Saturday, November 7 · Morning
Mindfulness immersed in the body: breath and metta, the five hindrances; guided whole-body breathing
The first morning introduced the two main techniques for the retreat, breath and metta, and the five hindrances that get in the way. It closed with a guided body scan and whole-body breathing.
Topics and questions in this session
Talk
- 0:00:00Breath and metta as the two main routes to jhana (MN 10, MN 119).
- 0:01:49The Satipatthana opening. Keep mindfulness going in the shower, at meals and on walks.
- 0:06:15Mindfulness of breathing (MN 118), with a short guided sit.
- 0:12:04Two ways to work with the breath: the whole body, or the entrance to the nostrils.
- 0:14:19The basic loop: notice the drift, release it, return, with an appreciative attitude.
- 0:17:14Metta (AN 8:63): phrases and images as scaffolding, dropped once the felt sense holds on its own.
- 0:28:22The five hindrances in practice (DN 2). They're habits, worn away by not feeding them (SN 46:51).
- 0:36:49The DN 2 similes for freedom from the hindrances, and the chain from gladness to concentration.
- 0:40:00A whole retreat spent deepening access concentration would still be well spent.
Q&A
- 0:26:46Do you stay with the breath during metta? No, metta is the object then. Switching is fine, but test it.
- 0:42:20What are the five hindrances again?
- 0:44:00Aversion to the sensation at the nostrils. Come to the nostrils from an already settled place, or use another spot.
- 0:45:22Physical pain. Get curious about its texture, or attend to the space around it (SN 36:6).
- 0:50:49Procrastination, and anxiety about loose ends at home.
- 0:53:25Spasms and involuntary jerks.
- 0:54:50Does a narrow object give stronger concentration than a broad one?
- 0:57:03Will the guided practice be on Zoom? Yes.
- 0:58:53If you're exhausted, take a nap rather than slog.
Guided practice
- 1:01:11Body scan, then whole-body breathing. Closing notes on the lute simile (AN 6:55) and walking with the gaze downcast.
0:00:00Okay, here we go again. I hope everyone has had a good morning of practice. (Oh, I became very blurry all of a sudden, here and online.) I gave pretty bare instructions at the end last night, just referring to the Satipatthana Sutta, the four foundations of mindfulness, and mindfulness immersed in the body. Mindfulness of breathing and the brahmaviharas, probably metta, are the two primary techniques I'll be teaching on this retreat as a means of generating sufficient samadhi for the hindrances to subside, the jhana factors to arise, and then to move into absorption proper. Both of these, mindfulness of breathing and the brahmaviharas, take place within the frame of the body. Whether you're working with the sensations of breath at the nostrils, in the abdomen or throughout your whole bodily frame, or you're eliciting and sustaining attention on the affective feeling of metta or one of the other brahmaviharas, this all takes place in the body. And again, I gestured at it last night, but continuity of mindfulness, continuity of practice all the time, and especially on retreat, really makes a massive difference.12
0:01:49I'm not sure how many hours we'll all actually be sitting or lying down or walking in formal sessions. But there's an awful lot of time when you're standing or walking or waiting around or eating or going to the bathroom, brushing your teeth, having a shower. All of these times we're not on our phones, I hope. We don't need to be talking to anyone. We don't need to be talking to ourselves most of the time. So all of that time you can be immersed in your bodily sensations. And if you're working with mindfulness of breath or metta, you can get creative: radiate metta out from the shower to everybody else on retreat. As an act of goodwill, don't take too long a shower. Practical applications. I'll go over this bit on mindfulness of the body again briefly, and the great pitch for the foundations of mindfulness: "This is the direct path for the purification of beings, for the overcoming of sorrow and lamentation, for the disappearance of pain and distress, for the attainment of the right method, and for the realization of unbinding," of nirvana.3
0:03:17In other words, the four establishings of mindfulness, and this morning we're mostly going to be talking about the first: "remaining focused on the body in and of itself, ardent, alert, and mindful, subduing greed and distress with reference to the world." This is a great line; there's a lot here. Subduing greed and distress with reference to the world: what does that mean? Often our attention is bound up in visual and auditory and conceptual objects in our sense experience, and there's a relationship either of greed ("Oh yes, this, I've got to hold on to this, I want more of this. That's over there, I would like it, I want it, I have to go over there, I have to bring that to me") (in the most basic sense, that's all a low-level manifestation of what's being referred to as greed here, a kind of dualistic clutching, grabbing, pulling, holding), or of distress, a manifestation of aversion: "Oh no, not that guy snoring next to me. Oh no. The sound of someone chewing. Ugh."
0:04:42Traditionally, in an idealized monastic environment, you would come together for alms round and communal meals, and then you'd go out to your separate solitary huts to do most of these practices. We don't have separate solitary huts here, so in a retreat environment one of the many things you get to work with, and to see in your mind moment by moment, is how you relate to the circumstances around you, within and without. The whole field of your perception is the field of your practice. When you notice this pendulation of greed and distress with reference to the objects of your experience, that right there is a notification that your mindfulness has lapsed: the energy that you could be consolidating and cohering and bringing back into the body, moment after moment, has gone out. So this is a very good way to train oneself, not only in a retreat environment but all the time. Impatience, frustration, anger, elation, hope, worry, fear: all of these really are, again, signs that mindfulness has lapsed.
0:06:15And how does one remain focused on the body in and of itself? As I was saying: "There is the case where a monk, having gone to the wilderness" (or Gabe's house) "to the shade of a tree, or to an empty building, sits down, folding legs crosswise, holding their body erect, and establishing mindfulness to the fore." I kid you not, there are entire essays about that one line, "mindfulness to the fore." What the hell does that mean? You're setting up mindfulness on your subject; mindfulness in front. You could read it a bunch of different ways. "Always mindful, you breathe in. Always mindful, you breathe out." So here, in this sutta and elsewhere, mindfulness of breathing is taught as a way of bringing all four foundations of mindfulness to their culmination, and also as the means of subduing the hindrances and accessing jhana. So rather than talk a whole lot about it, let's actually go through a brief guided practice with mindfulness of breathing. Uh-oh, some people showed up late. Sorry to those who were left waiting in the waiting room; we're just about to jump into mindfulness of breathing, a short guided session.4
0:07:38However you're comfortable. Do we have an extra cushion for you? Yeah, thank you. You can also get a chair from upstairs if you're more comfortable. That one's great, thank you. So, as before, settle into your posture like a pile of wet bags, letting the body and breath, everything, settle as completely as you can. It can be nice at the beginning to inhale at an extended length and exhale at an extended length. Then, on the inhale and the exhale, just feel within the field of your bodily sensations the effect that the inhale and exhale have. You may feel a swelling, a tingling, a rising, locally or globally throughout the field of your bodily sensations on the inhale. On the exhale you may feel a calming, a settling. It's almost as though, with each in- and out-breath, the whole field of bodily sensation is like a bellows, or a balloon inflating and deflating. Any time your attention is drawn to a thought, a sound or some other sensation, if you find it captured by an itch, a pain in the knee, whatever it is, notice that your attention has drifted and narrowed, release it, and reorient to the whole field of your bodily sensation, feeling the in- and out-breath again.
0:10:21As the actual text goes: "Breathing in long, you discern that you're breathing in long; breathing out long, you discern that you're breathing out long. Or breathing in short, you discern, 'I'm breathing in short'; breathing out short, you discern that you're breathing out short." There's a tendency, as you deepen into samadhi, for the breath to become more relaxed, but it can also become shallow. Past a certain point you may not be able to feel yourself breathing, but if that happens you can still maintain contact with a kind of echo of the breath sensation. "You train yourself, 'I will breathe in sensitive to the entire body'; you train yourself, 'I will breathe out sensitive to the entire body.' You train yourself, 'I will breathe in calming bodily fabrication'; training yourself, breathing out calming bodily fabrication. Just as a dexterous turner or his apprentice" (imagine a potter here, perhaps) "when making a long turn, discerns, 'I'm making a long turn,' or when making a short turn, discerns, 'I'm making a short turn'; in the same way," when breathing in long you know you're breathing in long, when breathing out long you know you're breathing out long, and likewise calm the bodily fabrication on the in- and out-breaths.5
0:12:04There are many ways of working with mindfulness of the breath, more passive and more active, and you've got some time on this retreat, and the rest of your life, to try out a whole bunch. But here I'm going to focus on just two. There's the whole-body breathing we've been going over just now, where you're oriented to the whole space of your bodily sensations, and whenever your attention narrows and contracts down within the body, or externally on some distraction, or gets caught by thought, you notice, release, and reorient to the whole space of the body and the breath's effect on that whole space. You're not trying to make anything happen or control anything. A little elongated breathing at the beginning can be nice, but that's about it. Another very powerful way of working with mindfulness of the breath is, without (I can't stress this enough) without tightening your mind like a vise around the object, gently placing your attention, like putting a kitten into a soft bed, at the entrance to your nostrils, where you can discern the passage of air flowing in and out.
0:14:19You don't need to shut out any other sensation, but you're gently focusing here, gently holding, through the whole length of the in-breath and in the gaps between (when the in-breath ends, before the out-breath begins; when the out-breath ends, before the in-breath begins), keeping your attention landed there. What can make these kinds of practices difficult is that they're extraordinarily simple. They're really not asking much of your mind at all. And because they're so simple, all of our habits of complication will arise in the form of the hindrances, and our job also gets simple: when we notice that our mind has drifted, notice, release, and return right back to the whole body or the tip of the nose. Something about the attitude, the appreciative attention you bring to this or any meditation object: imagine you're brushing your hand over, and admiring with your gaze, the most beautiful silk brocade, incredibly soft, luxurious, beautiful to behold. If you can bring that kind of attention to your object, it's not a chore, and you'll discover that the quality of your enjoyment of the present moment of consciousness has far more to do with your orientation and the quality of your attention.
0:17:14The object is almost irrelevant. So I leave it to you. If you're going to work with mindfulness of breathing, you can work with one or both of these and try them out. Not to give you too many options, but sometimes it can be nice: I like to start breathing with the whole body, sensitive to that, and then, once my mind has settled a bit, narrow in to the nostrils. But there's no fixed right way, so troubleshooting and individual clarification I'll leave to Q&A and interviews. Are there any questions about mindfulness of breathing before I move on to loving-kindness, metta? If not, okay. For metta, likewise, this is a lovely passage, which has each of the brahmaviharas fulfilling the four foundations and moving through the qualities of jhana as well: "You should train yourself thus: 'Goodwill, as my awareness-release, will be developed, pursued, given a means of transport, given a grounding, steadied, consolidated, and well-undertaken.' That's how you should train yourself. When you have developed this concentration in this way, you should develop this concentration with directed thought and evaluation."6
0:20:02I'm going to pause there. "With directed thought and evaluation": that's vitakka and vicara, factors of the first jhana. In the first jhana, compared to later ones, there's much more orienting and active attentional engagement on an intentional level, but it also just literally means some kind of cogitation, some thinking process. And for metta, at the beginning we often need some scaffolding, some support for the arising of the feeling. So, again jumping into actual practice: imagine in front of you, as a felt sense or as an image or a memory, some being (a pet, a friend, anyone) for whom it's easy and natural to have a spontaneous feeling of goodwill. Imagine that being right in front of you, adopt a slight smile, and feel into the area around your heart. There may already be a kind of warmth, openness, a softness, a spark. If you're feeling that, that's the primary meditation object. And phrases like "May you be well, may you be happy" (I think some of us here have stickers to that effect)
0:21:44serve as supportive conditions for the arising of the feeling in the body, as does any visualization or memory or anything else you may be using. So, with phrases or visualization or a felt sense or memory, whatever, as with the breath, let your attention rest and absorb and immerse in that sensation around the heart. May you be well. May you be happy.
0:22:42If the feeling fades away, you may need to bring in the supports more strongly, or just stay with the supports until the feeling arises. But once you have some sustain with the felt sense of metta in the body, you can begin to drop the supports and become more fully immersed and absorbed in the feeling itself. It can take on a life of its own without need of anything else. Whether you're using the breath in one of these two ways or some other way, or metta or one of the other brahmaviharas, stay with it, bringing your mind back again and again over minutes and hours. Your mind will clear. Thoughts will slow and settle. Greed and distress with reference to the world will be subdued. Your mind will leap up and have a kind of steadfast security with the object.
0:24:52The metta may fill the body and expand out beyond. The breath may begin to feel like movements of energy, something less physical, and with either, the jhana factors may begin to arise. Or you may find that you're slogging through the hindrances, which is what I'll turn to now, after leaving space for any questions about the technique of metta. I have an ambitious slate of topics for the retreat, so I'm moving at a relatively fast clip. Please stop me and interject and clarify things, either here or in interviews. "Some clarification about what you were saying about the primary meditation object: at a certain point, should you just stop thinking at all about the being you were initially thinking about to cultivate the sensation? How do you know when to shift fully to the sensation?" Yeah. I don't think the audio from the room is getting through; you didn't hear the question, did you? Or you did? You did hear the question. Oh, great. That wasn't working last night. I don't know why it's working now; I won't question it.
0:26:46When the sensation is sustained (when you move your attention to it and it doesn't decrease, and you can stay with it steadily) after a while you'll just have a felt sense. You'll know when you don't need to gin up anything more. But you may have to test it: is it time now? If I drop the supports, the phrases, the sense of the being, does it stay for a little bit and then go away? Does it stay and increase? It's nothing you need to figure out in advance. But as a rule of thumb, if it will hold your attention, you can start to drop off the supports. "Are you still with the breath the entire time?" Thank you for the question. Within these first couple of days, you may find that you want to switch between breath and metta, or between different ways of working with the breath or metta. I'm not going to put a time on it, but I do recommend that sometime today or tomorrow, or on the third day at the latest, you pick a primary method and start to keep it going all the time, whether you're standing, walking, sitting or lying down.
0:28:22As you're falling asleep, as soon as you wake up, while you're eating, while you're sweeping: that's your job, really, all the time. Once you've chosen, once you've got a sense (maybe you already have one) of which of these objects you're most comfortable with and have some traction with, just stay with it with gentle persistence, and you can build up a really incredible momentum with it. Eventually you can reach the place where it's actually [unclear] object. That's a good sign. Does that answer the question? "And are you just staying with the breath the entire time, through the metta practice?" Oh, through the metta practice. No. If you're working with metta, leave the breath. You may notice it in the periphery; that's fine. But no. Okay. I'm going to talk about access concentration and the first jhana in more detail tonight, but as it's the first morning, a little more about the hindrances, which most of us encounter, at least to some extent, when we actually try to practice.
0:30:18Again, with the monastic model in mind, this is what the sutta says; this is from the Samaññaphala Sutta: "Endowed with this noble aggregate of virtue" (okay, so we're all keeping our behavior in check; we don't have any cause for remorse; we're all good, so when we sit down our mind isn't too troubled), "this noble restraint over the sense faculties" (we're not looking around, grabbing and reaching and fantasizing), "this noble mindfulness and alertness, and this noble contentment, they seek out a secluded dwelling: a wilderness, the shade of a tree, a mountain, a glen, a hillside cave, a charnel ground" (not popular these days; if you ever do get a chance to meditate with a corpse, I recommend it) "a forest grove, the open air, a heap of straw. After the meal, returning from alms round, sitting down, crossing legs, holding the body erect, bringing mindfulness to the fore, abandoning covetousness with regard to the world..." Covetousness: wanting. This is also often glossed as sense desire. There's some object we have some longing for, often due to long habituation (food, sex, food, music) that our mind is preoccupied with, wandering off and reaching for.7
0:31:47That's a hindrance. Thankfully, it's just habit, and you wear away habits by not feeding them and redirecting the mind again and again. "Abandoning ill will and anger, dwelling with an awareness devoid of ill will, sympathetic with the welfare of all living beings." It's hard to meditate when you're thinking about how that asshole screwed you over, or how you're going to get one over on your enemies. "Abandoning sloth and drowsiness, dwelling with an awareness devoid of sloth and drowsiness, mindful, alert, percipient of light." This is a reference to a common phenomenon. Not everyone experiences it, but many do: when the mind begins to get free of the shackles of the hindrances, externally you may find that your senses become more vivid, that the visual field is actually brighter. Your mind isn't jittering and jostling around; things get clearer and brighter. And with eyes closed you may have lights arising, or a diffuse field, or speckles, or color washes; people get all kinds of different things. There's no need to do anything with them, but they are a sign of concentration.89
0:33:25"You cleanse your mind of sloth and drowsiness. Abandoning restlessness and anxiety, dwelling undisturbed, your mind inwardly still." This refers both to a mental restlessness and to a gross physical restlessness, and these are really on a continuum. They're manifestations of the same root shaking, an unsteadiness in the mind, which on a subtle level leads to the proliferation of thought and unsteadiness with the object, and at a grosser level causes you to shift and move about. A practical means of seeing the subtle restlessness clearly is to not move. Then all the wavering and shaking of the mind that can't rest with the object becomes more apparent, and you can drop it off more and more. This is another reason for following things like the precepts, or your own favorite ethical alignment: so that when you sit down you have no cause for regret, which would manifest as internal and external restlessness. Likewise anxiety: if you've taken care of what you need to take care of in the rest of your life, then when you sit down the job's done; there aren't a whole bunch of dangling threads.
0:35:00For those of us with procrastination issues, this one is a little difficult. "Abandoning uncertainty," sometimes translated as skeptical doubt: doubt in oneself, doubt in the efficacy of the practice, doubt in its worth. I don't know if all of you will believe me, but every single one of you here has the capacity, if you so choose and you put in the time, to traverse any and all jhanas to whatever depth you want, and to walk the path to its culmination. You've got a mind, you've got a body, you're breathing, your sense faculties as far as I can tell are intact, and even if they weren't, you could still work with that. You have everything you need to take this as deep as you want to. So see for yourself, but I have confidence in all of you. If you choose to do this, you can and you will. And from your own experience and the reliable testimony of others, you know that it can be done: that these practices do work, that they're wholesome, that they lead to your own welfare and that of others. So it's a very good thing to do.
0:36:49There's an extended analogy here about the five hindrances, those undesirable things in life. When these five hindrances are not abandoned, the practitioner regards them as a debt, a sickness, a prison, slavery, a road through desolate country. But when they are abandoned, they may regard them as unindebtedness, good health, release from prison, freedom, and a place of security. "When you see that they are abandoned, gladness is born. In one who is gladdened, rapture is born. Enraptured at heart, your body grows calm. Your body calm, you are sensitive to pleasure. Feeling pleasure, your mind becomes concentrated." So this is getting to the point of access concentration beginning and becoming mature, and opening up into the first jhana. When all of this restless activity of the mind, in all its various forms, settles, all of the energy that's usually pulling within and reaching without coheres and collects and begins to express as rapture, as pleasure, and away it goes. You don't need to do anything special for this to happen. When your mind is collected and contented and the hindrances are abandoned, it's the inevitable result.10
0:38:30The extent to which the hindrances are present or absent, and the rapidity and ease with which they disappear and these factors of mind arise, is a pretty good gauge at any moment of your practice, both on retreat and off. Not that you should get stuck in evaluating and measuring your practice: "Oh my goodness, yesterday it was so easy, the hindrances were so light, and today..." Don't fall into that, but it is a good gauge. Most of the time, for any and all of these hindrances, you really don't need to do anything but let them be in the periphery without engagement, just as you would a more minor distraction. Let them fall off in their own time while you reorient and stay with the breath, stay with the metta. If something is really persistent, if you're having the same stuff come up again and again every sit, then something a little more targeted might be called for. Again, I'm happy to go into that in Q&A or in interviews, and that can sometimes be a more involved process.
0:40:00But usually all that's required is patient persistence: letting things go as they arise, and returning and reorienting to the object again and again. And I really recommend taking your sweet time with this. This is the foundation for the rest of this retreat and for any other practice you might want to do. This kind of stable, calm, collected, energized attention is the fuel for any and all practice you might want to do. Time spent continuing to develop, mature and refine these qualities and this kind of practice is never wasted, really never wasted. If you spent the entirety of this retreat just maturing into deeper and deeper access concentration, never once tipping over into jhana even if it were accessible, that would be a retreat well spent. If you spent all of this retreat plugging away and letting go of hindrances as they arise, and that was the whole of the retreat, that would be time well spent: work not only worth doing, but necessary to do.
0:41:41So while I'm going to cover a lot in the coming days, because I want to give you all, as best I can, an outline of a really broad sweep of what's possible, there's no expectation of pace, and everything I'm going to talk about is something to be returned to, deepened and refined over the course of a whole lifetime of practice. You never really move beyond these fundamentals.
0:42:20Okay, that's pretty much all I have to say for now. Are there any questions about the hindrances, about mindfulness of breathing, about metta? "I'm just trying to track all of them. Other than restlessness, tiredness and [unclear], what are the other two?" Sense desire and ill will. "Sense desire and ill will." Or covetousness, here. Okay. And again, don't get stuck in practice. When you notice that you've become distracted and gone off the object, you don't need to engage in reflective analysis: "Okay, which hindrance was it? And how do I get rid of it?" That's at a very high level. You don't need to do that. As soon as you recognize, "Oh, I've drifted," no problem: let it go, come back, relax. We're not doing forensic analysis on our meditation. We're just trying to do it. "I have a question." Oh, yeah. Oh, sorry, you can go first, in the room. You go. "Okay. This might be weird, I don't know. With the meditation focus objects, something weird happens when I try to...
0:44:00A common prompt is to focus on the air entering and exiting your nose. Some weird thing happens for me where, when I focus on that sensation, it's deeply uncomfortable. I don't have better language for it, but I hate it. It's quite visceral; there's aversion. Is that meant to be part of the practice and something to work through, or should I just pick a different thing to focus on? Watching my chest go up and down is still part of breathing, and it doesn't bring up the same negative energy in me, for example." Yeah. It's not intended to happen. You could work through whatever aversion you have to that sensation, or to that region of your bodily field of sensation, and that might be of benefit; it might be worth doing at some point. But if there's some other object you don't have that aversive reaction to, there's no need to engage in unnecessary struggle. Also, when you get to a more deeply settled state, it can be a very interesting experiment to run.
0:45:22Say you get really well settled with the breath in the abdomen or in your chest or through the whole body. What happens when you approach the breath at the nostrils from a really well-settled place, rather than using it as a means of settling? You can discover that how an object manifests in your experience, and whether you find it aversive or attractive, has a lot to do with your state when you approach it. I don't know why you find it aversive, but you might be able to discover that for yourself by playing like that at some point. "It's inconvenient, because it rules out a lot of breathwork. I can't do a lot of breathwork, because when I increase the amount of air, I hate it even more." You don't have to do something you hate when there are easier options that work just as well. "Thanks." "I was curious whether you have any tips for physical pain, because my whole mind seems to contract around it. I can get glimpses of the breath, and then it's straight back over."
0:46:51I'm not sure that came through: the question was about working with physical pain. One: we're sitting a whole lot on this retreat, so if you're not used to sitting a lot, a very simple thing is just to move to a chair or find some more comfortable way to sit. If you can get a wadded-up blanket, put it under your knee, or whatever you need to do to actually be comfortable, do that. We're a little cramped down here, but if there's space for you to lie down, you're welcome to lie down. Now, if you want to work with pain: as a larger point, there will come a time for all of us, at the point of death if not before, when there's nothing we can do. That happens every time we get sick. We usually just distract ourselves from it, or take some painkillers. But learning to be with pain without reacting, without being averse to the raw sensation, is incredibly valuable.
0:47:59A retreat, or meditation in general, is a great laboratory for unpicking and understanding this: "Okay, there's the sensation. I'm going to pinch my arm here. Here's the sensation," which is unpleasant. But then there's everything the mind does to wriggle and squirm and try to pull away or push away, and that makes the pain. You can discern at the level of sensation that it actually increases the unpleasantness of the sensation tenfold, a hundredfold, depending. You may find that, just as with other distractions or hindrances, by reorienting to your object again and again, the pain actually subsides: it goes away or just decreases in intensity. But if you find again and again that you're unable to stay with your primary meditation object, and your mind is just saying, "Okay, no, there's no way; this knee, something in my back, it's just not going away," then you can shift to take the pain as the object. With the same quality of attention you would give to the breath or to metta, you plunge into the pain and appreciate it, get curious about its texture, and don't resist, don't pull away.11
0:49:36If your mind is pretty well collected, you may find that not only does it stop hurting so much, it actually becomes a fascinating object, and the pain itself can break up into neutral or even pleasant sensation. You can enter jhana by focusing on pain. I'm not going to recommend that when there are more pleasant ways in, but you can. "Just to clarify: that technique would be to become really curious about the texture and sensation and quality of the pain?" Another thing you can do is focus on the space around the pain, if focusing directly on it is too much. If you can imagine a bubble around it, that may allow the pain sensations to move and break up. Because the worst thing with pain is the back-and-forth: it grabs your attention, you're pulled in, you go "Oh, no," and then you yank your attention away, and you're just stuck again. It's like a pinball between the pain and something else.
0:50:49Every time it goes back to the pain, it gets more agitated. So, yeah. But again, I leave that to you. If you want to practice a lot with pain, I recommend it at some point, because it prepares you: we're all going to age, we're all going to be sick, we're all going to die. It's good to get comfortable with what's uncomfortable, but do that on your own initiative, in your own time. I'm not going to push anyone to do that. "Do you have any advice for procrastinators on dealing with anxiety when, inevitably, threads won't be handled while you're here?" You're on retreat? It's too late. Everything will be waiting for you when you return. And you can take that same attitude when you begin a session of practice at home. You sit down, and it's: "Oh my God, I don't have time to meditate. I've got all these things to do, so many things." Okay. You say, "Okay, I've got so many things, and I will get to them as soon as this period of meditation is done.
0:52:10We'll see to you." Like someone flustered who comes up to you and grabs you by the shoulders: "You don't understand, this is so urgent." "Okay, we'll get to it. No problem. There's this lovely couch here; would you mind just sitting there? We'll see to your concern as soon as possible." And then you'll be more resourced, hopefully, at the end of this retreat or at the end of an individual period of meditation. As for larger patterns of procrastination, meditation alone may not be enough. I think it's pretty well known at this point that Shinzen, one of my teachers and well known in these circles, struggled for years and years with almost life-destroying procrastination, and he had to get some therapeutic intervention. So meditation sometimes isn't enough. You need behavioral feedback and accountability and all of these things to get to the root of the issue, which may be rooted more deeply in early-childhood attachment stuff. People have different opinions; I'm not going to opine too much here.
0:53:25"You mentioned how to work with pain. Is it the same if you have sudden reflex sensations that you can't control, or spasms where you can't even control what's happening?" Yeah, I'm glad you brought this up. I know at least one other person on the retreat often experiences these spontaneous muscle spasms when deepening into concentration. That's a normal thing that happens to many people (not everybody) as part of the process of the bodily sense being pacified. You may experience jolts of energy that make you tremble or spasm, and they may come in shocks or they may persist. I remember this happening for months: every time I sat, I would get these jerks. In my own experience, and from talking to lots of people, most of these things tend to resolve themselves. As your mind-body system gets more used to descending into deeper samadhi and making that transition back and forth, these, I don't know, energetic somatic irregularities tend to diminish and go away over time.
0:54:50So unless they're really severe, you can just let them happen, and they'll tend to go away. But if they're very persistent, you could do what I recommended for the pain with them. There's a way of leaning into them that might actually make them more intense. Don't do that. If you find that by paying attention to them you're actually energizing them, and both the sensation and the external motor activity are becoming more intense, don't do that. If that's happening, the approach I mentioned, paying attention to the space around the sensation, might be better than focusing directly on it. Yeah. I see [a participant's] hand up. "You had a response to an earlier question about breathing. I share that great discomfort with breathing in the nose area, so sometimes I don't want to deal with it, and I switch to another place. My question is about the size of the other place. Will I generally develop greater concentration, stronger jhana and so on by focusing on a narrow part of the body rather than a larger part?"
0:56:24I think it differs by person, honestly. I get stronger concentration more quickly with a more restricted spatial focus, and some people notice that. For some people, no, it really doesn't matter. Find out. And if you don't want to stay at the nostrils, that's fine. You can stay with a more restricted spatial focus related to the breath someplace else, or you can just stay with the whole body.
0:57:03It seems we've exhausted the questions, so since we've been sitting here for an hour or so, I'm going to give folks between five and ten minutes to go to the bathroom and get a sip of water, and then we'll go into a period of guided practice until about noon our time here in Colorado. Sound good? So, five or ten minutes, back here. "Do you know if they'll have us on Zoom for the guided practice, or are they just going to do that over there?" Yes. Yep. We're going to stay on until noon Colorado time. Okay. I was just saying to the folks in person (for those here): a lot of us traveled a ways, and that's always exhausting. A lot of us were busy right up until the beginning of the retreat, and a couple of people have come up expressing exhaustion and fatigue, which is understandable, especially on the first day of a retreat. If you're in a similar boat today... It might be stricter tomorrow; we'll see.
0:58:53But today, anyway, if during the group sessions you feel your wellbeing and your practice would be better served by taking a nap, just take a nap. It's better to take a nap and be well rested than to slog through a sleepy, hazy sit. You can just meditate comfortably as you're taking a nap, on your way in and on your way out. I like strict containers, where even a bit of voluntary sleep deprivation is involved; some of us are sick and enjoy that kind of thing. This is not that. Take care of yourself, sleep, be well rested. Yeah, pro naps. So you're welcome to go nap until lunch if you like, or you can just fall asleep in here while I guide a meditation; that's also fine. Could someone get the door?
1:01:11Settle into your seat, feeling the points of contact with the floor or your chair. It can be nice at the beginning to do a quick body scan and release any unnecessary muscular tension that may be present. Starting at the crown of the head, expanding outwards over and down the scalp, down through your forehead and temples, through the muscles of the face, notice and, if possible, relax and release any unnecessary muscular tension you find, as though warm water is being poured down over you with your attention, releasing and relaxing any knots, any tensions. Down through the cheeks and jaw, mouth, through the neck, down through your shoulders and arms, chest and abdomen, hips and pelvis, down through your legs, until finally your attention comes to rest in the soles of your feet, all the accumulated energy and stress in the body drained out. From here, reorient to the space of the whole body. Having just passed down from crown to toes, open the aperture of your attention to embrace the whole of your body.
1:04:32Just see what you notice (tingling, pressure, warmth, coolness, motion, stillness, tiredness, pain, whatever's there), and just notice without collapsing down onto any of it.
1:05:32Then feel into the breath sensation. You may feel it most strongly in the abdomen, but stay sensitive to the whole area of the body. Stay with the breath through the whole duration of the inhale and exhale, and the gaps in between too: a gentle constancy of contact, like savoring the texture of a rich fabric, or enjoying the flavor of delicious ice cream, or like gently brushing a razor's edge with a feather, so lightly that the feather doesn't get cut, and yet the contact is constant. See if you can attend to the breath like that.
1:09:37If and when you notice that your mind has wandered into thought, memory, planning or expectation, or collapsed down onto some part of the body, just let it go, reorient, and open back up to the whole field of bodily sensation, feeling the breath come and go. When you're really attuned, when your attention is really collected and settled in the body, you can feel every breath in your fingertips, very literally. There's nothing boring here.
1:12:49Anchoring the mind, bringing it back again and again, settling in. I don't know how many of you have had the experience of comforting a fussy infant, but see if you can regard your own mind, your own habitual tendencies, with the kind of care you would give a distressed, fussy baby, and gently rock yourself back into comfort. Except that the arms, in this case, are the sensations of breath, or whatever else your object is.
1:13:41It's truly amazing how we've trained ourselves to be so uncomfortable in our own skin. Just feel your body. Come back, get reacquainted.
1:17:08Like holding your own hand on a long walk home. See if you can develop that kind of relationship with meditation in general, whatever object you're using. Here it's the breath in the whole body, but that principle applies to any object.
1:17:35It's good to bring a kind of energy and intensity to practice, but not one that results in straining and clenching. Most of the diligence and effort comes in the persistence, and in noticing when we've fallen away, without a whole lot of fuss,
1:18:10coming back hundreds and thousands and hundreds of thousands and millions of times, and doing so energetically and enthusiastically, again and again.
1:18:45We can't force the mind to settle. We just set up the conditions so that a natural process can take place.
1:19:17Trust that with time and the patient application of effort, not too tight, not too loose, your mind will settle and the hindrances will subside. Your mind will become bright, energized, malleable, clear, immovable, stable, open like the sky,12
1:19:49returning, actually, to its natural condition: vast, open and free.
1:20:19But there can be a lot of unlearning to do. So as we here in person move into lunch (it may be ready; we might have to wait a couple of minutes), and as you all online get on with whatever you'll be doing next, maybe just keep practicing.
1:20:46Maintain your practice as you exit your posture. Whether you're sitting with legs crossed or sitting in a chair, maintain full-body awareness as your limbs move, as you uncross your legs, as you stretch, as you sit up, as you begin to move. And notice: the eyes are a dead giveaway every time.
1:21:16Notice where and why your eyes move. The traditional discipline around this, in stricter training environments, is to keep your eyes down past the end of your nose pretty much all the time, unless you actually need to see something to engage with it for a practical reason. I'm not going to insist on that, but it's a very good way of training, and of noticing how conditioned most of us are to jump out visually. So let yourself stay fully immersed in your bodily sensations, in your breathing, and if you find that keeping your gaze downcast helps with that, do it. If you notice that you're looking around for some stimulation, just as you would if you noticed yourself fidgeting while sitting, let it go. Let your eyes rest, either closed or open without a point of focus, not actually engaging the visual field, keeping the mind and awareness immersed in the body. And a point about mindful eating may be helpful: it's quite easy to get lost, and for the mind to spin up, when you begin to eat.13
1:22:55Something practical that can help: when you place the morsel in your mouth, put the utensil down, hands off, and stay with the sensations of chewing, with the rest of your body. It's almost as though the pace at which we shovel food in can keep pace with the proliferation going on in our minds at times. So, thank you for joining online. Next for us here and with you will be interviews; the signups are there, same Zoom link. I think that's it. Okay. Thank you, everybody.
Sources
- The four establishings of mindfulness; mindfulness immersed in the body. MN 10 Satipatthana Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN10.html ↩
- Mindfulness immersed in the body as the frame for both breath and metta. MN 119 Kayagatasati Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN119.html ↩
- “This is the direct path for the purification of beings ...” MN 10, opening. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN10.html ↩
- “Having gone to the wilderness ... establishing mindfulness to the fore”; breathing as bringing the four establishings to culmination. MN 118 Anapanasati Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN118.html ↩
- Breathing in long and short; the turner simile. MN 10 (the turner simile is in MN 10 and DN 22, not MN 118) dhammatalks.org/suttas/MN/MN10.html ↩
- Goodwill “as my awareness-release” developed through the forms of concentration and the four establishings. AN 8:63 Sankhitta Sutta (Thanissaro, “In Brief”; Access to Insight) accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/an/an08/an08.063.than.html ↩
- The five hindrances and their abandoning. DN 2 Samaññaphala Sutta. dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN02.html ↩
- Hindrances as habits worn away by not feeding them. SN 46:51 Ahara Sutta (what feeds and starves each hindrance) dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN46_51.html ↩
- “Percipient of light” as the remedy for drowsiness. AN 7:58 Capala Sutta (the seven remedies for nodding) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN7_58.html ↩
- The hindrances as debt, sickness, prison, slavery and a desert road; gladness, rapture, calm, pleasure, concentration. DN 2. dhammatalks.org/suttas/DN/DN02.html ↩
- The extra pain the mind adds to raw sensation. SN 36:6 Sallatha Sutta (the second arrow) dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN36_6.html ↩
- Effort “not too tight, not too loose” AN 6:55 Sona Sutta (the lute simile) dhammatalks.org/suttas/AN/AN6_55.html ↩
- Keeping the eyes downcast. Sn 3:1 Pabbajja Sutta: “his eyes downcast, looking only a plow-length before him” dhammatalks.org/suttas/KN/StNp/StNp3_1.html ↩