreat I'll go through those again, and I invite you all to feel into each as it's pertinent to you.
0:08:38The point of these, of course, is not to make us feel down or glum or grumpy, but to focus our minds on what's important. I know I've wasted an awful lot of time. I've hurt people close to me. I've hurt myself by being heedless and careless, not recognizing the preciousness of my own life and the lives of others around me.
0:09:36Okay, so picking up from this morning: when your mind has become collected, settled and stabilized with the breath or with metta (really with anything; you could stare at a doorknob and get this done, it doesn't matter), when the mind is free from the agitation and pulling apart and grasping of the hindrances, you may begin to notice that your mind doesn't waver or wobble as it does at the beginning of practice. You're on the object more than you're off it. Perhaps your body feels calm, light and clear. You may begin to see light behind your eyes. The train of thoughts and associations may slow and stutter, and stop for periods of time. This is not a term you'll find in the suttas, but there are a lot of good things that aren't in the suttas, so we can't hold that against it: access concentration, so called because it gives access to the jhanas. It's really a whole range, from relatively shallow, where you can just get your foot in the door, a wedge, and then walk in, to extremely deep.2
0:11:50In fact, the far end of access concentration is deeper than what most people call the jhanas, depending on the lineage of practice you're in. But for just getting your foot in the door, and this is a somewhat arbitrary standard, something to shoot for is 15 or so minutes on the object without serious interruption. By serious interruption we don't mean a wobble, a little unsteadiness, or a half-second slip and reorientation; it means you're never fully off the object and completely lost. When you're able to sustain that kind of continuity with the object for about 15 minutes, you may begin to get some of the signs I was talking about: light, different sensations in the body. You may feel parts of your body grow large or become small or disappear; all kinds of things may happen. There may be a ringing in your ears. At that point it's worth checking (and this may creep up on you)
0:13:20whether there isn't some pleasant, pleasurable sensation somewhere in the body. If you're working with metta, [unclear] the metta itself: it's plenty pleasant. But say you're working with the breath, you've been with it for about 15 minutes, and you look around in the body: oh, there's this really lovely glow in my hands. Oh, there's actually a kind of tingling there, huh? Whether there's tingling or not, if you have that stability of concentration, it's worth giving it a shot: find some pleasurable sensation in the body, switch your attention over to it, and stay with it for five minutes or so. The pleasant sensation may increase in volume or intensity, and you may begin to get the telltale signs of the arising of piti, this kind of electric, fuzzy, effervescent sizzling, which can show up differently for different people. It may also be accompanied by physical heat, and sometimes wobbly shaking. This too spans a whole range, from quite mild at the beginning to overwhelming in intensity, maybe so strong that it's actually unpleasant.
0:14:54But you can ride a pleasant sensation up into piti, and then ride the piti up into the first jhana, if you're able to stay with the object without serious interruption for that long. There are different approaches, but this is the way of instruction coming from Leigh and Ayya Khema and so on. All you have to do, dead simple, is stay with the pleasant sensation. It turns into piti; stay with the piti, and a natural feedback loop will get set up. At a critical threshold, both samadhi and the object, in this case piti, will go exponential and erupt, and you'll notice a simultaneous stepwise increase in the depth and stability of your absorption. It'll be as though your mind gets locked in or fused with the experience of rapture in the body, rapture and happiness, and the intensity will increase correspondingly, quite a bit. If you can hang out there, that's the first jhana. And for our purposes here, the first jhana also has quite a spectrum of breadth and depth.3
0:16:20I encourage you all, as you edge into this territory, not to worry so much about whether you're in or out. If you have piti and it will sustain your attention, and you can stay with it and have it increase and begin to spread through the body, great. Is it jhana? By whose standards? Who cares? If you come to me in an interview, I'll ask you more detailed questions about your experience, but I won't be holding up a measuring stick, so I invite you to drop yours too. The thing to keep in mind on this retreat and going forward is that there's a profound depth to be explored, if and when you want to, when you have the time and the inclination. It's really profound and beautiful, what the mind and body can do, and these incredible states are vast from the first one onward. This is the canonical description of the first jhana: "Quite secluded from sensuality, secluded from unskillful qualities, they enter and remain in the first jhana: rapture and pleasure born of seclusion, accompanied by directed thought and evaluation.4
0:17:42They permeate and pervade, suffuse and fill this very body with the rapture and pleasure born of seclusion. Just as if a dexterous bathman or bathman's apprentice would pour bath powder into a brass basin and knead it together, sprinkling it again and again with water, so that their ball of bath powder, saturated, moisture-laden, permeated within and without, would nevertheless not drip; even so, this very body is permeated by the rapture and pleasure born of seclusion. There is nothing of the entire body unpervaded by rapture and pleasure born of seclusion. This is a fruit of the contemplative life, visible here and now, more excellent than the previous ones and more sublime." This is a description of a really well-consolidated and stable first jhana. If there's much of an outline to the body at this point, the sense of the body may diffuse into a field of the relevant jhana factors, rather than something outlined in limbs; but top to bottom, side to side, back to front, it's evenly and totally saturated and pervaded by an even intensity of rapture and happiness. That spans the spectrum from quite refined, light or mild to something unearthly, orgasmic, comparable only with drug experiences.
0:19:07Take it further in intensity and absorption and the body will disappear completely; there's just a well-defined field of experience, vibrating at the relevant frequencies. That whole range is possible, and well worth exploring and experiencing for yourself. A lot of people on this retreat, myself included, are also fans of Rob Burbea, who (influenced by Thanissaro Bhikkhu and some other sources) teaches a slightly different approach from Leigh's, though not ultimately a contradictory one: as soon as you're able to get some pleasantness or piti, you just stay with it and build it up gradually. Leigh's approach is more like shaking a seltzer or Coca-Cola bottle until it's really fizzy and then it pops off. You do that by getting really strong access concentration, ideally. The stronger you get it before you turn to the piti, the more the piti is going to pop off. Or you just let it build and build in the background.
0:20:24That's very good; you'll get a very strong, very stable jhana that way. You can also, as soon as you're able to make contact with the piti, just stay with it, enjoy it and really savor it. And you can take a more active approach as well, massaging it or spreading it through the body with your attention. I've talked about this a little already, but these states are great. Getting high on your own supply is amazing. Why not? But what they afford, in progressively radical ways, is a stilling of the ordinary fabrication of our experience and a seclusion from our usual sensory involvements, in a way that lets us see really clearly (both entering and exiting, and depending on the depth of absorption, during the state) how we usually construct and construe our experience as solid, as me, as mine. On the basis of such a clear and well-collected mind, we can investigate the state, if we're not too absorbed, or as we emerge from it.
0:21:47We can investigate our mind and body and really see their nature. We can see the nature of our mind. And it's really fun, so it deserves the hype. I said a little already about striving and right effort, and I got some questions about it today in interviews. A retreat like this, and in fact most framings of practice, is goal-directed: we're here attempting to do something. And that's okay. Effort is not bad. Having a goal is not bad. Striving is not bad. Biting down on a wooden dowel like your life depends on it, tensing up your whole body, being really macho about things: that doesn't help much. If you catch yourself doing that, relax. But striving, persistence, diligence, having a goal and working to attain it: this is good, and it applies within the contemplative domain too. We have a couple of musicians in the room. If you want to play freestyle jazz, it really helps to know your scales really well, to be able to go up and down them and play around with chords and so on.
0:23:38So too with working on these fundamentals and gaining fluency and mastery of jhana. If you gain fluency and mastery with the principles involved in something like mindfulness of breathing or metta, and then fluency and comfort with the jhanas, you can do anything else in the contemplative domain and you will do very well. Your mind becomes very malleable, very pliable, very clear, and very enjoyably so. So make the effort, without clenching and clamping down, and put in the time, and you will get there. It also behooves me to say, because the first jhana can be uncomfortably intense for some people (it can come on so strong), in case that does happen to you and you're unfamiliar with it: if it's erupting and it's too intense, take a deep breath in and a long exhale out. While you're exhaling, sweep your attention down from the crown of your head through the floor, and switch your attention from the higher-frequency buzzing of the piti to the warm background pleasure of the happiness, the sukha.
0:25:31That should switch you over, or lean you towards the second jhana. At least the piti should come down. While I'm talking about the factors of jhana, I should probably mention the others. The first jhana is characterized by vitakka and vicara, directed thought and evaluation, as it's translated here. There may still be quite a bit of thinking in the first jhana. "Is this the first jhana? Whoa, this feels amazing. Whoa. How long should I stay here? I can't believe it." In the commentarial tradition these terms also refer to the initial and sustained application of attention, and that's something going on both in access concentration and in the first jhana: there's a more active holding. It's not fully cohered yet, as it is in the second jhana and beyond. And finally, ekaggata, usually translated as one-pointedness, which makes it sound as though there's some spatial restriction going on. That's not what the first jhana is like. But the mind is really cohered and collected; translations like "singleness" or "unity of mind"5
0:27:07make more sense. So, to reiterate, there's no expected pace for where people are or where you'll get to on this retreat. I want to deliver a roadmap and a lot of information that will hopefully be of use to you for the rest of your contemplative life. But this is your time, your practice, your retreat, your pace, your process, and your own body and mind are your own laboratory, your own artist's studio. You've got the brushes. You've got the palette. It's yours to play and work with. In these talks I'm giving a general exposition, and it's up to you. I'll help you as much as I can in the interviews and in Q&A, but it's really up to you to find your own way with the tools and the time available. I'll say just a little more about the attitude or approach to bring to one's meditation object, since it came up several times in interviews today.
0:28:34I tried to hint at this in the morning's instruction: a real kind of rapturous, almost entranced engagement. Like a beautiful silk brocade that you're gazing at, savoring its texture, or delicious food. The breath, the metta, your own bodily sensations: you can appreciate them as much as you do the eyes and gaze of someone you love, a gorgeous sunset, or a beautiful piece of art. If you can find beauty, a texture, a quality, a tone in your meditation object that you can appreciate more and more, it makes the whole process a pleasure from beginning to end, not a chore. And as the quality of your attention refines, you'll also notice a change in the object. Your breath might at first seem rough or coarse, or your bodily sensations disordered or unstable. There's a mutual dependence between the quality of attention you bring to the object and the object itself. So see if you can play around with that and find beauty in the breath, something to savor.
0:30:40Okay, that's all I've got to say on access concentration and the first jhana, dipping into the second. Tomorrow night I'll go into more depth and detail on the instructions for all of the first four jhanas. But now I'd like to leave plenty of time for any questions anyone may have about anything so far. Yes? "I've been using the breath at the tip of the nostrils as my object. When I'm between formal sits, should I continue to hold that, or should I use a broader mindfulness of the body? What would you suggest?" Either one, or some mixture of both, is good. In my own experience, if my mind is amenable to it, coming as close as possible to absolute continuity of mindfulness with a single object over a long period of time yields the quickest and best results in terms of depth of absorption. But this also came up in a bunch of interviews: attempting to prematurely wrestle your mind into submission ("Okay, only this object. That's it from now on. Don't you move")
0:32:06just doesn't work very well. You're liable to get frustrated, and parts of your mind will rebel. So do feel free to switch it up: a broader mindfulness of the body as you're moving around, or, if you're settled here with the breath during formal sessions, you can expand to take in the breath sensation through the rest of the body. For most people, most of the time, especially at the beginning of a retreat like this, attempting to narrow in and go for rigorous one-pointedness may not work so well, and you may just burn out and grind on it. But it's for you to experiment, explore and find out what works. Likewise, between the two ways of working with mindfulness of breathing that I briefly went over, and metta (this came up several times in interviews), feel free to add dashes: if you'd like to begin a sit with metta for a couple of minutes, or end with metta, great. You can bookend that way. Or if you want to start with a broader appreciation of bodily sensation, the breath through the body, and then narrow in, or narrow in and then widen out:
0:33:43there's no fixed rule set here about what will work best for you. You have to figure that out, and it won't necessarily always be the same. I'm keeping to three main methods of access (these two ways of working with the breath, and metta) because at the opposite end of the spectrum you could spend a whole retreat trying a thousand different things and not gain momentum with any of them. But don't feel too constrained. Time is limited, so explore. Find the balance for yourself. Hopefully by the end of day two, coming into day three, you'll have a good sense of what you're getting traction with, what's working, what you can double down on and take forward. You had your hand up first. "When tuning into piti and trying to savor it, sometimes, honestly, the sense of the body isn't as clear, and sometimes I can't tell whether I'm fading into distraction or actually going into the piti.
0:35:09Does that make sense?" Like whether the body is dissolving into the piti, or the piti is dissolving the body, or you're just lacking clarity about it? Say more. "Sometimes the piti is not super intense; it's kind of so-so, and then the sense of the body... I can't tell if I'm starting to go to sleep or if I'm really going into the piti." I don't associate piti with sleepiness, personally. "If it's very subtle, not very strong, it can be a more [unclear] quality rather than fast and spiky. You can almost relax into it, and it can have an almost relaxing quality." Yeah, this is good disambiguation. Piti can begin to manifest as waves of energy or sensation in the body that are pretty coarse-grained. It can also be fine, like mist, or really rapid, electric and high-frequency.
0:36:26Generally, the more concentrated you are, the more intense and high-frequency it is, and definitely not conducive to sleep. So there may be some piti present while you still have some of the hindrance of sloth and torpor, sleepiness, present: totally possible. The first really strong experience of piti I had happened when I was waking up from a nap. I had sleep paralysis, I was half awake, and for some reason it just kicked on. So, and you're all probably going to hear me say this a lot over the retreat: when in doubt, spend more time with the base object and get more concentrated. Is that helpful? "It is." Okay. All right. "So when I'm working with the breath and there's also pain in the body, I'm kind of bouncing between the two. I find it useful to attend to the breath and [unclear] the space around the pain.
0:37:58But then, if the pain moves somewhere else, it's like my object is always changing, so it feels like I can't really practice the same thing for very long. It could be somewhat stable, because the breath is always there. But is that maybe a problem?" You can gain continuity and momentum of concentration with an object that's moving around, or even with changing objects: you get a kind of momentary concentration like this doing vipassana, with shifting objects of experience. But if you notice that pain spots are moving around in the body, you might be better served staying with a whole-body focus, and again, doing whatever you can to get comfortable. If it's just whack-a-mole without improvement over a while, you may be better served going for a broader aperture. Another thing with pain, and this also works for difficult emotion: if you have a sense of the flow of the breath in the body (this is also true of metta) and you're able to direct it within the body,
0:39:23if there's a clear current of breath and sensation, you can breathe into the pain, move it through the pain, or bring metta to the pain. That may help, likewise, with emotional blocks or odd energetic complaints of uncertain origin. "When I attend to the space in between, piti often comes fairly soon after, and then I can kind of move it towards the pain." Yeah, if you can make contact with piti, it's a great natural painkiller. And if you can direct its flow and spread and expand it, as in the simile of the bathman and the bathman's apprentice: if you can be a dexterous bathman with the piti and spread it through areas of discomfort, you may find you're much more comfortable. "I was wondering if you could explain a little more about Leigh's method versus Rob Burbea's. The way I've been working is that when there's piti present, I try to really tune into it, and that has variable results.
0:40:50To be honest, I never stay very long in that really absorbed state. So I'm curious. And you were saying, with access concentration, we're confused about what that is. From what I can gather, it's the ability to pin the mind on an object?" Not necessarily pin, but have the mind be stably with the object. And in really deep access concentration it becomes more receptive than active. (On a silent retreat, teaching and talking all the time, I get tired.) What was the other part of your question? "The metaphor of shaking up a bottle... the difference between these, and Rob. When there is piti, should I...? So the two methods would be: stay with the object even in the presence of piti, or make the piti the object." Yes, two ways to go here. You could just stay with the primary object, the breath, and let the piti build and build. If it wants to sustain your attention when you go to it, it just stays, and then it's like, oh!
0:42:21You go through cycles of that again and again. Stay with the object for longer. If you think, "Oh, now is a good time, I could try to switch," do another 5 or 10 minutes, then try. That would be typical of Leigh's approach. Or, if you want to take the approach that could be more gradual for some people: with any sensitivity to piti at all, just ride it, just stay with it. You can spread it. It might decrease or it might increase, but as long as you can maintain contact with the piti, you can gradually build it up, like that lovely fire we have, slowly adding little bits of kindling until it's blazing. "And when you say spread it, is that an active choice, or is it a receptive opening to the piti?" Both can happen. If the piti is strong enough and your mind is malleable enough, the concentration strong enough, you can willfully direct it to flow through the body, and it can spread and sustain and intensify and increase.
0:43:35If you try that and it doesn't work, the concentration isn't quite strong enough yet, or the piti doesn't have enough sustain yet. And also, if it's relatively local at first and you just stay with the piti, it may spread all on its own, without you needing to do anything at all. Similar to metta: if you just energize the metta again and again with your attention, it may spread and radiate naturally, without intentional direction. Same kind of thing. "Thanks." Yeah. "I've been practicing with metta since our conversation this afternoon, which has been very lovely at times. I find, when I'm staying with it hour after hour, that when I first tune into the felt sensation it feels distinct enough. Over time I start getting curious: oh, that's more like affection, which is a little different from metta, and how is that related to bodhicitta? Not that I'm even lost in thought about it so much, but it feels like I'm chasing something thin, or a little uncertain."
0:44:56Yeah, these different qualities of the heart can have slightly different shades. The brahmaviharas are pretty close in feeling space; if they were on a color wheel, they'd be neighbors. And you don't need to analyze. If there's a warm openness in your heart that's full of goodwill and isn't grasping, that's good. You can work with that. Another layer is how it's being directed, and the intention behind it. But as an embodied felt sense, which is more what we're driving at, the cognitive and interpretive layers are not so relevant. Is that helpful? "Yeah, let me think for a moment. It just feels unavoidable that, as I direct my attention towards metta again and again over a long period of time, part of what I'm doing is learning what metta is, learning all its different shades and colors." Yeah, it won't be the same experience every time.
0:46:40It may boom or blossom in your chest differently, or have a slightly different textural quality, more strength or more femininity or this or that or whatever. None of this is an issue for building attention, for building concentration. And as the concentration deepens, as with piti, you may get a purer, more refined tone as the coherence develops, and you may be able to pick it out more clearly in a process of refinement. But enjoy the variability. Enjoy all the shades. "I've been having this experience of heat and sweating. Most times it's moderate, and I can be okay with it. But the last time we sat together it was intense, so intense, and it spread through my body, and I just wanted to cry and go away. Thoughts were coming in, trying to make sense of it, telling me to stay with it, and then it just [unclear], amplifying, and I'm like, man, I feel like I'm in a fire pit or a volcano.
0:47:58I don't know if this is a teaching or not, but I felt like I wanted to cry, to escape, so I thought, I'll just cry, and I had some tears, and then I kind of let go. It didn't feel as uncomfortable in terms of wanting to run away, but it was very hot, too hot. Does that get better? Is that part of it? I'm new to this; I don't know. When you said heat, I thought, okay, I've had lots of heat, and sometimes it's comfortable but sometimes it's really uncomfortable." Yeah. Some people get heat along with the sensation of piti; they might get heat without the sensation, or one might come before the other. When I first started getting into access concentration regularly, I'd be drenched in sweat sometimes; sometimes I'd get that and sometimes I wouldn't. These days it still seems to be a sometimes thing: if it's really strong and I really ramp up the intensity, I'll sweat, unless I'm in a well-ventilated space.
0:49:14It's something you can eventually develop an ability to modulate, and you might just not want to spend that much time in the first jhana, or in the territory of the first jhana. You can calm the piti with what I was talking about earlier, taking a deep breath out and sweeping the attention down through the body, and see if that modulates the heat or the rising energy at all. And if it's not physically uncomfortable, it can also be really enjoyable: okay, I'm sweaty and really hot, but the heat can actually be experienced as a form of bliss. I know there are some tummo practitioners in the room. [unclear] this kind of heat. There are some contemplative methodologies that deliberately [unclear] this intense bodily production of heat and bliss and take it to higher and higher levels. So, yeah, it's a good sign. "Likewise the electricity. I didn't know that was a thing, because I do experience it, and that's when, like I mentioned, it feels like an electrical shock and I can't help but move.
0:50:26I'm sorry if I disrupt anybody, but my legs [jolt] out, and I can't control it, because it's like electricity. To me that's an intensity, because sometimes I feel it without the jolting. Could the breath help that situation as well?" Yeah, 100%. If you feel there's too much current moving through and it's coming out in tremors, a long exhale and sweeping the attention down through the body may help to calm it. Also, see if you can do a bit of a foreground-background switch. If there's a warmer, more diffuse, softer quality present in the body, take the attention and the energy away from the electricity and the heat and shift it more to that warmer, softer quality of happiness. It's a little quieter. Along with the long out-breath and the sweeping down, you may be shifting into the calmer, cooler waters of the second jhana.
0:51:29And don't worry: it's a room full of weirdos here. If you're [unclear] over there, we'll just assume you're having a good time. "So, someone said [unclear], and switching from that, it might become more refined. Are you drawing a parallel with these methods: if you develop this concentration and then switch, that might send you deeper?" Yeah, for sure. In my experience, anyway, that principle is fully generalizable: the deeper the access concentration you have with any object, when you then shift to some other practice (you could get incredibly absorbed with mindfulness of breathing and then switch to metta), it will just pop off. It'll be incredibly strong right from the get-go. And folks online, I'm always looking over, so if you have a question, just unmute and jump in. "Yes, I'm wondering if you could say something about working with expectation. Now that I've had some experiences with [piti], it's like, okay, great, now that I've been attending to the breath for a while, I expect it to come.
0:53:05I'm still sensing the breath, but I can also tell there's something else that's sort of getting in the way. I can sort of let it go and just put more energy into the breath, but do you have any techniques for that?" Yeah. When the anticipation arises, let it be the same as any other unnecessary mental activity. If the anticipation is showing up as a tensing or bracing, or as a kind of giddiness, just let it be. Don't feed it; don't push it away. Likewise, if there's a thought like, "Oh, we just felt the shiver of [unclear]. Is that it? Can I have some more of that, please?", just let that pass by too. Sometimes people are told not to have expectations in practice, and then for the next sit, or several days of the retreat, it's: "Okay, no expectations. I'm not expecting anything. I'm not." Then they're trying not to try, or trying not to expect something. So, as best you can,
0:54:26let whatever is arising in your mind and body arise, without engaging with that whole area of expectation, and just come back again and again to the actual sensations, the actual practice. You'll be fine. Is that helpful? "Yeah. Could you give the quick and dirty again about getting into access concentration? I'm noticing I want to hear the mechanism for going into access concentration again, because hearing you talk about it just now, it hit me: okay, that's what I need to focus on, for me personally. Do you get the question?" Okay, a lesson for everybody. This is everything I've learned about samatha in over a decade of loving samatha. We're all going to look at my finger. Here's my finger, the index finger on my right hand. Look at the tip, and just gently rest your gaze on the tip of my finger. We're not trying to squeeze the tip of my finger with our eyeballs.
0:56:06Don't furrow your brow. Relax your body. Just gently rest your gaze, without straining, not looking left or right or up or down: just place and rest your attention. Whatever else may be going on (other sensations in the body, sounds in the room, other things in the visual field), let it all be there. It's totally fine. Your only job is to let your attention rest and remain on the tip of the finger. You don't care about anything else; it's none of your business. You don't need to block it out. You don't need to suppress it. You don't need to chase it. Leave it be. You do this long enough, and when you find that your gaze wanders or your mind moves completely off the object, no big deal. Whoops. Let it go. Come right back. Do that long enough, enough times. And when you drift away, don't then push away whatever you got caught by, yank your attention back and grip back on with a fierce grip.
0:58:12That's a whole lot of wasted energy. You'll get tired, and you won't have much fun that way. It drifts: oh, no big deal. Let it go. Come back. Do that enough times for long enough, with the tip of my finger, with metta, with the breath, with a doorknob, a colored disc, a visualized image, it doesn't matter, and the hindrances will slow and fade away and fall off. Your body will become light and clear, like a crystal vase. You'll be filled with assurance and coherence and calm and collectedness, and bliss and rapture will be born just from the power of your mind settling. Before you know it, you'll be deep into access concentration, on the cusp of the first jhana, if not falling into it. "Good. That was fantastic, so helpful. To the extent that it matters, are you trying to keep your eyes focused, or letting them go completely unfocused?" It doesn't matter. Well, as a practical point, if you're using an external visual object, your gaze in that case is actually focused, more or less.
0:59:48You're engaging focal vision. And if you want to use an external visual object, about an arm's length away is pretty good: put something on a wall or on a table in front of you. Generally, though, if you're meditating with eyes open, keep a relaxed, unfixated, unfocused gaze. "Has anyone ever told you that you have a lovely [finger]?" I'm not going to answer that question. "Using pain as a meditation object has come up a couple of times, and I take people's word for it that it's possible to experience the sensations of pain without aversion. But when I introspect on my own feeling of pain, it's basically impossible for me to imagine what that would be like, because the aversion seems built into the sensation. So I'm curious whether you could say something about what's going on there. Is there some sort of phase shift in the experience of pain when a certain amount of concentration is achieved?
1:01:24Or is it just gradual: it bothers you less as your mind is less agitated about it, all the way down?" Aspects of all of what you said. But to make it vivid, I can pull out a story. When I thought I was going to ordain, in Thich Nhat Hanh's order, there was an older Vietnamese monk responsible for training us in monastic etiquette. He was in his 40s and had been a monk since he was 13, trained in the old style, in the Vietnamese equivalent of Rinzai. He told us how he had been trained at 13: "Oh yeah, you wake up at 3:30 a.m. and you sit for three hours in full lotus without moving. At first it's terribly painful. Oh my God, the pain, unbelievable." By the way, he's the only person I've ever met who could put his legs up into full lotus without using his hands.6
1:02:36He said, "It's funny. At first you think pain is this solid thing. No. You sit for long enough, and you realize the pain comes like this, and there's a gap. Pain, no pain. Pain, no pain. Pain, no pain. And if you start paying more attention to the no-pain, the gaps between the spikes of pain, then your mind gets really settled, and you can start to play and have a lot of fun." That's a bit of an extreme example, but it is like that: the kind of phase shift you're talking about. With a calm, clear and collected mind, whether you get it by focusing on pain or on something else, you can discern that what appears to be a solid block of sensation is not. You can see through it and pick it apart, and it may also begin to move and undulate and break up. You can see the gaps, and also that it flows. The artifact of your perceiving it as a solid, awful block is dependently arisen with the aversion you're manifesting.
1:04:00In fact, the more averse you are to it, the more solid and immovable it will seem. Is that helpful? "Yeah, I think so. I have noticed it doesn't really seem solid when I pay attention to it; there's a kind of waviness. But it goes from very unpleasant to extremely unpleasant, rather than having gaps of no pain." So you have to sit for three hours in full lotus. Okay. No, but it's good that you're able to notice that; now follow it further down the stack, to its logical conclusion. And again, we're talking a lot about pain. Not to force anyone here: make yourself comfortable, or move to a chair, or if you feel like working with pain, work with pain. "I have a question. It isn't physical pain; it's more like fear. A lot of times when I go deep into access concentration, I get into a state where it feels like vertigo, like I'm falling.
1:05:28A lot of fear comes up. I know I'm physically safe, but there's still a lot of fear, and it's really hard to find gaps in the fear. The mind is seriously going, 'I'm falling, I'm dying.' How would one work with that?" There are a couple of thresholds in the jhanic arc where fear is likely to come up. One is deepening into access concentration. The body may become very still. You may feel like you're falling through the ground, or floating up into the air; body parts may be doing weird things. The experience may just be very intense. You may feel a loss of control, a loss of orientation. So: normal. Part of it is just an acclimatization issue. If any of you had the experience as a kid of learning to swim in the deep end: you might have gone just up to the edge where your feet were beginning to lose contact with the bottom, and you'd push off a little, float for a second, bear floating for just half a second, and then put your foot down.7
1:06:43And then you're able to do it a little longer. Progressing into deeper levels of samadhi can be like that, and it's really something your body has to learn is okay, is safe, much more so than your mind. You can know conceptually, "I'm safe. I'm just meditating. I'm sitting here, still. I'm fine. I'm hydrated. I'm fine." Your body doesn't know that. When I was first starting to hit this territory, along with the sweats I would get shivers and shakes of panic, along with the heat and the electric sensations. Sometimes my body would almost convulse, and I'd nearly jump up: "Oh, what? Oh, no." So don't overtax yourself. Take a break, take a breather, splash some water on your face. But it can just be a process of acclimatization. Also bring in some leavening with metta, to make your emotional and physical being comfortable and reassured.
1:08:04I've never heard of anyone trying this, but a weighted blanket might help. I don't know; worth a try. Is that helpful? "Yeah. I'm trying to figure it out, because a lot of times that fear creates an aversion to actually meditating. It's almost like a vicious cycle. So what I'm hearing is that once I get into that territory, it's better to be more conservative and gentle rather than trying to keep pushing." Yeah. Or you could be like me and just white-knuckle it again and again. No, I don't really recommend that. Another thing you can do (you'll lose a little depth of concentration) is just open your eyes and reorient, touch your body: "Okay, yep, still here, all good." That may bring things down. There's no need to rush. Okay. No more questions? No more questions. To close out the talking portion of the evening, I'll give some brief guidance to conclude each evening.
1:10:19We'll meditate together until 9. Before we go on a brief break, though, these are verses on a shining night of prosperity. Gathered here together with such fine folks, meditating: that's what I call a night of prosperity. "One should not revive the past, nor speculate on what's to come. The past is left behind; the future is unrealized. In every presently arisen state, there, just there, one clearly sees. Unmoved and unagitated, such insight is one's strength. Ardently doing one's task today, for tomorrow, who knows? Death may come. Facing the mighty hordes of death, indeed, one cannot strike a deal. To dwell with energy aroused, thus, for a night of non-decline: that is a night of shining prosperity. So it was taught by the peaceful sage." Thank you, everybody. We'll gather back in 10 minutes for a briefer concluding meditation with a little guidance. Okay, I think it's been about 10 minutes; I forget when we broke. We'll just do a little metta to close out the day: the Metta Sutta as a closing lullaby.8
1:11:58Now [the] chant of the Buddha's words on loving-kindness. "This is what should be done by one who is skilled in goodness and who knows the path of peace: let them be able and upright, straightforward and gentle in speech, humble and not conceited, contented and easily satisfied, unburdened with duties and frugal in their ways, peaceful and calm and wise and skillful, not proud or demanding in nature. Let them not do the slightest thing that the wise would later reprove. Wishing: in gladness and in safety, may all beings be at ease. Whatever living beings there may be, whether they are weak or strong, omitting none, the great or the mighty, medium, short or small, the seen and the unseen, those living near and far away, those born and to be born, may all beings be at ease. Let none deceive another or despise any being in any state. Let none, through anger or ill will, wish harm upon another. Even as a mother protects with her life her child, her only child, so with a boundless heart should one cherish all living beings, radiating kindness over the entire world, spreading upwards to the skies and downwards to the depths, outwards and unbounded, freed from hatred and ill will. Whether standing or walking, seated or lying down, free from drowsiness,9
1:13:41one should sustain this recollection. This is said to be the sublime abiding. By not holding to fixed views, the pure-hearted one, having clarity of vision, being freed from all sense desires, is not born again into this world." And even for those heretics among us who hew to the later Buddhist tradition and the non-duality of samsara and nirvana, we don't have to take that last part so literally: rather, seeing through the born to the unborn, which is the nature of all of this already. Metta helps. So, whether standing or seated (I don't think anyone's walking; some of us are lying down, maybe not so free from drowsiness), feel into the area around your heart and bring a smile to your face. You may be able to contact the feeling of loving-kindness directly and settle in with it right away, without any additional scaffolding; or, if it helps, call to mind a being (a friend, a pet, some celestial being or bodhisattva, yourself). It's all good. Whatever is easy and allows you to make contact with that feeling in and around your heart, of goodwill, of open warm-heartedness. Phrases too, as you like.
1:16:05May you be happy. May you be well.
1:17:05Anything and everything that helps the arising and sustaining, and if you like, the increase, of the metta, you can bring in. You can get creative with it. You can imagine golden light pervading and filling you and spreading outwards towards the being you wish goodwill for, spreading outwards and filling this room, all of us. May we all be happy. May we all be well.
1:20:08Metta is really a remarkable thing. The more you give, the more you receive. The deeper you go with it, the blurrier that boundary becomes: giver and receiver, self and other.
1:20:47May we all be happy. May we all be well.
1:23:18If you're able to have some sustained contact with the metta, whether it's localized someplace in the body or you can feel it radiating out into the space around, see if you can find the texture of it that is most enjoyable. Maybe it's brighter or smoother.
1:24:17By tuning in to what's enjoyable and deepening into concentration, you may also find arising some tingling, a feeling of electric current, heat, however it may show up. If any of that is present, you don't need to turn to it, but you can let it be part and parcel of the field of metta that's radiating from you.
1:25:01If you lose contact with the metta or it fades away, re-spark it with intention, with a little scaffolding: imagination, phrases, imagery, memory, whatever works. If you have trouble directing or feeling metta, especially towards yourself, it can also work better sometimes to practice receiving it, from someone else, an actual person or an imagined other. Right now we don't actually have to imagine, so here's a little experiment. Right now, make a choice whether you're going to be sending or receiving. If you're sending, begin sending metta to everyone in the room, including yourself, and everyone online.
1:26:31And if you're receiving, know that right now at least a bunch of the people gathered here are sending you nothing but goodwill. They are sincerely wishing for your happiness, for your well-being.
1:28:20Okay. If you were sending, switch. If you were receiving, switch.
1:29:17May we all be happy. May we all be well.
1:32:40Thank you. And for the last couple of minutes, radiate that feeling of goodwill, or at least intend for it to radiate, to all beings near and far. Everyone here. Everyone in the locale where you are. The city.
1:33:14Expanding to encompass the state.
1:33:30The country.
1:33:40The continent. The whole world. Finally, boundlessly, everywhere, without limit, without measure, without border or boundary, in all directions, throughout all space and time: may all beings be well; may all beings be happy.
1:38:45Okay, everyone, thank you and good night. A reminder: as you prepare for bed and move into the next thing, keep the practice going. Whether it's metta or the breath, as you're falling asleep, see if it can be the last thing you're aware of as you drift off, and the first thing you're aware of when you wake up in the morning. Definitely, before you move, before you get out of bed, re-establish the practice and keep it going as you stand up and start moving around.
1:39:25Okay, good night.
Sources
- The five subjects for frequent recollection (aging, illness, death, separation, kamma) AN 5:57 Upajjhatthana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN5_57.html ↩
- Access concentration (“not a term you’ll find in the suttas”) Correct: upacara-samadhi is commentarial. The closest canonical picture of the threshold is AN 3:102 (the dirt-washer) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN3_102.html ↩
- Leigh Brasington’s method (via Ayya Khema): shift to a pleasant sensation, let piti build. Leigh Brasington, Right Concentration: A Practical Guide to the Jhanas (Shambhala, 2015) ↩
- The first jhana formula and the bathman simile. DN 2 Samaññaphala Sutta (also AN 5:28) dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN02.html ↩
- Jhana factors: directed thought and evaluation (vitakka, vicara), singleness (ekaggata) MN 43 Mahavedalla Sutta lists the first jhana’s five factors. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN43.html ↩
- Pain seen as gaps and flux rather than a solid block. SN 36:6 Sallatha Sutta (the second arrow) dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN36_6.html ↩
- Fear and falling sensations at the threshold of absorption. MN 128 Upakkilesa Sutta: the Buddha’s own “panic” and other obstacles to concentration. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN128.html ↩
- Verses on “a night of shining prosperity” MN 131 Bhaddekaratta Sutta (Thanissaro: “An Auspicious Day”) dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN131.html ↩
- Chanted Metta Sutta. Khp 9 / Sn 1:8 Karaniya Metta Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/Khp/khp9.html ↩